# Transport Across Membranes

> A lipid bilayer stops ions and most polar molecules, so every cell relies on proteins to move them: channels, carriers and pumps. This lesson sorts those proteins by how they work, shows how to predict which way an ion will flow from its concentrations and the membrane voltage, and teaches you to read a single-channel recording and a tracer-uptake experiment. Afterwards you can compute a Nernst potential, decide the direction of passive ion flux, and tell a channel from a carrier from the data.

Course: Cell Biology (Membranes and compartments). Level: core university (third year). About 30 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/membrane-transport/

Builds on: Membrane Organization and Topology · Crossing the Membrane

## What you'll learn

- Compare simple diffusion, channels, carriers (uniport, symport, antiport) and pumps, including secondary active transport driven by an ion gradient.
- Calculate an ion's equilibrium potential with the Nernst equation and use Vm − E_X to predict the direction of its net passive flux.
- Interpret single-channel recordings in terms of unitary current, open probability and patch orientation.
- Distinguish exchange from net uptake, and saturation from linear flux, in tracer-flux data.

The first film used a voltage clamp, an amplifier that fixes the membrane voltage at a chosen value whatever current flows, to show potassium reversing direction while its concentrations stayed fixed. It left open how measurements reveal the route a solute takes.

## The wall and the one rule

A lipid bilayer has an oily core about as thick as two lipid tails. Gases such as oxygen and carbon dioxide and small nonpolar molecules dissolve in that core and cross it by simple diffusion, needing no protein. Water crosses too, though slowly. Ions and larger polar molecules such as glucose cross almost not at all, because leaving water for oil costs them too much energy. You met the chemistry behind this in [membrane structure and function](https://stemhop.com/lessons/membrane-structure-function/).

So ions and sugars cross the bilayer in useful amounts only through proteins, and the proteins are specific: a potassium channel passes potassium and almost no sodium, and the glucose carrier GLUT1 passes glucose and not fructose. A cell decides what crosses by choosing which proteins to build, where to put them and when to open them. The sidedness of those proteins in the membrane, covered in [membrane organization and topology](https://stemhop.com/lessons/membrane-organization-topology/), fixes which face of each protein looks into the cell. For a pump that orientation sets which way it pushes; for a channel or a passive carrier, the gradients decide.

> **The one idea to carry through this lesson** is the film’s hill. Any solute, charged or not, flows on its own only downhill in its own electrochemical energy, the sum of a concentration push and a voltage push. Channels and passive carriers decide *which* solute crosses and *how fast*, never *which way*. Uphill transport is coupled to something running further downhill: ATP splitting (a pump), light or electron flow in some pumps, or another ion’s gradient (a symporter or antiporter, such as sodium-glucose cotransporter 1 (SGLT1)). The coupled total must still be downhill.

The rule sets the direction of *net* flow at a given moment. Here, concentrations stand in for **activities**, meaning effective concentrations. Separate questions are how fast transport runs and where a cell permeable to several ions will rest (that is [the resting membrane](https://stemhop.com/lessons/resting-membrane-passive/)). Water follows the rule too: aquaporins open a path, and water’s own energy difference, set mainly by the solutes on each side (and by pressure, in walled cells), decides the direction.

## Two pushes, one number

Now calculate the hill for moving one mole of solute from outside to inside. The **concentration push** runs from high concentration to low. The **voltage push** depends on Vm, inside minus outside: a negative Vm favours entry for cations and opposes it for anions. Their sum is one number:

> **Equation card: Which way any solute will flow on its own: negative means in, positive means out.**
>
>     ΔG_in = RT × ln([X]in / [X]out) + zF × Vm
>
> In words: Delta G in equals R T times the natural log of inside over outside concentration, plus z F times the membrane potential.
>
> - ΔG_in: the free energy change for moving one mole of X from outside to inside. Negative means downhill. (J/mol)
> - RT × ln([X]in / [X]out): the ln measures the concentration difference on a log scale; negative when X is moving to the side where it is scarcer (J/mol)
> - zF × Vm: charge z (with its sign) times F times Vm. Zero for an uncharged solute. (J/mol)
> - R: 8.314 J per mol per K (J/(mol·K))
> - T: the absolute temperature, in kelvin (37 °C = 310.15 K) (K)
> - F: the charge on one mole of +1 ions, 96 485 C per mol (C/mol)
> - Vm: the membrane potential, inside minus outside (V)
>
> Sanity check: Equal concentrations and Vm = 0 give ΔG_in = 0: nothing pushes either way.
> Try one number Sodium entering a cell at −70 mV, with teaching values of 145 mM outside and 12 mM inside, at 37 °C. Concentration push: RT × ln(12/145) = 2579 J/mol × (−2.49) = −6.4 kJ/mol. Voltage push: (+1) × 96 485 × (−0.070) = −6.75 kJ/mol. Total: about −13.2 kJ/mol. Both slopes run inward, so sodium is steeply downhill into the cell. Keep this number; SGLT1 spends it below.

For each ion there is one voltage at which the two pushes cancel exactly. That is its **equilibrium potential**, EX. Set ΔGin to zero and solve for Vm, and you have the Nernst equation:

> **Equation card: The voltage at which an ion’s concentration push and electrical push cancel: its equilibrium potential.**
>
>     E_X = (RT / zF) × ln([X]out / [X]in)
>
> In words: E sub X equals R T over z F, times the natural log of the outside concentration over the inside concentration.
>
> - E_X: the equilibrium potential of ion X (V or mV)
> - R, T, F: as in the card above: the gas constant, the absolute temperature and the Faraday constant (—)
> - z: the ion’s charge, with its sign: +1 for K+, −1 for Cl− (no unit)
> - ln: the logarithm to base e. ln(1) = 0; a ratio below 1 gives a negative ln, above 1 a positive one. (no unit)
> - [X]out: the ion’s concentration outside the cell (mM)
> - [X]in: the ion’s concentration inside the cell (mM)
>
> Sanity check: If the concentrations are equal, the ratio is 1, ln(1) = 0, and E_X = 0: with no concentration push, no voltage is needed to balance it. For a cation that is more concentrated inside, like K+, the ratio is below 1, the ln is negative, and E_X is negative. Flip the sign of z (an anion) and E_X flips sign too.
> Try one number Where the “61.5 mV per tenfold” shortcut comes from. At 37 °C, RT/F = (8.314 × 310.15) / 96 485 = 26.73 mV. A tenfold ratio has ln(10) = 2.303. So for a +1 ion, a tenfold ratio gives 26.73 mV × 2.303 = about 61.5 mV. That is why E = 61.5 mV × log10(ratio) gives the same answer as the ln form.
> Where it comes from optional Step 1, at equilibrium nothing is downhill: 0 = RT × ln([X]in / [X]out) + zF × E_X. Step 2, move the concentration term across: zF × E_X = −RT × ln([X]in / [X]out) = RT × ln([X]out / [X]in), because flipping a ratio flips the sign of its ln. Step 3, divide by zF.

At EX the ion’s net passive flux is zero. Ions still cross; equal numbers cross each way.

For an ion you can fold the two pushes into one gap. The gap between Vm and EX is the **driving force**, and multiplying it by the charge gives the same ΔGin as before:

> **Equation card: Which way an ion will flow on its own: in, out, or neither.**
>
>     ΔG_in = zF × (Vm − E_X)
>
> In words: Delta G in equals z F times the gap between the membrane potential and the ion’s equilibrium potential.
>
> - ΔG_in: the free energy change for moving one mole of the ion from outside to inside. Negative means downhill. (J/mol)
> - z: the ion’s charge, with its sign (no unit)
> - F: 96 485 C per mol (C/mol)
> - Vm: the membrane potential, inside minus outside (V)
> - E_X: the ion’s equilibrium potential, from the Nernst equation (V)
>
> Sanity check: If Vm equals E_X, ΔG_in is zero: no net flow, which is what equilibrium potential means. If ΔG_in is negative, net passive flow is inward; if positive, outward. Units: coulombs per mole times volts gives joules per mole.
> Try one number Keep z’s sign. Take a cation (z = +1) with Vm − E_X = +10 mV. ΔG_in = (+1) × 96 485 × 0.010 = +965 J/mol, about +0.96 kJ/mol. It is positive, so net flow of the cation is outward.
> Where it comes from optional Step 1, from the Nernst derivation, the concentration push equals −zF × E_X. Step 2, substitute it into the two-push form: ΔG_in = −zF × E_X + zF × Vm. Step 3, take out the common factor: ΔG_in = zF × (Vm − E_X).

So comparing Vm with EX is the downhill rule, written for one ion.

**Worked problem.** Take a membrane permeable only to K+, at 37 °C (310.15 K), with [K+]in = 140 mM and [K+]out = 5 mM. These are teaching values close to those of a typical mammalian cell.

*Step 1: find EK.* RT/F = 26.73 mV (from the Nernst card). The ratio 5/140 = 0.0357, and ln(0.0357) = −3.332 (a calculator’s ln key; see [e and ln](https://stemhop.com/math-toolkit/#e-and-ln)). Here z = +1, so RT/zF = RT/F. So

> EK = 26.73 mV × (−3.332) = −89.1 mV

**Predict.** Clamp the membrane at −70 mV and open the channels. Does net K+ flow in or out? Now clamp at −100 mV.

> **Check your prediction.** *At −70 mV,* out. Vm − EK = −70 − (−89.1) = +19.1 mV, so ΔGin = (+1)(96 485)(+0.0191) = +1.84 kJ/mol. Moving K+ in is uphill. In two-push terms, the concentration push on entering K+ is +8.59 kJ/mol and the voltage push only −6.75 kJ/mol: the inside is not negative enough to hold potassium in.
>
> *At −100 mV,* in. Vm − EK = −10.9 mV, so ΔGin = −1.06 kJ/mol. The voltage push has grown to −9.65 kJ/mol and now outweighs the same +8.59. This is the reversal promised at the top.

*One channel.* Suppose a single K+ channel has a conductance γ (how easily current passes) of 20 picosiemens (pS) and behaves ohmically: its current is proportional to the driving force, Vm − EK, and is zero at EK. By convention, **positive current is outward movement of positive charge**. At Vm = −40 mV its current is

> i = γ × (Vm − EK) = 20 pS × 49.1 mV = 0.98 pA, outward

A current of 0.98 pA is 0.98 × 10−12 coulombs per second; dividing by the charge on one ion (1.602 × 10−19 C) gives about 6.1 × 106 ions per second through one pore.

**Predict.** Now take chloride (z = −1) with the same gap, Vm − ECl = +10 mV. Which way does net chloride flow?

> **Check your prediction.** Inward. ΔGin = (−1) × 96 485 × 0.010 = −965 J/mol, negative. Because z is negative for an anion, the same Vm − EX gives ΔGin the opposite sign.
>
> The physical reading, for the usual case of chloride more concentrated outside and a negative inside: the negative inside pushes chloride out. When Vm is less negative than ECl, that outward electrical push is weaker than chloride’s inward concentration push, so chloride comes in.

Do not conclude that a cell rests at EK. A real membrane is permeable to several ions, and the resting potential usually lies between their equilibrium potentials, pulled toward each according to its share of the membrane’s conductance (see [the resting membrane](https://stemhop.com/lessons/resting-membrane-passive/)). Many cells rest less negative than EK for exactly this reason.

## The machinery, sorted by the rule

The first film used the simplest case; here is the fuller machinery. Two kinds of protein carry solutes across: **channels** and **carriers**. (“Carrier” and “transporter” mean the same thing here. A pump is a carrier with its own power supply.)

### Downhill only: channels and uniporters

**Channels** form an aqueous pore that, when open, connects both sides at once. Ions flow through, often in single file, down their electrochemical gradient. A channel can switch between open and closed (gating) in response to voltage, a ligand or stretch, but while open it has no cycle to complete, so it is fast: millions of ions per second through one pore. Aquaporins are water channels. Ligand-gated channels that act as receptors belong to [ion channels as receptors](https://stemhop.com/lessons/ion-channels-as-receptors/) in the signaling course.

**Carriers** work differently. A carrier binds its solute on one side, changes shape, and releases it on the other; in the ideal cycle its binding site is never open to both sides at once, though some carriers also have a small channel-like leak. This is **alternating access**. Because each crossing needs a shape change, a carrier works far more slowly than a channel, and because it has a limited number of binding sites, its rate saturates as solute rises, like an enzyme with [Michaelis-Menten kinetics](https://stemhop.com/lessons/enzyme-kinetics/).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* An open channel is one pathway joining both sides at once, so ions stream through. A carrier's binding site is open to one side at a time: it binds its solute on one side, changes shape and releases it on the other, which is why it is slower and can saturate. Image: three panels of a plasma membrane. In the first, an open channel has a pore running straight through it with ions in single file. In the second, a carrier's binding site is open only to the outside with one solute bound. In the third, the carrier has changed shape and its site is open only to the inside.

A **uniporter** is a carrier that moves one solute, as GLUT1 moves glucose into red blood cells. Glucose has no charge, so only the concentration push counts: GLUT1 can speed glucose across, but with glucose alone, only until inside and outside are equal; it can never concentrate it.

### Uphill by coupling: pumps, symporters and antiporters

**Pumps** couple transport to a direct energy source, usually ATP hydrolysis, and so move ions uphill. This is **primary active transport**. Pumps work by alternating access too. The Na+/K+-ATPase in the plasma membrane of animal cells exports three Na+ and imports two K+ for each ATP it splits. At −70 mV both moves are uphill, but together they cost less than one ATP supplies (Going deeper, “The pump’s bill”). It moves one net charge out per cycle, so it makes the inside more negative directly. In most cells that direct effect is small, a few millivolts, but in some it is large. Mostly it builds the sodium and potassium gradients that other proteins spend.

Carriers that move two or more solutes can do the same with no ATP. A **symporter** moves them the same way. An **antiporter** (or exchanger) moves them opposite ways, as the Na+/Ca2+ exchanger brings sodium in and sends calcium out. Spending one solute’s gradient to move another is **secondary active transport**.

Sodium-glucose cotransporter 1 (SGLT1) in intestinal cells brings glucose in with sodium. You will see SGLT1 again in [digestion](https://stemhop.com/lessons/digestion/), and the same logic with protons instead of sodium in [the proton-motive force](https://stemhop.com/lessons/proton-motive-force/).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* The Na+/K+-ATPase spends ATP to keep sodium high outside. SGLT1 then lets sodium run downhill into the cell, and that downhill run pays for glucose to go uphill; the pump never touches the glucose. Image: a cell membrane with the Na+/K+-ATPase on the left moving three Na+ out and two K+ in using one ATP, and on the right the transporter SGLT1 carrying two Na+ and one glucose into the cell down the sodium gradient.

**Predict.** Block the pump with a drug. What happens to glucose uptake through SGLT1, and does it happen at once?

> **Check your prediction.** Uphill glucose uptake fails, but not at once. SGLT1 needs only that the coupled total, sodium’s payment plus glucose’s cost, is still downhill. With the pump blocked, the sodium gradient runs down as sodium keeps leaking in, the payment shrinks, and SGLT1 can no longer pull glucose uphill.

How far uphill can that payment carry glucose?

> **Equation card: The most that a sodium-glucose symporter can concentrate glucose, set by how much sodium pays per trip.**
>
>     n × ΔG_in(Na+) + RT × ln([glucose]in / [glucose]out) ≤ 0
>
> In words: n times the free energy for one mole of sodium entering, plus R T times the natural log of the glucose ratio, must be zero or less.
>
> - n: the number of Na+ carried with each glucose: 2 for SGLT1 (no unit)
> - ΔG_in(Na+): the free energy for one mole of Na+ entering: about −13.2 kJ/mol in the two-push example (J/mol)
> - RT × ln(...): concentration only, since glucose has no charge. Positive when glucose piles up inside. (J/mol)
>
> Sanity check: With n = 0 the glucose term alone must be zero or less, so glucose can never be concentrated inside: that is the uniporter.
> Try one number At 37 °C, each tenfold step uphill costs glucose RT × ln(10) = 5.94 kJ/mol. With 2 Na+ per glucose, the payment is 2 × 13.2 = 26.4 kJ/mol. That buys 26.4 / 5.94 = 4.44 tenfold steps: 10^4.44, about 27,500-fold. With 1 Na+ per glucose, 13.2 / 5.94 = 2.22 steps: about 166-fold. One extra sodium per trip multiplies the ceiling by about 166. These are thermodynamic ceilings, not measured ratios: leaks, and glucose leaving the cell by other carriers, keep real cells far below them.

Downhill flow cannot tell a channel from a carrier, since both carry it; net uphill flow points to a coupled carrier. The second film picks up here: for downhill flow, read the traffic pattern to tell a channel from a carrier.

**Film transcript: Read the Traffic**

### Film transcript: Read the Traffic

Chapter one showed that the energy hill sets which way a solute moves. So how can data reveal whether it crossed through a channel or a carrier? Watch the traffic, not the protein's name. An open channel is a continuous pore between both sides. Ions stream through without waiting for a transport cycle. A channel can switch between open and closed; a carrier must finish each alternating-access cycle. A carrier opens to one side, closes around its solute, then opens to the other. That shape change limits each trip. A single channel gives the detector square current steps. Millions of ions per second can cross one pore, producing measurable current.

Each jump marks an opening. The step height is the unitary current through one open channel. The fraction of recording time spent open is its open probability. Those are different measurements. Now a drug makes the openings last longer, but every step keeps the same height. What changed: current through one open channel, or open probability?

Decide from the trace. Open probability increased: the channel spent more of its time open. Unchanged step height means unchanged unitary current at this voltage. A whole-cell current alone mixes channel number, unitary current, and open probability, so it cannot separate them. Carriers leave a different signature.

Raise substrate concentration and their limited binding sites become occupied. The rate bends toward a ceiling called Vmax. A pore or simple diffusion can stay nearly proportional over the tested range. Channels can saturate too, usually only at much higher concentrations.

Saturation points toward a carrier, but it is evidence, not proof. Tracer experiments add a detectable tag to some substrate molecules. The counter sees tagged molecules entering, not the total amount inside. Take carrier vesicles with substrate already equal inside and outside. Add tagged substrate outside. Tagged molecules enter as untagged ones leave, so the total inside stays the same. A chemical assay of total substrate supplies what the tracer counter lacks. That is exchange, not net uptake.

Label has its own concentration difference, so it can run in while total substrate stays level. A rising count alone never proves accumulation. So measure the total, and combine exchange with rate, saturation, and single-channel steps instead of trusting one clue. The hill from chapter one tells you which way traffic can run. The pattern of that traffic reveals the route. Square steps point to a pore. Saturation and exchange point toward a carrier. Mechanism lives in the measurements, not the family name.

From the film

- An open channel forms a continuous pore, while a carrier completes an alternating-access cycle.
- A single-channel trace separates unitary current from open probability.
- A rate that saturates at low substrate concentrations points toward a carrier.
- Tracer entry can be exchange rather than net uptake.
- Mechanism comes from combined functional evidence, not a protein family name.

## Telling a channel from a carrier from the data

The chapter gave the signatures: rate, single-channel steps, saturation and exchange. The numbers and controls below show their limits and put them to work.

### Rate

The worked problem’s one open K+ channel carried about 6.1 million ions per second. Carriers typically cycle from tens to a few thousand times a second, and even the fastest known reach only tens of thousands, far below a million, so millions per second through one protein points to a pore.

### Watching one channel

In 1976 Erwin Neher and Bert Sakmann recorded square steps of a few picoamperes (trillionths of an ampere) from a small patch of frog muscle membrane, each step the current through one open channel. The 1981 **[gigaseal](https://stemhop.com/methods/patch-clamp/)** methods made such records routine; a gigaseal is an extremely high-resistance seal between glass and membrane. Each opening lasts a random time and openings come at irregular intervals. In a patch with one simple channel every opening has the same height, though some channels also show lower sub-levels.

The **unitary current**, i, the step height, is set by the channel’s conductance and the driving force. The **open probability**, Po, is the fraction of time the channel is open. A drug that changes Po without changing i alters gating; one that changes i alters conduction or driving force. Across N identical channels, the mean current combines the chapter’s two readouts with channel number:

> **Equation card: The current from a whole population of identical channels, built from what one channel does.**
>
>     I = N × i × P_o
>
> In words: The total current equals the number of channels, times the current through one open channel, times the fraction of time each is open.
>
> - I: the mean current through all the channels (pA)
> - N: the number of channels (no unit)
> - i: the unitary current: the step height through one open channel (pA)
> - P_o: the open probability: the fraction of time a channel is open, from 0 to 1 (no unit)
>
> Sanity check: If P_o is 0, there is no current however many channels there are.
> Try one number Round values: 100 channels, a 1 pA unitary current, and P_o = 0.5. I = 100 × 1 pA × 0.5 = 50 pA. Fifty channels that are always open (P_o = 1) give the same 50 pA: 50 × 1 × 1 = 50. That is why a whole-cell current alone cannot separate N, i and P_o.

The sandbox below is the worked problem’s 20 pS K+ channel. Move the clamp voltage first: the step height follows Vm − EK and flips to inward below −89.1 mV. Then move Po: only the time spent open changes.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Single-channel record: step height and open time

Orientation matters. In an **inside-out** patch, pulled off the cell, the cytoplasmic face meets the bath; in an **outside-out** patch, the outer face does. A substance that cannot cross, such as ATP, added to each bath shows which side it acts from. Closures briefer than the recording can resolve vanish from the trace, so openings look longer than they are.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* In an inside-out patch the cytoplasmic face meets the bath; in an outside-out patch the outer face does. Applying a substance that cannot cross the membrane to the bath of each shows which side it acts from. Image: three panels showing a glass pipette sealed to a patch of a cell's membrane, then an inside-out patch whose cytoplasmic face meets the bath, then an outside-out patch whose outer face meets the bath.

### Counting molecules: tracer flux

One carrier moves too few molecules per second to show up as a current step, so carriers are often studied by counting. In a **tracer-flux** experiment you add radiolabelled substrate outside cells or vesicles, stop uptake at timed points by filtering and washing, and count the label inside. The early, straight part of the time course gives the initial rate. Apply the chapter’s signatures to these two invented teaching experiments.

**Does the rate level off?** Two unknown proteins, A and B, are each put into matched vesicles. You measure the initial rate of uptake at six substrate concentrations and subtract the rate into protein-free vesicles.

| Substrate outside (mM) | A: rate (pmol/min) | B: rate (pmol/min) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 0.5 | 20 | 2.5 |
| 1 | 33 | 5 |
| 2 | 50 | 10 |
| 5 | 71 | 25 |
| 10 | 83 | 50 |
| 20 | 91 | 100 |

Look at the last two rows first: doubling substrate from 10 to 20 mM doubles B’s rate but raises A’s by about a tenth.

**Predict.** Which protein behaves like a carrier?

> **Check your prediction.** A. Its rate climbs steeply at first, then levels off toward a ceiling near 100 pmol/min (its Vmax), and it reaches half that ceiling at 2 mM (its Km). This is the Michaelis-Menten curve, v = Vmax[S] / (Km + [S]): once the few binding sites are nearly always occupied, more substrate cannot speed them up. B’s rate stays proportional to concentration across the whole range, which is what a pore or simple diffusion does. Channels can saturate too, but usually only at tens to hundreds of millimolar, while carriers often level off at micromolar to low millimolar substrate.

**Is label going in the same as substrate building up?** Now a third protein, C. Preload one batch of C vesicles with 10 mM unlabelled substrate and leave another batch unloaded. Add 1 mM labelled substrate outside both. After a minute, measure the label inside and, by chemical assay, the *total* substrate inside.

| Vesicles | Label inside | Total substrate inside |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Unloaded | little | little |
| Preloaded with 10 mM | a lot | unchanged |

**Predict.** Label pours into the preloaded vesicles. Are they taking up substrate?

> **Check your prediction.** No. The total inside did not rise. C is swapping: labelled molecules come in as unlabelled ones go out, one for one overall, so the total stays put. At first, label counts only inward traffic; the outgoing molecules were unlabelled, so the counter missed them. The unloaded vesicles take up little label because C moves quickly only when it has something to carry back on the return trip. That is the mark of an **exchanger** (though preloading can also speed up some uniporters; Going deeper, “Trans-stimulation and exchange”).

Did the label enter *against* a gradient, 1 mM outside and 10 mM inside? At first, no. Labelled molecules have a gradient of their own, 1 mM outside and none inside, and they ran down it. Given time, an exchanger can even pile label up inside well above 1 mM, the classic counterflow test for a carrier, because each labelled molecule that enters is paid for by an unlabelled one leaving down its own gradient.

A carrier’s Km is not a simple binding constant (Going deeper, “Km is not a binding constant”).

### Family does not decide mechanism

Cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR), the chloride channel mutated in cystic fibrosis, belongs to the ABC family, most of whose members are ATP-driven transporters, yet it is a channel. It still binds and splits ATP, but to open and close its gate, not to push chloride uphill: chloride flows through it downhill. The reverse surprise came in the ClC family of chloride channels: its bacterial member ClC-ec1, from *E. coli*, proved in reconstituted vesicles to be a carrier that exchanges protons for chloride. Only functional tests like those above decide.

### Design problem

You inject RNA for an unknown membrane protein, Q, into [Xenopus oocytes](https://stemhop.com/methods/heterologous-expression/), and the oocytes become more permeable to chloride. Oocytes have chloride channels of their own. Is Q itself a chloride pore, or a protein that switches on an endogenous channel? And how would you tell whether Q is a channel or a carrier?

> **One way to do it.** Start with controls: compare Q-injected oocytes with oocytes injected with the same volume of water, from the same frog and on the same day, so that any change can be traced to expressing Q. That alone does not make Q the pore: high expression of many foreign membrane proteins switches on the oocyte’s own chloride current.
>
> Then take Q out of the oocyte. Purify it, put it into lipid vesicles and fuse them with a planar bilayer. If chloride current appears with purified Q and no other protein, Q is enough to form the pathway. This is how Christine Bear, John Riordan and colleagues showed in 1992 that purified CFTR is itself a regulated chloride channel.
>
> Next, look for single-channel events: square current steps of fixed height whose reversal potential (the voltage at which the current changes direction) tracks ECl as you change chloride on one side. Then mutate residues you suspect line the pore. If a mutation changes the unitary conductance or which anions pass, Q most likely forms the pore. A mutation that changes only Po is consistent with Q being a regulator, or a channel whose gating you hit, so it decides less.
>
> To separate a channel from a carrier, weigh rate, saturation, discrete unitary events, and exchange (does chloride entry need another ion leaving?). Remember ClC-ec1: a family name will not answer this for you.

## Going deeper

### 58 or 61.5 mV per tenfold

Using base-10 logs gives the same EK as the worked problem: 61.5 mV × log10(5/140) = 61.5 × (−1.447) = −89.0 mV, the small difference being rounding. Many books quote 58 mV per tenfold change in concentration. That figure holds near room temperature. At 37 °C it is 61.5 mV.

### Resting with several ions

With two ions, in the simple conductance picture (passive currents only, no pump current), the resting potential sits nearer the equilibrium potential of the ion with the larger conductance. With three or more, that can fail: if a second ion’s conductance nearly matches potassium’s and a third ion pulls the same way, the voltage can end up nearer the second ion’s equilibrium potential than EK, as [the resting membrane](https://stemhop.com/lessons/resting-membrane-passive/) works through.

### The pump’s bill

At −70 mV, with the lesson’s teaching values, pushing Na+ out costs about +13.2 kJ/mol (the two-push example, reversed) and bringing K+ in +1.84 kJ/mol. Three Na+ out and two K+ in cost about 3 × 13.2 + 2 × 1.84 ≈ +43 kJ/mol. Splitting ATP in a cell releases roughly 50 to 60 kJ/mol, so the coupled total is downhill, with a margin, as the rule requires.

### Km is not a binding constant

A carrier’s Km depends on the conditions on the far side (trans conditions), on the membrane voltage and on any coupled ion. Different protocols, such as zero-trans uptake (nothing inside to start) and equilibrium exchange (the same substrate on both sides), give different values for the same protein.

### Trans-stimulation and exchange

The preloaded-vesicle test above read fast label entry as exchange. A uniporter whose empty return step is slow also speeds up when preloaded, so faster label entry into preloaded vesicles alone does not prove an obligate exchanger. Exchange and net flux can even be pulled apart within one protein: in 2023 a study of the E. coli carrier DgoT found a mutant, E133Q (glutamate 133 replaced by glutamine), that kept robust substrate exchange although Glu133 is needed for net flux.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/membrane-transport/
