# Habitat and Niche

> Different niches can reduce competition, helping species share a habitat. How can five kinds of insect-eating birds share the same spruce forest? Use a tree model, then read real data on where each kind spent its time. Afterwards you can tell a habitat from a niche and make a careful claim about how the warblers share the forest.

Course: Life Science (Living together). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/habitat-and-niche/

Builds on: Competition and Cooperation · Producers, Consumers and Decomposers · Food Webs and Energy

## What you'll learn

- You will explain the difference between a habitat (the place where an organism lives) and a niche (its role: how it lives and uses resources there).
- You will explain how a niche helps an organism survive, how the amount of food and other resources changes a niche, why heavy niche overlap creates more chances to compete when resources are short, and why different niches can reduce competition.
- You will read MacArthur’s warbler data and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, about how five kinds of warblers share one forest.

**Five kinds of small birds called warblers spend the summer in the same spruce forests of Maine and Vermont. All five eat mostly insects that they pick from the trees.**

In 1956 and 1957, Robert MacArthur watched these birds and timed where they spent their time. If they hunt in the same trees, why does one kind not take all the food? Some of these warblers also pass through Virginia when they migrate. First, decide what you think now.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. A habitat and a niche are the same thing. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** A habitat is the place where an organism lives. A niche is its role there: what it eats, where and when it feeds, and what eats it. Two warblers can live in the same forest, so they share a habitat, but still use it in different ways. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** A habitat is the place where an organism lives. A niche is its role there: what it eats, where and when it feeds, and what eats it. Two warblers can live in the same forest, so they share a habitat, but still use it in different ways.
2. An animal’s niche is just what it eats. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Food is only one part. When scientists timed warblers in spruce trees, the birds differed in where they spent time and how they moved while hunting. Where, when and how an animal feeds, and what eats it, are all part of its niche. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Food is only one part. When scientists timed warblers in spruce trees, the birds differed in where they spent time and how they moved while hunting. Where, when and how an animal feeds, and what eats it, are all part of its niche.
3. Two kinds of animals can live in exactly the same way in the same place with no problem. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** If two species need the same limited food in the same spot, they compete. In a study of warblers, the species used the trees in different but overlapping ways. In a study of barnacles, the larger kind crowded out the smaller kind in many places. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** If two species need the same limited food in the same spot, they compete. In a study of warblers, the species used the trees in different but overlapping ways. In a study of barnacles, the larger kind crowded out the smaller kind in many places.

## Explore: share a tree with five kinds of birds

Now test the first film’s rule in a second model. The spruce has top, middle and lower bands, each with inner and outer branches. You set how many kinds share the tree, from 1 to 5. You also choose whether they feed everywhere or keep to their own zones, and how many insects there are. A bar shows how many insects each kind eats in one sampled day.

**Predict.** At full insect supply, will one kind that feeds everywhere catch as many insects after four more kinds join it?

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Share a tree with warblers

**Try this.**

1. Set five kinds to feed everywhere. Resample several days. Notice which kinds fall short.
2. Give each kind its own zone. Predict how the bars will change, then check.
3. Make insects much lower in both settings. Compare how many kinds fall short.

This model is deliberately simple. Insects begin evenly spread and return at a fixed rate. The birds differ only in where they feed, and there are no predators or migration. Here, a niche means only feeding zones.

## Explain: a place to live and a way to live

- habitat
- niche
- species
- resource
- competition
- biodiversity

The first film named the warblers’ spruce forest their **habitat**, the place where an organism lives. A pond, marsh or rotting log is a habitat too. A **niche** is an organism’s role: how it lives and uses resources there. It includes:

- what it eats
- where and when it feeds
- the space it uses, such as treetops or soil
- what eats it
- what it does in the ecosystem, such as breaking down dead leaves

As a memory aid, think of the habitat as an address and the niche as a job. The comparison breaks down because a niche is more than one job.

**Predict.** A gray squirrel and an earthworm both live in one oak forest. Do they share a habitat, a niche, or both?

In a Virginia oak forest, they share a habitat. The squirrel eats acorns and nuts and buries some in the ground. Hawks and foxes hunt it. The earthworm eats dead leaves and bits of soil and helps break them down, as you saw in [Producers, Consumers and Decomposers](https://stemhop.com/lessons/producers-consumers-decomposers/). Their niches are very different.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* The squirrel and earthworm share an oak forest habitat but use its resources in different ways. Image: a cutaway of an oak forest. Above ground a gray squirrel holds an acorn beside a small hole while a hawk soars overhead and a fox watches from behind a log; below ground an earthworm pulls a dead leaf into its burrow. A gold bracket spans the whole scene.

**Key idea:** A habitat is where an organism lives; a niche is its whole way of living there.

**The one idea:** Different niches can reduce competition, helping species share a habitat.

**Scope:** This rule applies when species share a habitat and need some of the same limited resources. Different niches do not remove all competition. Weather, food supply and how strongly each species competes also matter.

## Explain: a niche helps an organism survive

The first film defined a **resource**: something a living thing needs and takes from its habitat, such as food, water, shelter or space. Part of a niche is how an organism gets them, and the amount of a resource can change a niche. When food is plentiful, an animal may feed in a few favourite spots. When food runs short, it may search more places or eat other things.

**Key idea:**

A niche includes how an organism gets needed resources, and it can shift when resources or conditions change.

## Explain: sharing a habitat

The first film called a **species** one kind of living thing. For animals such as birds, members of one species can breed with each other and have young that can also breed. It called **competition** a struggle for resources in short supply. So a deer and a warbler that share a forest but eat different foods do not compete for food just by living there.

When the shared resource is in short supply, heavy niche overlap creates more chances to compete for it. Species using different places, times or foods may compete less.

**Biodiversity** is the variety of living things in a place. Niche differences can help a habitat support more kinds of living things, but they do not guarantee it.

- The two species share a habitat because blank.
- Their niches are different because blank.
- This may help them share the forest because blank.

**Key idea:**

When resources are short, more niche overlap creates more chances for competition. Different resource use may reduce it.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge top bandmiddle bandlower bandbare inner branch baseouter branch tips top bandmiddle bandblankblankblank W

The figure above is a simplified version of MacArthur’s real zone map. Both models gave each kind its zone by rule, but real birds do not stay inside painted borders. The second film shows how MacArthur filled that map with timed observations.

**Film transcript: Reading the Warblers' Tree Map**

### Film transcript: Reading the Warblers' Tree Map

The film's tree and your simulation both gave each kind its own zone by rule. Did real warblers use spruce trees in different patterns? To find out, keep the same tree and replace imagined paths with recorded observations.

Robert MacArthur divided spruce trees into named zones. Height bands ran down from the treetop. Each branch also had a base, a middle, and outer tips. Using the same map for every bird made their patterns comparable. When MacArthur could see a bird, he timed how long it stayed in each zone. The forest was dense, and birds were often hidden. Many hours of watching produced few useful seconds. Each colored timer fills only while its bird remains visible. For each kind, the recorded seconds became percentages of its total recorded time. Darker zones mean more time there. The maps show different centers of activity, but their colored areas still overlap.

No bird owns a private slice of the tree. Some kinds centered activity high in the tree. Others centered lower, or spread their time more widely. Predict how to read a shared zone. Both kinds clearly have recorded time there. Does that show complete separation, or does it show overlap? Hold your answer while both cells glow.

It shows overlap. Both kinds spent recorded time in that zone. Their percentages can still differ, so overlap does not mean identical use. Read down a column to compare kinds, then read across a row to find each kind's pattern. A large value marks a strong center of activity. Smaller values still matter because they show shared use. Now separate observation from explanation.

The table records time, not insects eaten. Some records were singing birds, not feeding birds. Visibility matters because dense branches can hide birds. Percentages summarize what the observer could record, not everything birds did. The study did not directly measure competition. Different tree use may reduce competition, but the table alone cannot prove that cause. A careful claim keeps those parts apart. The warblers shared a habitat and used it in different, overlapping patterns. That pattern carefully supports a possible explanation for sharing. It remains evidence for the idea, not proof of every step.

From the film

- MacArthur recorded where each kind of warbler spent time in spruce trees.
- The five kinds used different but overlapping patterns of tree zones.
- Recorded time does not show how much food a bird ate or measure competition.
- Different niches can reduce competition, helping species share a habitat.

## Elaborate: where the warblers spent their time

Here are the numbers behind the second film’s zone map. The last column gives the single zone where each kind spent the most recorded time.

| Warbler | Top band, 0 to 6 m (% of time) | Middle band, 6 to 12 m (% of time) | Lower band, 12 to 15 m (% of time) | Lowest zone, below 15 m (% of time) | Most-used single zone (% of time) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Cape May | 92.0 | 4.5 | 0.0 | 3.5 | outer tips, top 3 m: 49.9 |
| Blackburnian | 74.6 | 25.4 | 0.0 | 0.0 | outer tips, top 3 m: 34.8 |
| Black-throated green | 44.6 | 52.8 | 2.6 | 0.0 | outer tips, 6 to 9 m down: 21.8 |
| Bay-breasted | 27.2 | 70.2 | 2.6 | 0.0 | branch middles, 6 to 9 m down: 19.1 |
| Myrtle (yellow-rumped) | 25.0 | 30.8 | 16.5 | 27.7 | lowest zone, below 15 m: 27.7 |

Source: MacArthur, Ecology, 1958, Figures 2 to 6, from summer observations in 1956 and 1957 in spruce forests of Maine and Vermont. Each value is a percent of that species’ recorded time, not of birds. The bands are not equal thirds. Some records were of singing birds, not feeding birds. For bay-breasted warblers, all records in the top 3 m and most in the next 3 m were of singing males. So the table shows where birds spent time, not how much each ate.

**Predict.** Cape May and Blackburnian warblers used the same treetop-tip zone most. How many percentage points apart were their values?

Subtract 34.8 from 49.9 to get 15.1 percentage points. Both values are above zero, so their use overlapped, but Cape May warblers used that zone more.

1. Which kind spent the most time in the middle band? Which kind spread its time most evenly?
2. Which kinds overlapped in the top band? Compare values down that column.
3. Find another pair that differed but still overlapped. Use two numbers.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the question: how can five kinds of insect-eating warblers share one forest? Use the table.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The five warblers can share the forest because blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: Cape May warblers spent blank percent of their time in the top band, while bay-breasted warblers spent blank percent in the middle band.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This supports my claim because blank, which means the birds compete blank for insects. One limit of the data is blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** The five warblers can share the forest because each kind uses the trees in its own pattern. Cape May warblers spent 92.0 percent of their time in the top band, while bay-breasted warblers spent 70.2 percent in the middle band. Using the trees differently may help the birds compete less for the same insects, but the table does not measure competition. It shows where birds spent time, not how much each ate. The patterns still overlap: Cape May and Blackburnian both used the treetop tips most.

Saved in this browser only.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

The five warblers shared one habitat and used it in different but overlapping patterns. The table did not measure competition or food eaten, so it supports a careful explanation, not proof: different niches can reduce competition, helping species share a habitat.

**Science practices you used:** using a model to test a prediction, reading a data table and comparing percents, making a claim backed by evidence and reasoning, and planning a fair investigation.

### Design problem

Plan an investigation to find out whether two kinds of birds in your schoolyard feed at different heights. You will use two bird feeders and a timer, and you will not touch or catch any birds.

**Predict.** If both feeders stayed at the same height, could this investigation test whether feeder height changes visits? Explain.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Do two kinds of birds, such as chickadees and mourning doves, visit a high feeder and a low feeder equally?
> - **Independent variable:** feeder height, 0.5 m or 2.0 m above the ground.
> - **Dependent variable:** the number of visits by each kind of bird in 15 minutes.
> - **Constants:** the same tray feeder that both kinds can use, the same seed mix and amount, the same time of day, and feeders about 3 m apart.
> - **Control:** after 5 of the 10 days, swap which feeder is high and which is low. This helps check that the spot is not causing the difference.
> - **Repeated trials:** watch on 10 different days and find the mean visits for each kind at each height.
> - **Safety:** an adult hangs the feeders. Watch quietly from at least 10 m away or from a window. Never touch birds, nests or droppings, and wash your hands after filling feeders.
>
> If one kind visits the low feeder much more and the other visits the high feeder more, they may use different feeding heights here.

## Going deeper

### Notes on MacArthur’s data

MacArthur’s height zones were 10 feet deep, so the metres in this lesson are converted and rounded. The branch base he mapped was bare or lichen-covered.

Weather could shift tree use. Most of the time, MacArthur’s Cape May warblers fed near the treetops. In cold, wet, windy weather they fed low in willows and cherry trees instead, often among flowers.

### What else may help warblers share a forest

MacArthur thought other things mattered too. The birds also hunted in different ways. Each kind may be held back by food in different forests. Cape May and bay-breasted warblers became common mainly in years with outbreaks of spruce budworm caterpillars. Scientists still debate how much feeding zones explain why these warblers can share a forest. You will see more in [Competition and Cooperation](https://stemhop.com/lessons/competition-and-cooperation/).

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/habitat-and-niche/
