# People Change Habitats

> When people change an ecosystem, populations may rise or fall. You test that rule by releasing blue catfish, changing shoreline habitat and changing fishing in a model river. Then you read Virginia survey data for blue and white catfish from 1988 to 2022 and make a careful claim about how the river community changed.

Course: Life Science (Changing ecosystems). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/people-change-habitats/

Builds on: Food Webs and Energy · Competition and Cooperation · Populations Rise and Fall

## What you'll learn

- You will explain how people are part of ecosystems and depend on them, and how land use, farming, taking resources, habitat destruction, pollution and invasive species can make populations rise or fall, with effects that spread through the ecosystem.
- You will explain how a disruption changes competition between species, for example when an invasive species uses the same food or space as native species.
- You will read Virginia river survey data on blue catfish and native white catfish and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, about how the river community changed after an invasive species arrived.

**In the 1970s and 1980s, people put blue catfish into Virginia’s James, Rappahannock and York river systems. Today these big fish are common in parts of those rivers.**

Blue catfish are native to the Mississippi River basin and other waters outside Virginia’s Bay rivers. People stocked them here to give anglers big fish to catch. Their numbers grew fast in the 1990s. What could this new fish mean for the crabs, small fish and native catfish already living there?

> **The one idea to carry through this lesson.** When people change an ecosystem, populations may rise or fall. Use this rule for changes in land, resources, pollution, introduced species or restoration. It does not predict which population will change or prove what caused a survey pattern.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. What people do does not really change the environment. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** People are part of ecosystems and depend on them for food, water and energy. When people clear land, pollute water or bring in a new species, populations may change. People can also help by restoring habitats. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** People are part of ecosystems and depend on them for food, water and energy. When people clear land, pollute water or bring in a new species, populations may change. People can also help by restoring habitats.
2. People can change forests, but not rivers or the ocean. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Rain carries fertilizer from farms and lawns into rivers, and fishing removes fish. People also carried blue catfish into Virginia rivers. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Rain carries fertilizer from farms and lawns into rivers, and fishing removes fish. People also carried blue catfish into Virginia rivers.
3. When two species compete, they fight each other. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Competition can happen without a fight. If one species eats food that another species needs, less is left. Scientists report that blue catfish and native white catfish eat similar prey, so they may compete for it. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Competition can happen without a fight. If one species eats food that another species needs, less is left. Scientists report that blue catfish and native white catfish eat similar prey, so they may compete for it.

## Explore: test a model river

Test the first film’s pathway: more blue catfish, less shared prey, less food for white catfish. The model river’s bars use relative units, not measurements.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Release a new fish into a model river

**Predict 1.** Release many blue catfish. Will the white catfish bar fall, hold steady or rise? Does the model follow the film’s pathway?

**Predict 2.** Keep the blue catfish and also take away half the shoreline habitat. Will crabs and small fish fall further than with blue catfish alone?

**Predict 3.** Will heavy fishing for blue catfish bring the other bars back all the way, partway or not at all? Play 20 years and check.

A model shows possible effects, not what caused a change in a real river.

## Explain: follow the change

- habitat
- population
- land use
- habitat destruction
- pollution
- native species
- invasive species
- competition

- A **habitat** is where an organism lives and finds the food, water and shelter it needs ([more on habitats](https://stemhop.com/lessons/habitat-and-niche/)). A **population** is every member of one species in one area at one time.
- **Land use** means how people use land: for farms, homes, roads or forest. Rain can carry fertilizer and manure from farm fields into streams.
- Taking wood, coal, fish or gravel changes an ecosystem. Digging gravel out of a stream changes the streambed.
- **Habitat destruction** removes or ruins habitat, such as filling a marsh. Animals there must move or die, so local populations often drop.
- **Pollution** is harmful material added to air, water or soil. Extra fertilizer can feed fast algae growth. Later, the water can run low on oxygen ([follow the steps](https://stemhop.com/lessons/eutrophication-and-big-changes/)).

Habitat destruction, pollution and invasive species are three ways people disrupt ecosystems. A food web links species by who eats whom ([food webs](https://stemhop.com/lessons/food-webs-and-energy/)), so one change can spread: some populations go up, and others go down.

People and ecosystems also affect each other through climate, water supply, air quality, energy production, ocean acidification and waste management. Ocean acidification means ocean water becomes more acidic as it takes in carbon dioxide from the air.

Human effects are not always negative. In Virginia’s coastal bays, people spread eelgrass seeds. A 2020 study reported that underwater grass returned and the total mass of fish rose ([Helping Ecosystems Recover](https://stemhop.com/lessons/restoring-ecosystems/)).

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge habitat destructionpollutionblue catfishwhite catfishblue crab blankblankblue catfishblankblue crab Word 

**Key idea:**

People depend on ecosystems, and land use, habitat destruction, pollution and invasive species can make populations rise or fall.

## Explain: a new fish and shared food

A **native species** lives in a place naturally, without people bringing it. An **invasive species** is brought to a new place, spreads and causes harm to native species or people; being new is not enough.

|  | Blue catfish | White catfish |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Native to Virginia’s Bay rivers? | No (Mississippi River basin and other waters) | Yes |
| How it got here | People stocked it: James and Rappahannock in the 1970s, York River system in 1985 | Already here |
| What it eats | Plants and animals, including fish and sometimes blue crabs | Prey similar to what blue catfish eat |

Blue catfish can grow about as long as many adults are tall.

The first film showed **competition**: species need the same limited resource, such as food or space ([more on competition](https://stemhop.com/lessons/competition-and-cooperation/)). No fight is required. Scientists report that the two catfish eat similar prey, so they may compete.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Competition needs a shared, limited resource, but it does not need a fight. Image: two underwater views of the same river bottom. On the left, two pale white catfish swim near plenty of small fish and crabs. On the right, a much larger blue catfish swims beside the same two white catfish, and only a few small fish and one crab are left. No fish is fighting.

Shared food is like pizza at a party: a new guest can leave less for others. Unlike pizza, river prey reproduce, move and change with the seasons.

If blue catfish eat many blue crabs, fewer may remain for other crab eaters, including people.

- Blue catfish are invasive in Virginia because blank.
- Blue catfish and white catfish may compete because blank.
- If blue catfish eat many crabs, then blank.

**Key idea:**

An invasive species can lower native populations by eating the same food they need, even without a fight.

Competition is a possible explanation, not an observation. Checking whether real catfish populations changed takes years of river records.

**Film transcript: Reading the River's Record**

### Film transcript: Reading the River's Record

The first film followed ripples through one model river. How can scientists tell whether real blue and white catfish populations changed? They need the river's record, not one visit. Murky water hides fish from view. Scientists from the Virginia Institute of Marine Science repeat bottom tows at many places. A boat pulls the same kind of net for a set time. The catch is sorted and counted. Repeating the method makes years more useful to compare. Those counts become a survey index for each fish. An index tracks how common that fish is in the surveyed area. It is not a count of every fish in the river. Think of it as a consistent signal from repeated samples.

Keep blue catfish blue and white catfish gold, matching the first film. Build a separate trace for each fish across time. The two indexes use different math and river areas. Their heights cannot be compared directly with each other. Now the full traces grow from left to right. The blue index rises from early zero catches, though it jumps between years. The white index is lower after its early high values. Each dot is one year inside a longer pattern. One blue point towers above nearby years. Should that single point settle the story, or should scientists use the full series? Make your prediction.

Use the full series. One year can be unusually high or low. A zero also means none were caught in that survey, not that none lived anywhere in the river. The other years keep one point in context. Compare each fish with itself across time. The blue index became higher, while the white index stayed below its early high values. That opposite pattern shows that the surveyed river community changed. An index tracks change; it does not count every fish. But a survey shows a pattern, not its cause.

Shared prey makes competition one possible explanation. Pollution, habitat loss or other changes could also have affected white catfish. The graph alone cannot choose among those possibilities. A careful claim has three parts. State the pattern, point to values from the same years, then explain a possible link. Keep may in the reasoning because the cause remains uncertain. That small word keeps the evidence honest. The survey adds evidence to our river picture. When people change an ecosystem, populations may rise or fall.

Evidence shows the pattern; further tests are needed to identify causes. Good science protects that line between observation and explanation.

From the film

- When people change an ecosystem, populations may rise or fall.
- A survey index tracks how common a fish is in the surveyed area; it is not a count of every fish.
- Compare each fish with itself over time, because the two indexes use different math and river areas.
- A survey shows a pattern, not its cause; competition is one possible explanation.

## Elaborate: read the James River surveys

In the second film, repeated bottom tows by the Virginia Institute of Marine Science (VIMS) became a **survey index**. It tracks how common a fish is in the surveyed area from year to year. It is not a count of every fish. The film left the numbers and the cause to you.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Repeated bottom tows become a survey index that tracks change, not a whole-river count. Image: a side view of a river with a small boat on the surface pulling a cone-shaped net along the muddy bottom, with catfish inside the net. A small side view shows the catch sorted on deck into a tub of blue catfish and a tub of white catfish, with tally marks on a clipboard.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* The blue index rises, with big swings between years. After 1995 the white index stays below its 1990 and 1995 highs; its

| Year | Blue catfish survey index | White catfish survey index |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1988 | 0.00 | 0.20 |
| 1990 | 0.00 | 1.83 |
| 1995 | 8.97 | 1.31 |
| 2000 | 17.44 | 0.05 |
| 2005 | 47.07 | 0.15 |
| 2010 | 16.45 | 0.41 |
| 2015 | 58.84 | 0.20 |
| 2019 | 317.77 | 0.23 |
| 2020 | 47.74 | 0.32 |
| 2022 | 54.42 | 0.16 |

Source: VIMS trawl survey of the James River, September to November tows, older fish (age 1 and up, judged by length); Tuckey and Fabrizio, 2023 annual report, Tables 9 and 19.

Compare each fish only with itself, because the two indexes use different math and river areas. Three more cautions. Values from 2015 on were adjusted for a new boat and net. The years are not evenly spaced. And the white index was 0.06 in 1994 but 1.31 in 1995, so the size of a drop depends on which years you pick.

Worked comparison: the blue index went from 8.97 in 1995 to 54.42 in 2022.

**later index ÷ earlier index = 54.42 ÷ 8.97 ≈ 6.1**

So the 2022 blue index was about six times the 1995 index. That is a pattern, not its cause.

**Predict 4.** The white index changed from 1.31 to 0.16. Will the percent drop be closer to 10, 50 or 90 percent? Then calculate: subtract, divide by 1.31 and multiply by 100.

1. In which year does the blue index first rise above zero? Describe its pattern after that.
2. Find the mean of the ten white index values.
3. Find the mean of the blue values with and without 2019. How much does one year move it?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the question: what happens to a river when people bring in a big new fish? Use the table.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that as blue catfish became blank, native white catfish became blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: In 1995 the blue catfish index was blank and the white catfish index was blank. In 2022 they were blank and blank.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: Blue catfish and white catfish eat similar blank, so more blue catfish may leave less blank for white catfish.

> **Compare with a model answer.** As blue catfish became more common in the James River, native white catfish became rarer. In 1995 the blue catfish index was 8.97 and the white catfish index was 1.31. In 2022 they were 54.42 and 0.16. The two catfish eat similar prey, so more blue catfish may leave less food for white catfish. One limit: these surveys show a pattern, not its cause. Something else, such as pollution or habitat loss, could also have lowered the white catfish.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

A town plans homes beside a creek. Some people want lawns to the water. Others want a strip of plants along the bank as habitat. Plan a test with soil trays: does a plant strip keep soil out of the creek?

**Predict 5.** Which tray should release less soil: bare soil or soil with a plant strip? What result would change your mind?

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Does a strip of grass at the low end of a soil tray reduce soil washed off by rain?
> - **Independent variable:** a grass-sod strip 10 cm wide at the low end, or bare soil.
> - **Dependent variable:** the runoff soil mass, in grams, after the water dries in a pan.
> - **Control:** bare-soil trays with no grass strip.
> - **Constants:** the same soil, tray size, tilt, and 1 liter of water poured from the same watering can for 1 minute.
> - **Repeated trials:** three trays of each kind; find each mean.
> - **Safety:** wear gloves, wipe spills so no one slips, and wash your hands.
> - **Meaning:** less soil from grass trays supports keeping plants along the bank. A tray is a model, not a real creek.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

When people change an ecosystem, populations may rise or fall. In the James River surveys, blue catfish became more common while native white catfish became rarer. Similar prey makes competition possible, even without a fight, but the survey shows a pattern, not its cause. Land use, habitat destruction and pollution can also change populations, and restoration can help.

**Science practices you used:** reading a graph and table, finding a mean, comparing change over time, testing a model and naming its limits, planning a fair test, and making a claim from evidence.

## Going deeper

### How the catfish survey is done

Each bottom tow lasts five minutes and is made in daytime, from September to November.

### Eelgrass restoration in numbers

People spread about 74.5 million eelgrass seeds in Virginia’s coastal bays. The 2020 study reported that underwater grass grew back across 3,612 hectares.

### The longest blue catfish

The U.S. Geological Survey lists the longest blue catfish at 165 cm.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/people-change-habitats/
