# Mutualism, Parasitism and Coevolution

> An interaction's sign is set by each partner's net of benefit minus cost, so it can shift when conditions or the partner's own evolution push a net across zero. This lesson builds that rule with root fungi, shows how soybean hosts cut the reproduction of rhizobia that stop fixing nitrogen and how fertilized Lotus stops discriminating, separates arms races from fluctuating selection with time-shift assays and pond-sediment records, and ends with rotifer and alga cycles in chemostats as a case of evolution feeding back on population dynamics. Afterwards you can classify an interaction from fitness data, design a time-shift assay, and say what a predator-prey lag does and does not show about evolution.

Course: Ecology and Evolution (Interactions and communities). Level: core university (third year). About 16 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/mutualism-parasitism-coevolution/

Builds on: How to Test an Evolutionary Explanation · Natural Selection in Ecological Context · Predation and Community Effects

## What you'll learn

- Classify interactions by their net effect on each partner (mutualism +,+; commensalism +,0; parasitism +,-) and explain, with mycorrhizae, soybean sanctions and nitrogen-fertilized Lotus, why the sign is an outcome that shifts with conditions.
- Define coevolution as reciprocal evolutionary change, distinguish arms races from fluctuating selection, and explain how time-shift assays, resurrection ecology and genome sequencing test them.
- Explain what the rotifer-alga chemostat experiments showed about eco-evolutionary feedback: when prey could evolve, predator-prey cycles changed, and the work demonstrated prey evolution but not predator evolution. Calculating the phase lag from peak times is in Going deeper.

After the first film’s root fungus, this text covers what it left out: how far the continuum reaches, how a mutualism survives cheaters, and what it takes to show that two species shaped each other.

> **The one idea.** Each partner’s side of an interaction is a net: benefit minus cost, measured against life without the partner. The interaction’s sign is the pair of those nets, so it can change when conditions, or the partner’s own traits, push a net across zero. When each partner evolves in response to the other, the two **coevolve**; pairing partners from different times is one powerful way to test for it.
>
> *Scope:* **fitness** (survival and reproduction) in one environment, compared with the same organism without the partner. The rule is bookkeeping: it says what to measure, not which mechanism produces the benefit or the cost. “Reciprocal” means change in both partners; change in one partner while the other stays fixed is adaptation, not coevolution. Time-shift shapes are predictions of simple models: evidence, not proof. A difference across time shows that something changed. A treatment with one partner held fixed helps tell reciprocal feedback from one-sided adaptation, but showing coevolution still needs heritable change measured in both partners. These limits apply to every time-shift result below.

## Signs are measured nets

Beyond the film’s sketch, the real case is an **arbuscular mycorrhizal fungus**, the most widespread kind of root fungus. Johnson, Graham and Smith (1997) argued that when the plant’s costs exceed its benefits, as can happen when nutrients are plentiful, the fungus might be considered parasitic from the plant’s side. Calling the whole pair parasitism also needs the fungus’s net to stay positive. [Predation](https://stemhop.com/lessons/predation/) shares the parasite’s +,- sign but usually kills the prey outright.

Microbes sit on the continuum too. In early tests, *Escherichia coli* carrying the phage M13, a virus that infects without killing its host, grew faster and reached higher density than uninfected cells. Shapiro, Williams and Turner (2016) read this as a **facultative mutualism**, a helpful partnership the host can live without: a virus, usually filed as a parasite, scored as a partner.

## Keeping a mutualism honest

A **host sanction**, the host cutting the fitness of partners that do not deliver, holds back the film’s non-fixing rhizobia only if the penalty outweighs what they save by skipping the work. The hard part is showing that a sanction exists.

Kiers, Rousseau, West and Denison (2003) tested this in soybean, *Glycine max*, with *Bradyrhizobium japonicum*. Comparing a fixing strain with a non-fixing one would be confounded: two strains differ at many genes, so the plant could be responding to any of them. They kept the strain and removed the service, replacing the nitrogen in the air around roots or single nodules with argon. Rhizobial reproductive success fell by about 50% in nodules that could not fix. Reduced oxygen supply to those nodules was implicated as a possible mechanism, not shown to be the cause.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Kiers and colleagues kept one Bradyrhizobium strain and removed only its service with argon; rhizobia in nodules that could not fix reproduced about half as well. Image: two identical soybean root segments, each with one nodule inside a clear gas chamber; the left chamber is labelled Air and the right, tinted gold, Argon. A zoomed nodule below shows the same rod-shaped bacteria in both cases.

“Sanction” names a measured effect, not a decision: plants that cut the reproduction of rhizobia in non-fixing nodules, by whatever mechanism, leave fewer cheaters in the soil, and that effect is what selection can maintain.

**Predict.** Give a legume plenty of nitrogen fertilizer. Would you expect it to keep sanctioning rhizobia that do not fix?

> **Check your prediction.** Probably not, and in one laboratory study it did not. Fronk and colleagues (2025) grew *Lotus japonicus* with fixing and non-fixing rhizobia. Under nitrogen fertilization the plants no longer discriminated between them, and they reduced their overall investment, making small nodules with fewer rhizobia. With nitrogen in the soil, the rhizobium’s service is worth less to the plant, the sanction on non-fixers is lost and, on this reading, a non-fixer’s net rises relative to a fixer’s.

## When is it coevolution?

Daniel Janzen’s 1980 standard, from his note “When is it coevolution?”, asks for change in one partner, then a response in the other. It is strict because a good fit is easy to explain without coevolution. A fruit may suit a bird because the plant’s lineage evolved in response to other dispersers long ago, or because the bird happened to be able to use a fruit that was already there. Neither history is reciprocal.

In the one idea’s terms, each partner’s traits sit on the other’s balance. Hosts and parasites with short generations, such as bacteria and phages or water fleas and their microparasites, give some of the clearest tests, because they evolve quickly and can impose strong selection on each other. The second film shows how frozen samples from many times are paired and read.

**Film transcript: Reading Evolution Across Time**

### Film transcript: Reading Evolution Across Time

The first film scored each partner's side as a net. When both partners evolve, each resets the other's net. How can you see that? Take a bacterium and a phage, a virus that infects bacteria. Freeze samples of both every two weeks, to revive later.

Now cross them in a time-shift assay. Phages from one time meet hosts from the past, the same time and the future. If neither partner's heritable traits changed, every pairing should give about the same infection rate. A repeatable difference means at least one partner changed. The shape hints at how. First, an arms race. Host resistance and phage infectivity both rise, in repeated rounds. Take one phage from the middle of the series. Test it on past, same-time and future hosts. Which does it infect best?

The past hosts. This phage has never met the resistance that later hosts evolved. Infection falls from past hosts to future ones, and keeps falling as the gap grows. Fluctuating selection works differently. Whichever host type is common gets attacked most. Rare types then gain, and the advantage keeps shifting.

Phages track the common host type, so they tend to do best on hosts of about their own time. As the gap grows, infection rises and falls, with no long-run trend. So read the shape as evidence, not proof. A one-way trend points to escalation. A wave with no long-run trend points to tracking. Evolution can also act within a population cycle.

Picture a chemostat, a vessel with a steady inflow and a matching outflow. Rotifers graze on algae. In classical models, prey rise, predators multiply, prey crash, predators starve. Rotifer peaks trail algal peaks by about a quarter cycle. That delay, as a fraction of the period, is the phase lag. Takehito Yoshida and colleagues started the algae in two ways. A clone is a set of genetically identical cells. One clone cannot evolve by selection among clones.

Several clones can. One clone gave short cycles, close to the quarter lag. Several clones gave long cycles, with rotifer and algal peaks largely out of step. The algae carry their own balance. Defence against grazing costs them in nutrient competition. Many rotifers favour defence. Few rotifers favour fast growth.

These runs showed prey evolution changing population cycles. Predator evolution was not tested. So this is eco-evolutionary feedback, not shown coevolution. Pairing partners from different times reveals change. A trend points to escalation, a wave to tracking. Coevolution also needs heritable change in both partners, checked with controls.

From the film

- A time-shift assay pairs parasites with hosts from the past, the same time and the future; if neither partner's heritable traits changed, every pairing should give about the same infection rate.
- In an arms race, a parasite infects past hosts best and future hosts worst, and the difference grows with the time gap: a one-way trend points to escalation.
- In fluctuating selection, parasites do best on hosts of about their own time, and infection rises and falls as the gap grows: a wave points to tracking. Both shapes are evidence, not proof: coevolution also needs heritable change in both partners.
- In rotifer-alga chemostats, algae able to evolve gave long cycles with predator and prey peaks largely out of step, and defended algae were poorer competitors for nutrients.
- Those runs showed prey evolution changing population cycles, not coevolution: predator evolution was not tested.

## Arms races, cycles and the length of the record

The film’s tracking is usually driven by **negative frequency-dependent selection**, whose arithmetic is in [population genetics](https://stemhop.com/lessons/population-genetics/). Arms races need not run forever: escalation can slow or stop.

**Predict.** A lab samples a phage and its host for 20 weeks. In its time-shift assay, infection falls steadily from past hosts to future ones. Can it conclude that this is an arms race?

> **Check your prediction.** Not yet. Under fluctuating selection, infection rises and falls with the time gap, and a record that covers only one slope of that wave also shows a steady fall. The length needed depends on the cycle, which is rarely known in advance. Long, densely sampled records with many replicate lines are what tell the two apart.

Real systems mix the two: in one bacterium-phage time-shift study most phages fitted frequency-dependent selection and some also showed directional selection (Betts and colleagues, 2014). Sequencing adds a second test, against phage on a host held at one genotype (Paterson and colleagues, 2010). Both are in Going deeper; phage biology is in [bacterial and phage genetics](https://stemhop.com/lessons/bacterial-and-phage-genetics/).

Decaestecker and colleagues (2007) used dormant *Daphnia* eggs and parasite spores from dated layers of pond sediment, a method called **resurrection ecology**. Parasites had adapted to their hosts within a few years, and **virulence**, the harm done to an infected host, increased through the record. In that Daphnia system the result ran against the common claim that parasites evolve toward harmlessness, though it comes from one host and one parasite. Myxoma virus in Australian rabbits is the classic field case: after its release around 1950 its virulence fell to intermediate levels, not to zero.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Pond sediment keeps dated layers of dormant Daphnia eggs and parasite spores, so hosts and parasites from different years can be revived and tested against each other. Image: cross-section of a pond with a water flea above and four layers of mud below, each holding dormant egg cases and tiny parasite spores, older layers lower down. A three-step inset shows an egg lifted out, hatched in a dish, and spores added.

## Rotifers and algae: evolution inside a population cycle

The second film’s [chemostat](https://stemhop.com/methods/microcosm-experiments/) runs come from Yoshida, Jones, Ellner, Fussmann and Hairston (2003): the rotifer *Brachionus calyciflorus* grazing the alga *Chlorella vulgaris* under nitrogen limitation, with the algae started as one **clone** or several.

**Predict.** Suppose a one-clone run had also given long cycles with peaks largely out of step. What would that do to the case that prey evolution caused the long cycles?

> **Check your prediction.** It would undercut it. One-clone algae cannot evolve by selection among clones, so the long lag would need another cause, which could act in the multiclonal runs too. A long lag alone does not show that algae evolved; the causal case came from that design contrast and from a measured trade-off: algal clones that resisted grazing were poorer competitors for nutrients.

That trade-off closes a loop. Grazing favours defended clones; as they spread, edible food for rotifers falls; rotifers decline; with grazing relaxed, faster-growing undefended clones regain ground, and the cycle repeats. The loop is **eco-evolutionary feedback**: evolution changes population numbers, and the numbers change selection. It rests on the same kind of trade-off you met in [competition](https://stemhop.com/lessons/competition/), and the general case is in [selection in an ecological context](https://stemhop.com/lessons/selection-in-ecological-context/).

### Design problem

You have frozen samples of a bacterium and its phage taken every two weeks for 20 weeks. Design a test that separates an arms race from fluctuating selection.

> **One way to do it.** Revive hosts and phage from all 11 time points (weeks 0, 2, 4 up to 20). For each phage time point, challenge hosts from the past, the same time and the future, for example phage from week 10 against hosts from weeks 4, 10 and 16. Measure infection as the proportion of host colonies a phage lyses, with several colonies per host-phage pairing.
>
> Predictions. Add the hosts’ side to the second film’s two shapes: under an arms race, hosts resist past phage best. Under fluctuating selection, infection shows a peak or a dip at or near contemporary hosts, depending on which partner is ahead.
>
> Controls. Run several replicate lines, since one line could follow either path by chance. Sample long and densely enough to catch a reversal. Add Paterson’s constant-host treatment, phage evolving on a host held at one genotype, to help tell reciprocal change from phage-only adaptation. To claim coevolution, also show heritable change in both hosts and phage.

## Going deeper

### Worked problem: reading a phase lag from peak times

In classical models predator peaks trail prey peaks by about a quarter of a cycle, as the second film showed.

**Worked problem.** Here is an invented data set. Assume the cycles are regular, the period does not change during the run, and each predator peak is matched with the prey peak just before it. (In the real experiment the treatments did not share a period; here they do, to keep the arithmetic clean.)

- Run A: prey peak on days 10, 40 and 70; rotifers peak on days 17.5, 47.5 and 77.5.
- Run B: prey peak on the same days; rotifers peak on days 25, 55 and 85.

1. *Period.* 40 - 10 = 30 days, and 70 - 40 = 30 days. The period is 30 days.
2. *Lag in run A.* 17.5 - 10 = 7.5 days, so 7.5 / 30 = 0.25 cycle. That is the classical quarter lag.
3. *Lag in run B.* 25 - 10 = 15 days, so 15 / 30 = 0.50 cycle. Predator peaks sit at prey troughs: **antiphase**, the far end of “largely out of step”.

> **phase lag (cycles) = delay between peaks (days) / period (days)**

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Phase lag — read it from the peaks

1. *Compare.* The real single-clone runs came close to it, with a mean lag of 0.32 cycle (range 0.26 to 0.36). Run B’s 0.50 is antiphase, near the long multiclonal cycles, whose mean lag was 0.56 cycle (range 0.41 to 0.68). Run B resembles the evolving-prey runs.

### Commensalism as a stable outcome

A commensal zero is a net, so small costs and benefits can cancel. Mathis and Bronstein’s 2020 review argued that commensalism can persist as a stable outcome rather than a waystation to something else.

### Other root fungi

Ectomycorrhizal fungi on many forest trees mainly supply nitrogen rather than phosphorus.

### The phage that stopped helping

Shapiro, Williams and Turner (2016) followed the M13 partnership through [experimental evolution](https://stemhop.com/methods/experimental-evolution/). After evolution in treatments that allowed both vertical and horizontal spread, the phage no longer helped the ancestral strain, even though the infected bacteria evolving alongside it grew fastest.

### Scope of the soybean result

The roughly 50% fall in rhizobial reproduction belongs to soybean in that study, not to every legume.

### Time-shift and sequencing details

The time-shift study of Betts, Kaltz and Hochberg (2014) used *Pseudomonas aeruginosa* PAO1 and six lytic phages (phages that burst the cells they infect), and five of the six gave patterns consistent with frequency-dependent selection, while two of the six also showed directional selection. Paterson and colleagues (2010) let the phage phi2 evolve with *Pseudomonas fluorescens* SBW25 or with a host held at a constant genotype. Sequencing showed faster phage molecular evolution, and more divergence between replicate populations, when the host coevolved. Both results apply to those laboratory populations and say nothing about phage therapy.

### The worm, probiotic and phage-therapy bridge

For human health, these laboratory and field systems show mechanisms, not treatments. Pathogen variants that escape host defences, such as those in [Toll-like receptor signalling](https://stemhop.com/lessons/tlr-and-nf-kb/) and [antigen receptors](https://stemhop.com/lessons/antigen-receptors-and-checkpoints/), can leave more descendants, which puts those defences under reciprocal selection. Experiments in the nematode *Caenorhabditis elegans* (Rafaluk-Mohr and colleagues, 2018) found that a mildly parasitic gut bacterium, newly paired with the worm, coevolved with its host toward a protective, mutually beneficial partnership when a pathogen was present. That is a worm result, not evidence for any human probiotic or phage therapy.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/mutualism-parasitism-coevolution/
