# Microbes in Bodies and Ecosystems

> Microbes that unlock matter feed life; pathogens cause disease in their hosts. Some microbes take apart matter that others cannot use and hand it on, and life depends on them. You switch groups of microbes off in a model ecosystem, follow bacteria that break down dead leaves, feed soybeans with nitrogen from the air, digest fiber in your gut and make yogurt and insulin, and meet microbes that cause disease. Afterwards you can read field data on soybean nitrogen and argue that the same kind of organism can help or harm depending on where it lives.

Course: Biology (Bacteria and viruses). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/microbes-in-ecosystems/

Builds on: Respiration and ATP · Living or Not? Viruses and Bacteria · How Microbes Multiply

## What you'll learn

- You will explain the helpful roles of bacteria (decomposition, nitrogen fixation, digestion by the gut microbiome, and making foods and medicines) and their harmful roles as pathogens that cause disease in plants, animals and humans.
- You will explain how bacteria and viruses shape ecosystems and biodiversity, including viruses that kill bacteria and algae in the ocean and diseases that change wildlife populations.
- You will read data on soybean nitrogen fixation and use them to support a claim that microbes can be helpful or harmful depending on the situation.

**Dig up a soybean plant and you can find small round bumps on its roots; cut an active one open and it is often pink inside. Those bumps are packed with bacteria that turn nitrogen from the air into a form the plant can use.**

Your gut also holds trillions of bacteria, and some help break down your food. Yet most of us learn the word “bacteria” next to the word “germs.” So which is it: are bacteria and viruses enemies, or are they partners that life depends on?

Watch the first film at the top of the page before you read on. It answers with a pattern:

> **The one idea.** Microbes that unlock matter feed life; pathogens cause disease in their hosts. Some microbes take apart matter that most living things cannot use alone, such as nitrogen gas in the air, dead leaves, the fiber in your food and the remains of burst cells. They hand some of it on, so life depends on them. A pathogen is a microbe or virus that causes disease in its host. Whether a microbe helps, harms or does neither can depend on its **strain** (a genetic variety within one kind of microbe) and where it lives.
>
> *Scope:* this is a pattern for the microbes in this lesson, not a definition of every microbe. Many microbes live on a host without harming it, and some make their own food from sunlight. Pathogens harm in several ways: by blocking, by damaging tissue, by releasing poisons called toxins, or by setting off harmful responses in the host. Strain and place are not the whole story either: the host and its surroundings can change the outcome too.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. All bacteria are harmful. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Field studies of soybean roots show bacteria supplying the plant with nitrogen, and yogurt is made by two kinds of bacteria growing in milk. Some bacteria do cause disease, such as one that blocks the water pipes of grapevines. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Field studies of soybean roots show bacteria supplying the plant with nitrogen, and yogurt is made by two kinds of bacteria growing in milk. Some bacteria do cause disease, such as one that blocks the water pipes of grapevines.
2. Viruses and bacteria only cause disease. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** In a lab model ecosystem, a virus burst ocean algae cells, and when bacteria broke down the remains, nitrogen and phosphorus appeared in the water for other living things to use. Bacteria that break down dead leaves in streams return nutrients too. Disease is one of several things microbes do. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** In a lab model ecosystem, a virus burst ocean algae cells, and when bacteria broke down the remains, nitrogen and phosphorus appeared in the water for other living things to use. Bacteria that break down dead leaves in streams return nutrients too. Disease is one of several things microbes do.
3. There are ten times more bacterial cells than human cells in your body. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** In 2016 Ron Sender, Shai Fuchs and Ron Milo added up published counts for a reference adult man weighing 70 kg. They estimated about 38 trillion bacterial cells and about 30 trillion human cells, close to one to one. The older ten-to-one figure came from a rough estimate that newer counts replaced. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** In 2016 Ron Sender, Shai Fuchs and Ron Milo added up published counts for a reference adult man weighing 70 kg. They estimated about 38 trillion bacterial cells and about 30 trillion human cells, close to one to one. The older ten-to-one figure came from a rough estimate that newer counts replaced.

## Explore: switch microbes off in an ecosystem

The simulation shows a field of soybeans, a stream with fallen leaves, a deer, a person and some ocean water. Switch off one group of microbes at a time. Bars show how much matter moves along each path and how large each population is, in numbers meant only for comparison.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Microbe roles web: switch a group off

**Try this.**

1. Before you switch off the decomposers, predict what happens to the dead leaves and the soil nutrients. Then test it.
2. Switch off the nitrogen fixers. Predict which population changes first, the soybeans or the deer that eat plants.
3. Switch off the pathogens. Predict whether the deer population grows without limit or levels off. Watch what happens to the plants.
4. Come back after the second film. Switch off the viruses in the ocean water, and predict what happens to the number of bacteria and to the nutrients dissolved in the water.

## Explain: microbes that unlock matter

- decomposer
- nitrogen fixation
- nodule
- mutualism
- microbiome
- fermentation
- pathogen
- host
- bacteriophage
- biodiversity

### Feeding plants nitrogen

The first film showed the trade inside a nodule; it left out what “fixing” means and who can do it. To **fix** nitrogen is to fasten it into a compound that cells can build with (fix as in fasten, not repair). Among living things, only some bacteria and archaea, a second group of single-celled microbes, can do it; lightning and fertilizer factories fix nitrogen too. The nodule bacteria in soybeans, peanuts and other legumes join nitrogen to hydrogen to make **ammonium**, and the plant builds that nitrogen into its own proteins and DNA.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge energy-rich foodnitrogen gasnoduleammoniumbacteria blankblanknoduleblankblank Word bank: ammonium, bacter

**Predict.** You split a nodule and it is pink inside. Does that prove the bacteria are fixing nitrogen? Does it tell you how much?

> **Check your prediction.** No to both. Pink or red is a field sign of fixing: a good clue, not proof, and silent on how much. For the amount, researchers compare the forms of nitrogen atoms in the plant, as in the data below.

Most of the fixed nitrogen ends up in the harvested beans. When the rest of the plant dies, decomposers break down its roots, stems and leaves, and some fixed nitrogen returns to the soil (more in Matter Cycles).

### Breaking down the dead

The first film showed **decomposers** on a dead stem. They break down wastes as well as dead organisms, and the digesting happens outside the microbe, on the dead matter itself, where the released enzymes work. Without them, dead matter would pile up with its nutrients locked inside. Bacteria are not the only ones doing it: in an Ohio stream study, both fungi and bacteria grew on fallen maple and oak leaves, and the fungi always outweighed the bacteria.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Fungi and bacteria grow on fallen leaves and break them down, returning nutrients to the water. On leaves in streams, fungi usually make up more of the microbial mass. Image: fallen maple and oak leaves on a stream bed, with a magnified view of a leaf surface showing branching fungal threads and clusters of bacteria, and small dots of nutrients leaving the leaf into the water.

**Key idea:**

fixers and decomposers unlock matter for plants.

## Explain: partners in your body, and pathogens

### Your gut microbiome

The first film showed gut bacteria fermenting **fiber** without oxygen. They are part of your **microbiome**, the community of microbes that live in one place, such as soil, a stream or a body. Most of your gut’s bacteria live in the large intestine. The cells lining the large intestine can use the small acids the bacteria make as a source of energy. Diet matters to these partners: see the mouse study in Going deeper.

### Foods and medicines

People have used bacteria for a very long time. Yogurt forms when two kinds of bacteria ferment the sugar in milk and release lactic acid, which thickens the milk and makes it sour. Bacteria can also make human medicines: E. coli carrying lab-made genes for human insulin made its two parts, which researchers joined into human insulin (see the insulin story on this page; more in [Engineering Genes](https://stemhop.com/lessons/genetic-engineering/)).

### Pathogens

The first film met one **pathogen**, Xylella in its grapevine **host**. Pathogens, viruses among them, attack all kinds of hosts:

| Host | Pathogen | What it does |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Grapevine | the bacterium Xylella fastidiosa | causes Pierce’s disease, which blocks the vine’s water-carrying tubes |
| Cattle | the bacterium Mycobacterium bovis | causes bovine tuberculosis |
| Humans | the bacterium Helicobacter pylori | causes inflammation of the stomach lining |
| Birds and humans | West Nile virus, spread by mosquitoes | causes illness, sometimes severe |

Preventing and treating these diseases is the subject of [Germs, Vaccines and Antibiotics](https://stemhop.com/lessons/germs-vaccines-antibiotics/).

The first film’s E. coli showed strain at work: some strains carry extra genes that make them harmful, and people who swallow enough of them in food or water can get sick. Place matters too: E. coli from your own gut is the most common cause of bladder infections, which start when it reaches the urinary tract and clings to the bladder wall.

**Key idea:**

strain and place can decide whether a microbe helps or harms.

## Explain: viruses and diseases reshape ecosystems

Pathogens do not always kill. When one does kill the cells it infects, where does their matter go? The second film follows it in a flask of seawater, then across a landscape.

**Film transcript: When the Killer Is a Recycler**

### Film transcript: When the Killer Is a Recycler

Some pathogens kill the very cells they infect, and viruses often do. That arrow from the first film ran one way, from host to pathogen. But when a virus kills a cell, where does that cell's matter go? Picture a virus bursting a cell in the ocean. A moment ago, that cell held nitrogen. Where is that nitrogen now? Ocean water holds enormous numbers of viruses. A virus that infects bacteria is called a bacteriophage, or phage for short. Other ocean viruses infect algae. Researchers built a lab model ecosystem. It was a flask of seawater with an ocean alga called Phaeocystis. Then they added a virus that infects it. The viruses infected the algae.

Then the cells burst, spilling much of what was inside them into the water. The algae were dead. Was their nitrogen gone too? No. Bacteria swarmed the remains and broke them down. The water gained nitrogen and phosphorus, in forms other living things could use. Algae and bacteria can take them up. So the nitrogen was not destroyed. The virus killed the cell, but much of the cell's matter went back into the water. A killer can also be part of a recycling chain.

Virus, then bacteria, then other living things: each step moves matter on. Now zoom out to a whole landscape, the Serengeti in East Africa. Rinderpest is a virus disease of cattle and of wild grazing animals, such as wildebeest. In the 1960s, vaccinating cattle wiped rinderpest out of the Serengeti. The virus was gone. What happened to the land? Here is a question to try. With rinderpest gone, will the Serengeti end up with more trees, or with fewer trees?

More trees. Researchers traced the chain using decades of records and computer models. First, wildebeest numbers rose. More wildebeest ate more grass. Less dry grass meant less fuel for fires. Fewer fires burned, so more young trees survived. Their analysis supported this chain, from the loss of one virus to more trees. Two scales, two lessons. In the flask, matter from the dead cells went back into the water for other living things. On the savanna, losing one virus changed which populations grew.

Viruses that burst cells can recycle matter. Pathogens can reshape ecosystems.

From the film

- A virus that infects bacteria is called a bacteriophage; other ocean viruses infect algae.
- In a lab model ecosystem, a virus burst the alga Phaeocystis, bacteria broke down the remains, and the water gained nitrogen and phosphorus.
- Viruses that burst cells can recycle matter; pathogens can reshape ecosystems. When a virus bursts a cell, some of its matter can feed other living things.
- After rinderpest was wiped out in the Serengeti, wildebeest numbers rose, they ate more grass, fewer fires burned and more trees grew.

Seawater holds millions of virus particles, phages and others, in every milliliter. By one widely cited estimate, viruses kill roughly a fifth of the ocean’s microbial biomass (the total mass of its microbes) every day. These estimates are rough and vary a lot from place to place.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* In a lab model ecosystem, a virus burst ocean algae and bacteria broke down the remains, releasing nitrogen and phosphorus into the water for other living things. The drawing's cube-shaped viruses are simplified; real ones have many flat faces and look nearly round. Image: three circular frames joined by arrows. Left, labeled 'Virus infects the alga': a large green alga cell with small virus particles around it, drawn as simple cubes. Middle, labeled 'Cell bursts': green cell fragments and tan debris with rod-shaped bacteria, labeled 'Bacteria break down remains'. Right, labeled 'Nitrogen and phosphorus in the water': yellow dots scattered in the water beside two small green cells, labeled 'Other living things use them'.

Viruses also shape **biodiversity**, the variety of living things in a place. Each kind of phage usually infects only certain kinds of bacteria.

**Predict.** One kind of bacterium grows fast and becomes far more common than the rest. Will its phages spread faster or slower than the phages of rare bacteria? What happens to the other kinds of bacteria?

> **Check your prediction.** Usually faster. A phage spreads when an infected cell bursts and its new phages meet the next host, and a common host is easier to meet. So the most common kind can be cut back hardest, which may leave room and nutrients for rarer kinds. Ecologists call this “kill the winner.” It does not always happen: some bacteria resist their phages, and some phages hide inside cells instead of bursting them. Where it does, viruses can keep more kinds of bacteria alive at once.

On land, the film’s Serengeti chain shows a pathogen reshaping a whole landscape; the cattle-virus story on this page gives its source.

**Key idea:**

viruses that burst cells can recycle matter, and pathogens can reshape ecosystems.

## Elaborate: how much nitrogen do nodules add?

| Year | Sampling date | Soybean type | Total nitrogen above ground (kg N/ha) | Nitrogen from fixation (kg N/ha) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 2006 | 13 Sept | Nodulating | 282 | 195 |
| 2006 | 13 Sept | Non-nodulating | 150 | not applicable |
| 2007 | 12 Sept | Nodulating | 144 | 95.0 |
| 2007 | 12 Sept | Non-nodulating | 67.6 | not applicable |
| 2008 | 23 Sept | Nodulating | 148 | 90.3 |
| 2008 | 23 Sept | Non-nodulating | 61.6 | not applicable |

These data come from a field trial by Snapp, Wilke, Gentry and Zoellner, published in 2017, at the Kellogg Biological Station in Hickory Corners, Michigan. Each value is a mean over several farming systems for one growing season. Both soybean types were Williams 82 plants, nearly identical except that one cannot form nodules. A hectare is 10,000 square meters, about one and a half soccer fields.

“Nitrogen from fixation” was estimated with nitrogen isotopes: nitrogen atoms come in a common light form and a rare heavier form, and air and soil hold slightly different mixes. Researchers compared the mix in nodulating soybeans with the mix in non-nodulating plants grown in the same conditions. They also used a reference value for soybean nitrogen that comes only from the air.

1. In 2006, how much more nitrogen did nodulating plants hold than non-nodulating plants? Write it as a percentage of the non-nodulating value (divide the difference by the non-nodulating value, then multiply by 100).
2. Which year had the most nitrogen from fixation? Was the gap between the two soybean types the same every year?
3. Find the mean nitrogen from fixation over the three years.

**Predict.** In 2006 the rows differ by 132 kg N/ha, but the isotopes say the bacteria fixed 195. Where did the extra come from? Hint: subtract fixed nitrogen from the nodulating total.

> **Check your prediction.** Above ground, the nodulating plants held only 87 kg N/ha from sources other than fixation, such as the soil (282 − 195); the non-nodulating plants held 150. With a partner supplying nitrogen, the nodulating plants got less from those other sources, so the 132 gap is 63 kg N/ha smaller than the isotope estimate. Roots were not measured, so these numbers cover only the parts above ground. Each year the bacteria supplied about three-fifths to two-thirds of the nodulating plants’ above-ground nitrogen (61 to 69 percent).

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question for soybean nodule bacteria, using this data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The bacteria in soybean nodules were blank to the plants in this trial.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: In every year, nodulating soybeans held blank nitrogen than non-nodulating soybeans, for example blank compared with blank kg N/ha in 2006.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This shows blank because nitrogen fixation blank. Bacteria can also be pathogens, so whether a microbe helps or harms depends on blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** The bacteria in soybean nodules helped the plants in this trial. In all three years, nodulating soybeans held about two times (1.9 to 2.4 times) as much nitrogen above ground as plants that could not form nodules. The values were 282 compared with 150 kg N/ha in 2006, 144 compared with 67.6 in 2007, and 148 compared with 61.6 in 2008. The nodule bacteria turn nitrogen gas into a form plants use, and plants build proteins and DNA from it. Other bacteria are pathogens, so bacteria are not always harmful; it can depend on the microbe and where it lives. One limit: these are three seasons at one Michigan station, so a Virginia field could differ.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Plan an investigation to test whether adding nodule bacteria helps soybeans grow in nitrogen-poor soil. Name your variables, your control, what you keep the same, how many plants you use, and how you keep it safe.

> **One way to do it.** - Question: does adding nodule bacteria increase soybean growth in soil low in nitrogen?
> - Independent variable: nodule bacteria added (a garden-store legume inoculant made for soybeans) or not added.
> - Dependent variables: dry plant mass after six weeks, the number of nodules per plant, and how many split nodules are pink inside.
> - Control: pots of the same sterile, nitrogen-poor potting mix with no inoculant. Sterile mix matters, because ordinary soil may already hold nodule bacteria.
> - Constants: the same seed batch, pot size, amount of soil, water, light and temperature. Add no nitrogen fertilizer to either group.
> - Sample size and trials: at least 10 pots per group, with pots mixed together on the shelf so neither group gets the better light. Find the mean for each group. Repeat the whole test if you can.
> - Safety: wear gloves when handling the inoculant and soil, follow the product label, and wash your hands afterwards.
> - What results would mean: if the inoculated plants have more nodules and a higher mean mass, that supports a benefit from the bacteria in these conditions. If both groups match, the bacteria may not have formed nodules, so check the roots.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Microbes that unlock matter feed life; pathogens cause disease in their hosts. Viruses that burst cells can recycle matter, pathogens can reshape ecosystems, and whether a microbe helps or harms can depend on its strain and where it lives.

**Science practices you used:** predicting and testing in a model ecosystem, reading a data table and calculating a difference, a percentage and a mean, planning a fair test with a control and many plants, and naming the limits of one study’s data.

## Going deeper

### Fiber and the gut lining

In a 2016 study, mice carrying a set of human gut bacteria and fed a low-fiber diet had gut bacteria that began feeding on the protective mucus that lines the gut.

### Numbers from the algae experiment

In the lab model ecosystem of Jakob Haaber and Mathias Middelboe, a virus infected the ocean alga Phaeocystis. After bacteria broke down the dead algae, the water gained about 148 micrograms of nitrogen and 7 micrograms of phosphorus per liter that other living things could use.

### Viruses that wait, then burst

Some phages lie hidden inside a bacterium before bursting it. A 2019 experiment on coastal water found that when viruses switched from hiding to bursting, the bacterial community became more diverse.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/microbes-in-ecosystems/
