# Mutations and Variation

> Genes and environments shape variation; chance mutations add new genetic differences. A mutation's effect depends on the change and often on its environment. You run a model beetle population, work with height reference data for 12-year-olds, and compare real mutations. Afterwards you can explain which mutations animals can pass to offspring and why mutation does not mean bad news.

Course: Life Science (Change over time). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/mutations-and-variation/

Builds on: DNA: The Code of Life · Reproduction and Meiosis · Inherited or Acquired?

## What you'll learn

- You will explain that members of a population share the same basic features but vary in many traits, and that many traits depend on both inheritance and the environment.
- You will explain that a mutation is a change in the DNA sequence that can change a protein and can help, harm or have no effect. You will explain that copying mistakes, radiation or chemicals can cause mutations, and that in animals, only mutations in sex cells, not body cells, can pass to offspring.
- You will read real data on how height varies among 12-year-olds and a table of real mutations and their effects, and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, that new genetic variation arises by chance and may or may not help survival.

A **trait** is a feature such as colour, shape or height. A **population** is a group of the same kind of living thing in one area. **Variation** means differences among its members. Your class is like the oak leaves: everyone has two hands and one nose, yet heights and hair differ.

**The one idea:** Genes and environments shape variation; chance mutations add new genetic differences. A mutation’s effect depends on the change and often on its environment.

**Scope:** This rule describes variation within a population. Not every difference is inherited or visible. The effect can also depend on the living thing that carries the mutation. “Chance” means a mutation does not happen because a living thing needs its effect. The body-cell and sex-cell rule is for animals that reproduce with eggs and sperm.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Mutations are always harmful. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** A mutation can help, harm or make no difference. Scientists have found DNA changes that let some adults keep digesting milk sugar, and others that let bacteria grow with an antibiotic. They compare DNA with traits in many people and test bacteria in the lab. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** A mutation can help, harm or make no difference. Scientists have found DNA changes that let some adults keep digesting milk sugar, and others that let bacteria grow with an antibiotic. They compare DNA with traits in many people and test bacteria in the lab.
2. Any mutation in my body will be passed to my children. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Only changes in sex cells, the eggs and sperm, can reach a child. Scientists have found mutated patches of skin cells in people without skin cancer, more often in sun-exposed skin. Those changes stay in the skin and are not inherited. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Only changes in sex cells, the eggs and sperm, can reach a child. Scientists have found mutated patches of skin cells in people without skin cancer, more often in sun-exposed skin. Those changes stay in the skin and are not inherited.
3. Living things grow the variations they need, like a thicker coat when it gets cold. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Some mammals change their coat with the seasons, but that is their existing genes responding to the season. New genetic variations arise by chance, not because they are needed. In a 1943 experiment, bacteria that could resist a virus were already there before the virus was added. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Some mammals change their coat with the seasons, but that is their existing genes responding to the season. New genetic variations arise by chance, not because they are needed. In a 1943 experiment, bacteria that could resist a virus were already there before the virus was added.

## Explore: test where a new difference goes

In this model, 30 beetles vary in body colour and size. You set how often mutations happen (high stands for more radiation or chemicals). You also choose whether they happen in a body cell or a sex cell. Then press “Next generation” and watch the colour counts.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Beetle variation: new colours by chance

**Predict 1.** With the mutation rate at medium, will a new colour first appear in the same place every run?

> **Test your prediction.** Run the model three times and record the first new colour. Runs can differ because the model places mutations by chance.

Next, predict what a body-cell mutation does at the next generation, then try a sex-cell mutation and watch the bar graph. Last, change the background and predict whether a helpful colour stays helpful; check the tags.

## Two sources shape many traits

- trait
- population
- variation
- mutation
- body cells
- sex cells
- random

The first film named the two routes. **Inherited variation** comes from alleles passed from parents and reshuffled when sex cells form and join ([Reproduction and Meiosis](https://stemhop.com/lessons/reproduction-and-meiosis/)). **Environmental variation** comes from different conditions and experiences as an organism grows and lives. Height uses both: many genes, plus childhood food and health. You can sort traits by route in [Inherited or Acquired?](https://stemhop.com/lessons/inherited-or-acquired/).

The oak leaves add a source the first film left out: chance during growth.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Ten leaves from one white oak share one tree's genes and rounded lobes, yet vary because each leaf grew in a slightly different spot and by chance during growth. Image: ten white oak leaves from one tree in a row above a ruler, all with rounded lobes but each a slightly different length and shape. An inset shows one leaf measured from where the flat part meets the stalk to the tip.

## Mutation adds a new genetic difference

A **mutation** is a change in the DNA sequence, the order of the bases. Reshuffling mixes alleles the parents already have. A mutation can make a new allele. Recall from [DNA: The Code of Life](https://stemhop.com/lessons/dna-the-code-of-life/) that many genes carry the code for a protein. So a mutation can change that protein or how much of it a cell makes. Sometimes the protein works the same as before.

Causes include copying mistakes before a cell divides, radiation such as ultraviolet light from the Sun, and some chemicals.

Mutations are **random**: they happen by chance, not because a living thing needs their effect.

## In animals, location controls inheritance

As the first film showed, in people and other animals a body-cell mutation stays in that one body, but a sex-cell mutation can be passed to offspring. **Body cells** are all the cells of the body except eggs, sperm and the cells that make them, such as skin, muscle and bone cells. **Sex cells** are eggs and sperm. Bacteria and plants use other routes (see Going deeper).

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge skin cell with a mutationthe mutation stays in the parentsex cell with a different mutationthe child carr

**Follow the route:**

In animals that reproduce with eggs and sperm, a body-cell mutation stays in that body. A mutation in a sex cell can reach offspring.

Where a mutation goes does not tell us what it does. The second film asks that next.

**Film transcript: When a Mutation Matters**

### Film transcript: When a Mutation Matters

The first film showed how a new genetic difference can begin. How can one mutation help in one setting but not another? Follow its effect. Keep the DNA fixed while the world moves around it. A mutation does not come with a fixed label. Its effect depends on the change, and often on its environment. Start with colour. A label only makes sense beside a measured outcome. Place the beetle on a matching background. It is harder to notice there. Slide the same beetle onto a contrasting background. It becomes easier to notice. The model shows a possible effect, not a promised outcome. The DNA did not change during that move. The environment changed.

A colour that affects survival one way here may act differently there. That separation is the key test. Predict before the next move. If the background changes again, must the beetle's DNA change before the colour's effect changes? Hold your answer. Keep your eyes on the locked gold marker.

No. Keep the mutation fixed and change only the setting. The effect can change because survival and reproduction happen in an environment, not outside one. The same change now meets different conditions. Many mutations change little that matters for survival. Some harm how a protein works. A few can help under particular conditions. These are outcomes, not intentions. A mutation can also change how much protein a cell makes. Bacteria make the same point. One mutation can allow growth with an antibiotic. Yet with different food, which mutant grows best can change. Food and the drug are both parts of the environment. Human examples differ too.

Continued lactase production can help where adults drink milk. A dry-earwax change has no survival effect shown in this lesson's evidence. These cases test different traits under different conditions. Effect and inheritance are separate questions. In animals that reproduce with eggs and sperm, a helpful body-cell mutation still cannot reach offspring. A sex-cell mutation can pass without being helpful. Usefulness cannot open a blocked inheritance route. So do not judge a mutation from its name alone.

Compare the changed trait, the environment, survival, and reproduction. Evidence decides the effect in that setting. Without those comparisons, the label is only a guess. The tables below give that evidence. Use them to separate what changed from the conditions in which scientists tested it. The text also gives limits that this picture cannot carry.

From the film

- A mutation's effect depends on the change and often on its environment.
- A mutation can help, harm or make no difference. Many make little difference, some harm, and a few help.
- A helpful effect in one setting may not be helpful in another.
- Whether a mutation helps does not decide whether it can be inherited.

## Helpful, harmful or neither: test the claim

A mutation is like a misprint in a recipe. Many misprints change little, some spoil the dish, and a few make it better, perhaps only in one kitchen. The comparison stops there: a recipe has a writer, but no one chooses a mutation.

Mutations are the source of new genetic variation. Heredity passes it from parents to offspring, so offspring resemble their parents. That variation may or may not help an individual survive and reproduce. Individuals that happen to carry a helpful variation are more likely to survive and pass it on ([Natural Selection in Action](https://stemhop.com/lessons/natural-selection-in-action/)). Over many generations, natural selection and chance act on that variation, and this helps produce the diversity of life.

**Reminder:**

A mutation can help, harm or make no difference. Its effect depends on the change and often on its environment.

## Read the evidence: height

The table gives reference heights for children just over 12. A 25th-percentile height means about 25 percent of children in the reference were that height or shorter. These are CDC values from U.S. surveys, not seven measured children.

| Percentile | Boys’ height (cm) | Girls’ height (cm) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 5th | 137.3 | 139.2 |
| 10th | 139.9 | 142.0 |
| 25th | 144.3 | 146.5 |
| 50th | 149.3 | 151.5 |
| 75th | 154.4 | 156.4 |
| 90th | 159.0 | 160.8 |
| 95th | 161.9 | 163.5 |

For boys, subtract the 5th-percentile height from the 95th-percentile height:

> 161.9 cm − 137.3 cm = **24.6 cm**

This is how widely the middle 90 percent of boys in the reference spread. It does not explain one child’s height.

**Predict 2.** Is the girls’ 5th-to-95th-percentile spread greater than, less than or equal to 24.6 centimetres?

> **Calculate and check.** 163.5 − 139.2 = **24.3 centimetres**, which is 0.3 centimetres smaller.

**Predict 3.** At the 50th percentile, which reference height is greater, and by how much?

> **Calculate and check.** 151.5 − 149.3 = **2.2 centimetres**, with the girls’ value greater.

## Read the evidence: mutation effects

| DNA change | Living thing | What it does | Effect |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Keeps adults making lactase, a milk-digesting protein | People in East Africa | Adults can digest milk sugar | Helpful where people drink milk |
| Change in one bacterial gene | E. coli bacteria in a lab | Bacteria grow with the antibiotic rifampicin | Helpful to bacteria with the drug |
| Loss of a protein needed for dark colour | Cane toads in captivity, gene-edited | Albino toads competed and fed worse | Harmful |
| Change in one gene | People | Dry earwax instead of wet | No survival effect shown |
| Sun-linked change in skin cells | People | Small patches of mutated skin cells | Body cells only; not inherited |

In the bacteria study, which mutant grew best changed when the food changed. Sources are under Going deeper.

1. Which rows name an environment in which the change is helpful?
2. Which row gives no survival effect shown?
3. Which row shows a mutation that cannot be inherited from those cells?

**Predict 4.** In a made-up class experiment, five dishes have resistant-colony counts of 0, 0, 7, 0 and 1 after an antibiotic is added. Does that uneven pattern fit mutations that arose by chance before the drug? Or does it fit the idea that the drug caused the needed mutations? That would give similar small counts in every dish.

> **Check your prediction.** It fits chance mutations before the drug. An early change can leave many resistant descendants in one dish, while another dish gets none. Real tests use more dishes.

- The heights vary from blank cm to blank cm, which shows blank.
- The blank mutation was helpful because blank, but the blank mutation was harmful because blank.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: why is no living thing exactly like another, and are all mutations bad?

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: Living things vary because blank, and mutations are blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: For boys, height ranged from blank cm at the 5th percentile to blank cm at the 95th. The table shows blank.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This variation matters because blank, and a mutation's effect depends on blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Living things vary because of their genes and their environment, and mutations are not all bad. For 12-year-old boys, height runs from 137.3 cm at the 5th percentile to 161.9 cm at the 95th, a spread of 24.6 cm. The mutation table shows a helpful change (lactase in adults who drink milk), a harmful one (albino toads) and one with no survival effect shown (earwax). A DNA change can alter a protein, and whether that helps depends on the environment, as lactase helps only where people drink milk. A limit: the height values are U.S. reference values from surveys taken decades ago, and five mutations are a tiny sample of all mutations.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Plan a study of how much white oak leaves vary. Do leaves from the sunny side of one tree differ in length from leaves on the shady side?

**Predict 5.** Before collecting data, can you know whether the sunny-side leaves will be longer or shorter?

> **Check your prediction.** No. The environment may affect growth, but measurements must show the direction.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Are oak leaves from the sunny side of a tree longer or shorter than leaves from the shady side?
> - **Independent variable:** the side of the tree, sunny or shady.
> - **Dependent variable:** leaf length in centimetres, measured from where the flat part of the leaf meets the stalk to the tip.
> - **Constants:** one tree, leaves collected on the same day, the same ruler and the same start and end points.
> - **Control:** comparing the two sides of the same tree, so the tree’s genes are the same.
> - **Repeated trials:** pick 20 leaves from low branches on each side, then repeat with a second tree.
> - **Safety:** pick leaves only from branches you can reach from the ground, wash hands afterwards, and never climb the tree.
>
> If one side’s leaves are clearly longer, the environment affects leaf length. The spread within each side shows variation even with the same genes.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Leaves on one oak share nearly the same inherited DNA, so their differences come from growth conditions and chance during growth. Height is shaped by both inheritance and environment. New genetic variation starts with mutations, which arise by chance. Many make little difference, some harm and a few help, and in animals only those in sex cells can reach offspring.

**Science practices you used:** making predictions with a model, reading and comparing data in tables, calculating a difference, planning a fair test with constants and repeated trials, and naming the limits of data.

## Going deeper

### Other inheritance routes

The body-cell and sex-cell rule is for people and other animals that reproduce with eggs and sperm. Some animals can also make young by budding or from a broken-off piece, and then a body-cell change can reach the young. A bacterium can pass a DNA change to descendant cells when it splits. In a plant, a change near a growing tip can reach cells that later make flowers.

### Where the height numbers come from

The heights come from the CDC 2000 growth charts (file statage.csv). The CDC built them mostly from U.S. surveys taken from 1963 to 1994.

### Sources and gene names for the mutation table

Lactase persistence in people in East Africa: Tishkoff and colleagues (2007). A change in the bacterial gene called rpoB in E. coli in a lab: Soley and colleagues (2023). Gene-edited albino cane toads in captivity: Funk and colleagues (2025). A change in the gene called ABCC11 in people: Yoshiura and colleagues (2006). Sun-linked changes in skin cells in people: Jonason and colleagues (1996).

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/mutations-and-variation/
