# Living Together: Symbiosis

> Sort symbiosis by what each partner gains or loses. You test pairs of species in a model, use that rule to sort Virginia examples, and read real data on marigolds grown with and without a root fungus. Afterwards you can name each kind of symbiosis and support a claim with evidence.

Course: Life Science (Living together). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/living-together-symbiosis/

Builds on: Producers, Consumers and Decomposers · Predators and Prey

## What you'll learn

- You will explain symbiosis as a close relationship between individuals of different species living together, and how living together can help, harm or leave each partner unaffected.
- You will use the three kinds of symbiosis (mutualism, commensalism and parasitism) to sort Virginia examples.
- You will read growth data for plants grown with and without a fungus partner and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, about which kind of symbiosis it shows.

Use the outcome key from the first film on any close partnership.

**The one idea:**

Sort symbiosis by what each partner gains or loses.

**Scope:**

use this rule for close relationships between individuals of different species living together, not for brief meetings such as a predator catching prey.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Symbiosis always means both partners are helped. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Scientists sort close partnerships by what each partner gains or loses. In some, both gain. In others, one gains and the other is not affected. In others, one gains and the other is harmed. All three count as symbiosis. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Scientists sort close partnerships by what each partner gains or loses. In some, both gain. In others, one gains and the other is not affected. In others, one gains and the other is harmed. All three count as symbiosis.
2. Parasites always kill their hosts quickly. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** A parasite does not have to kill its host quickly. A tick can stay attached to a living deer or person and feed for days. If a host dies, a parasite that lives on it can lose its home and its food. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** A parasite does not have to kill its host quickly. A tick can stay attached to a living deer or person and feed for days. If a host dies, a parasite that lives on it can lose its home and its food.
3. Partners help each other on purpose, because they are being kind. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** A fungus and an alga do not choose to be kind. Scientists explain partnerships with survival and reproduction. Partners that lived together survived and had offspring, so the relationship carried on over many generations. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** A fungus and an alga do not choose to be kind. Scientists explain partnerships with survival and reproduction. Partners that lived together survived and had offspring, so the relationship carried on over many generations.

## Explore: test pairs of species

The simulation gives each species a population bar for 20 weeks. Choose whether living together helps, does not affect or harms each species. Then run it and name the relationship. You can also pick a lichen’s fungus and alga, a lichen and tree, or a tick and deer.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Pair up two species: helped, unaffected or harmed

**Predict.** Set both species to harmed. Does that match any of the three kinds in this lesson?

> **Check after you run it.** No. In all three kinds, at least one partner is helped. You will meet their exact definitions next.

Now try a helped–helped pair and a helped–harmed pair. Watch both bars before naming either relationship.

## What the names mean

- symbiosis
- lichen
- mutualism
- commensalism
- parasitism
- host
- parasite

**Symbiosis** is a close relationship between individuals of different species living together, often for a long time.

A **lichen** is a fungus and an alga or a cyanobacterium (a bacterium that can make its own food) living as one body. Beyond the trade the first film showed, the lichen body soaks up water from the air as well as from rain.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge rain and water from the airfungus threadsgreen alga cellssugartree bark blankfungus threadsblankblanktree

The three kinds:

- **Mutualism** is symbiosis in which all the partners benefit.
- **Commensalism** is symbiosis in which one partner benefits and the others are unaffected.
- **Parasitism** is symbiosis in which one partner benefits and the others are harmed.

**Key idea:**

name both partners and record each outcome before choosing a category.

| Virginia example | What happens to partner A? | What happens to partner B? | Kind |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Fungus and alga in a lichen | fungus gets food | alga gets shelter and water | mutualism |
| Fungi on tree roots | fungus gets food from the tree | tree gets minerals from the soil | mutualism |
| Bacteria in soybean root bumps | bacteria get food from the plant | plant gets nitrogen it can use | mutualism |
| Lichen on tree bark | lichen gets a place to live | tree seems unaffected | commensalism |
| Blacklegged tick on a deer | tick gets blood | deer loses blood | parasitism |

The two lichen rows are the first film’s two relationships. Experts say ordinary lichens on bark almost always do not harm the tree. “Seems unaffected” means no one has measured any harm or help. That is why commensalism is hard to prove.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Mutualism helps both partners, commensalism helps one without affecting the other, and parasitism helps one while harming the other. Image: three panels. Soybean roots with small bumps, one zoomed to show bacteria inside, both partners marked as benefiting; lichen patches on the bark of a healthy tree, the lichen benefiting and the tree unaffected; a blacklegged tick attached to a deer's skin, the tick benefiting and the deer harmed.

**Predict.** Bacteria in soybean root bumps get food and turn nitrogen from the air into a form the plant can use. Which kind is this?

> **Check your prediction.** It is mutualism because both partners gain. You met these bacteria in [Nitrogen for Life](https://stemhop.com/lessons/nitrogen-for-life/).

In parasitism, the **host** is the living thing that the other partner lives on or in. The **parasite** benefits by feeding on the host. Blacklegged ticks, like the one in the first film, live in Virginia.

The first film set a parasite beside a predator. The main difference: a parasite usually does not kill its host. Compare them in [Predators and Prey](https://stemhop.com/lessons/predators-and-prey/).

## Why partnerships last

The first film showed that no partner chooses kindness or harm. So how does a partnership carry on? In mutualism, partners that lived together survived and reproduced better than ones that lived apart. So over many generations, the partnership carried on. A parasite can carry on the same way, although its host is harmed.

That is how mutualism supports the survival of both partners. A lichen can grow on bare rock. There, the alga alone might dry out, and the fungus alone would have no food, because no fungus can make its own.

- In a blank, partner A blank and partner B blank, so it is blank.
- This is not blank, because blank.

**Key idea:**

outcomes can keep a relationship going across generations; kindness is not required.

Many plants grow with a fungus on their roots. The fungus brings minerals from soil into roots, and the plant passes food it made to the fungus.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A root fungus can bring minerals to a plant while receiving plant-made food. Image: a potted plant with its roots shown, and a zoomed root tip wrapped in fine fungus threads. One arrow carries minerals from the soil along the threads into the root; another carries food from the root out to the fungus.

That trade is only a prediction until evidence shows the plant really benefits. The second film tests it.

**Film transcript: Does the Fungus Help?**

### Film transcript: Does the Fungus Help?

The first film sorted close partnerships by each partner's outcome. But how can we tell whether a root fungus really helps a plant? We need a fair comparison. The proposed trade is clear. Fungus threads bring minerals from soil into roots. The plant passes food it made to the fungus. That suggests mutualism, but a suggestion is not a measurement. Researchers grew Jubilee marigolds with living root fungus and without it. Matching pots received the same water level. The fungus was the planned difference, so plant growth could be compared fairly. The experiment also tested drought. Less water reduced growth in both groups. That lets us ask whether the fungus benefit appears across the tested conditions, not just once.

After growth, the shoots were cut and dried until their water was gone. Then each shoot was weighed. Drying means water in the shoots cannot confuse the comparison. What pattern would support a plant benefit from the fungus?

Choose before the bars appear: higher dry mass with fungus, equal mass, or lower mass. Across the tested water levels, mean shoot mass was higher with fungus. The paired bars now use the study values shown on screen. Yet the smallest gap could be due to chance. Each bar is a mean, an average for a group. It does not say every plant had that mass. Group averages make the planned comparison visible. Researchers also test whether a gap is larger than expected from chance variation. The smallest gap did not pass that check. The other gaps did in this study. The dry-mass evidence supports a benefit to these marigolds under these greenhouse conditions. It does not show how many plants lived.

It also does not measure the fungus's gain. Other evidence shows root fungi receive plant-made food. Combine that with the plant-growth result, and mutualism fits this case. The claim stays tied to what was tested and measured. A label is never permission to assume the outcome. Another plant, fungus, or condition may give a different result. Compare partners fairly, measure outcomes, and keep every limit attached. Start with the exchange, then ask what the evidence supports for each partner. That turns help, harm, or no measured effect into a testable scientific claim.

From the film

- Sort symbiosis by what each partner gains or loses.
- Compare plants with and without the fungus under the same conditions.
- Dry mass gives evidence about plant growth, not every possible effect.
- Plants with the fungus had more mean shoot mass at every water level, but the smallest gap could be due to chance.
- A result supports a claim only within the conditions tested.

## Evidence: does a root fungus help a plant grow?

Here are the numbers behind the second film’s bars, so you can do the arithmetic it skipped.

| Water given (% of what the soil can hold) | Root fungus | Mean shoot dry mass (g per plant) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 100% | present | 5.29 |
| 100% | absent | 4.44 |
| 75% | present | 4.12 |
| 75% | absent | 3.28 |
| 50% | present | 3.06 |
| 50% | absent | 2.89 |
| 25% | present | 2.62 |
| 25% | absent | 2.01 |

These means come from a drought experiment by Asrar and Elhindi, published in 2011. They grew Jubilee marigolds in a greenhouse at King Saud University in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. Seeds were sown in September 2009. Six weeks after the seedlings moved into pots, the researchers dried and weighed the shoots.

**Predict.** At 25% water, how much more dry mass did plants with fungus have? About what percent more is that than plants without fungus?

> **Work it through.** Difference: 2.62 g minus 2.01 g equals 0.61 g. Percent more: 0.61 divided by 2.01, times 100, is about 30%. The mass without fungus is the comparison, so it belongs in the denominator.

Now repeat the steps.

1. At 75% water, find the difference and percent more with fungus.
2. The gap in grams is largest at 100% water. Work out the percent more at 100% water. Is the percent gap largest there too?

In the authors’ statistics, the smallest gap, 0.17 g at 50% water, could be due to chance. The other three gaps are large enough to trust.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim about which kind of symbiosis the marigold and its root fungus show, using this data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The marigold and the root fungus show blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: At every water level, plants with the fungus had blank shoot mass, for example blank g compared with blank g at 25% water.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This fits blank because the plant blank and the fungus blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** The marigold and its root fungus show mutualism. At every water level, plants with the fungus had more mean shoot mass than plants without it, though the gap at 50% water was too small to be sure of. At 25% water, they had 2.62 g compared with 2.01 g, which is 0.61 g more. So the plant benefited. Other studies show that root fungi receive food from the plant, so the fungus benefits too. One limit: this is one kind of plant in one greenhouse, and the table does not measure the fungus’s gain or how many plants survived.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

**Predict.** Every fungus pot sits by a bright window, while every control pot sits farther away. Can a mass difference be credited to the fungus?

> **Check your prediction.** No. Light and fungus both changed, so either could explain the result. Mix the groups together on the shelf.

Plan a test of whether a root fungus helps bean plants grow. Name the variables, control, constants, number of plants, metric measurement and safety steps.

> **One way to do it.** - Question: do bean plants grow more shoot mass with a root fungus than without one?
> - Independent variable: living root fungus added (a garden-store root fungus powder), or the same powder after an adult has heated it in an oven to kill the fungus.
> - Dependent variable: dry shoot mass in grams after six weeks. Cut the shoots and dry them all the same way in paper bags for about a week. Weigh them on a balance, let them dry two more days, and weigh again; use the mass once it stops changing.
> - Control: pots with the same potting mix and the same amount of the heat-killed powder, so the only difference is living fungus. If you cannot kill the powder, say that you tested the product, not just the fungus.
> - Constants: the same seeds, pot size, amount of potting mix, water, light and temperature. Use a potting mix with little or no added fertilizer, because lots of fertilizer can stop root fungi from helping.
> - Trials: at least 10 pots per group, mixed on the shelf so neither group gets better light. Find each group’s mean.
> - Safety: wear gloves and avoid breathing the powder, follow the label, wash your hands afterward, and never taste anything.
> - What results would mean: a higher mean mass with the fungus supports a benefit to the plant in these conditions. If a teacher has a microscope, check stained roots to see if the fungus grew.

## Going deeper: when the simple model needs refining

The fungus–alga picture can leave members out. In 2016, scientists found yeast cells, another kind of fungus, inside some lichens. They still debate what the yeast does there, how many lichens have it and whether it is a true partner.

The same kind of partnership can also turn out differently for different partners. In a 2022 study, 99 related wheat lines each grew with the same mix of five root fungi for five weeks. Shoot growth ranged from 34% less to 89% more. The fungi raised shoot growth by over 10% on average, but only 12 lines differed clearly from no change. The effect must be measured, not assumed.

## Check your thinking

Return to the lichen patch. Inside it, both main partners gain. On the bark, the tree seems unaffected. A tick gains while its host is harmed. In each case, check both outcomes before naming the relationship.

**Science practices you used:** testing predictions with a model, sorting examples, finding a difference and a percent in a data table, planning a fair test with a control and many plants, and naming one study’s limits.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/living-together-symbiosis/
