# Natural Selection and New Species

> Inherited traits spread when their carriers leave more reproducing offspring. How does a drought shift a finch population, and when can separated populations become different species? You test the mechanism in a model, read real beak measurements, and use the evidence to explain natural selection, rates of change and speciation.

Course: Biology (Evolution). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/natural-selection-and-speciation/

Builds on: Variation and Survival · Meiosis and Variation

## What you'll learn

- You will explain natural selection as variation, inheritance and unequal reproductive success acting together: inherited traits spread when their carriers leave more reproducing offspring, and over generations this produces adaptations.
- You will explain how change can be fast (antibiotic resistance, tuskless elephants) or take millions of years, compare gradualism with punctuated equilibrium, and explain why a species that cannot adapt may go extinct.
- You will explain speciation as the formation of new species, often when one species splits into groups that no longer interbreed and produce fertile offspring, or do so only rarely (frequently after geographic isolation), and use beak-depth data to support a claim about selection.

**In 1977 a severe drought struck Daphne Major, a small island in the Galápagos, and most of its medium ground finches died. Researchers had already measured hundreds of the birds. The survivors had deeper beaks on average. Did the drought reshape the birds, or change which birds were left?**

The first film followed that puzzle through one generation. Now read what the measurements can and cannot show.

> **The one idea.** Inherited traits spread when their carriers leave more reproducing offspring.
>
> *Scope:* This is the direction natural selection pushes a trait within a population in a particular environment. Chance and gene flow can also move trait frequencies, and when the environment changes, selection can push in a new direction.

- natural selection
- variation
- inherited trait
- fitness
- adaptation
- mutation
- extinction
- gradualism
- punctuated equilibrium
- species
- speciation
- geographic isolation

## How natural selection changes a population

The first film named the three conditions. **Natural selection** is the process in which individuals with some inherited traits survive and reproduce more than others.

- **Variation:** the differences among individuals in a population, such as in beak depth.
- **Inheritance:** the differences pass to offspring. An **inherited trait** is carried in genes from parent to young.
- **Unequal reproductive success:** the differences change how many reproducing offspring an individual leaves.

**Fitness** is how many offspring an individual leaves that survive to reproduce. The third condition means fitness differs with the trait. Fitness does not mean strength: a strong animal that leaves no young has a fitness of zero.

A **mutation** is a change in DNA and the source of new versions of genes; sexual reproduction shuffles them (see [meiosis and variation](https://stemhop.com/lessons/meiosis-and-variation/)).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Beak depth is the height of the beak at its base. Measuring each banded bird before the drought made beak depth a testable predictor of survival. Image: a medium ground finch held in a hand, with calipers measuring the height of its beak at the base and a band on its leg. An inset compares a shallower and a deeper beak.

An **adaptation** is an inherited trait that helps an organism survive and reproduce in its present environment. On Daphne Major in 1977, a deep beak was an adaptation. Large birds, especially males with large beaks, survived best because they could crack the large, hard seeds left after the drought.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge a spread of beak depthslarge, hard seedsdeep-beaked birds survive and breedthe next generation blanklarge

## Explore: test the model

The model runs the first film’s mechanism for many generations, with inherited beak depth and some variation in the young. You set the seed supply; a histogram shows the whole population each generation. A second tab splits it with a river.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Selection on beak depth, and a river that splits a population

**Try this.**

1. Predict where the mean beak depth will move with only large, hard seeds. Run five generations and check the whole histogram.
2. Switch to small, soft seeds. Predict whether the mean will move back, stay or keep rising, then test it.
3. Set every starting bird to the same beak depth, then test the Predict question below.
4. On the river tab, run both sides for many generations. Watch the gap between the two trait lines and, separately, the chance that a cross gives fertile young.

**Predict.** If every starting bird has the same inherited beak depth, can selection favour one beak depth over another?

> **Check your prediction.** No. The environment may kill birds, but without inherited variation in beak depth, it cannot sort birds by that trait. Mutation may later add new variation.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Survival of the fittest means the strongest animals survive. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** To a biologist, fitness means how many offspring an individual leaves that survive to reproduce. Strength counts only when it leads to more young. A strong animal that leaves no young has a fitness of zero. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** To a biologist, fitness means how many offspring an individual leaves that survive to reproduce. Strength counts only when it leads to more young. A strong animal that leaves no young has a fitness of zero.
2. Animals adapt because they need to. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** No finch grew a deeper beak because it needed one; the survivors already had deeper beaks when measured before the drought. Need does not change an animal’s genes. The population changed because some birds died and others lived and bred. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** No finch grew a deeper beak because it needed one; the survivors already had deeper beaks when measured before the drought. Need does not change an animal’s genes. The population changed because some birds died and others lived and bred.
3. Natural selection makes the new traits a population needs. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** New inherited variation comes from mutation, and sexual reproduction shuffles it into new combinations. Selection only sorts the variation that is already there. If no finch had carried a deeper beak, the drought could not have favoured one. Scientists see this when they track the same measured birds over time. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** New inherited variation comes from mutation, and sexual reproduction shuffles it into new combinations. Selection only sorts the variation that is already there. If no finch had carried a deeper beak, the drought could not have favoured one. Scientists see this when they track the same measured birds over time.

## Read the drought data

The table uses a real classroom sample of 100 medium ground finches. Each beak was measured before the drought. The sample was chosen to hold 50 survivors and 50 nonsurvivors.

| Beak depth before the drought (mm) | Nonsurvivors (number of birds) | Survivors (number of birds) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 7.5 to under 8.0 | 5 | 0 |
| 8.0 to under 8.5 | 8 | 4 |
| 8.5 to under 9.0 | 9 | 9 |
| 9.0 to under 9.5 | 11 | 8 |
| 9.5 to under 10.0 | 8 | 9 |
| 10.0 to under 10.5 | 4 | 10 |
| 10.5 to under 11.0 | 4 | 7 |
| 11.0 to under 11.5 | 1 | 3 |
| Mean beak depth (mm) | 9.11 | 9.67 |

Counts are calculated from HHMI BioInteractive’s “Finches in the Galápagos” dataset, using data from Peter and Rosemary Grant. The birds were measured about 1976 and sorted by survival of the 1977 drought.

**Predict.** In which beak-depth range will survivors first outnumber nonsurvivors?

> **Check the table.** From 9.5 to under 10.0 mm, survivors first outnumber nonsurvivors. They also outnumber them in every larger range shown. The groups still overlap, so no single beak depth guarantees survival.

1. Subtract the two means. How much deeper, on average, were the survivors’ beaks?
2. Describe the overlap. Why would “every deep-beaked bird survived” be wrong?

**Predict.** Can this table tell you what share of all the island’s finches survived?

> **Check your prediction.** No. The sample was built to contain equal groups, so its 50–50 split is not the island’s survival rate. It can compare beak measurements between the two groups.

A separate Open University summary of the Grants’ figures gives a mean beak depth of about 9.2 mm for adults before the drought, about 9.9 mm for survivors that bred, and about 9.7 mm for their young hatched in 1978. Those are different groups from the table, so do not mix the two sets.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question for the Daphne Major finches, using these data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that during the drought, birds with blank beaks were more likely to survive, so the trait became blank in the population.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: Survivors had a mean beak depth of blank mm, compared with blank mm for nonsurvivors, and the 1978 young averaged about blank mm.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: Beak depth varied among birds and is blank, so when deep beaks helped birds crack blank, the next generation had blank beaks on average.

> **Compare with a model answer.** During the 1977 drought, finches with deeper beaks were more likely to survive, and deeper beaks became more common in the next generation. The survivors in the sample had a mean beak depth of 9.67 mm, compared with 9.11 mm for nonsurvivors, and, in a separate Open University summary of other groups, the young hatched in 1978 averaged about 9.7 mm, deeper than the pre-drought adults at about 9.2 mm. Beak depth varied and is strongly inherited, and deep beaks could crack the large, hard seeds that were left. One limit: these are birds from one island in one drought, and body size varied with beak size, so beak depth may not be the only trait that mattered.

Saved in this browser only.

The first film left two things out. Selection makes a population better suited to its environment, but not perfectly suited. And the Grants saw selection on Daphne Major change direction more than once as rainfall and seeds changed. Traits spread through unequal reproduction, but selection is not the only force acting.

## From population change to a species split

For this lesson, a **species** is a group of populations whose members interbreed in nature and produce fertile offspring, while rarely breeding with other groups. This is the **biological species concept**, the definition most biology courses use. It works only for organisms that reproduce sexually, and its edges are fuzzy. Darwin’s finch species on Daphne Major still hybridise now and then, so gene versions can even arrive from another species.

**Speciation** is the formation of new species. It often happens when one species splits into groups that become reproductively isolated: they no longer interbreed and produce fertile offspring in nature, or do so only rarely. A split often begins with **geographic isolation**, when a river, mountain range or canyon separates populations and reduces **gene flow**. Gene flow moves gene versions between populations when individuals, or sex cells such as pollen, arrive and add their genes.

The second film splits one finch population with a river and asks when the two halves count as two species.

**Film transcript: When One Population Becomes Two**

### Film transcript: When One Population Becomes Two

The first film showed inherited beak differences spreading through unequal reproductive success. When does one changing population become two species? Start with one mixed finch population. Its members can meet, breed, and exchange gene versions across the island. Biologists often use interbreeding as the test. A species includes populations whose members interbreed in nature and produce fertile offspring. They rarely breed with other groups. This biological species concept applies to sexual organisms, and its edges can be fuzzy. Now a river divides the habitat.

Birds on opposite sides meet less often, so gene flow falls. The river creates geographic isolation. Has the river already made two species, or has it only started a possible split? Make your prediction. Separation alone is not speciation. On the day the river appears, the birds may still breed if they meet.

Distance describes where the groups are. The species test asks what happens when their members meet and try to reproduce. Across many generations, different mutations may arise on each side. Different conditions may favour different inherited traits. Chance can shift small groups too. The two colour distributions may move apart while reduced gene flow keeps differences from mixing freely. Gene flow moves gene versions between populations when individuals, or sex cells such as pollen, arrive and add their genes. Before the river, that mixing can keep the groups connected. After isolation, less mixing lets differences build more easily.

Reduced gene flow allows divergence; it does not prove that divergence or speciation occurred. or sex cells, can keep the groups connected. It does not prove that divergence or speciation occurred. Within each group, the same selection rule still works.

Inherited traits spread when their carriers leave more reproducing offspring. The environment can make different traits helpful on each side. This can support divergence, but selection does not define the species boundary. Imagine the barrier disappears. If the groups interbreed regularly and exchange genes, the split is incomplete under this concept. If barriers prevent interbreeding, or allow only rare hybrids, the groups count as separate species. That is reproductive isolation. Real boundaries can remain fuzzy. Some named species hybridise occasionally, and the concept does not fit organisms reproducing without sex.

Speciation can also begin without a barrier. The river is one useful model, not a rule that every lineage follows. So a barrier can start a split by reducing gene flow. Mutation, selection, and chance may then make populations diverge. Interbreeding tests whether the split is complete. The same mechanism that changes populations can help separate them across generations.

From the film

- A barrier can start a split; interbreeding tests whether it is complete.
- A barrier reduces gene flow; mutation, selection and chance may then make the groups diverge, but they need not.
- Geographic separation alone does not make two species.
- If barriers prevent interbreeding, or allow only rare hybrids, the groups count as separate species.

## What the simple split leaves out

Real cases are less tidy than the second film’s river. The Kaibab squirrel north of the Grand Canyon looks different from Abert’s squirrels to the south. Yet biologists usually treat it as a subspecies of Abert’s squirrel, so as one species. The split may or may not be finished.

Speciation can also begin fast, and not only by splitting. On Daphne Major, an immigrant male from another finch species bred with a resident medium ground finch. Their hybrid descendants bred only among themselves and stopped breeding with the island’s other finches within three generations. This special case, in which two species give rise to a third, is **hybrid speciation**.

**Key idea:**

A barrier can start a split; interbreeding tests whether it is complete. If barriers prevent interbreeding, or allow only rare hybrids, the groups count as separate species.

## Fast change, slow change and extinction

Natural selection can shift a population within days or over millions of years, depending partly on how fast generations turn over. Bacteria divide often, so an antibiotic can sort a population within days. In one laboratory study, *E. coli* grew resistant to a very high antibiotic dose in about 10 days as mutations arose and spread one after another. Read more in [germs, vaccines and antibiotics](https://stemhop.com/lessons/germs-vaccines-antibiotics/). Large animals can change in decades: ivory poaching in Mozambique favoured female elephants with no tusks.

How fast one population changes is a different question from the two long-term patterns biologists see in the fossil record.

| Pattern | What the change looks like | Picture |
| --- | --- | --- |
| **Gradualism** | Small changes add up steadily over long periods | A ramp |
| **Punctuated equilibrium** | Species stay much the same for most of their history; most change comes in bursts when new species branch, bursts that are fast in geologic time | A staircase |

A geologically short burst can still last thousands of years, so it is not the same as fast change in bacteria or elephants. Both patterns can occur in one lineage at different times.

**Predict.** A fossil lineage changes little for a long interval, then changes during a geologically short branching event. Which pattern fits?

> **Check your prediction.** Punctuated equilibrium fits the staircase-like pattern. “Geologically short” does not mean a few days or even a human lifetime.

**Key idea:**

Selection can change a population within days or over millions of years; gradualism and punctuated equilibrium describe patterns in the fossil record.

A species that cannot adapt to change may suffer **extinction**, the death of every member. Adaptation does not guarantee rescue. A population can become better suited and still shrink to nothing if its environment worsens faster than it changes.

### Design problem

A different island has seed-eating finches that have never been studied. Plan a study that could show whether the next drought selects on beak depth.

**Predict.** Why would a wet year help test whether drought caused the pattern?

> **Check your prediction.** It gives a comparison. If beak depth predicts survival only during the drought, selection by drought conditions becomes a stronger explanation.

> **One way to do it.** Before any drought, band as many birds as you can, a few hundred if possible. Measure each beak depth three times with the same tool, then take the mean. Record body mass too, since big birds tend to have big beaks. Keep the method, measurer and season constant. Handle each bird briefly, release it unharmed, and work under the permits wildlife studies require.
>
> After a drought, record which banded birds are alive. Beak depth is the independent variable and survival the dependent variable. Compare the mean beak depth of survivors and nonsurvivors. Use a wet year as the comparison. Then measure the survivors’ young. A higher mean in them, with young resembling their parents, is evidence that the change was inherited. Equal means in survivors and nonsurvivors would suggest that selection did not favour deeper or shallower beaks.

## Check your thinking

Use the evidence chain: the birds varied before the drought; beak depth was inherited; and birds with deeper beaks were more likely to survive and breed.

**Science practices you used:** planning a fair study with variables and a comparison, reading counts and means, using a model and naming its limits, and making a claim from evidence.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/natural-selection-and-speciation/
