# Nitrogen for Life

> Nitrogen is never used up, but the air's nitrogen gas is locked until bacteria, lightning or factories change it into usable nitrogen, so what a field can grow depends on its usable nitrogen, not on the air. You run a model of a soybean field and a cornfield, read real field data on soybeans with and without root nodules, and follow nitrogen around the cycle and out to the Chesapeake Bay.

Course: Life Science (Matter and energy in ecosystems). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/nitrogen-for-life/

Builds on: Photosynthesis Feeds the World · The Carbon and Water Cycles · Producers, Consumers and Decomposers

## What you'll learn

- You will explain how the nitrogen cycle moves nitrogen from the air, through the soil, into living things and back to the air, and why bacteria, lightning or factories must change nitrogen gas before plants and animals can use it.
- You will explain why plants and animals need nitrogen to build proteins and DNA, how the amount of nitrogen changes which living things an ecosystem holds and how many, and how the nitrogen cycle connects to the carbon and water cycles.
- You will read real field data on soybeans that can and cannot form root nodules and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, about where those plants get their nitrogen.

**The air around you is about 78 percent nitrogen. Yet corn farmers in Virginia usually add nitrogen to their fields, while soybeans next door can often get by with little or none.**

The first film’s answer is a locked gate: nitrogen gas stays locked until something changes it. Here you find the lock and test the answer on a real field.

> **The one idea.** Nitrogen goes around a loop and is never used up, but the loop has a locked gate. Plants cannot use nitrogen gas from the air until it is changed into **usable nitrogen**: nitrogen changed out of the gas into small particles that roots can take in, mostly from soil water. Animals then get their nitrogen by eating plants or other animals. So what a field can grow depends on how much usable nitrogen it has, not on how much nitrogen is in the air.
>
> *Where this holds:* the nitrogen-changing bacteria are the exception, because they are the gate. And usable nitrogen sets growth only where nitrogen runs short; water, light or other nutrients can hold growth back instead.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Plants get their nitrogen straight from the air, since the air is mostly nitrogen. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Air is mostly nitrogen gas, but plants and animals cannot use it in that form. Certain bacteria, some free in soil and some in root bumps, change it into usable nitrogen that roots take up. A plant with no source of usable nitrogen grows poorly, even in open air. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Air is mostly nitrogen gas, but plants and animals cannot use it in that form. Certain bacteria, some free in soil and some in root bumps, change it into usable nitrogen that roots take up. A plant with no source of usable nitrogen grows poorly, even in open air.
2. More fertilizer is always better for plants. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Plants can use only so much. In one 2018 greenhouse test (see Going deeper), a soybean type that cannot form nodules grew larger with more nitrogen up to a point, then grew less at the highest amount. In that test, soybean types with nodules grew about the same at every amount. Extra nitrogen that plants do not take up can wash away in rain. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Plants can use only so much. In one 2018 greenhouse test (see Going deeper), a soybean type that cannot form nodules grew larger with more nitrogen up to a point, then grew less at the highest amount. In that test, soybean types with nodules grew about the same at every amount. Extra nitrogen that plants do not take up can wash away in rain.
3. The nitrogen cycle runs on its own. It has nothing to do with the water and carbon cycles. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Rainwater carries usable nitrogen through soil and into streams. Plants also need sugar from photosynthesis, which is part of the carbon cycle, to build proteins with nitrogen. Scientists track these links in fields and in the Chesapeake Bay. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Rainwater carries usable nitrogen through soil and into streams. Plants also need sugar from photosynthesis, which is part of the carbon cycle, to build proteins with nitrogen. Scientists track these links in fields and in the Chesapeake Bay.

## Explore: grow a soybean field and a cornfield

Turn root bacteria on or off and set the fertilizer and the rain. Bars show plant growth, usable nitrogen in the soil and nitrogen washing into a nearby stream.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Grow a soybean field and a cornfield

**Try this.**

1. Turn the root bacteria on, add no fertilizer and run the season. Then predict what will happen to the soybeans if you turn the bacteria off. Test it.
2. Predict what will happen to the corn if you add a little fertilizer, then a lot. Test both and watch the soil bar.
3. Add a lot of fertilizer and turn the rain up. Predict where the extra nitrogen goes. Then check the stream bar.

## Explain: what the lock is

- usable nitrogen
- nitrogen cycle
- protein
- bacteria
- root nodule
- decomposer
- fertilizer
- biodiversity
- algal bloom

Every **protein** (a large molecule that builds and runs cells) and all DNA contain nitrogen, as the first film showed. A particle of nitrogen gas is two nitrogen atoms stuck together very tightly; that link is the lock. Pulling the atoms apart takes a lot of energy, so every changer needs a big energy source:

- **Lightning** brings huge energy in one flash.
- Factories that make **fertilizer** (material farmers add to soil to supply nutrients such as nitrogen) use a lot of energy.
- **Bacteria** (tiny living things, each made of one cell) that change nitrogen gas need a large energy supply. Those in **root nodules**, small bumps on the roots of beans, peas, soybeans and peanuts, get it as food the plant makes from its sugar. Other nitrogen-changing bacteria get energy in other ways.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Bacteria in soybean root nodules trade usable nitrogen for food made from the plant's sugar; corn has no nodules, so it depends on usable nitrogen already in the soil. Image: a soybean plant pulled from the soil, with small round bumps on its roots. A close-up of one bump shows it packed with rod-shaped bacteria, with an arrow of sugar going in from the root and an arrow of usable nitrogen going out to the plant. A second close-up shows corn roots with no bumps.

**Key idea:**

Living things need nitrogen for proteins and DNA, but nitrogen gas must be changed into usable nitrogen before plants can use it.

## Evidence: do the bumps open the gate?

In Michigan, scientists grew two nearly identical kinds of soybean side by side in one field for three summers. One kind cannot form root nodules. Nobody added fertilizer, so both stood in the same air and soil. Late each summer they cut the plants above the ground, dried them and measured their nitrogen.

**Predict.** The nodules help, but by how much: a little more nitrogen, about twice as much, or ten times as much? Decide, then look at the graph.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* In the same field and the same air, with no fertilizer added, soybeans with root nodules held about twice as much nitrogen as soybeans without nodules (1.9 to 2.4 times), every year from 2006 to 2008. Image: a bar graph drawn by code from the table below: nitrogen held, in kg per hectare, by soybeans with nodules (green) and without (grey outline): 2006, 282 and 150; 2007, 144 and 67.6; 2008, 148 and 61.6.

**How to read the graph.** Each pair of bars is one summer: green for soybeans with nodules, outlined for none. Bar height shows the nitrogen the plants held in one hectare. A **hectare** is 10,000 square meters, about the size of one and a half soccer fields.

**A worked example.** In 2007, plants with nodules held 144 kg of nitrogen per hectare. Plants with no nodules held 67.6 kg. The difference is 144 − 67.6 = 76.4 kg. So the plants with nodules held about twice as much.

1. In each year, which kind of soybean held more nitrogen?
2. In 2008, how many more kilograms of nitrogen per hectare did the plants with nodules hold?
3. Find the mean (average) nitrogen over the three years for plants with nodules: add the three numbers and divide by 3. Do the same for plants with no nodules.

> **See all the numbers.** | Year | Soybean type | Dry plant mass (tonnes per hectare) | Nitrogen in plants above ground (kg per hectare) |
> | --- | --- | --- | --- |
> | 2006 | With nodules | 8.9 | 282 |
> | 2006 | No nodules | 6.6 | 150 |
> | 2007 | With nodules | 5.2 | 144 |
> | 2007 | No nodules | 3.5 | 67.6 |
> | 2008 | With nodules | 4.9 | 148 |
> | 2008 | No nodules | 2.8 | 61.6 |
>
> Source: Snapp, Wilke, Gentry and Zoellner, Agronomy Journal, 2017, field trial at the Kellogg Biological Station, Hickory Corners, Michigan, 2006 to 2008. Each number is an average of several plots that had been farmed in different ways before the test.

Remember the one idea: what a field grows depends on its usable nitrogen, not on the air. The air above one hectare holds about 78,000 tonnes of nitrogen (a tonne is 1,000 kg). Yet the soybeans with nodules held on average only about 0.19 tonnes (191 kg) above the ground. Those with no nodules held about half that, from usable nitrogen already in the soil. Even the plants with nodules took some nitrogen from the soil, so the difference between the bars is not an exact measure of what the bacteria supplied.

- In every year, soybeans with nodules held blank nitrogen than soybeans with no nodules.
- The plants with no nodules still held some nitrogen, which came from blank.
- One reason to be careful with this claim is blank.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: where did the soybeans with nodules get their extra nitrogen? Use the Michigan data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The soybeans with nodules got extra nitrogen from blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: In blank, plants with nodules held blank kg of nitrogen per hectare, but plants with no nodules held only blank.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: Plants cannot use nitrogen gas, but bacteria in blank change it into blank, so blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** The soybeans with nodules got extra nitrogen from the bacteria in their root nodules. In 2007 they held 144 kg of nitrogen per hectare, while plants with no nodules held only 67.6 kg, and no fertilizer was added. Plants cannot use nitrogen gas, but nodule bacteria change it into usable nitrogen. One limit: this is one Michigan station over three years, and the difference is not an exact measure of what the bacteria supplied.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Do root bacteria help pea plants grow in soil with little usable nitrogen? Plan an investigation.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Do pea plants grow more mass when their seeds are coated with root-nodule bacteria?
> - **Independent variable:** seeds coated with a garden inoculant (a powder of root-nodule bacteria sold for peas and beans) or not coated.
> - **Dependent variable:** dry mass of each plant above the soil, in grams, after five weeks. Also count the nodules on each plant’s roots.
> - **Constants:** the same pea variety, pot size, new low-nitrogen mix (such as sand or vermiculite), plant food with every nutrient except nitrogen, water, light and temperature for all pots.
> - **Control:** pots of uncoated seeds.
> - **Repeated trials:** six pots of each kind. Find the mean mass.
> - **Safety:** wear gloves when handling the powder and soil, wash your hands after, and do not eat any seeds or plants.
>
> If coated plants have nodules and more mass, the data support the idea that the bacteria supplied nitrogen.

Where does the soybean’s nitrogen go next? The second film follows one nitrogen atom to find out.

**Film transcript: Around the Loop, and Out of It**

### Film transcript: Around the Loop, and Out of It

Follow one nitrogen atom. Once it is part of a soybean leaf, is it there for good? Or does it keep on moving? In the first film, nitrogen gas stayed locked until a changer opened it. Now follow one atom that a nodule changed. Here is our atom, one half of a grey pair in the air. A nodule changes it into usable nitrogen. The plant builds it into a protein in a leaf. A white-tailed deer wanders over and eats the leaf. The deer digests the leaf's proteins. Our atom becomes part of a protein in the deer's body. Animals get nitrogen by eating plants or other animals. Later, the deer dies in the woods. Is its nitrogen gone for good, or not? Pause and decide.

No, it is not gone. Decomposers go to work. A decomposer is a living thing, such as a fungus or a bacterium, that breaks down dead things and wastes. Decomposers break down the deer's body and its droppings. Our atom returns to the soil as usable nitrogen, one green dot in the soil water. A corn root reaches it and takes it up. Same atom, second plant. The corn builds our atom into a brand new protein in one of its leaves. Later, the corn plant dies.

Decomposers return our atom to the soil as one usable form. In soil with oxygen, other bacteria change it into a second usable form. Then heavy rain soaks the soil, and little oxygen is left. Different bacteria change that second form back into nitrogen gas. Our atom rises into the air again. This loop, from the air, through the soil and living things, and back to the air, is the nitrogen cycle. At every step, our atom changed form. It was never made, and never destroyed. Now a second case. A farmer spreads far more fertilizer than the corn can take up. The pool of green dots fills, and then overflows. Then a heavy rain falls. Water moving over and through the soil carries the extra green dots into a stream.

The stream flows toward the Chesapeake Bay. In the Bay, the extra nitrogen feeds an algal bloom, a fast growth of algae in the water. The water near the surface turns thick and green. So nitrogen goes around the loop, changing form, and is never used up. But water can carry it out of a field, and into the Bay.

From the film

- Nitrogen moves from the air, into the soil, into plants and animals, and back again; this loop is the nitrogen cycle.
- Animals get nitrogen by eating plants or other animals.
- Decomposers break down dead things and wastes and return usable nitrogen to the soil.
- Other soil bacteria change some usable nitrogen back into nitrogen gas in the air, especially in soggy soil with little oxygen.
- Usable nitrogen the plants do not take up can wash into streams and the Chesapeake Bay.

## Explain: never used up, but it can leave

In the nitrogen cycle, nitrogen atoms are never made or destroyed; they only change form. But a field can still lose nitrogen: some washes out in streams, and some goes back into the air as gas.

Usable nitrogen comes in more than one form, as the second film showed. You will learn the name of each form and each step in Biology.

The loop is the **nitrogen cycle**: the movement of nitrogen from the air, through the soil, into living things and back to the air. Label the figure with these steps.

1. Bacteria, lightning and factories change nitrogen gas into usable nitrogen.
2. Plant roots take it up from the soil.
3. Animals get nitrogen by eating plants or other animals.
4. **Decomposers** (fungi and bacteria that break down dead things and wastes) return it to the soil as usable nitrogen.
5. Other soil bacteria change some usable nitrogen back into nitrogen gas in the air, especially in soggy soil with little oxygen.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge nitrogen gaslightningcorndeerroot noduledecomposer blankblankcorndeerblankblank Word bank: decomposer, li

Moving water ties this cycle to the water cycle, as the second film showed. Sugar ties it to the carbon cycle. Plants use sugar from photosynthesis to build proteins with nitrogen, so the two cycles meet inside every leaf. (Review: [The Carbon and Water Cycles](https://stemhop.com/lessons/carbon-and-water-cycles/).)

**Key idea:**

Nitrogen moves from air to soil to living things and back to the air, changing form along the way.

## Explain: too little or too much nitrogen

The amount of usable nitrogen changes what can live in a place. Many ecosystems (places and all the living things in them) have too little, so plants grow less and deer and other animals have less food.

Farms are not the only source of the second film’s **algal bloom** (a fast growth of algae) in the Chesapeake Bay. Rain also washes nitrogen from lawns and other places.

**Predict.** A bloom does not last. The algae die and sink. What could that do to the fish and crabs near the bottom?

> **Check your prediction.** Decomposers break down the dead algae, and as they do, they use up oxygen that fish and crabs need. You will see more in [Big Changes](https://stemhop.com/lessons/eutrophication-and-big-changes/).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Too much nitrogen: rain carries it to the Bay, it feeds an algal bloom, and decomposers breaking down the dead algae use up oxygen that fish and crabs need. Image: three numbered steps. 1, rain washes extra nitrogen from a fertilized field into a stream. 2, the Bay water near the surface is thick with green algae. 3, dead algae sink to the bottom, where decomposers break them down near a fish and a blue crab.

Extra nutrients also change which plants grow. When scientists added nutrients, including nitrogen, to grassland plots around the world, the plants grew thicker, but fewer kinds grew. So adding nutrients can lower **biodiversity**, the variety of living things in an area.

**Key idea:**

Too little nitrogen limits growth, and too much can feed algae or crowd out some plants, so nitrogen shapes which living things an ecosystem holds.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Now answer the hook. Corn needs usable nitrogen in the soil, so farmers often add it. Soybean nodule bacteria change nitrogen gas for the plant, so soybeans often need little or no added nitrogen fertilizer.

**Science practices you used:** asking a testable question, planning a fair test with a control and repeated trials, reading a bar graph and finding a mean, and making a claim with evidence and reasoning.

## Going deeper

### The grassland nutrient experiment

The experiment ran in 40 grasslands on six continents. Fewer kinds of plants grew mostly because the thicker growth left less light near the ground for small plants. Where grazing animals ate enough plants to let light back in, more kinds of plants survived.

### How scientists estimated where the nitrogen came from

A test that tracks two natural forms of nitrogen atoms (isotopes) showed that about 60 to 70 percent of the nitrogen in the soybeans with nodules came from the air through the bacteria. This is an estimate, not an exact measure. It is higher than the simple difference between the bars, because plants with nodules take less nitrogen from the soil than plants without them.

### A greenhouse test of nitrogen dose

Scientists grew a soybean that cannot form nodules in greenhouse pots in 2018. Mean dry mass of the above-ground part per plant was 12.37 g with no added nitrogen, 27.77 g at 50 mg of nitrogen per kg of soil, 47.75 g at 100 mg and 32.40 g at 150 mg. So more fertilizer did not always give a bigger plant.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/nitrogen-for-life/
