# What an Organism Has to Do

> A leaf in air not saturated with water vapour cannot take in carbon dioxide without losing water through the same pores, at a price set, to a first approximation, by the two concentration gaps across them; it is the course's first example of a solution paid for somewhere else. This lesson sets out the five problems every multicellular organism faces (energy and materials; exchange and transport, wastes included; a relatively stable inside; defense; reproduction) as the course's checklist, compares the price a barley leaf and a human lung pay, reads a barley experiment with far fewer stomata, and separates how questions from why questions. Afterwards you can calculate a water-use efficiency, say why structure fits function without calling it design, and sort an explanation into proximate or ultimate.

Course: Organismal Biology (Organisms and their diversity). Level: first- and second-year university. About 20 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/organism-problems/

Builds on: Crossing the Membrane · Capturing Sunlight · Variation and Survival

## What you'll learn

- Name the five recurring problems of a multicellular organism (energy and materials; exchange and transport, including wastes; control and relative internal stability; defense; reproduction as lineage continuation) and use them as a checklist for any organ system.
- Calculate a water-use efficiency from carbon gained and water lost, and use it to explain why the same exchange surface can be better in one environment and worse in another.
- Explain that structure fits function because lineages with better-working heritable variants left more descendants, and that every structure is also shaped by trade-offs, history and chance.
- Distinguish proximate explanations (mechanism, development) from ultimate explanations (adaptive significance, evolutionary history) of one trait, and say why a full account needs both.

To grow, a barley leaf must take in carbon dioxide, and the main way in is through tiny pores that also let water vapour out. How much water does each bite of carbon cost, and can a plant pay less?

> **The one idea.** A leaf’s carbon dioxide comes in, and its water vapour goes out, through the same pores. The price, water lost per carbon dioxide gained, is set by the two concentration gaps across the pores; each gap is the difference between the air inside the leaf and the air outside. The pores set how fast gas moves; fewer or narrower pores change the price only by changing a gap, and cannot make it zero.
>
> *Scope:* a first approximation for a leaf in air not saturated with water vapour, with the pores as the main path (Going deeper lists what it leaves out). A lung also pays water for oxygen, but breathing sets its price. This is the course’s first example of a solution paid for somewhere else; for any other solution, find and test the cost rather than assume it.

## Five problems, one checklist for the course

A multicellular organism, a body of many cells that depend on one another, faces five problems. The first film named them; this course uses them as a checklist for every organ system. The list is a teaching frame; other books divide the ground differently.

1. **Energy and materials.** All organisms use an energy source to run their chemistry; animals get theirs from food they ingest or absorb. Plants capture light energy in their leaves and use it to fix carbon from the air; splitting water along the way gives off oxygen as a by-product ([the light reactions](https://stemhop.com/lessons/light-reactions/), [the Calvin cycle](https://stemhop.com/lessons/calvin-cycle/)). The roots of seed plants absorb water and minerals from the soil.
2. **Exchange and transport, including wastes.** Materials must cross a surface and reach every cell, and wastes must leave. **Diffusion**, the net movement of molecules from higher to lower concentration, can do much of this in a small organism. In a large one, transport systems carry the load: blood vessels in animals; in plants the **xylem**, which carries water and minerals up from the roots, and the **phloem**, which carries sugars from where they are made to where they are used ([size, scale and surface](https://stemhop.com/lessons/size-and-scaling/), [gas exchange](https://stemhop.com/lessons/gas-exchange/), [moving water and sugar in plants](https://stemhop.com/lessons/plant-transport/)).
3. **Control and relative internal stability.** **Homeostasis** is the maintenance of a relatively stable internal environment. Adult humans hold their core temperature near 37 degrees C; a plant closes its leaf pores when its leaves run short of water ([tissues, organs and homeostasis](https://stemhop.com/lessons/tissues-and-homeostasis/)).
4. **Defense.** Animals have skin, mucus and immune cells ([innate immunity](https://stemhop.com/lessons/innate-immunity/)); in the small plant Arabidopsis, closing the stomata can be part of the defense against bacteria that enter through those pores.
5. **Reproduction, as continuation of a lineage.** Reproduction passes DNA, and the genes it carries, to offspring. It is a problem for the **lineage**, a line of ancestors and descendants, not for every individual: honeybee workers rarely reproduce while a queen is present, yet the colony goes on producing queens and males (more in Going deeper).

## Where the price comes from: one leaf, one lung

The first film showed a barley (Hordeum vulgare) leaf passing carbon dioxide in and water vapour out through its **stomata** (singular stoma), the pores between pairs of **guard cells**; that water loss is **transpiration**, water evaporating from the wet cell walls inside. Here is the arithmetic the film left out.

**The leaf.** Both gases take the same path, so one **stomatal conductance**, how freely gas passes through the stomata (measured for carbon dioxide), sets both flows:

> **carbon in = conductance × carbon dioxide gap**
>
> **water out = 1.6 × conductance × water vapour gap**

Water vapour, a lighter molecule, diffuses about 1.6 times faster than carbon dioxide. Divide the second line by the first and the conductance cancels:

> **water lost per carbon gained = 1.6 × water vapour gap / carbon dioxide gap**

In moderately dry air, with carbon dioxide scarce and the air inside the leaf close to saturated, the water gap is about a hundred times the carbon dioxide gap, so the leaf pays about 1.6 × 100 = 160 water molecules per carbon dioxide, roughly 150 to 300 as the carbon dioxide inside the leaf runs a little higher or lower. Humid air shrinks the water gap and the price; hot, dry air raises both.

**The lung.** Breathing moves air in bulk, and the airways wet incoming air and recover some water on the way out, so the two-gap rule does not apply; work from one breath. Air breathed in at about 21% oxygen leaves at about 16%: about 5% of its volume is taken up as oxygen. Room air at 20 degrees C and half humidity holds about 1% water vapour; the breath out, nearly saturated near body temperature, holds about 4 to 5% more. So the lung pays about one water molecule per oxygen, a rough size that breathing rate, oxygen extraction and the air’s temperature and humidity move (cold, dry air raises it).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A leaf pays hundreds of water molecules for each carbon dioxide; a lung pays about one for each oxygen; only the leaf can close its pores. Image: two side-by-side schematics. In a barley leaf, a pore between two guard cells in a waxy surface lets carbon dioxide in and water vapour out. In a human lung, gas crosses a moist air-sac lining, each breath out carries water vapour away (most of it picked up in the airways on the way in), and the lung sits inside the chest and cannot close.

## Worked problem: what a leaf pays

> **water-use efficiency = carbon gained / water lost**, the price turned upside down

These numbers are illustrative, not barley data. Leaf A **assimilates** (takes up and fixes) 20 umol CO2 per m2 per s and transpires 5 mmol H2O per m2 per s. Leaf B, with fewer stomata under the same light and temperature, assimilates 16 umol CO2 per m2 per s while transpiring 3 mmol H2O per m2 per s. Assume both rates stay constant.

1. *Efficiency.* Leaf A: 20 / 5 = 4.0 umol CO2 per mmol H2O. Leaf B: 16 / 3 = 5.3 umol CO2 per mmol H2O.
2. *Read it as molecules.* A mmol is 1,000 umol, so 4.0 umol per mmol means 4 carbon dioxide for every 1,000 water molecules: one for every 1,000 / 4 = 250. Leaf B pays 1,000 / 5.33, about 190.
3. *Compare.* Leaf B gains 16 / 20 = 0.8 of A’s carbon, 20% less. It loses 3 / 5 = 0.6 of A’s water, 40% less. Its efficiency is 5.33 / 4.0 = 1.33 times A’s.

**Predict.** Leaf B’s water loss fell twice as far as its carbon gain. The pores set how fast gas moves; the gaps set the price. So how can fewer pores lower the price?

> **Check your prediction.** Through a gap. With fewer open pores, carbon dioxide arrives more slowly while the cells go on fixing it, so its concentration inside the leaf falls and the carbon dioxide gap widens, propping up carbon gain while water loss falls with conductance. One caution for a real leaf: with less water evaporating it can run warmer, depending on sun and wind, which would widen the water gap and give back part of the saving.

Neither leaf is better everywhere: when water is scarce, leaf B keeps more of it per unit of carbon gained; when water is plentiful and carbon limits growth, leaf A gains more.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Water for carbon: two leaves

Leaf B was made up. Can a real crop be built with fewer pores without paying in grain? The second film follows the experiment.

**Film transcript: Fewer Pores**

### Film transcript: Fewer Pores

If you remove most of a barley leaf's pores, does the plant go hungry? Or can it save water and still fill its grain? On paper, a leaf with fewer pores can pay less water for its carbon. A real experiment tested what fewer pores do to a crop. Julie Gray's team, with Hughes as first author, worked in barley. They made plants overexpress a barley gene, HvEPF1. That means making extra of the gene's product. This gene limits leaf cells from entering stomatal development and moving through it. So extra product should mean fewer stomata. They compared these plants with empty-vector controls. Leaf surface impressions told the story. Two engineered lines kept only about a quarter and an eighth of the controls' stomata.

Why the controls, and why two lines? The procedure itself might change a leaf. And the inserted gene lands somewhere in the genome. Two independent lines make a landing-spot effect less likely. Next, a leaf was clamped in a small chamber that measures gas exchange. In well-watered plants, leaves with fewer stomata exchanged much less gas with the air. Gas exchange fell steeply. So what happened to the carbon taken in, and to the grain? Did they fall just as steeply?

In general, if fewer pores slow gas flow while photosynthesis continues, carbon dioxide inside the leaf falls. Its gap widens, and that props up carbon gain. So a leaf can save more water than it loses carbon. In this study, one efficiency measure rose in both lines under water restriction. The measures did not all agree. the grain? In a greenhouse trial, neither line showed a statistically significant drop in yield, well watered or water restricted. No drop was detected. But each group held only five plants. A small loss could still hide below what the trial could see. No drop detected is not proof of equal yield. So what kind of answer is this?

It shows how one gene limits stomata, and what fewer stomata do to gas, water and grain. It says nothing about why wild barley evolved its stomatal density. That second question is about lineages and their history, not one plant. Answering it needs different evidence, and it is where the lesson goes next.

From the film

- Barley made to overexpress HvEPF1 formed far fewer stomata: two lines had about a quarter and an eighth of the control density.
- Well-watered plants with fewer stomata exchanged much less gas with the air.
- With fewer pores, a leaf can save more water than it loses carbon, so carbon gained per water lost can rise.
- In a small greenhouse trial, no drop in grain yield was detected, which is not proof that yields were equal.
- The experiment shows how HvEPF1 limits stomata and what fewer stomata do, not why wild barley evolved its stomatal density.

## A test in barley: what the film left out

The second film showed barley that **overexpresses** HvEPF1 (makes extra of its product): far fewer stomata, much less gas exchange, no grain loss detected. It left out three things.

- **Which efficiency.** Leaf A and leaf B used assimilation divided by transpiration; the study’s measures, and where they disagreed, are in Going deeper.
- **A drought test.** In a separate test where water was withheld, the engineered lines kept photosystem II, part of the light-capturing machinery, working about four days longer than controls.
- **Not the field.** None of these tests was run in a field.

## Why structure fits function, and why never perfectly

Structures usually fit what they do because of history, not intention. Individuals differ, some differences are inherited, and some inherited differences change how many offspring an individual leaves; over generations, those variants can become more common. That process is **natural selection**, and a heritable trait it shaped because it helped survival and reproduction is an **adaptation**. A trait can also be useful now without having been selected for that use; such a co-opted trait is sometimes called an **exaptation**.

So an evolutionary claim about stomata has this shape: “in dry places, barley lineages with fewer stomata lost less water and left more descendants.” The shorthand “barley has fewer stomata to save water” skips that history and can read as if the plant had a goal.

**Predict.** Suppose a single barley plant whose soil dries out makes fewer stomata on its new leaves. Is that plant evolving?

> **Check your prediction.** No. One plant changing its leaves within its own lifetime is a developmental response, a proximate question for the last section; populations evolve across generations. Testing an evolutionary claim is the subject of [testing evolutionary explanations](https://stemhop.com/lessons/testing-evolutionary-explanations/) and [selection in ecological context](https://stemhop.com/lessons/selection-in-ecological-context/).

The fit is never perfect, for at least three reasons.

**Trade-offs.** A **trade-off** is a link between two traits such that improving one worsens the other. More stomata raise a leaf’s capacity to take in carbon and also to lose water, though actual rates depend on stomatal size, how wide the pores open and the conditions. Water loss is not only a cost: the flow of water through the plant helps carry minerals up from the roots and cools the leaf. Lifetime trade-offs, such as reproducing early against growing larger, appear in [life histories](https://stemhop.com/lessons/life-histories/).

**History.** The human arm, the bat wing and the whale flipper share one pattern: an upper arm bone, two forearm bones, wrist bones and digits. They are **homologous**, inherited from a common ancestor and modified in each lineage ([reading phylogenetic trees](https://stemhop.com/lessons/reading-phylogenetic-trees/)). Selection on a whale’s ancestors could reshape those bones, but it began from them. Evolution does not move a population toward a preconceived ideal.

**Chance and by-products.** Not all evolutionary change is adaptive. Some traits spread by chance, especially in small populations, and some are by-products of other features, not selected for themselves. Gould and Lewontin called such by-products spandrels, after the leftover spaces between a Venetian cathedral’s arches, later decorated but not built for decoration.

So “perfectly adapted” is never the right phrase. No living organism is “more evolved” than another, either: a honeybee and a human have both had the same length of time since their common ancestor, and each lineage has its own solutions to the same five problems.

## How questions and why questions

“Why does a barley leaf have the stomatal density it has?” can mean two different things. In 1961 Ernst Mayr distinguished **proximate** causes, which act within an organism’s lifetime, from **ultimate** causes, which lie in the lineage’s evolutionary history. “Ultimate” does not mean purpose: an ultimate answer is a history of what happened to a lineage, such as which variants left more descendants. In 1963 Niko Tinbergen set out four questions, and biologists now usually group them two to each kind:

| Kind | Question | Barley stomata |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Proximate | Mechanism: how does it work now? | How guard cells open and close the pore |
| Proximate | Development: how does it form? | How genes such as HvEPF1 set how many stomata a leaf makes |
| Ultimate | Adaptive significance: what effect on survival and reproduction? | Whether density changes reproductive success in a given field environment |
| Ultimate | History: how did it change over the lineage? | How stomatal density changed across grasses on a tree |

The barley experiment answers proximate questions in engineered lines: the development row, and what fewer stomata do to gas exchange, water use and grain. It does not test how guard cells open and close. A full account needs both kinds of answer.

### Design problem

Guppies (Poecilia reticulata) in Trinidad streams live with many predators below some waterfalls and few above them. Reznick, Shaw, Rodd and Shaw (Science, 1997) reported on fish moved from high-predation sites into low-predation streams above waterfalls. At one site, El Cedro, males from the introduced population matured later than males from the source population within about four years. How would you show that this difference is inherited rather than a direct effect of food or water, and is that a proximate or an ultimate question?

> **One way to do it.** Collect fish from the introduced population and, at the same time, from the source population as a control, and rear their descendants side by side in one laboratory environment (a common-environment, or common-garden, design), with the same food, temperature and density, for at least two generations; the study used second-generation laboratory fish. Two generations dilute effects passed on through the mother’s condition. In that assay the adjusted mean male maturation ages were 60.6 days for source fish and 72.7 days for introduced fish; measured female traits had not changed significantly at four years (by 7.5 years females were larger at first birth and tended to be older, a difference that fell just short of significance).
>
> *Figure (AI-generated illustration).* If introduced-population males still mature later after two generations side by side in one laboratory environment, the difference is likely inherited. Image: guppies from a stream pool below a waterfall with predators are moved to a stream above the waterfall with fewer predators. In the laboratory, descendants of the source fish and the introduced fish are kept in two identical tanks under the same conditions for a second generation.
>
> An inherited, probably genetic, basis still does not show what caused the change. Moving fish above a waterfall may change density and food as well as predation, so to link the change to predation, compare several high- and low-predation streams and measure density and food at each.
>
> Why later maturation spread where predators are few is an ultimate question, about adaptive significance and history; how a guppy’s body times its maturation is a separate, proximate one.

## Going deeper

### Reproduction without every individual reproducing

In many **eusocial** species (animals that live in colonies with a division of reproductive labour) the workers reproduce little or not at all. A worker that does not reproduce still passes on copies of its genes indirectly, by helping raise close relatives.

### The barley test: lines, watering levels and efficiency measures

In the mature sixth leaf, the two lines kept about 24% and 12% of the control stomatal density. In making them, the team inserted the barley gene HvEPF1 behind a promoter, a DNA switch, that keeps it turned on.

In a greenhouse, plants were grown at 60% or 25% on the authors’ calibrated soil-water scale. Under water restriction, carbon assimilation and stomatal conductance did not differ significantly from controls. Water-use efficiency integrated over the life of the flag leaf (the uppermost leaf, just below the grain head), estimated from carbon isotopes in the leaf, rose in both lines under water restriction and in one line when well watered. The intrinsic efficiency measure from gas exchange, assimilation divided by stomatal conductance, rose in one line when well watered but in neither line under water restriction; the measures are not interchangeable.

### What the gap rule leaves out

The two flow equations hold at steady state when the pores are the main resistance: the still layer of air over the leaf (its boundary layer) is thin, water lost through the waxy layer is small, and the air inside the leaf is treated as saturated. Otherwise the boundary layer, the waxy layer, leaf temperature and photosynthesis itself also shift the ratio; in saturated air the water gap, and the price, fall to about zero, and with the stomata shut both flows fall toward zero.

### Worked problem: a 10-hour day

Over a 10-hour day (36,000 s), Leaf A loses 5 mmol x 36,000 = 180,000 mmol = 180 mol H2O per m2, or 180 x 18 g per mol = 3,240 g, about 3.24 kg. Leaf B loses 3 x 36,000 = 108 mol, or 1,944 g, about 1.94 kg.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/organism-problems/
