# Mutation: Where Variation Comes From

> Mutation creates heritable DNA variants; selection changes how common they become. This lesson separates DNA-level changes from protein consequences, uses fluctuation-test and replica-plating evidence to place resistant mutants before selection in the systems tested, and distinguishes mutation rate from mutant frequency. Afterwards you can trace copying errors or unrepaired damage into mutations, classify spontaneous and induced sources, and read an Ames test without claiming more than it shows.

Course: Genetics and Molecular Biology (DNA: copying, changing, repairing). Level: core university (third year). About 20 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/mutation/

Builds on: DNA Replication: Semiconservative Copying and Its Machinery · Probability, Crosses and the Chi-Square Test · DNA Is the Genetic Material

## What you'll learn

- State that mutation supplies the new heritable variation that selection acts on, and describe how replication errors and unrepaired damage, spontaneous or induced, become mutations.
- Classify point mutations by DNA change (transition, transversion, insertion, deletion) and by effect on the protein (silent, missense, nonsense, frameshift, in-frame indel), and explain why a silent change is not always harmless.
- Explain how the Luria and Delbrück fluctuation test and the Lederbergs' replica plating showed that resistant bacteria arose before exposure to the selecting agent.
- Distinguish mutation rate from mutant frequency and estimate a rate per cell division from fluctuation-test data with the zero-class method.
- Interpret an Ames test, including what a positive or negative result cannot show.

**The one idea:**

Mutation creates heritable DNA variants; selection changes how common they become.

**Scope:**

The rule does not say every mutation is equally likely: mutation rates and types can depend on cellular conditions. Selection is not the only sorter; chance (drift) also changes how common variants become, especially in small populations. The experiments below establish the mutation-first order for resistance in the bacteria tested.

## Classify the sequence change, then its consequence

A **mutation** is a heritable change in the DNA sequence. Here, **point mutation** means a change to one base pair or the addition or removal of a few bases. Classify it twice: by the DNA change, then, in a coding sequence, by the protein effect.

**By the DNA change.** A **transition** swaps a purine for a purine (A and G) or a pyrimidine for a pyrimidine (C and T). A **transversion** swaps a purine for a pyrimidine or the reverse. Each base has one transition partner and two transversion partners, so there are 4 possible transitions and 8 possible transversions. Even so, in many organisms studied, transitions are the more common kind. An **insertion** or **deletion** (together, an **indel**) adds or removes bases.

**Predict.** A G:C base pair becomes T:A. Is that a transition or a transversion? Can this alone tell you its protein effect?

> **Check your prediction.** A transversion: G, a purine, is replaced by T, a pyrimidine. Its protein effect depends on whether it lies in a coding sequence and which codon it changes.

**By the protein effect.** Inside a coding sequence:

- A **synonymous** (silent) change gives a codon for the same amino acid.
- A **missense** change gives a different amino acid. Some missense changes leave the protein working; the label does not tell you the severity.
- A **nonsense** change turns an amino-acid codon into a stop codon.
- A **frameshift** is an indel whose length is not a multiple of three, so every codon downstream is read in different groups.
- An **in-frame indel** adds or removes a multiple of three bases. The downstream frame is kept, and the protein gains or loses amino acids.

Think of a sentence written in three-letter words: THE CAT ATE THE RAT. Change one letter and one word changes. Delete one letter and every group after it changes. Delete one whole word and the later groups stay aligned.

**Predict.** A deletion removes exactly three bases from the middle of a coding sequence. Must it shift the reading frame?

> **Check your prediction.** No. Three bases make one codon, so the frame is kept and later codons stay grouped as before. The coding sequence loses one codon’s worth of bases. A deletion aligned with a codon usually removes one amino acid; one that straddles two codons can also change the junction amino acid, and if the junction becomes a stop codon, the protein is cut much shorter.

“Silent” describes the codon, not the consequence. Exons also carry signals for splicing, mRNA stability and translation speed, so a synonymous change can still lower the amount of protein. How the code is read is the subject of [the genetic code lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/genetic-code-and-translation/).

## Does selection cause the mutation? Luria and Delbrück

The first film showed both hypotheses and the test. In numbers: repeated samples of one bulk culture measure sampling and plating error alone; induction predicts a variance close to the mean; mutation first predicts one far larger. Luria (experiments) and Delbrück (theory) used *E. coli* B and phage T1, virus α in their 1943 *Genetics* paper. Independent cultures scattered far beyond sampling error, so they concluded that, in their system, resistance arose independently of the virus.

### From scatter to a mutation rate

Ten independent 0.2 mL cultures and one bulk culture of *E. coli* each grow to about 2 x 108 cells per 0.2 mL. Each independent culture and ten 0.2 mL bulk samples are plated on T1. Assume every mutant survives plating and is counted, mutants grow like the parent, no mutations arise after plating, and divisions roughly equal the final cell number.

Independent cultures: 0, 0, 1, 0, 3, 0, 0, 52, 2, 2. Bulk samples: 4, 8, 6, 3, 9, 5, 7, 6, 8, 4.

1. **Means.** Both sets sum to 60, so both means are 6.0.
2. **Variances.** Sample variances are about 262 for the independent cultures and 4.0 for the bulk samples (arithmetic under Going deeper).
3. **Interpretation.** The bulk variance is close to its mean, as Poisson sampling predicts. The independent variance is about 44 times its mean. Mutation before exposure fits; induction does not.
4. **Rate.** Five of ten cultures have no mutants, so p0 = 0.5. If mutation events per culture follow a Poisson distribution with mean m, then p0 = e−m.

> **m = -ln(p0) = -ln(0.5) = 0.69 mutation events per culture**
>
> **rate = m / divisions = 0.69 / (2 x 108) = 3.5 x 10−9 per cell per division**

**Mutant frequency** is mutant cells divided by all cells; **mutation rate** counts mutation events per division. In the jackpot culture, frequency is 52 / (2 x 108) = 2.6 x 10−7, about 75 times the rate, from what was probably one early event. Confusing them makes one lucky culture look like a mutator, a strain with an elevated mutation rate.

**Predict.** Suppose the jackpot clone gains 100 more resistant descendants, but no new mutation event occurs. Does p0, and therefore this zero-class rate estimate, change?

> **Check your prediction.** No. That culture was already nonempty, so p0 is unchanged. Mutant frequency rises; this rate estimate does not.

Rates do change with a cell’s condition, as in pulses of mutagenesis after alkylation damage in single *E. coli* cells, and debate over stress and mutation continues; none of this reverses the 1943 result for phage resistance.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Fluctuation test: induced or already there?

## Replica plating: seeing the mutants before the test

The [fluctuation test](https://stemhop.com/methods/fluctuation-test/) is an argument from statistics. In 1952 Joshua and Esther Lederberg gave a direct one. They pressed sterile velvet onto a master plate grown without a selecting agent, then printed its colonies in the same positions onto fresh plates with phage or streptomycin.

**Predict.** If resistant cells were already present on the master, what spatial pattern should appear on separate selective prints?

> **Check your prediction.** Resistant colonies should appear at matching positions. Each match points back to the same colony on the unexposed master plate.

That is what the *E. coli* K-12 prints showed. The Lederbergs sampled those master-plate spots, whose cells had never touched the phage or drug, and purified resistant cultures through repeated growth and re-plating. Replica plating also became a workhorse for finding mutants that fail to grow on one medium, the start of many screens like those in [complementation and pathways](https://stemhop.com/lessons/complementation-and-pathways/).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Matching resistant colonies on separate selective prints trace back to cells on the unexposed master plate, so those mutants existed before selection. Image: a master petri dish with colonies, a velvet pad being pressed onto it, and two printed dishes with phage that show resistant colonies at the same positions as two ringed spots on the master, with an inset showing a sample taken from the ringed spot.

Both experiments fit the rule: **mutation creates heritable DNA variants; selection changes how common they become.** The second film follows how a variant begins.

**Film transcript: When Damage Becomes Mutation**

### Film transcript: When Damage Becomes Mutation

The first film separated a variant's origin from selection. Now a DNA strip is damaged; is the cell mutated yet? Follow how that variant begins. The red mark appears before any daughter sequence has formed. A mutation is a heritable change in DNA sequence.

Heritable matters here. A temporary chemical lesion is damage, but it is not automatically a changed sequence. The sequence must change and persist when the cell divides. Changes can begin in two broad ways. Copying can place the wrong block. Or chemistry can damage a block before the next copy. Either route can end without a mutation. Damage enters a fork.

Repair may restore the original block. If repair misses it, copying may preserve the original sequence or produce a different one. The lesion's presence does not choose the outcome. Before the strip reaches that fork, predict: must a red damage mark become a mutation? Trace every possible path before choosing.

No. On one path, repair removes the lesion and restores the blue block. After copying, both daughter strips keep the original sequence. The cell had damage, yet no mutation remains. On another path, copying places a wrong block opposite the lesion. At the next copy, that wrong block templates a full base-pair change. The damaged strand goes to a separate daughter, where repair or bypass can follow. In the changed lineage the lesion is gone, but its consequence persists. Internal chemistry and ordinary copying create spontaneous mutations without an applied mutagen. Outside agents are mutagens when they raise mutation. Both routes end the same way.

A change becomes a mutation only if repair or copying leaves a heritable sequence change. The effect on a protein may range from none to loss of function, and occasionally a changed or gained function. Those consequences come after the inherited sequence change. Only after a heritable variant exists can an environment change its representation. The first film followed that later sorting step with phage resistance.

Selection cannot reach backward and request that earlier change. Damage becomes mutation when repair or copying leaves a heritable sequence change. Repair can erase the damage first. The inherited sequence, not the lesion, is the mutation. A red mark alone never satisfies the definition. The lesson now names the specific sources of these changes. Then the Ames test asks whether a chemical raises mutations in bacteria. Those details belong in the text that follows.

From the film

- Damage becomes mutation when repair or copying leaves a heritable sequence change.
- Repair can restore the original sequence before a change is inherited.
- Spontaneous mutations arise from internal chemistry and ordinary copying; mutagens are outside agents that raise mutation.
- A mutation is the inherited sequence change, not the first chemical lesion.

## Where mutations come from: spontaneous and induced

**Spontaneous** mutations arise from the cell’s own chemistry and copying, with no applied mutagen.

- **Replication errors.** DNA polymerase sometimes inserts the wrong base (see [DNA replication](https://stemhop.com/lessons/dna-replication/)).
- **Deamination.** Cytosine loses its amino group and becomes uracil, which repair enzymes recognize as foreign. 5-Methylcytosine deaminates to thymine, a normal base, so the G:T mismatch is harder to resolve correctly. CpG sites, where cytosines are often methylated in vertebrates, are hot spots for C:G to T:A transitions. The chemistry is in [nucleotide metabolism](https://stemhop.com/lessons/nucleotide-metabolism/).
- **Depurination.** The bond between a purine and its sugar breaks, leaving a site with no base to copy.
- **Slippage.** In repeated bases, the new strand can loop out or slip back during copying, adding or removing repeat units.

**Induced** mutations come from outside agents, called **mutagens**.

- **Base analogs** such as 5-bromouracil are built into DNA in place of a normal base and mispair, giving transitions.
- **Alkylating agents** such as ethyl methanesulfonate ([EMS](https://stemhop.com/methods/forward-genetic-screen/)) add groups to bases. EMS chiefly gives G:C to A:T transitions.
- **Intercalators** such as proflavine slip between base pairs and favor single-base insertions and deletions, so frameshifts.
- **Ultraviolet light** joins adjacent pyrimidines into dimers. Each dimer is damage until repair or copying past it leaves a heritable sequence change.
- **Ionizing radiation** breaks DNA strands and damages bases.

Hermann Muller reported in *Science* in 1927 that X-rays greatly raise the mutation rate in *Drosophila*, in experiments that counted new lethal mutations on the X chromosome. He received the Nobel Prize in 1946. How cells fix damage before it becomes mutation is the subject of [DNA repair and recombination](https://stemhop.com/lessons/dna-repair-and-recombination/).

## The Ames test and what it can and cannot say

Bruce Ames’s test uses *Salmonella* strains that cannot make histidine because of a mutation in a histidine gene. On a plate with only a trace of histidine, they divide a few times and stop unless a new mutation restores histidine synthesis. Each **revertant** colony marks such an event, sometimes at the original site and sometimes at a second, compensating site. TA100 reverts mainly by base-pair substitution; TA98 reverts mainly by frameshift. Plates run with and without **S9**, a rat-liver enzyme fraction, because many carcinogens become reactive only after liver metabolism.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Each revertant colony marks a new mutation that restored histidine synthesis; plates with and without S9 test whether liver metabolism makes a chemical mutagenic. Image: a petri dish with many tiny stalled bacterial specks and three larger revertant colonies, with an inset showing a test chemical passing through an S9 liver fraction to become a reactive metabolite that reaches a bacterium.

Read an Ames result in a fixed order: compare with spontaneous background, look for a dose response, compare strains, then compare with and without S9.

A positive result shows that a chemical, or a metabolite, mutates bacteria; it does not measure cancer risk in people. A negative result does not prove safety, because some carcinogens act without mutating DNA or through processes bacteria lack.

### Design problem

**Predict.** TA100 gives about 120 spontaneous revertants per plate and TA98 about 30. Compound X is tested at three rising doses. TA100 without S9: 125, 118, 130. TA100 with S9: 240, 480, 950. TA98 with S9: 30, 28, 35. What does X do, and what does the result not show?

> **One way to do it.** TA100 without S9 stays at about 120 at every dose, so X itself shows no detectable mutagenic activity in TA100 at these doses. TA100 with S9 rises to about 2, 4 and 8 times background: a dose-dependent rise in base-pair substitutions after liver metabolism. TA98 with S9 stays at about 30, so there is no detectable frameshift activity in TA98.
>
> Conclusion: a metabolite of X is a base-substitution mutagen in *Salmonella*. This does not show that X causes cancer in people, since the test measures bacterial mutation with rat-liver enzymes.

## Going deeper

### The arithmetic behind the variances

For the independent cultures, the squared deviations from 6 are 36, 36, 25, 36, 9, 36, 36, 2,116, 16 and 16, summing to 2,362. Divided by 9, the sample variance is about 262. For the bulk samples, the squared deviations sum to 36, so the variance is 36/9 = 4.0.

### Tautomers and mismatch shapes

Rare alternative forms of bases, called tautomers, were proposed long ago as one cause of mispairing. Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) work has since detected short-lived tautomeric and ionized forms that let a wrong pair take the shape of a correct one, though how much they add to mutation in living cells is still being worked out.

### Ames validation counts

In 1973 Ames and colleagues reported that liver homogenate converted 18 tested carcinogens into frameshift mutagens. In McCann and colleagues’ 1975 set, 156 of 174 tested carcinogens were positive, a figure for that set of chemicals, not a general probability that a carcinogen will test positive.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/mutation/
