# Inherited or Acquired?

> Gene-coded traits can pass on; ordinary changes gained during life, such as scars and learned skills, cannot. Use a garden model and real mouse counts to trace what reaches offspring, see how genes and environment can shape one phenotype together, and explain why a dominant trait can still be rare.

Course: Life Science (Heredity). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/inherited-or-acquired/

Builds on: Predicting Traits with Punnett Squares · Reproduction and Meiosis · DNA: The Code of Life

## What you'll learn

- You will explain that gene-coded traits can pass on, but ordinary changes gained during life cannot, such as scars, injuries, dyed hair, or skills and muscles built by practice in people and other animals.
- You will explain that many traits depend on both genes and the environment, and that dominant tells how an allele shows, not how common it is; Mendel's rules explain how many inherited traits are passed on.
- You will read real data from an experiment that cut the tails off mice for five generations, and a table of how common some traits are, and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, about which traits are inherited and whether dominant traits must be common.

The first film gave one test: trace a characteristic’s cause, then ask whether that cause has a path through genes to the young. Try it on two puzzles. Two cuttings from one hydrangea have the same genes, yet one can bloom blue and the other pink. And doctors think one kind of small extra finger is passed on by a dominant allele, yet it is rare.

**The one idea:** Gene-coded traits can pass on; ordinary changes gained during life cannot.

**Scope:** Ordinary changes gained during life means scars, injuries, dyes, learned skills and muscles built by exercise in people and other animals. The environment can still change the phenotype that a genotype produces. *Going deeper* explains how the rule differs for sex cells, plant cuttings and some effects of a parent’s experiences.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. If a parent builds big muscles at the gym, the baby can be born with big muscles too. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Muscles grow when used, but that change is in muscle cells. A baby grows from an egg and a sperm, and exercise does not change their genes. In breeding studies, injuries to parents did not show up in their young. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Muscles grow when used, but that change is in muscle cells. A baby grows from an egg and a sperm, and exercise does not change their genes. In breeding studies, injuries to parents did not show up in their young.
2. Dominant traits are always more common than recessive traits. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Dominant only means one copy of an allele is enough for the trait to show. It says nothing about how many people have that allele. Counts of real babies show that a trait thought to be passed on by a dominant allele can be rare. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Dominant only means one copy of an allele is enough for the trait to show. It says nothing about how many people have that allele. Counts of real babies show that a trait thought to be passed on by a dominant allele can be rare.
3. A trait comes from your genes or from your environment, but never from both. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Height is a good example. Genes from both parents matter, and so does food while you grow. Gardeners see the same thing in some flowers, where the soil changes a color that the genes make possible. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Height is a good example. Genes from both parents matter, and so does food while you grow. Gardeners see the same thing in some flowers, where the soil changes a color that the genes make possible.

## Explore: grow a garden of genes and soil

In the simulation you grow plants like hydrangeas. A plant carries color alleles, or white alleles that block color, and you set the soil from acidic to less acidic.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Grow a garden of genes and soil

**Try this.**

1. Choose a plant with two color alleles. Move the soil slider and record which flower color shows.
2. Switch to two white alleles. Answer Predict 1, then test it.
3. Dye a parent’s petals, or cut its stem, and grow its seeds. Check several young plants.

> **Predict 1.** Switch to two white alleles. Will moving the soil slider still change the flower color? Give a reason before you test it.

## Explain: what can be passed on

- variation
- inherited trait
- acquired trait
- allele
- genotype
- phenotype
- dominant
- recessive
- environment

Scientists describe living things by features like color, shape, body covering and height. **Variation** is the differences among living things of the same kind.

An **inherited trait** is a trait passed from parents to offspring through genes, such as eye color or the shape of a pea seed. An **acquired trait** is a characteristic a living thing gets during its life, such as a scar, dyed hair, a skill like playing piano, muscles built by exercise, or the language you speak.

The first film showed why an acquired trait stops at the parent. A scar or exercise changes body cells, not the genes in sex cells. The film could not test this. The mouse experiment below tests one narrow part of it: does cutting the parents’ tails change their young’s tails?

- A scar is an blank trait, because it blank.
- Eye color is an blank trait, because it is passed on through blank.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge cut tailsex cellsgenes pass to the youngyoung with full tails cut tailblankblankyoung with full tails Wor

## Explain: genes and environment work together

The **environment** is everything around a living thing that can affect it, such as soil, light, water, food and temperature.

You get one **allele**, or version of a gene, from each parent (review it in [that lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/predicting-traits/)). Your **genotype** is the pair of alleles you have. Your **phenotype** is the trait that shows, such as purple or white flowers.

The first film’s hydrangea cuttings are clones with the same genes. In many kinds, acidic soil lets the roots take up more aluminum, which turns the flowers blue; less acidic soil gives pink. Gardeners measure acidity with soil pH, a number where lower means more acidic.

| Soil pH (Virginia extension guide) | Flower color in color-changing hydrangeas |
| --- | --- |
| About 5.0 to 5.5 | Blue |
| 5.6 to 5.9 | In between |
| Above about 6.0 to 6.5 | Pink |

Some kinds of bigleaf hydrangea stay pink or white in any soil. The genes set which colors are possible, and the soil helps decide which one appears.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* The same genes can produce different flower colors when the soil differs. Image: a hydrangea bush gives two cuttings. One, planted in acidic soil, blooms blue; the other, planted in less acidic soil, blooms pink. A circle zoom shows roots in the acidic soil taking up more aluminum.

People show the same pattern. Your height depends on many genes and on food and health while you grow.

**Key idea:**

Many traits depend on both genes and the environment, so the same genes can give different phenotypes in different places.

Once genes are involved, the next question is how different alleles show. The second film follows it from one individual to a whole group.

**Film transcript: Dominant Is Not Popular**

### Film transcript: Dominant Is Not Popular

The first film traced which changes can reach offspring. If an allele is dominant, must most individuals carry it? Watch a few blue cards move through this group. An allele is a version of a gene. In this simple model, an individual receives one copy from each parent. The pair is its genotype. The trait that appears is its phenotype.

Dominant and recessive describe how the pair of allele copies affects that phenotype. A dominant allele shows its trait even when only one copy is present. A recessive allele shows its trait only when both copies are recessive. So a dominant allele can mask a recessive allele in one individual.

Neither word means stronger, healthier, or better. Only a few blue allele cards are in this group. When one blue card enters a genotype pair, will its trait show? Decide before the window changes. The blue card enters, and the trait shows. That is dominance inside this individual. Yet the population bowl still contains very few blue cards. The rule for showing changed the phenotype window. It did not make the allele common in the group. Now move more blue cards into the bowl without changing the showing rule. The group display rises. Move them out, and it falls. The individual display still follows the allele pair.

Frequency belongs to the group. Dominance belongs to the relationship between alleles. A dominant trait may be common or rare. A recessive trait may also be common or rare. These are separate questions. One asks what an allele does beside another allele. The other asks how many copies exist across a whole group. The everyday word dominant can sound like winning.

Genetics uses it more narrowly. It describes how a phenotype appears when different alleles share a genotype. It does not say one allele will spread, replace another, or become common. Population frequency is a separate pattern to measure. To test a claim about commonness, count traits or alleles in a defined group. To test dominance, follow which phenotypes appear in offspring, as Mendel did with peas. One kind of evidence cannot replace the other. Later courses add inheritance patterns beyond simple dominance. So when you hear dominant, look inside one genotype pair.

Ask whether a copy shows beside a different allele. When you hear common, look across the whole group. Ask how often the allele, or its trait, occurs. Never use one answer for both questions.

From the film

- Dominant tells how an allele shows, not how common it is.
- A dominant allele shows its trait even when only one copy is present.
- A recessive allele shows its trait only when both copies are recessive.
- How common an allele or trait is in a group is separate from dominance.

## Explain: dominant does not mean common

A **dominant** allele shows its trait even when only one copy is present; it masks the recessive one. A **recessive** allele shows its trait only when both copies are recessive. These rules, first worked out with peas by Gregor Mendel, explain how many inherited traits are passed on. Later courses add more patterns.

| Word | What it tells you | What it does not tell you |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Dominant | One copy is enough for the trait to show | How many people have the trait |
| Recessive | Two copies are needed for the trait to show | Whether the trait is rare |

**Key idea:**

Dominant tells how an allele shows, not how common it is. The real counts in the next section measure how common each trait is.

## Elaborate: cut tails and counted traits

Starting in 1887, the German biologist August Weismann cut the tails off white mice and let them breed. He did this to the parents for five generations and looked at the young’s tails.

> **Predict 2.** Suppose a cut tail were inherited more strongly in each generation. In which later groups would you expect changed tails to appear?

| Group of tail-cut parents | Young born | Young with short or abnormal tails |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | 333 | 0 |
| 2 | 237 | 0 |
| 3 | 152 | 0 |
| 4 | 138 | 0 |
| 5 | 41 | 0 |
| Total | 901 | 0 |

Source: August Weismann, Essays upon Heredity, English edition, 1889. He gave totals for each group, not a measurement for each mouse.

> **Predict 3.** Add the young in the five groups. What fraction had short or abnormal tails? Write the fraction before reading the CER model.

| Trait | Allele | How common (per 100 people) | Who was counted |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Small extra finger beside the little finger | Dominant (thought to be) | 0.035 | Babies the study grouped as White, Boston hospital records, 1972 to 2012 |
| Small extra finger beside the little finger | Dominant (thought to be) | 0.91 | Babies the study grouped as Black, same study |
| Rh-negative blood | Recessive | About 15 | People of European ancestry, rough estimate from a 2005 reference book |
| Rh-positive blood | Dominant | About 85 | Same group (100 minus 15) |

Sources: Holmes and colleagues, Birth Defects Research (2018) for the extra-finger rows, and Laura Dean, Blood Groups and Red Cell Antigens (2005) for the Rh rows. These are different groups counted in different ways, so the rows are a rough comparison, not a controlled test.

> **Predict 4.** Compare the 0.035-per-100 extra-finger row with the about-15-per-100 Rh-negative row. Which is more common, and about how many times more common? Is the extra finger rare in the 0.91-per-100 row too? Why is this only a rough comparison?

> **Check your comparison.** Rh-negative blood is about 15 / 0.035, or roughly 430 times, as common as the extra-finger trait in the 0.035 row. Even in the 0.91 row, Rh-negative blood is about 16 times as common, so the dominant trait is rare in both groups. The comparison is only rough because the groups and counting methods differ.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the question: can an injury to parents be inherited by their young? Use the mouse data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that cutting the parents’ tails blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: Out of blank young from five generations, blank had short or abnormal tails.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: If injuries were inherited, we would expect blank. This makes sense because inherited traits pass from parent to young through blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Cutting the parents’ tails did not change the tails of their young. Out of 901 young from five generations of tail-cut parents, 0 had short or abnormal tails. If injuries were inherited, some young should have been born with short tails, at least in the later groups. A cut tail is an acquired change in body cells, and inherited traits pass to the young through the genes in sex cells. One limit is that this is one experiment, on one kind of animal and one kind of injury.

Saved in this browser only.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Now answer the two opening puzzles. The two hydrangea cuttings have the same genes, which allow blue or pink; the soil in each garden decides which color shows. The small extra finger is thought to be passed on by a dominant allele, but few people carry that allele, so the trait is rare.

**Science practices you used:** asking questions about a puzzle, planning a fair test with a control and repeated trials, reading data tables, and making a claim with evidence and reasoning.

### Design problem

Plan an investigation to test whether light changes a trait in plants with the same genes.

> **Predict 5.** Which variable will you change, which measurements will you make, and what must stay the same for a fair test?

> **One way to do it.** **Question:** Do cuttings from one plant grow to the same height in bright light and in shade?
>
> - **Plants:** 10 stem cuttings from one coleus plant, so all have the same genes.
> - **Independent variable:** light. Put 5 pots by a bright window and 5 pots in a shady corner of the same room.
> - **Dependent variables:** height in centimetres and number of leaves, measured each week for 4 weeks.
> - **Constants:** the same pot size, the same soil, the same 50 millilitres of water twice a week, and the same room temperature.
> - **Control:** the bright-window group, which gets normal growing light.
> - **Repeated trials:** 5 cuttings in each group; find the mean height of each group.
> - **Safety:** wash your hands after handling soil. Never put plants in your mouth; some houseplants are harmful if eaten.
>
> If the groups differ, the environment changed the phenotype, since the genes were the same.

## Going deeper

### An old inheritance idea

An old idea, often linked to the naturalist Jean-Baptiste Lamarck, said giraffes stretched their necks and passed longer necks to their young. Scientists do not accept it, because using a body part changes body cells, not the genes in sex cells.

### Plants, sex cells and parents’ experiences

In animals, changes in the DNA of body cells are not passed on, but changes in sex cells can be, as the lesson on [mutations and variation](https://stemhop.com/lessons/mutations-and-variation/) explains. Plants are different: a cutting is made of body cells, so a change in one branch can show up in plants grown from its cuttings. Scientists are also studying whether some experiences, such as a parent’s diet, can affect the young in other ways. That is not the same as passing on a scar or a skill.

### Details of Weismann’s mouse counts

Weismann’s counts are on pages 431 to 433. He bred white mice from 1887 to January 1889. Normal newborn tails were 10.5 to 12 millimetres long.

### Details of the extra-finger counts

The extra-finger study counted extra digits on hands and feet, mostly hands. It covered 289,365 births, stillbirths and pregnancy terminations for fetal anomalies.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/inherited-or-acquired/
