# One Cell or Many

> Cells fit life's jobs through structure and gene use, alone or together. You will test how one cell and a group of cells handle the same life processes, compare a Paramecium with specialized plant and animal cells, and use real measurements to connect cell form with function. Then you will explain how cells with essentially the same DNA can look and work so differently.

Course: Biology (Cells). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/one-cell-or-many/
Note: parts of this lesson are still being checked ("Under review").

Builds on: Crossing the Membrane · Organelles as a System

## What you'll learn

- You will explain that a unicellular organism carries out every life process in one cell, while a multicellular organism has specialized cells that do particular jobs; in most animals and plants these are organized into tissues, organs and organ systems.
- You will explain how the structure of a specialized cell fits its function (neuron, red blood cell, muscle cell, root hair cell, guard cell), and that nearly all body cells with a nucleus carry essentially the same DNA but use different sets of genes.
- You will use real cell size and shape data to make a claim about how structure relates to function in specialized cells.

**How can one Paramecium do every job of life inside a single cell?** Start by testing where an organism can place those jobs.

**The one idea:**

Cells fit life’s jobs through structure and gene use, alone or together.

**Scope:**

a unicellular organism carries out every life process inside one cell. In most animals and plants, specialized cells share major jobs and build tissues, organs and organ systems. Nearly all body cells with a nucleus carry essentially the same DNA but use different sets of genes.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Single-celled organisms are simple and can’t do much. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Microscope studies show that a Paramecium has cilia for swimming, a groove that takes in food, sacs that digest it and pumps that push out extra water, all in one cell. One cell can be very complex and carry out every life process. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Microscope studies show that a Paramecium has cilia for swimming, a groove that takes in food, sacs that digest it and pumps that push out extra water, all in one cell. One cell can be very complex and carry out every life process.
2. Different cells in your body have different DNA. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Biologists have long known that nearly every body cell with a nucleus carries essentially the same DNA. What differs is which genes each kind of cell uses. A few cells, such as mature red blood cells, are exceptions. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Biologists have long known that nearly every body cell with a nucleus carries essentially the same DNA. What differs is which genes each kind of cell uses. A few cells, such as mature red blood cells, are exceptions.
3. All cells are basically the same shape and size. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Measured cells vary enormously. A human red blood cell is about 7 to 8 micrometres across, while some human nerve cells reach about a metre long. Plant root hair cells grow long tubes. Each shape matches what that cell does. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Measured cells vary enormously. A human red blood cell is about 7 to 8 micrometres across, while some human nerve cells reach about a metre long. Plant root hair cells grow long tubes. Each shape matches what that cell does.

## Explore: share out life’s jobs

In the model you get five life jobs: take in food, move, sense the surroundings, reproduce and remove extra water. You can give every job to one cell, or build a group of cells and give each cell one or two jobs. Each cell has a limited energy supply, and you can make the organism bigger and see which arrangement keeps up.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Division of labour: share out the jobs

**Try this.**

1. Give all five jobs to one small cell. Predict whether it can keep up, then run it.
2. Make that single cell bigger, step by step. Predict what happens to how well it keeps up, then test.
3. Build a group of cells and give each one a single job. Predict whether the group keeps up as it grows, then run it.
4. Remove the cells doing one job, such as taking in food, but do not run the model yet.

**Predict 1.** Can the other cells keep the group growing after every food-taking cell is removed?

> **Check your prediction in the model.** No. Sharing work creates dependence: if no cell does one required job, the other specialists do not replace it.

## Explain: one cell that does it all

- unicellular
- multicellular
- cilia
- contractile vacuole
- binary fission
- specialized cell
- tissue
- organ
- organ system
- gene expression

The first film followed one Paramecium through its four jobs. Here are its terms. A **unicellular** organism is made of one cell, and a **multicellular** organism is made of many. **Cilia** are short hair-like structures that beat together like oars. Food such as bacteria is swept into a groove and digested in food vacuoles. Pond water has fewer dissolved particles than the cell, so water keeps moving in by osmosis (see [Crossing the Membrane](https://stemhop.com/lessons/crossing-the-membrane/)). A **contractile vacuole** is a sac that fills with this extra water and squeezes it out. **Binary fission** is reproducing without a partner: one cell divides into two.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge ciliaoral groovefood vacuolecontractile vacuole ciliablankfood vacuoleblank Word bank: contractile vacuol

**Key idea:**

A unicellular organism carries out every life process inside one cell, using different structures within that cell for different jobs.

## Explain: specialized cells, from tissues to systems

The first film built the levels of organization with a heart. In words: a **specialized cell** is a cell with a structure that suits it to a particular job; a **tissue** is a group of similar cells working together; an **organ** is several tissues working together; an **organ system** is a set of related organs.

> cell → tissue → organ → organ system → organism

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Cell, tissue, organ, organ system, organism: each level is built from the one before it. Image: a strip of five frames: one muscle cell, a patch of muscle tissue, a heart, a torso outline showing the heart and blood vessels, and a whole person.

**Predict 2.** A layer of similar cells covers a plant root, and root hair cells grow from that layer. Which level is the layer, and which level is the whole root?

> **Check your prediction.** The layer of similar cells is a tissue. The whole root is an organ, built from several tissues.

As the first film’s muscle cell showed, **specialized** means especially fitted for a job, not limited to only one job.

Levels say where cells sit, not how they became so different. The second film shows how cells in one body become different while keeping the same DNA.

**Film transcript: Different Cells, Shared DNA**

### Film transcript: Different Cells, Shared DNA

The first film showed how many-celled organisms share life's jobs. How can their cells become different enough to do those jobs? A specialized cell has a structure suited to a particular job. Form is not decoration. It changes what the cell can reach, carry, or move. A neuron grows a long, thin axon. It can carry a signal from the spine to the foot. Its reach fits long-distance signalling. A skeletal muscle cell is a long cylinder packed with fibres that shorten together. A root hair cell grows a thin tube into soil, adding contact where water enters. Structure can affect survival. In Arabidopsis seedlings, lines with longer root hairs stayed anchored better after simulated rain. Their main roots were about the same size.

So root hair length is the likely reason. Now compare two red blood cell cartoons. One is a stiff sphere. The other is a flexible disc dented in the middle. Which passes a narrow vessel? The flexible dented disc bends and squeezes through. A mature red blood cell also has no nucleus. Its small flexible form suits transport through narrow vessels. Different shapes raise a deeper question. Do nerve and muscle cells carry different instructions?

Mostly no. Nearly every body cell with a nucleus carries essentially the same DNA. What differs is gene expression, the use of a gene's instructions to make a product. Each kind of cell uses a different set of genes. Cells fit life's jobs through structure and gene use, alone or together. A muscle cell uses genes for proteins that slide and shorten it. Other genes stay unused. A developing red blood cell uses genes for hemoglobin, the protein that carries oxygen. Later it pushes out its nucleus. Its earlier gene use helped build its specialized contents. This is a main model, not a claim without exceptions. Some immune cells rearrange DNA.

Egg and sperm cells carry one chromosome set, while most body cells carry two. Experiments support the model. A few frog gut-cell nuclei, moved into eggs, still built tadpoles with nerve, muscle, and blood cells. In those nuclei, specializing had not thrown the unused genes away. So cell differences need not mean different instruction books. Different cells use different parts of a shared book, building structures that suit their work.

From the film

- Cells fit life's jobs through structure and gene use, alone or together.
- A specialized cell has a structure suited to a particular job.
- Nearly every body cell with a nucleus carries essentially the same DNA.
- Each kind of cell uses a different set of genes.

The second film left out one plant cell: the guard cell.

**Predict 3.** Guard cells curve around a leaf pore. If they change shape, what can they control?

> **Check your prediction.** They can open or close the pore, controlling gas movement through the leaf surface.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Five specialized cells, each with a shape that fits its job. They are not drawn to the same scale: an axon can reach about a metre, while a red blood cell is about 7 to 8 micrometres across. Image: five specialized cells side by side: a neuron with a very long axon, a dented red blood cell bending into a narrow vessel, a long muscle cell with several nuclei, a root hair cell with a tube reaching into soil, and two guard cells around a leaf pore.

| Cell | Structure | How it fits the job |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Neuron (nerve cell) | Long, thin extension called an axon | Carries signals long distances, such as from the spine to the foot |
| Red blood cell | Small, flexible disc dented in the middle; no nucleus when mature | Large surface for oxygen to cross; bends to squeeze through narrow vessels |
| Skeletal muscle cell | Very long cylinder with many nuclei | Packed with protein fibres that shorten together to pull on bone |
| Root hair cell | Long tube growing out from the root surface | Adds surface touching the soil, where water and minerals enter |
| Guard cell | Two cells, often curved, around a pore in a leaf | Change shape to open and close the pore, letting gases in and out |

**Key idea:**

In most animals and plants, specialized cells with shapes suited to their jobs are organized into tissues, organs and organ systems.

## Explain: same DNA, different genes

As the second film showed, cells with the same DNA differ in **gene expression**: the use of a gene’s instructions to make a product such as a protein. Many genes stay unused in each cell.

The film did not say where the shared copy comes from. It was copied from the first cell you began as. See how that copying works in [The Cell Cycle and Mitosis](https://stemhop.com/lessons/cell-cycle-and-mitosis/), and how genes are read in [From DNA to Protein](https://stemhop.com/lessons/protein-synthesis/). Exceptions besides the mature red blood cell are in Going deeper.

**Key idea:**

Nearly all body cells with a nucleus carry essentially the same DNA, but each kind of cell uses a different set of genes, which gives it its own structure and job.

## Elaborate: measuring specialized cells

Here are published measurements of specialized cells.

| Cell or part measured | Size (with unit) | Structural feature | Where the value comes from |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Human red blood cell | about 7 to 8 µm across | Dented disc; no nucleus when mature | Textbook description |
| Long human axon | up to about 1 m long | Long extension of a nerve cell | Textbook description, spine-to-toe example |
| Human oocyte (developing egg cell) | 115 ± 12.1 µm across (mean ± standard deviation) | Large round cell | 1,563 immature oocytes from 75 patients, measured after an attempt to mature them in the lab; not all matured |
| Human sperm head | 4.96 µm long (mean) | Head measured on its own | 10 fertile men, live cells |
| Human sperm tail | 38.22 µm long (mean) | Tail measured on its own; the short midpiece between head and tail was measured separately | Same 10 men |
| Human skeletal muscle cell | up to about 30 cm long | Long cylinder, many nuclei | Textbook, a long thigh muscle |
| Arabidopsis root hair, young seedling | 0.49 ± 0.11 mm long | Tube growing from a root surface cell | Seedlings 3 to 5 days old |
| Arabidopsis root hair, older plant | 0.38 ± 0.19 mm long | Same kind of tube | Plants 10 to 14 days old |
| Arabidopsis root hair | 9.9 ± 2.2 µm wide | Width of the tube | Average of earlier studies |
| Arabidopsis root surface cell body | 146.2 ± 36.1 µm long | The cell the hair grows from | Seedlings 3 to 5 days old, average of earlier studies |

Sources: OpenStax Anatomy and Physiology 2e (2022) for red blood and muscle cells; Alberts and colleagues, Molecular Biology of the Cell (2002) for the axon; Pors and colleagues (2022) for egg cells; Kamieniczna and colleagues (2022) for sperm; Choi and Cho, Scientific Reports (2019), Table 1, for Arabidopsis. The rows come from different studies with different methods, not one survey. One µm (micrometre) is a thousandth of a millimetre.

**Predict 4.** Convert the young root hair length to micrometres. About how many times longer is the hair than it is wide? About how many times wider is the egg cell than a red blood cell?

> **Work it through.** Convert the units first: 0.49 millimetres is 490 micrometres. Then 490 ÷ 9.9 is about 50. This compares pooled means, not one hair.
>
> For the egg, 115 ÷ 7.5 is about 15. Dividing gives how many times wider; subtracting would only give a difference in micrometres.

**Predict 5.** Can you add the sperm head and tail means to get the whole cell’s mean length?

> **Check your prediction.** No. The study measured the parts separately, so head plus tail leaves out the midpiece.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: how does a specialized cell’s structure relate to its job? Use the table.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that specialized cells blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: A young root hair is blank µm long but only blank µm wide, while a red blood cell is about blank µm across.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This shape fits the job because blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Specialized cells have sizes and shapes that fit their jobs. A young Arabidopsis root hair is 0.49 mm, or 490 µm, long but only 9.9 µm wide, so it is about 50 times longer than wide. That long, thin tube adds surface touching the soil, where water enters. A red blood cell is only about 7 to 8 µm across and flexible, so it fits through narrow vessels. Some axons reach about a metre, long enough to carry a signal from the spine to the foot. Limits: the rows come from different studies, and the 50-times figure comes from dividing the mean length by the mean width, not from measuring one hair.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Do radish seedlings grown on drier paper towels grow longer root hairs than seedlings grown on wetter towels? Plan an investigation using a hand lens or a microscope with a scale. Name your variables, constants, control, sample size and safety steps.

> **One way to do it.** - **Independent variable:** how wet the paper towel is. Add a set volume of water per towel, such as 5 mL for drier and 15 mL for wetter.
> - **Dependent variable:** length of root hairs, measured on the same part of each root with a scale in view.
> - **Constants:** seed batch, number of seeds per dish, temperature, light, towel type and the day you measure.
> - **Control:** the dishes given the usual amount of water used for sprouting seeds.
> - **Sample size and trials:** several dishes per group, ten or more seedlings per dish, and at least ten hairs per seedling. Report the mean and the spread.
> - **Fairness:** a partner codes the dishes so the person measuring does not know the group.
> - **Limit:** this tests one plant species at one age.
> - **Safety:** handle slides and cover slips with care, wash hands after handling seeds, and do not eat them.

## Going deeper

### A bridge between one cell and many specialists

Some multicellular organisms have only a few kinds of cells. Volvox, a green alga, lives as a hollow ball of many cells. In Volvox carteri, about 1,000 to 2,000 small cells swim and make food but can no longer divide, while up to 16 large cells are set aside for reproduction. Even with just two kinds of cells, Volvox shows a clear division of labor.

### How many cells and cell types?

A 70-kilogram reference adult man holds about 30 to 36 trillion cells, according to two careful estimates (2016 and 2023); the 2023 model gave about 28 trillion for a reference woman and about 17 trillion for a 10-year-old child. Textbooks often say there are about 200 kinds of cells. A 2022 atlas that sorted cells by the genes they use counted more than 400 types in the tissues it sampled, so the true number depends on how finely you sort.

### Exceptions to the shared-DNA model

Some immune cells cut and rejoin pieces of their DNA as they mature, to build the genes for their antibodies or receptors. A maturing red blood cell pushes out its nucleus and also gets rid of its mitochondria, which hold a little DNA of their own, so a mature one has no DNA left. Egg and sperm cells carry one set of chromosomes, while most body cells carry two.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

A Paramecium survives alone because its one cell holds every structure it needs. Your body shares those jobs among specialized cells whose shapes fit their work, nearly all carrying essentially the same DNA but using different sets of genes. Cells fit life’s jobs through structure and gene use, alone or together.

**Science practices you used:** using a model and naming its limits, reading a data table with means and spread, converting units and comparing sizes, and planning a fair test with enough repeated measurements.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/one-cell-or-many/
