# Meiosis and Variation

> Meiosis separates homologous pairs first, then sister chromatids, while crossing over and assortment remix alleles. Follow one model cell through both divisions, test how chromosome pairs can line up, calculate the combinations, and use crossover measurements to explain why siblings inherit different mixes.

Course: Biology (DNA and inheritance). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/meiosis-and-variation/

Builds on: The Cell Cycle and Mitosis · DNA: Structure and Copying

## What you'll learn

- You will explain that meiosis makes sex cells (gametes) with half the parent’s chromosomes, one from each pair, through two divisions: the first separates the two chromosomes of each pair and the second separates the copies, giving four cells.
- You will explain how crossing over (in the first division) and the independent assortment of chromosome pairs make new combinations of alleles, and calculate the number of chromosome combinations as 2 to the power n.
- You will compare mitosis and meiosis (purpose, number of divisions, number and kind of cells made, genetic sameness), and explain why genetic diversity helps a population survive a changing environment.

The first film tracked the chromosomes. Now ask: how can siblings each get half from each parent, but not the same half?

> **The one idea.** Meiosis separates homologous pairs first, then sister chromatids, while crossing over and assortment remix alleles.
>
> *Scope:* in animals the products become gametes; in plants they become spores that later make gametes. In human egg formation only one product becomes the egg; the small cells beside it, called **polar bodies**, do not. Mutation, not meiosis, creates new alleles.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Meiosis is just mitosis done twice. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** In meiosis the DNA is copied once, then the cell divides twice. The first division does something mitosis never does: it pulls apart the two chromosomes of each pair. Biologists see this in stained cells under the microscope, and DNA studies of single sperm and eggs confirm which chromosomes ended up where. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** In meiosis the DNA is copied once, then the cell divides twice. The first division does something mitosis never does: it pulls apart the two chromosomes of each pair. Biologists see this in stained cells under the microscope, and DNA studies of single sperm and eggs confirm which chromosomes ended up where.
2. Children get exactly half their traits from each parent, so they look half like each. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Each parent gives half of their chromosomes, but traits are not split into neat halves. Many traits, like height, depend on many genes and on the environment. Some alleles also hide others. So a child can look much more like one parent in one feature and like the other in another. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Each parent gives half of their chromosomes, but traits are not split into neat halves. Many traits, like height, depend on many genes and on the environment. Some alleles also hide others. So a child can look much more like one parent in one feature and like the other in another.
3. Sex cells have the same number of chromosomes as body cells. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Counting chromosomes in human cells shows 46 in a typical body cell and 23 in a typical egg or sperm. If sex cells had 46, a fertilized egg would have 92, and the number would double every generation. Halving before fertilization keeps the number the same. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Counting chromosomes in human cells shows 46 in a typical body cell and 23 in a typical egg or sperm. If sex cells had 46, a fertilized egg would have 92, and the number would double every generation. Halving before fertilization keeps the number the same.

## Explore: shuffle chromosomes in a model cell

The meiosis shuffler runs a model cell with two or three chromosome pairs. One chromosome of each pair is colored for the mother and one for the father. A side panel runs mitosis for comparison.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Meiosis shuffler — two divisions, new mixes

**Try this.**

1. Predict how many chromosomes each new cell will have after meiosis. Run both divisions and count.
2. With two pairs and crossing over off, predict how many different sex cells are possible. Try every way the pairs can line up, then do the same with three pairs.
3. Turn crossing over on. Predict whether the number of different sex cells will go up, go down or stay the same. Then run it several times.
4. Run the mitosis panel. Predict whether its two cells will match each other, then check.

## Explain: two divisions make half

- meiosis
- gamete
- homologous chromosomes
- diploid
- haploid
- sister chromatids
- allele
- crossing over
- independent assortment
- fertilization
- genetic diversity

A typical cell in your body has 46 chromosomes, in 23 pairs. You got one chromosome of each pair from your mother and one from your father. The two chromosomes of a pair are **homologous chromosomes**: they carry the same genes in the same order but may carry different versions. An **allele** is one version of a gene, such as an allele for purple or white flowers in a pea plant.

A cell with two sets of chromosomes, one set from each parent, is **diploid**. A cell with one set is **haploid**. A **gamete** is a sex cell, an egg or a sperm, and in humans it is haploid, with 23 chromosomes.

**Meiosis** makes haploid cells from a diploid cell. Before it starts, the cell copies its DNA once. Each chromosome is then two **sister chromatids**, identical copies joined together (until crossing over, below, exchanges pieces with the paired chromosome).

**Predict.** A model cell starts with six chromosomes in three pairs. Just after DNA copying, how many chromosomes and how many chromatids are present?

> **Check your prediction.** There are still six chromosomes because joined sister chromatids count as one chromosome. There are 12 chromatids.

This table tracks what stays joined, to prevent the common counting mistake.

| Moment | What separates | What each cell holds afterward |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Meiosis I | The two homologous chromosomes of each pair | One chromosome from each pair, still made of joined sister chromatids |
| Meiosis II | The sister chromatids | One chromosome from each pair; no DNA copying occurred between divisions |

The simple model usually ends with four such cells.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge sister chromatidshomologous chromosomesMeiosis IMeiosis IIhaploid blankblankMeiosis IMeiosis IIblank Word

Beyond the first film’s notes on eggs and plant spores, two refinements: in males, the X and Y match only near their ends, yet still pair; and the human egg pauses during meiosis II and finishes only after a sperm enters.

**Fertilization** is when an egg and a sperm join. Their two sets of 23 make a diploid cell with 46 again. A sex cell gets only one chromosome from each pair. So if a parent has two different alleles of a gene, each sex cell has a 50 percent chance of getting either one.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Halving and restoring: meiosis turns 46 chromosomes into 23 in each sex cell, and fertilization brings the number back to 46. In a woman the divisions are uneven and make one large egg. Image: a loop in which a diploid cell from the mother and a diploid cell from the father each go through meiosis to make an egg and a sperm, which join at fertilization into one fertilized egg. An inset shows one large egg beside three small polar bodies.

**Key idea:**

Meiosis copies the DNA once and divides twice, first separating the pairs and then the copies, so each sex cell gets one chromosome from each pair.

That 50 percent chance holds separately for every pair. So why do two sex cells from the same parent rarely match? The second film shows two ways meiosis remixes alleles.

**Film transcript: How Meiosis Remixes Alleles**

### Film transcript: How Meiosis Remixes Alleles

The first film made haploid cells by separating homologous pairs first, then sister chromatids. Why do those cells carry different allele mixes? Return to the same model. Green chromosomes came from one parent, and orange chromosomes came from the other. Each homolog carries the same genes in matching positions, but its alleles may differ. Copying makes sister chromatids. The homologs then lie side by side during the first division, placing matching DNA regions beside each other. Crossing over exchanges matching pieces between non-sister chromatids of paired homologs. Watch two chromatids cross, break at matching positions, and reconnect. Each changed chromatid now carries green and orange sections, combining alleles from that parent's parents.

A second process mixes whole chromosomes. Each homologous pair can face either direction before it separates. One pair's direction does not direct another pair. This is independent assortment: every pair adds another either-or choice. Look at these paired chromosomes. The long green homolog and short orange homolog face the same pole. If only the short pair flips, which chromosome mix will enter that side? Predict before the arrows move.

After the short pair flips, green from both pairs faces the left side. Separation sends that new whole-chromosome mix left. Changing one pair changed the outcome, while every final cell still receives a member of each pair. The count grows by doubling. For each pair, a gamete can receive either homolog. Each added pair doubles the running count across many separate meioses. The screen shows the computed pattern. Crossing over adds more combinations within those whole chromosomes. The doubling rule counts whole chromosomes and ignores crossing over. It also has a limit for genes. Genes close together on one chromosome tend to travel together. Independent assortment applies to genes on different chromosomes.

Meiosis separates homologous pairs first, then sister chromatids, while crossing over and assortment remix alleles. Crossing over remixes chromosome sections. Assortment remixes whole chromosomes. Fertilization then joins independently made egg and sperm cells, usually giving siblings different combinations. The variation is not a promise that every individual survives. It gives a population more allele combinations. When conditions change, some combinations may work better than others.

Diversity raises the chance that some members survive and reproduce; it does not guarantee survival.

From the film

- Meiosis separates homologous pairs first, then sister chromatids, while crossing over and assortment remix alleles.
- Crossing over exchanges matching pieces between non-sister chromatids of paired homologs.
- Independent assortment gives two choices per pair, or 2 to the power n combinations.
- Genes close together on one chromosome tend to travel together.

## Explain: count the mixes

The second film showed both. In **crossing over**, non-sister chromatids of paired homologous chromosomes exchange matching pieces during meiosis I. In **independent assortment**, each pair lines up and separates on its own, whatever the other pairs do. It did not show how often crossing over happens. Studies reading single human sperm found donor averages of about 22 to 28 crossovers per sperm, counted on the 22 non-sex chromosomes.

Its tree gave 8 combinations for three pairs, because each pair doubles the count.

**Predict.** With five pairs, how many combinations are possible?

> **Check your prediction.** Thirty-two. Five doublings give 2 × 2 × 2 × 2 × 2 = 2⁵ = 32.

> number of chromosome combinations in a sex cell = 2ⁿ, where n is the number of chromosome pairs

For humans, n = 23, so one parent can make 2²³ = 8,388,608, or about 8.4 million, whole-chromosome combinations. Two parents together give 8,388,608 × 8,388,608, more than 70 trillion pairings from shuffling alone. These are possibilities across many meioses, not children anyone could have, and they ignore crossing over, which adds far more. So siblings almost never get the same mix unless they are identical twins.

The second film’s limit still holds: 2ⁿ counts whole chromosomes. Genes close together on one chromosome tend to travel together, so independent assortment applies to genes on different chromosomes.

**Key idea:**

Crossing over swaps pieces between paired chromosomes, and independent assortment shuffles the pairs, so nearly every sex cell carries a new mix of alleles.

## Explain: mitosis and meiosis side by side

You met **mitosis**, the division that makes two cells with the same chromosomes as the parent cell, in [The Cell Cycle and Mitosis](https://stemhop.com/lessons/cell-cycle-and-mitosis/).

|  | Mitosis | Meiosis |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Purpose | Growth, repair, asexual reproduction | Making gametes (in animals) |
| DNA copied | Once | Once |
| Divisions | One | Two |
| Cells made | Usually two | Usually four (one egg in females) |
| Chromosome sets | Diploid stays diploid | Diploid becomes haploid |
| Genetic sameness | Cells match the parent cell | Each cell is a new mix |

The “match” in mitosis is close, not perfect: rare copying mistakes, called mutations, can change a cell’s DNA. Mutations make new alleles; crossing over and shuffling mix them into new combinations.

Asexual reproduction, with one parent and mitosis-like division, makes offspring that are genetically the same as the parent. Sexual reproduction makes offspring that differ. **Genetic diversity** is the variety of alleles and allele combinations in a population. As the second film showed, when conditions change it raises the chance that some members survive and reproduce, but it does not guarantee survival. Selection acts on individuals; diversity describes the population.

**Predict.** Would sexual reproduction help a population whose environment stays comfortable and never changes?

> **Check your prediction.** Not necessarily. In a 2012 experiment, sexual yeast populations adapted more than asexual ones at a stressful 37 °C with added salt, but at a comfortable 30 °C sex gave no overall advantage.

**Key idea:**

Mitosis makes two matching cells for growth and repair; meiosis makes four varied haploid cells, and that variety helps a population face a changing environment.

## Elaborate: count the combinations

The first four rows are calculated with 2ⁿ from known chromosome numbers. The last four are measured crossovers in human sex cells.

| What is counted | n (pairs) | Value | Units |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Pea, chromosome combinations | 7 | 128 | combinations per sex cell (calculated) |
| Fruit fly, chromosome combinations | 4 | 16 | combinations per sex cell (calculated) |
| Human, chromosome combinations | 23 | 8,388,608 | combinations per sex cell (calculated) |
| Dog, chromosome combinations | 39 | 549,755,813,888 | combinations per sex cell (calculated) |
| Human sperm, one donor (Lu, 2012) | 23 | about 26.0 | crossovers per sperm, average |
| Human eggs and embryos (Ottolini, 2015) | 23 | 41.6 (standard deviation 11.3, 51 samples) | maternal crossovers per egg or embryo, average |
| Human sperm, lowest donor average (Bell, 2020) | 23 | 22.2 | crossovers per sperm |
| Human sperm, highest donor average (Bell, 2020) | 23 | 28.1 | crossovers per sperm |

Sources: chromosome numbers from the National Human Genome Research Institute chromosomes fact sheet (updated 2020) and, for pea, Yang and colleagues, Nature Genetics (2022). Crossovers: Lu and colleagues, Science (2012), 99 sperm from one man in his late forties (the 26.0 average counts crossovers on the 22 non-sex chromosomes, in the sperm that carried a complete set of chromosomes); Ottolini and colleagues, Nature Genetics (2015), eggs and early IVF embryos; Bell and colleagues, Nature (2020), 31,228 sperm from 20 donors, also counting crossovers on the 22 non-sex chromosomes. The studies used different people and methods, so they are not a controlled egg-versus-sperm comparison.

1. A dog has 39 pairs and a human has 23. How many more pairs does the dog have, and about how many times more combinations does that give?
2. Compare the egg average with the sperm averages. Which is higher, and by about how much?
3. The Bell donor averages range from 22.2 to 28.1. What does that range tell you that the single Lu value cannot?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question, using the combinations and crossover data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: Siblings differ because blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: Shuffling 23 pairs alone gives each parent blank combinations, and a typical sex cell also carries about blank crossovers.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: Each child comes from a different egg and a different sperm, and because blank, those cells almost never carry the same mix.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Siblings differ because each one grows from a different egg and sperm, and meiosis makes each sex cell a new mix. Shuffling the 23 pairs alone gives each parent 8,388,608 combinations. Crossing over adds more: a study of one man counted about 26 crossovers per sperm, and a study of eggs and early embryos found an average of 41.6 maternal crossovers each. So two siblings almost never get the same chromosomes. The limits matter: 2ⁿ is a calculation that treats every chromosome as different, and the crossover numbers come from small samples, including just one sperm donor.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Does sexual reproduction help a population adapt to a harsh environment? Plan a lab investigation with yeast, which can reproduce with or without meiosis. Name your variables, constants, controls, sample size and repeated trials, and say how you will stay safe.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Do yeast populations that go through meiosis and mating adapt faster to a hot, salty environment than populations that cannot?
> - **Independent variable:** whether the population can reproduce sexually. Use a strain that can and a closely matched strain that cannot.
> - **Dependent variable:** fitness after many generations, measured by growing each evolved population mixed with its ancestor and seeing which one increases.
> - **Constants:** the same growth medium, number of generations, number and timing of starvation rounds that trigger meiosis and spore formation, and transfer schedule.
> - **Controls:** run both kinds of population in a comfortable environment too, so you can tell whether the benefit depends on the environment. Also keep frozen ancestors to compare against.
> - **Sample size and trials:** several separate populations of each kind in each environment, since one population can change by chance.
> - **Safety:** use lab yeast strains, wear goggles, handle heat and sterilizing equipment with your teacher, and follow the lab’s rules for disposing of cultures.
>
> A larger gain for the sexual populations only in the harsh environment would support the idea that sex helps most when conditions are harsh. Both environments stay the same throughout, so this design does not test a changing environment. In the real experiment, the authors thought sex helped by combining new helpful mutations and separating them from harmful ones.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Brothers and sisters differ because each grows from a different egg and a different sperm. Meiosis separates homologous pairs first, then sister chromatids, while crossing over and assortment remix alleles, so every sex cell is a new mix; shuffling the 23 pairs alone gives millions of combinations. Identical twins come from one fertilized egg, which is why they match so closely.

**Science practices you used:** making predictions and testing them with a model, calculating combinations with a formula, reading a table of measured averages and ranges, planning a fair test with controls and repeated trials, and naming the limits of a model and of small samples.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/meiosis-and-variation/
