# Organelles as a System

> A eukaryotic cell sends a protein out along a route of parts, and each part can only work on what the part before it hands over. For insulin, a messenger RNA copy of the gene leaves the nucleus; the protein is built at a ribosome on the rough ER, carried by vesicle to the Golgi apparatus, packed, and released at the cell membrane, with much of the energy supplied as ATP made by mitochondria. You will follow insulin through a pancreatic beta cell, switch off one cell part at a time in a model, and read real data on where a newly made protein travels and how organelles differ between cells. Afterwards you can name the job of each cell structure, trace a protein from gene to release, and compare prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells.

Course: Biology (Cells). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/organelles-as-a-system/

Builds on: Respiration and ATP · What Am I Made Of?

## What you'll learn

- You will name the job of each cell structure on the Virginia list (cell membrane, cell wall, chloroplasts, cytoplasm, endoplasmic reticulum, Golgi apparatus, lysosome, mitochondria, nucleus, ribosomes and vacuoles) and say whether it is found in plant cells, animal cells or both.
- You will explain how organelles work as a system by tracing a secreted protein's route: a messenger RNA copy of its gene leaves the nucleus, ribosomes on the rough ER build the protein, and vesicles carry it to the Golgi and out through the cell membrane, with mitochondria supplying much of the ATP.
- You will compare prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells, and explain why cells with different jobs contain different numbers and kinds of organelles, such as many mitochondria in muscle cells and many chloroplasts in leaf cells.

**The first film followed insulin from a beta cell’s nucleus to its cell membrane.** First, check three ideas you may bring with you.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Plant cells have chloroplasts instead of mitochondria. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Plant cells have mitochondria too. Chloroplasts capture light energy and store it in sugar. Mitochondria release energy from sugar and store it in ATP, day and night, in leaves, roots and stems. Electron microscope pictures of plant cells show mitochondria, including in root cells that have no chloroplasts. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Plant cells have mitochondria too. Chloroplasts capture light energy and store it in sugar. Mitochondria release energy from sugar and store it in ATP, day and night, in leaves, roots and stems. Electron microscope pictures of plant cells show mitochondria, including in root cells that have no chloroplasts.
2. A cell is like the diagram in my textbook: every part stays in its place. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** A diagram is one frozen picture. In 2017 scientists filmed six kinds of labelled organelles in living cells, taking a picture every 5 seconds. The organelles kept moving and coming into contact with one another. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** A diagram is one frozen picture. In 2017 scientists filmed six kinds of labelled organelles in living cells, taking a picture every 5 seconds. The organelles kept moving and coming into contact with one another.
3. Bacteria have a nucleus, just like our cells. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Bacteria have DNA, but it is not wrapped in a membrane. Electron microscopes show bacterial DNA sitting in an open region of the cell. Bacteria do share some parts with our cells, such as a cell membrane, cytoplasm and ribosomes. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Bacteria have DNA, but it is not wrapped in a membrane. Electron microscopes show bacterial DNA sitting in an open region of the cell. Bacteria do share some parts with our cells, such as a cell membrane, cytoplasm and ribosomes.

> **The one idea.** Each cell part on a route can only work on what the part before it hands over. When a eukaryotic cell (one with a nucleus) sends out a protein such as insulin, a messenger RNA copy of the gene leaves the nucleus first. Then the protein travels: from a ribosome on the rough endoplasmic reticulum (ER), by vesicle (a small bubble of membrane) to the Golgi apparatus, and out when another vesicle fuses with the cell membrane. Many steps use energy, much of it as **ATP** (a small molecule that carries energy cell parts can use) made by mitochondria. So if one step is blocked, the protein cannot reach the stops after it.
>
> *Scope:* the usual route for exported proteins; a few take shortcuts (Going deeper). If a handoff, such as leaving the ER or the Golgi, is blocked, protein already on the route may build up before the block at first. Some may be broken down, and over hours the cell may make less. Blocking the copy or the ribosome instead stops new protein being made. Bacteria, with no nucleus, ER or Golgi, do it differently (below).

## What the first film left out

**Finding the endoplasmic reticulum (ER).** The first stretch of a new insulin chain is an address tag. A helper particle reads the tag and brings the ribosome and its growing chain to a channel in the ER membrane, and the chain grows through it into the ER.

**The cut.** That chain is an insulin precursor, one chain longer than insulin. In the storage vesicles that leave the Golgi, cuts remove a middle stretch, leaving two short chains held together: insulin, stored until needed.

**The trigger.** When blood sugar rises, more sugar enters a beta cell, and its mitochondria break the sugar down and make more ATP ([Respiration and ATP](https://stemhop.com/lessons/respiration-and-atp/) shows how).

**Predict.** ATP pays for work. How else could a beta cell use a rise in its ATP?

> **Check your prediction.** As a signal. The rise sets off a chain of events, passed on by calcium acting as a messenger, that makes more storage vesicles fuse with the cell membrane and release insulin. Beta cells also release a smaller amount between meals.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge nucleusrough ERvesicleGolgi apparatuscell membranemitochondria nucleusblankblankblankblankmitochondria Wo

## Parts on the route, and parts off it

- organelle
- cell membrane
- cell wall
- cytoplasm
- nucleus
- ribosome
- endoplasmic reticulum
- Golgi apparatus
- vesicle
- mitochondria
- chloroplast
- lysosome
- vacuole

An **organelle** is a structure inside a cell that does a particular job; most are wrapped in their own membrane. Of the eleven structures on the Virginia list, five are on insulin’s route (nucleus, ribosome, endoplasmic reticulum (ER), Golgi apparatus, cell membrane). Mitochondria supply much of its energy, and the vesicles travel through the cytoplasm. The other four do other jobs (cell wall, chloroplast, lysosome, vacuole).

| Structure | Main job | Plant cells | Animal cells |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **Cell membrane** | Thin outer layer that controls what enters and leaves the cell | Yes | Yes |
| **Cell wall** | Stiff layer outside the membrane that supports the cell | Yes | No |
| **Chloroplast** | Carries out photosynthesis, storing light energy in sugar | In green cells, such as leaf cells | No |
| **Cytoplasm** | Everything inside the membrane but outside the nucleus; many reactions happen here | Yes | Yes |
| **Nucleus** | Holds most of the cell’s DNA, its instructions | Yes | Yes |
| **Ribosome** | Builds proteins | Yes | Yes |
| **Endoplasmic reticulum (ER)** | Folded membranes; rough ER, dotted with ribosomes, folds new proteins for export or for membranes, and smooth ER makes lipids | Yes | Yes |
| **Golgi apparatus** | Sorts and packs proteins and sends them on | Yes | Yes |
| **Lysosome** | Sac of digestive enzymes that breaks down worn-out cell parts | Usually not; the vacuole does similar digesting | Yes |
| **Mitochondria** | Release energy from sugar and store it in ATP | Yes | Yes |
| **Vacuole** | Sac that stores water and other materials | One large central vacuole that presses on the wall and keeps the cell firm | Small ones, in some cells |

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A typical leaf cell and a typical animal cell share most parts, including mitochondria. The plant cell adds a cell wall, a large central vacuole and, because it is green, chloroplasts. Image: a leaf plant cell and an animal cell side by side. The plant cell has a thick wall, a large central vacuole, green chloroplasts, mitochondria and a nucleus; the animal cell has a thin membrane, a nucleus, mitochondria and small lysosomes.

**Key idea:**

Each cell structure has a job; plant and animal cells share most of them, and plant cells add a cell wall, a large central vacuole and, in green cells, chloroplasts.

## Explore: test the one idea in a model

Switch off any one part of this model beta cell and run the insulin shipment again; a meter shows the ATP supply.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Protein shipping route: switch a cell part off

**Try this.**

1. Run the route with every part on. First predict how many stops the shipment passes (each vesicle counts as a stop). Then count.
2. If the Golgi apparatus is off, where does the shipment get stuck? Predict, then test it.
3. Switch the Golgi back on and the mitochondria off. Predict, then run it.
4. Switch off the lysosomes, which break down worn-out cell parts. Does insulin still leave? What might build up over days?

## A factory model, and where it breaks

In a factory model, the nucleus is the office that keeps blueprints and sends out copies, ribosomes the assembly line, the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and Golgi finishing and shipping, vesicles delivery trucks, and mitochondria the power plant. It breaks in four places.

- No single manager gives orders; signals such as calcium, and chemistry at each step, set what happens.
- Mitochondria do not create energy; they move energy from sugar into ATP.
- A cell’s parts move around and touch one another all the time.
- Real proteins do not travel as one neat shipment.

**Key idea:**

A messenger RNA copy of the gene leaves the nucleus; the protein is built at a ribosome on the rough ER, carried by vesicle to the Golgi and out through the cell membrane, with mitochondria supplying much of the ATP.

How did anyone show that real proteins take this route, in this order? The second film shows the experiment.

**Film transcript: Catching Proteins on the Move**

### Film transcript: Catching Proteins on the Move

How do we know proteins really travel in this order? The first film drew the route, from the rough ER to the Golgi to the cell membrane. But a drawing is not evidence. In 1967, James Jamieson and George Palade found a way to test it. They used thin slices of guinea pig pancreas. The cells they studied make digestive enzymes, not insulin. But they too send proteins out.

Here is the problem. A cell is always making new protein. If every protein carries a mark, the mark is everywhere, and you learn nothing about order. You need to mark just one batch. So they gave the slices a short pulse of a radioactive building block. Only proteins made during those few minutes carried the mark. Then came the chase: plenty of the ordinary building block. Proteins made after that carried no mark. The marked batch was now on its own. They followed the batch in two ways. In one, broken cells were spun in a centrifuge, so their parts settled into layers. In the other, electron microscope pictures showed where radioactive grains sat.

Time for a prediction. The clock reads zero minutes of chase. Right after the pulse, where do you predict most of the marked protein will be? Over the rough ER. At the start of the chase, most grains sat there. That is where ribosomes build new protein. Minutes later, the marked batch had spread out. By seven minutes, Golgi vesicles held almost as many grains as the rough ER. Golgi vesicles are small vesicles at the Golgi's edge. Later still, the mark moved on again. The grains gathered in condensing vacuoles. These are storage granules that are still being formed. At the last time point shown, more than half the grains sat in finished storage granules. These hold the protein until the cell releases it.

Each part's share of the mark peaked in turn. Rough ER, then Golgi vesicles, then condensing vacuoles, then storage granules. The chart shows only four moments of that journey. These were digestive enzyme cells, not beta cells. Still, this experiment gave direct evidence for the order of stops that textbooks still draw. A drawing had become a measurement. So how do we know the order? Mark one batch of new protein, then watch where it goes over time. Each stop's share peaks later than the stop before it.

From the film

- A short pulse of a radioactive building block marks only the proteins made during it.
- Following that marked batch over time shows where it goes in the cell.
- Each part's share of the mark peaked in turn: rough ER, then Golgi vesicles, then condensing vacuoles, then storage granules.
- The marked batch spread out as it moved: by 7 minutes, Golgi vesicles held almost as many grains as the rough ER.
- These cells make digestive enzymes, not insulin, and they gave direct evidence for the order of the stops.

## How a marked batch really moves

The second film’s **chase** times count minutes after a 3-minute pulse ended, and its **condensing vacuoles** are forming storage (zymogen) granules, not the plant vacuole in the table.

**Predict.** The film skipped 17 minutes. Which part held the largest share of grains then: rough endoplasmic reticulum (ER), Golgi vesicles or condensing vacuoles?

> **Check your prediction.** Almost a tie. At 17 minutes the rough ER (37.6%) and the Golgi vesicles (37.5%) held nearly equal shares, with 19.5% over condensing vacuoles. A marked batch moves as a spreading wave, not one parcel. Each part’s own share peaks later than the part before it, but the largest share does not hop neatly from part to part.

Values are the share of counted grains over each part (%); a dash means not quoted here.

| Minutes of chase | Rough ER | Golgi vesicles | Condensing vacuoles | Storage (zymogen) granules |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 0 | 86.3 | — | — | — |
| 7 | 43.7 | 43.0 | — | — |
| 17 | 37.6 | 37.5 | 19.5 | — |
| 37 | — | — | 48.5 | — |
| 57 | — | — | 35.8 | 32.9 |
| 117 | — | — | — | 58.6 |

Source: Jamieson and Palade, Journal of Cell Biology, 1967, paper II, Table II; digestive-enzyme cells, not beta cells. Only some values from the full table are shown, so the rest of each row’s grains were in other parts.

1. At 57 minutes of chase, which two parts held most of the counted grains?
2. The pulse lasted 3 minutes. How many minutes after the pulse began were the grains counted in the 7-minute row?

The model’s mitochondria switch is based on a 1968 follow-up in the same digestive-enzyme cells. Chemicals that blocked the mitochondria’s ATP making stopped proteins moving from the rough ER to the Golgi. That is the one idea at work for this step: the move needs energy, and without it the protein cannot reach the stops after it.

## Same jobs, simpler parts: prokaryotic cells

A **prokaryotic** cell has no nucleus and none of the membrane-bound organelles on this route; bacteria and archaea (another group of single-celled microbes) are prokaryotes. A **eukaryotic** cell has a nucleus and membrane-bound organelles; plants, animals and fungi are eukaryotes.

| Feature | Prokaryotic cell | Eukaryotic cell |
| --- | --- | --- |
| DNA | In an open region with no membrane, the **nucleoid** | Mostly inside a nucleus; mitochondria and chloroplasts hold a little |
| ER, Golgi and mitochondria | None | Yes |
| Cell membrane, cytoplasm, ribosomes | Yes | Yes |
| Cell wall | Often | Plants and fungi, not animals |

A single bacterium still carries out every life process with this simpler set of parts.

**Predict.** A bacterium also sends proteins out, yet it has no endoplasmic reticulum (ER) or Golgi. How do you think it does the job? Hint: think about the membrane, or membranes, around the cell.

> **Check your prediction.** With channels in its membranes. Its ribosomes build the protein in the cytoplasm, and a channel in the cell membrane moves it across. Many bacteria also have a second, outer membrane, which needs another channel or a system that spans both membranes. In bacteria that use oxygen, the cell membrane also makes much of the ATP, the job mitochondria do in your cells. Others make most of theirs in the cytoplasm.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A bacterium keeps its DNA in an open region with no membrane around it and sends proteins out through channels in its membranes; a eukaryotic cell keeps most of its DNA in a nucleus and sends proteins along a route of membrane-bound parts. Not drawn to scale. Image: a small rod-shaped bacterium with loose DNA in an open region and scattered ribosomes beside a larger eukaryotic cell whose DNA sits inside a nucleus, with mitochondria and other organelles.

## Cells built for their work

Cells that need a large, steady supply of ATP made using oxygen often hold more mitochondria. In one study of mouse muscles, mitochondrial content differed nearly tenfold between muscle types. In normal mouse hearts, which beat without rest, mitochondria filled about 30% of muscle cell volume. These are single studies, and disease can change the amount too (Going deeper).

Chloroplasts follow the work too. Inner leaf cells (mesophyll cells) of the small plant *Arabidopsis*, which do most of its photosynthesis, held 121 chloroplasts each on average; root cells underground are not green and have none.

**Predict.** Plants with a change in a nuclear gene called *arc5* had only 13 chloroplasts per leaf cell. Does that mean their leaf cells have only a small fraction of the normal amount of chloroplast?

> **Check your prediction.** Not necessarily: each fully grown *arc5* chloroplast was about six times larger, so the count alone understates how much chloroplast is there. Count the parts, and measure their size too. The gene also shows one organelle depending on another: it sits in the nucleus, yet changes how chloroplasts divide.

| Cells measured | What was measured | Value |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Heart muscle cells, normal mice (3 mice) | Mitochondria, % of cell volume | 30.2 ± 1.1 |
| Arabidopsis leaf mesophyll cells, normal plants | Chloroplasts per cell (average) | 121 |
| Arabidopsis leaf mesophyll cells, arc5 mutant | Chloroplasts per cell (average) | 13 |

Sources: Rajab and colleagues, Scientific Reports, 2022 (six-month-old mice; value is mean ± standard error); Pyke and Leech, Plant Physiology, 1994.

**Key idea:**

Prokaryotes do many of the same jobs without a nucleus or the eukaryotic ER-to-Golgi route, and in eukaryotes the amount of an organelle often reflects the cell’s work.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: how do the parts of a cell work together? Use both tables.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that a new protein moves blank, and that cells blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: Right after the pulse, blank% of the grains were over the blank. Later the label was in blank. Mitochondria filled blank% of normal heart muscle cells.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This shows the parts work as a system because blank, and mitochondria matter because many steps on the route use ATP, so cells with a large, steady need for ATP hold blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Cell parts pass a protein along in order. Right after the pulse, 86.3% of the grains were over the rough ER. By 7 minutes of chase many were over Golgi vesicles, and by 117 minutes 58.6% were in storage granules. Mitochondria filled 30.2% of normal mouse heart muscle cells, and content differed nearly tenfold between mouse muscle types, so cells with different work can hold different amounts. Limits: the pulse-chase used digestive-enzyme cells from guinea pigs, not human beta cells, and each value comes from one study.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Do leaves grown in brighter light have more chloroplasts per cell? Plan an investigation with a light microscope. Name your variables, constants, control, sample size and safety steps.

> **One way to do it.** - **Independent variable:** light level. Grow plants of one species from one seed batch, some in bright and some in dim light.
> - **Dependent variable:** chloroplasts per cell in a thin leaf sample, focusing slowly up and down so no layer is missed.
> - **Constants:** species, plant age, leaf position, watering, temperature, magnification and the counting rule.
> - **Control:** the dim-light plants are the comparison group.
> - **Sample size:** several plants per group, several leaves per plant, at least 20 cells per leaf. Report the mean and the spread.
> - **Fairness:** a partner codes the slides, so the counter does not know the group.
> - **Limit:** chloroplasts can overlap and be missed or counted twice; use one counting rule for every cell.
> - **Safety:** handle slides and cover slips carefully and report broken glass.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Without looking back, explain to a partner where new insulin would first pile up if vesicles could not bud off the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), and why switching off the lysosomes in the model did not stop insulin leaving the cell.

**Science practices you used:** using a model and naming its limits, reading data tables with means and their standard errors, doing a time calculation from data, and planning a fair test with a large enough sample.

## Going deeper

### Two more mitochondria numbers, and a fair test

In the same heart study, mitochondria filled 41.1 ± 2.7% of heart muscle cell volume in GENA348 disease-model mice. That does not show amounts fit a cell’s work; it may be a response to the disease. In 5 normal rats, liver-cell mitochondria made up 18% of the whole liver’s volume (Weibel and colleagues, Journal of Cell Biology, 1969). Why is comparing 30.2% in heart cells with 18% in liver not a fair, matched comparison?

> **One answer.** Two things differ: the species (mice, rats) and the measure (share of one cell type’s volume, share of the whole organ’s volume).

### Shortcuts and other energy carriers

A few exported proteins skip the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and Golgi. And ATP is not the only energy carrier on the route: ribosomes and the machinery that buds vesicles also use a close chemical relative of ATP.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/organelles-as-a-system/
