# Natural Selection in Action

> Inherited traits that help survival and reproduction become more common over generations. You run a model of birds hunting pale and dark moths on clean and sooty bark, then read real counts of dark peppered moths near Cambridge, England. Afterwards you can explain natural selection, adaptation and artificial selection, and use moth data to support a claim.

Course: Life Science (Change over time). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/natural-selection-in-action/

Builds on: Mutations and Variation · Predicting Traits with Punnett Squares · Adaptations for Survival

## What you'll learn

- You will explain natural selection: individuals in a population vary in inherited traits, those whose inherited traits suit their environment are more likely to survive and reproduce, so those traits become more common over generations. Others die or leave fewer young. Some may move away, which is a different way a population changes.
- You will explain that an adaptation is a structure, function or behaviour that comes from natural selection and helps an organism survive and reproduce. You will also explain that people shift traits by artificial selection, and that natural selection is one cause of evolution, the one that produces adaptations.
- You will read real counts of dark peppered moths over several years and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, about how a change in the environment changed the population.

**The one idea:** Inherited traits that help survival and reproduction become more common over generations.

**Scope:** This is natural selection in a population, in a particular environment. Individuals must vary in inherited traits, and those traits must affect how many offspring they leave. Chance and movement can also change a population.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. A moth can evolve a new colour during its life. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** An adult moth keeps the wing colour it inherited. Scientists count how common each colour is in a population, year after year. What changes is the share of moths of each colour, as some die and others survive and have young. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** An adult moth keeps the wing colour it inherited. Scientists count how common each colour is in a population, year after year. What changes is the share of moths of each colour, as some die and others survive and have young.
2. Moths change their colour on purpose because they need to hide. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Colour is inherited, and a moth cannot choose it. Scientists found that birds removed a larger share of the colour that showed up more on the bark, so the other colour became more common. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Colour is inherited, and a moth cannot choose it. Scientists found that birds removed a larger share of the colour that showed up more on the bark, so the other colour became more common.
3. Natural selection means only the strongest animals survive. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** In peppered moths, colour mattered more than strength. Scientists placed pale and dark model moths on trees and checked which ones birds ate. The model that matched the bark survived better. What counts is which traits suit the environment and help an animal have young. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** In peppered moths, colour mattered more than strength. Scientists placed pale and dark model moths on trees and checked which ones birds ate. The model that matched the bark survived better. What counts is which traits suit the environment and help an animal have young.

## Explore: be the birds that hunt moths

In this model, pale and dark moths rest on bark you choose: dark and sooty, or clean and pale with lichen. Eaten moths have no young, and survivors have young of their own colour. That is a simplification: a real moth gets colour genes from both parents.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Birds and moths: natural selection in a sketch

**Try this.** Start on sooty bark with only a few dark moths and run 30 generations. Then switch to clean bark partway through, the way cleaner air did. The first film showed the direction; the model shows the speed.

**Predict 1.** Make the birds less sharp-eyed. Will the percent of dark moths change faster or slower?

> **Check after you run it.** It changes more slowly. When birds miss more moths of both colours, matching the bark gives a smaller advantage.

## Explain: how natural selection works

- population
- environment
- generation
- trait frequency
- natural selection
- adaptation
- artificial selection
- evolution

The first film named the parts. A **population** is a group of the same kind of living thing in one area, such as the peppered moths in one wood. An **environment** is everything around a living thing, such as bark, air, food and predators. A **generation** is one step from parents to their offspring. **Trait frequency** is how common a trait is in a population, often given as a percent. Here it is the percent of dark moths.

**Natural selection** is the process in which individuals whose inherited traits suit their environment are more likely to survive and reproduce, so those traits become more common over generations. It changes trait frequency in a population, not any one moth. It works on inherited variation that first appears by chance, as you saw in [that lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/mutations-and-variation/).

Some individuals may move away, which changes the population in a different way, called **gene flow**.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge moths vary in colourbirds spot moths that stand outsurvivors reproducethe next generation moths vary in c

You may hear “survival of the fittest.” In biology, fit means well suited to the environment and able to leave offspring. It does not mean strongest. A dark moth on sooty bark is fit because birds miss it more often.

Birds never choose which moths breed; they only find some moths more often. The second film asks what changes when a person does choose.

**Film transcript: Who Selects the Breeders?**

### Film transcript: Who Selects the Breeders?

The first film showed birds and bark sorting inherited moth colours. Can people shift a trait by choosing who reproduces? Keep the parent row, offspring row and changing trait frequency. The population picture still works.

Replace the moths with a row of plants that vary in an inherited trait. Some show the wanted form strongly. Others show it less. Their colours match the first film's map. Each plant keeps its inherited version of the trait. A farmer marks the plants with the wanted trait and saves seeds from those plants. The choice is deliberate. The choice changes who contributes offspring.

Plants without the mark may grow, but their seeds are not used here. If the farmer repeats that choice, what should happen to the wanted inherited trait over generations? Watch the empty offspring rows before they fill. The next row has a larger share of the wanted form. The selected form came from the starting variation. No plant changed its own inherited trait. The population changed because selected plants contributed more offspring to the next generation. Repeat the cycle: inherited variation, chosen breeders, then offspring. Across generations, the wanted trait becomes more common. The trait shifts without any organism choosing to change.

This is artificial selection, when people choose which plants or animals breed. Bring back the moth filter. In natural selection, conditions such as predators affect which inherited traits help organisms reproduce. In artificial selection, people choose the breeders. Both can shift inherited traits across generations.

Neither process changes an organism during life. Both processes can shift a population in a few generations, while big changes usually take many. Inherited variation must be present, or first appear by chance, before selection can sort it. Natural selection also produces adaptations.

An adaptation is a structure, function or behaviour shaped by natural selection that helps survival and reproduction. Its value depends on the environment around the organism. Evolution is change in a population's inherited traits from one generation to the next. Natural selection is one cause of evolution. It is the cause that produces adaptations.

Big changes usually build across many generations. The shared pattern is unequal reproduction followed by inherited change. The important difference is what causes that unequal reproduction. In artificial selection, the cause is a person's choice. People shift inherited traits by choosing which organisms reproduce.

From the film

- People shift inherited traits by choosing which organisms reproduce.
- Natural and artificial selection both shift inherited traits across generations.
- An adaptation is shaped by natural selection, and its value depends on the environment.
- Natural selection is one cause of evolution.

## Explain: adaptations, breeders and evolution

The second film showed **artificial selection**: people choosing which plants or animals breed. Dog breeds, from tiny Chihuahuas to huge Great Danes, all came from breeding one kind of animal. Corn came from a wild grass called teosinte, after farmers kept seeds from the plants they liked best.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* When people repeatedly choose which organisms reproduce, wanted inherited traits become more common over generations. Image: a slim wild teosinte grass with a small seed head on the left and a corn plant with a large ear on the right, joined by three gold arrows with hands choosing kernels beneath them. An inset shows a tiny Chihuahua beside a huge Great Dane.

|  | Natural selection | Artificial selection |
| --- | --- | --- |
| What affects who breeds | Conditions such as predators or weather | People’s choices |
| Example | Dark moths on sooty bark | Dog breeds, corn |
| How fast | Can shift a population in a few generations; big changes take many | Can shift a population in a few generations; big changes take many |

An **adaptation** is a structure, function or behaviour that comes from natural selection and helps an organism survive and reproduce. Its value depends on the environment. Weight lost from hunger is not an adaptation. It comes from one animal’s experience, not from inherited traits shaped over generations.

**Evolution** is a change in the inherited traits of a population from one generation to the next. Natural selection is one cause of evolution, and the one that produces adaptations. If no individuals have traits that suit a changed environment, the population may die out, as you will see in [that lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/extinction-and-survival/). Fossils and DNA give more evidence for evolution, as [that lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/evidence-for-change/) explores.

**Key idea:**

Adaptations come from natural selection, people use the same idea in artificial selection, and natural selection is one cause of evolution.

## Elaborate: read the moth counts

Each year, moths were caught in light traps and the dark ones counted.

| Year | Dark moths (percent of moths caught) |
| --- | --- |
| 2001 | 12 |
| 2002 | 10 |
| 2003 | 6 |
| 2004 | 7 |
| 2005 | 4 |
| 2006 | 2 |
| 2007 | 1 |

Data from Cook, Grant, Saccheri and Mallet (2012), Table 2: wild peppered moths in light-trap samples at Madingley, near Cambridge, England, 2001 to 2007. The authors read these values from a graph by Michael Majerus, so each one is rounded.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* The dark form became less common across the full seven-year record, with a small rise in 2004.

From 2002 to 2007, Majerus released pale and dark moths nearby and checked which ones were gone.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Two ways the Madingley moths were studied: light traps counted each colour form at night, and released moths were checked hours after sunrise to see which ones birds had taken. Image: on the left, at night, pale and dark moths fly toward the lamp of a moth trap, with an inset of caught moths sorted by colour. On the right, in morning light, pale and dark moths rest on a tree's branches and trunk, one resting spot is empty, a bird eats a dark moth, and a person with a clipboard checks the tree.

**Predict 2.** In 2002, 162 of 706 pale moths and 31 of 101 dark moths were eaten or missing. Which colour had the larger share?

> **Check your calculation.** Pale: about 23%. Dark: about 31%, the larger share.

The whole experiment pointed the same way: birds removed a larger share of dark moths than of pale moths.

**Predict 3.** Trace the graph from left to right. Which year breaks the downward trend?

> **Check your reading.** The value rises from 6% to 7% in 2004, then falls again.

**Predict 4.** By how many percentage points did the dark form drop from 2001 to 2007?

> **Check your calculation.** Subtract the endpoint percentages: 12 − 1 = 11 percentage points.

**Predict 5.** What is the mean percent of dark moths across the seven years?

> **Check your calculation.** Add the seven percentages to get 42, then divide by 7. The mean is 6%.

- The percent of dark moths went from blank in 2001 to blank in 2007.
- This happened because birds blank, so blank moths had more young.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Use these data to make a claim that answers the essential question for the Madingley moths: why do some traits become more common over time? End with one limit of the data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that the blank form of the peppered moth became blank common over time.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: In 2001, blank percent of moths caught were dark. By 2007, only blank percent were dark.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: On clean bark, birds spot blank moths more easily, so blank moths survive and pass on their colour to blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** The dark form of the peppered moth became less common at Madingley. In 2001, about 12 percent of moths caught were dark, and by 2007 only about 1 percent were. On clean bark, birds spot dark moths more easily, and in a nearby experiment birds removed a larger share of dark moths. Pale moths survived and passed on their colour. One limit: this is one place over seven years, and the values were read from a graph, so they are rounded.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Plan a classroom model to test this question: does the colour of the background change which paper moths “predators” find first?

> **One way to do it.** Cut 40 paper moths, each about 2 centimetres wide: 20 white and 20 black. The independent variable is the background: a sheet of white paper or a sheet of black paper, each 50 centimetres by 50 centimetres. The dependent variable is how many moths of each colour a classmate picks up.
>
> Keep these the same: moth size and shape, the number of each colour, a picking time of 10 seconds, and a distance of 1 metre to the sheet. The picker looks away while you spread the moths. Run both sheets and compare them. Repeat with five different classmates and find the mean for each colour on each background. If fewer black moths are picked on black paper, and fewer white moths on white paper, background matching makes the paper moths harder to find. Field experiments with birds test whether this helps real moths survive. Safety: use safety scissors, and do not use anything to eat.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Dark moths first appeared as a rare, inherited form. Where pollution killed the lichen and soot darkened the bark, birds were more likely to find pale moths. So dark moths had more young and became common. When the air got cleaner and lichen grew back, birds found dark moths more easily. The pale form became common again in Britain and parts of the United States.

**Science practices you used:** planning a fair test with a comparison and repeated trials, reading a data table and finding a mean, using a model and naming its limits, and making a claim from evidence.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/natural-selection-in-action/
