# Living or Not? Viruses and Bacteria

> Bacteria are living cells; viruses are not cells and are classed nonliving. Use the characteristics of life to test that rule, compare the parts of a bacterium and a virus, sort bacteria by how they get energy, and interpret real sizes measured with microscopes.

Course: Biology (Bacteria and viruses). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/living-or-not/

Builds on: One Cell or Many · The Cell Theory and Its Evidence · Respiration and ATP

## What you'll learn

- You will explain why viruses are classed as nonliving infectious agents (they are not cells, have no metabolism of their own, and need a host cell to make copies), while bacteria are living single-celled prokaryotes that carry out life processes themselves.
- You will compare the parts of a virus (DNA or RNA inside a protein capsid, sometimes with a lipid envelope) with the parts of a bacterium (cell membrane, cytoplasm, ribosomes, DNA in a nucleoid, often a cell wall, sometimes flagella) and say what each part does.
- You will sort bacteria by how they get energy (heterotrophs, photoautotrophs, chemoautotrophs) and make, support and evaluate a claim about whether viruses are living, using the characteristics of life.

The first film ended on a rule. Test it against three common ideas, then the simulation.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Viruses are living organisms, just very tiny ones. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Most biology courses, including Virginia’s, class viruses as nonliving infectious agents. A virus is not a cell, has no metabolism of its own, and is copied only inside a host cell. Scientists still discuss the question, because viruses carry genes and change over generations. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Most biology courses, including Virginia’s, class viruses as nonliving infectious agents. A virus is not a cell, has no metabolism of its own, and is copied only inside a host cell. Scientists still discuss the question, because viruses carry genes and change over generations.
2. Viruses are cells, like bacteria but smaller. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Electron microscope images show a virus as a protein coat, often with spikes, that holds its genetic material. There is no cell membrane around cytoplasm, and there are no ribosomes. Some viruses also have a fatty outer layer, but that layer does not make them cells. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Electron microscope images show a virus as a protein coat, often with spikes, that holds its genetic material. There is no cell membrane around cytoplasm, and there are no ribosomes. Some viruses also have a fatty outer layer, but that layer does not make them cells.
3. Bacteria and viruses are the same thing, because both are germs. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Some bacteria and some viruses cause disease, so people call both germs. But a bacterium is a whole living cell that can grow and divide by itself in the right conditions. A virus can only be copied inside a host cell. Most bacteria are also many times larger than most viruses. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Some bacteria and some viruses cause disease, so people call both germs. But a bacterium is a whole living cell that can grow and divide by itself in the right conditions. A virus can only be copied inside a host cell. Most bacteria are also many times larger than most viruses.

## Explore: run the living-or-not checklist

In the simulation, pick a bacterium, a virus outside or inside a cell, a human red blood cell or a salt crystal. Switch on the characteristics it shows, then check your boxes.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Living-or-not checklist

**Predict.** Tick the boxes for a virus outside a cell, then for a virus inside one. Which box changes, and does that change make the virus alive?

> **Check your prediction.** The reproduce box changes to “only with a host cell,” because new viruses are built only inside a host cell. The cell and metabolism boxes stay unmet, so the classification does not change.

## Explain: what counts as alive

- virus
- host cell
- capsid
- envelope
- prokaryote
- nucleoid
- ribosome
- cell wall
- flagellum
- heterotroph
- photoautotroph
- chemoautotroph

The first film’s characteristics of life make a checklist. Living things:

- are made of one or more cells
- take in and use energy (all the chemical reactions that do this are called **metabolism**)
- grow and develop
- respond to their surroundings
- keep their inside conditions steady
- reproduce
- change over many generations (evolve)

As the first film’s red blood cell and crystal showed, no single box decides it. The key evidence here is different. A bacterium is a cell with its own ribosomes and metabolism. A virus is not a cell and must use a host cell’s.

A **virus** is an infectious agent made of genetic material inside a protein coat. A **host cell** is the living cell a virus infects; the first film showed it supplying ribosomes, energy and building blocks. Picture a factory running someone else’s blueprints. The picture has one limit. Depending on the virus, either the host’s enzymes or enzymes made from the virus’s own genes copy its genetic material.

**The one idea.** Bacteria are living cells; viruses are not cells and are classed nonliving. A virus has no metabolism of its own, and new copies are built only inside a host cell.

**Scope:** this is the classification in Virginia’s Biology standards (the SOL). Scientists still discuss definitions of life, and some living bacteria also depend on host cells, so needing a host does not decide the case by itself.

Many scientists agree, though viruses carry genes and evolve, and some giant viruses carry more than a thousand genes. Under a definition based on cells and metabolism, they are nonliving.

If a virus can carry that many genes, genes cannot be what separates it from a bacterium. The second film opens both to find what does.

**Film transcript: Parts Reveal the Difference**

### Film transcript: Parts Reveal the Difference

The first film classified bacteria and viruses by what they can do. If both carry genes, why can a bacterium grow while a virus waits? Open them and follow the work. Start with the bacterium, a prokaryotic cell. Its membrane controls what enters and leaves.

Cytoplasm fills the inside. Ribosomes build proteins from instructions in DNA. That DNA sits in a nucleoid, a region without a membrane. Many bacteria also have a cell wall that helps prevent bursting when water enters. Some have a capsule outside. Some have flagella that spin to push them through water. These parts vary, but the working cell remains. Now open the virus. Its DNA or RNA sits inside a protein capsid. Some viruses add a lipid envelope outside. There is no cytoplasm and no ribosome workbench. A host cell must build every viral protein. Genes are the shared part, not proof that both are cells. The bacterium reads its genes with its own ribosomes.

Viral genes can be read only after they reach a suitable host cell. A working cell also needs energy and carbon. Energy powers the work. Carbon supplies material for new parts. For a useful first model, sort bacteria into common patterns by where those inputs come from. Heterotrophs take in carbon compounds for both energy and carbon.

Photoautotrophs use light for energy and carbon dioxide for carbon. Chemoautotrophs use chemicals for energy and carbon dioxide for carbon. Predict the pattern in a dark spring. The bacterium uses sulfur compounds for energy and carbon dioxide for carbon. Which name fits, and which input tells you?

Chemoautotroph fits. Chemical energy selects chemo, and carbon dioxide supplies the carbon. The model is a simplification. Energy source and carbon source are separate questions, and a few bacteria mix the patterns. Dependence alone does not make a cell nonliving. Some bacteria grow only inside other cells, yet keep ribosomes and metabolism.

Viruses remain different because they are not cells and have no ribosomes of their own. Size does not decide the case either. Most viruses are smaller than typical bacteria. But some giant viruses are longer than small bacteria, so that shortcut breaks. Parts and work matter more than length. The comparison now has a reason. Bacterial parts let the cell obtain inputs and build proteins.

Viral parts carry genes between hosts. Bacteria are living cells; viruses are not cells and are classed nonliving.

From the film

- Bacteria are living cells; viruses are not cells and are classed nonliving.
- A bacterium has a membrane, cytoplasm, ribosomes and DNA in a nucleoid.
- A virus has DNA or RNA in a capsid, sometimes inside an envelope.
- Bacteria can get energy from carbon compounds, light or chemicals.
- Size does not decide whether something is living.

## Explain: parts reveal the difference

The second film opened both; this table lines up each part with its job. Bacteria are **prokaryotes**: one-celled living things with no nucleus and, typically, no membrane-covered organelles. Your cells are **eukaryotes**, which usually have a nucleus; mature red blood cells lose theirs. [One Cell or Many](https://stemhop.com/lessons/one-cell-or-many/) compares them.

| Part | Typical bacterium | Virus | What the part does |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Genetic material | DNA in the **nucleoid**, a region with no membrane around it | DNA or RNA, inside the capsid | Carries the instructions |
| Coat | Cell membrane around cytoplasm | **Capsid**, a protein coat | Membrane controls what enters and leaves; capsid protects the genes |
| **Ribosomes** | Yes | No | Build proteins; a virus uses the host cell’s |
| **Cell wall** | Often | No | Helps keep the cell from bursting when water rushes in |
| Outer layer | Some have a capsule | Some have an **envelope**, a fatty layer outside the capsid | Envelope helps some viruses enter cells |
| **Flagellum** (plural flagella) | Sometimes | No | A corkscrew-shaped tail that spins to push the cell through water |

Viruses infect all the main kinds of living thing: bacteria, archaea, plants, animals, fungi and protists. A virus that infects bacteria is called a phage. Each virus can enter only certain cells, because proteins on its surface must fit receptors on the host cell.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge cell wallribosomesnucleoidflagellumcapsidenvelope cell wallblankblankflagellumblankblank Word bank: capsi

**Key idea:**

a bacterium has all the parts of a living cell, while a virus is genetic material in a protein capsid, sometimes inside an envelope.

## Explain: three bacterial energy patterns

Every living cell needs energy to do work and carbon to build its parts. The table adds an example of each pattern from the second film.

| Group | Energy comes from | Carbon comes from | Example |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **Heterotroph** | Carbon compounds it takes in | The same compounds | E. coli in your gut; bacteria that decompose dead matter |
| **Photoautotroph** | Light | Carbon dioxide | Cyanobacteria in ponds and oceans |
| **Chemoautotroph** | Chemicals such as sulfur, iron or nitrogen compounds | Carbon dioxide | Bacteria near deep-sea vents and in soil |

**Predict.** Some bacteria use light for energy but take their carbon from other living things. Which row of the table do they fit?

> **Check your prediction.** Neither row fits cleanly: the energy column matches a photoautotroph, the carbon column a heterotroph. Energy source and carbon source are separate questions, so the three groups are a useful simplification.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Bacteria sorted by how they get energy: gold arrows show the energy source and grey-blue arrows the carbon source. Photoautotrophs and chemoautotrophs both take their carbon from carbon dioxide. Image: three labeled panels. Heterotroph: a purple rod-shaped bacterium above gut lining cells, with a gold arrow and a grey-blue arrow both running from the same food particles it takes in. Photoautotroph: a chain of green cells in sunlit water, with a gold arrow from the sun labeled light and a grey-blue arrow from carbon dioxide. Chemoautotroph: a yellow cell on deep-sea vent rock, with a gold arrow from the vent plume labeled chemicals such as sulfur compounds and a grey-blue arrow from carbon dioxide.

The second film’s bacteria that grow only inside other cells include Rickettsia, which cause diseases like Rocky Mountain spotted fever. They are still living cells with their own ribosomes and metabolism, though they take some energy molecules and nutrients from the host. Most bacteria carry out every life process themselves when conditions suit them; fully dried bacteria do not grow. [How Microbes Multiply](https://stemhop.com/lessons/how-microbes-multiply/) shows how bacteria divide.

**Key idea:**

bacteria get energy from carbon compounds (heterotrophs), from light (photoautotrophs) or from chemicals (chemoautotrophs).

## Elaborate: compare real sizes

A micrometer (μm) is a thousandth of a millimeter, and a nanometer (nm) is a thousandth of a micrometer.

| Object and what was measured | Reported size | Size in nanometers (nm) | Kind of sample |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19 virus), spike on the surface | about 9 to 12 nm | 9 to 12 | Virus grown from patient samples, electron microscope |
| SARS-CoV-2, particle diameter | about 60 to 140 nm | 60 to 140 | Virus grown from patient samples, electron microscope |
| Influenza virus, diameter of round particles | 80 to 120 nm | 80 to 120 | Range from a review of studies |
| T4 phage head, after drying | about 75 × 60 nm | 75 × 60 | Atomic force microscope |
| T4 phage head, in liquid | about 100 × 85 nm | 100 × 85 | Atomic force microscope |
| T4 phage, whole particle length | about 200 nm | 200 | Earlier electron microscope work |
| Tupanvirus (a giant virus), average length | about 1.2 μm | 1,200 | Electron microscope |
| E. coli bacterium, length × width | about 2 × 0.5 μm | 2,000 × 500 | Reference size for normal cells |
| Human red blood cell, mean diameter | about 7.5 μm | 7,500 | Medical reference for normal cells |

These values come from different studies, not one experiment. The SARS-CoV-2 sample was virus grown from patients admitted to a Wuhan hospital in December 2019. The sources are Zhu and colleagues (2020), a 2006 influenza review by Machała and Brydak, Kuznetsov, Chang and McPherson (2011), Abrahão and colleagues (2018), Maki and colleagues (2000), and a 1990 medical textbook chapter by Lynch. The last column uses 1 μm = 1,000 nm.

Most viruses are about 20 to 300 nm across. Typical bacteria are about 1 to 5 μm (1,000 to 5,000 nm) long, so they are larger. The two groups overlap only at the extremes. A giant virus such as Tupanvirus is longer than the smallest typical bacteria, and a few bacteria are big enough to see without a microscope.

**Predict.** About how many of the largest round influenza particles (120 nm) fit along an E. coli cell? Convert before dividing.

> **Check your prediction.** Convert 2 μm to 2,000 nm, then divide by 120 nm. The result is about 17. A typical 100 nm particle gives 20.

1. The T4 head measured about 100 × 85 nm in liquid and 75 × 60 nm after drying. Why must a scientist report sample preparation?
2. Tupanvirus is longer than an E. coli cell is wide. Does that make it alive? What evidence matters instead?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: are bacteria and viruses living? Use the characteristics of life and this data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: Bacteria are blank, and viruses are classed as blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: A bacterium has blank and can blank by itself. A virus has only blank, and the table shows it is usually blank than a bacterium.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This matters because living things blank, and a virus can only be copied blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Bacteria are living, and viruses are classed as nonliving. An E. coli cell is a cell with a membrane, cytoplasm and ribosomes, and it can grow and divide by itself in suitable conditions. A virus is genetic material in a protein coat with no ribosomes, and new viruses are built only inside a host cell. The table also shows most viruses are much smaller: an influenza particle is 80 to 120 nm, while E. coli is about 2,000 nm long. Size is not the test, though; the giant Tupanvirus is 1,200 nm and still is not a cell. One limit: these sizes come from different studies and preparations, and the T4 head shrank when dried.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

A jar of pond mud with a loose lid slowly grows dark specks of a mineral. Your partner says living bacteria are making the specks. Plan a test of that claim. Name your groups, what you keep the same, what you measure, how many jars you need, and how you stay safe.

> **One way to do it.** - **Groups:** jars of fresh mud (living microbes present) and jars of the same mud heated in a pressure cooker by your teacher to kill the microbes.
> - **Independent variable:** whether living microbes are present.
> - **Dependent variable:** the area covered by dark specks, measured from photos each week.
> - **Constants:** same amount of mud and water, same temperature, same light, same jar size and same number of weeks.
> - **Repeated trials:** at least three jars in each group, so one odd jar does not decide the result.
> - **Safety:** keep jars closed with a loose lid so gas can escape, wear gloves, never smell or taste the contents, and let your teacher dispose of them. Never grow microbes taken from people.
> - **What would mean what:** specks only in jars with living microbes support the claim. Specks in the heated jars too would point to a chemical reaction that needs no life. Even then, the specks do not prove the bacteria use that chemical for energy. A 2020 study of manganese-forming bacteria answered that by tracing whether carbon from carbon dioxide ended up in new cells.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Return to the switch. The virus there is not a cell and has no metabolism of its own. Only living host cells, such as the cells lining your nose, can build new copies of it. The course answer: bacteria are living cells; viruses are not cells and are classed nonliving.

**Science practices you used:** testing predictions in a model, converting units and comparing sizes in a data table, making a claim from evidence and naming its limits, and planning a fair test with a control group and repeated trials.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/living-or-not/
