# Gas Exchange and Breathing

> Oxygen and carbon dioxide cross every exchange surface by diffusion alone, so blood that takes up oxygen all along the surface can leave with no higher oxygen partial pressure than the water or air it last touched. This lesson uses Fick's law to explain why exchange surfaces are large, thin and moist, shows how the way water or air flows past the blood sets what it last touches in teleost gills and in the lungs of mammals, birds and alligators, compares skin and insect tracheae, and contrasts how a mammal, a frog and a bird move air. Afterwards you can calculate how area and thickness change a diffusion rate, tell minute from alveolar ventilation, and explain why carbon dioxide, more than oxygen, sets resting breathing in mammals.

Course: Organismal Biology (Supply and exchange). Level: first- and second-year university. About 21 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/gas-exchange/

Builds on: Size, Scale and Surface · What an Organism Has to Do · Tissues, Organs and Homeostasis

## What you'll learn

- Define partial pressure, tell it apart from the amount of oxygen, and use Fick's law (rate proportional to area x partial-pressure difference / barrier thickness) to explain why exchange surfaces are large, thin and moist, and calculate how a change in area and thickness alters the rate.
- Compare gas exchange through the skin (earthworms, amphibians), teleost gills, insect tracheae and lungs, and explain why breathing water is harder than breathing air.
- Distinguish countercurrent exchange in teleost gills, crosscurrent exchange with one-way airflow in bird lungs, and tidal ventilation in mammal lungs, and describe mammalian aspiration against frog buccal pumping.
- Explain how carbon dioxide and pH set resting breathing in mammals while the carotid bodies sense low oxygen, and calculate minute and alveolar ventilation.

**Water holds far less oxygen than air, yet a trout’s gill can send its blood out at a higher oxygen partial pressure than the water leaving it. Your lung cannot do that with air. Why not?**

The first film built the answer from **diffusion**, the net movement of a gas from higher **partial pressure** to lower (the pressure one gas in a mixture would exert alone: PO2 for oxygen, PCO2 for carbon dioxide), and showed that partial pressure is not amount. Vertebrate blood widens that gap: most of its oxygen is bound to haemoglobin, which adds to the amount without raising the PO2. In this lesson “richer” always means higher PO2.

> **The one idea.** Oxygen and carbon dioxide cross every exchange surface only by diffusion, which pulls the blood’s partial pressure toward that of the water or air beside it. So blood that takes up oxygen all along the surface can leave with no higher PO2 than the water or air it last touched, and blood that gives up carbon dioxide all along, with no lower PCO2. Fick’s law (area, thickness) and the flows of blood and of water or air set how close the blood gets; how those flows run past each other sets what it last touches; breathing keeps that water or air fresh.
>
> *Scope:* a ceiling on partial pressure, not total gas, for passive exchange at **steady state** (flows and rates constant), one gas at a time, while the water or air stays richer than the blood beside it all along the contact (lower in PCO2, for carbon dioxide), as in every case here. A small or thick surface, short contact time, mismatched air and blood flow, or blood that bypasses the surface leave real blood below it. When streams that touched different gas mix, as in birds, the ceiling holds for each stream, not the mix.

## Fick’s law: how fast gas crosses

**Predict.** These numbers are invented. Barrier 1 is 50 m2 and 0.5 micrometres thick; barrier 2 is 30 m2 and 1.0 micrometre thick. With the same gas, partial-pressure difference and material, does barrier 2 manage more or less than half of barrier 1’s rate?

> **Check your prediction.** Less than half: 30%, because the lost area and the added thickness multiply.

The rate across a sheet of tissue follows **Fick’s law** (see also [size and scaling](https://stemhop.com/lessons/size-and-scaling/)):

> **rate of gas transfer = k x A x (P1 - P2) / T**

A is the area, P1 - P2 the partial-pressure difference (ΔP), T the barrier thickness, and k a constant for that gas and barrier. For scale, dry air at sea level (about 21% oxygen at about 760 mmHg, 101 kPa) has a PO2 of roughly 160 mmHg (21 kPa).

**Worked problem.**

1. *Ratio.* Rate 2 / Rate 1 = (A2 / A1) x (T1 / T2), since k and ΔP cancel; thickness flips because it sits below the line.
2. *Area.* 30 m2 / 50 m2 = 0.60.
3. *Thickness.* 0.5 micrometres / 1.0 micrometre = 0.50.
4. *Multiply.* 0.60 x 0.50 = 0.30, so 30% remains.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Fick’s law — two barriers compared

## Water or air: skin, gills and tracheae

Water is hard to breathe: air-saturated fresh water at 15 to 20 degrees C holds roughly 30 times less oxygen per litre than air, and it is about 800 times denser and far more viscous, so a gill does more work for less oxygen.

**Skin.** An earthworm exchanges gases across its moist skin. Frogs combine skin and lungs, and adult lungless salamanders (family Plethodontidae) breathe through the skin and mouth lining alone. Skin breathing works where skin stays wet and oxygen demand per unit of surface is modest.

**Gills.** In teleost fish, the large group of bony fishes that includes trout, each gill is folded into filaments carrying thin plates called lamellae: large area, thin barrier. Most teleosts move water one way, in through the mouth and out under the gill cover; tunas ram it through an open mouth as they swim. Blood runs opposite to the water inside each lamella, the **countercurrent exchange** the first film built, which raises the ceiling to the PO2 of the incoming water. Reaching it is another matter.

**Predict.** A trout’s lamellae have plenty of area, but suppose the fish pumps only a trickle of water, carrying less oxygen per minute than the blood could take up. Does countercurrent flow still bring the leaving blood close to the incoming water?

> **Check your prediction.** No. The ceiling is unchanged, but the trickle loses much of its oxygen on the way, so its PO2 falls toward the blood’s before the blood is full. Getting near the incoming water takes both a large, thin surface and a water flow whose oxygen-carrying capacity per minute is at least the blood’s.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* In a teleost lamella blood runs opposite to the water, so a PO2 difference holds along the whole lamella. If the streams ran the same way, their PO2 values would come close to equal partway along, and the rest of the lamella would add little. Image: two flat schematics of a gill lamella. On the left, water flows right while blood flows left inside the lamella and a bracket covers its whole length. On the right, water and blood both flow right and only part of the lamella is marked as still adding transfer.

Blood from a teleost gill goes on to the body in a single circuit, as in [circulation and the heart](https://stemhop.com/lessons/circulation-and-heart/).

**Tracheae.** Most insects carry oxygen in air, not blood: air enters openings called **spiracles** into **tracheae**, branching tubes whose finest branches reach the tissues. Many larger insects pump the abdomen, and in 2003 Mark Westneat and colleagues used synchrotron X-ray imaging to watch tracheae in live beetles, crickets and ants compress and expand rhythmically.

A leaf, by contrast, exchanges gases by diffusion through pores called stomata, with no pump; see [moving water and sugar in plants](https://stemhop.com/lessons/plant-transport/).

## Three lungs: mammal, bird, alligator

A **lung** is an internal, air-filled exchange organ.

**Mammals: tidal.** Air flows in and out through the same airways, **tidal ventilation**, into tiny dead-ended sacs, the **alveoli**. Their PO2 sits near 100 mmHg in a resting adult human, below the roughly 150 mmHg of warmed, humidified inhaled air, for the reasons the first film gave.

**Birds: one way, crosscurrent.** Birds have no diaphragm, and their stiff lungs keep a nearly constant volume and exchange gas in narrow tubes called **parabronchi**. Thin-walled **air sacs** in front of and behind the lungs work as bellows as the sternum and ribs move. Through most parabronchi, air flows the same way during inspiration and expiration, so fresh air keeps arriving at one end.

Capillaries cross the parabronchus at right angles, each at a different point along it: **crosscurrent** exchange. Each capillary can at best match the air at its own point: nearly fresh air near the inflow end, only drained air near the outflow end. When the streams join, their oxygen contents combine, so the mixed blood lands between its richest and poorest streams and can carry a higher PO2 than the air leaving the parabronchi.

**Predict.** Take idealized gill, bird-lung and mammal-lung arrangements. Give each the same incoming PO2 in medium and blood, the same ratio of the medium’s oxygen-carrying capacity per minute to the blood’s, even flow everywhere and no diffusion limit. The first film put the gill above the mammal lung. Where does the bird lung fall, and why?

> **Check your prediction.** Between them. The gill’s leaving blood last touches incoming water; the bird’s, a spread of air from fresh to drained; the mammal’s, mixed alveolar gas. This ranks idealized shapes, not real animals (see Going deeper).

**Alligators: one way, no air sacs.** In 2010 C. G. Farmer and Kent Sanders reported one-way airflow in the bronchi they measured in the American alligator, Alligator mississippiensis, which has no air sacs. Birds and crocodilians are both **archosaurs**, the reptile group that holds them and their extinct relatives, and the shared trait fits inheritance from a common ancestor without proving it. Later work found one-way flow in monitor lizards and green iguanas too, so the trait may be older than archosaurs, or may have evolved more than once; see [reading phylogenetic trees](https://stemhop.com/lessons/reading-phylogenetic-trees/).

So air moves one way through most bird parabronchi and the alligator bronchi measured so far, while a mammal’s alveoli are dead ends whose gas depends on how much fresh air each breath delivers. One reminder of the rule: blood can at best match the gas it last touched, so a surface works only while that gas is renewed. The second film follows one breath in.

**Film transcript: Keeping the Gas Fresh**

### Film transcript: Keeping the Gas Fresh

Two people move the same total air each minute. So why is one of them building up carbon dioxide while the other is not? The first film ended at a dead-ended sac, the alveolus. Blood can at best match the gas inside it. Blood flow keeps bringing new blood. But the gas must be renewed too, through the airways. So what keeps moving fresh air in? A mammal pulls air in. The diaphragm, a dome of muscle under the lungs, contracts and flattens. The chest enlarges, pressure in the lungs falls, and air flows in. This is aspiration. But a tube leads to the sac. The airways, from nose and mouth down to the smallest bronchioles with no alveoli, exchange nothing. They are dead space.

So the first air into the sac each breath is stale air left in the tube. And fresh air still in the tube when you stop breathing in is breathed out unused. Take slow, deep breaths. Each breath clears the dead space and sends a large fresh portion into the sac. The total air moved each minute is minute ventilation. The fresh part reaching the alveoli is alveolar ventilation. Now keep the total air per minute the same, but take smaller, faster breaths. Does carbon dioxide in the sac rise, fall or stay the same?

It rises. Each small breath barely clears the dead space. Less fresh air reaches the sac, while the body makes carbon dioxide as fast as before. Here the first film's rule runs in reverse. Blood giving up carbon dioxide leaves with no lower partial pressure than the gas it last touched. So the blood's carbon dioxide climbs with the sac's. The brainstem watches that result. Carbon dioxide crosses into the brain's fluid and lowers its pH.

Sensors near the brainstem surface detect the fall, and the drive to breathe rises. Haldane and Priestley sampled the last of a forced breath out. In resting subjects, a small rise in alveolar carbon dioxide greatly increased breathing. Lowering oxygen did little until it fell far. So breathing keeps the gas the blood touches fresh. At rest, a mammal's controller mostly reads carbon dioxide. That level is the result of its own breathing, set against the body's carbon dioxide output. Too little fresh air, and carbon dioxide climbs. The sensors then push breathing back up.

From the film

- Breathing renews the air or water at the exchange surface and blood flow renews the blood; together they keep the partial-pressure difference up.
- In a mammal, the first air of each breath into the alveoli is stale air from the dead space, the airways where no exchange happens.
- At steady state, breathing ordinary air with carbon dioxide production unchanged, alveolar ventilation, not total air moved, sets alveolar PCO2.
- In resting mammals, carbon dioxide, sensed largely through brain pH, sets most of the drive to breathe.

## Moving the gas: aspiration and the frog’s pump

The second film showed **aspiration**, the **diaphragm** flattening to lower chest pressure, but not the ribs or the breath out. The external intercostal muscles lift the ribs as the diaphragm contracts, and the lungs follow the enlarging chest. Quiet expiration in adult humans is normally passive recoil of lungs and chest wall once the muscles relax; forceful expiration adds the internal intercostals and abdominal muscles.

The wet lining of the alveoli has surface tension, pulling inward like a soap bubble. **Surfactant**, a lipid and protein mixture secreted by alveolar cells, lowers it, raising **compliance** (how much the lung stretches for a given pressure change), so the lung inflates with less effort.

A frog works the other way. In **buccal pumping** it lowers the floor of its mouth with the nostrils open, drawing in air, then closes the nostrils, opens the glottis (the opening into the airway) and raises the floor, pushing air into the lungs under positive pressure. Mammals and birds both draw air in by lowering pressure: mammals in the chest, birds in the air sacs. Buccal pumping is thought to be the older method, from which aspiration in amniotes (reptiles, birds and mammals) evolved, but a living frog is its own lineage, not an ancestor of mammals or birds.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A mammal enlarges its chest and air flows in as pressure falls; a frog lowers its mouth floor with the nostrils open, then closes them and raises the floor to push air into its lungs. Image: a block-schematic mammal chest with a flattened diaphragm and lifted ribs drawing air into the lung, beside two side views of a frog, one with the mouth floor lowered and nostrils open, one with nostrils closed and the floor raised pushing air into the lung.

## Carbon dioxide runs the controller

Breathing rhythm comes from brainstem neurons (see [the nervous system map](https://stemhop.com/lessons/nervous-system-map/) and [the hypothalamus and autonomic system](https://stemhop.com/lessons/hypothalamus-autonomic/)). The second film gave J. S. Haldane and J. G. Priestley’s 1905 result, which made carbon dioxide the main resting stimulus in these men. Their method: because windpipe gas mixes fresh and stale air, they took the end of a forced breath out as alveolar air, with themselves and colleagues as resting subjects breathing added carbon dioxide or less oxygen. Alveolar PCO2 also stayed nearly constant for each man at rest.

Later work found two kinds of sensor: the **central chemoreceptors** the second film showed, which read the pH of brain extracellular fluid, and the **carotid bodies**, sensory clusters where each carotid artery forks, which respond mainly to low arterial oxygen and are also affected by carbon dioxide. In adult humans, ventilation rises steeply with **hypoxia**, too little oxygen, only once arterial PO2 falls well below normal. In teleosts, low oxygen in the water is a major ventilatory stimulus.

**Predict.** A resting person breathes a gas mixture low enough in oxygen to drop arterial PO2 well below normal, and ventilation rises steeply. Carbon dioxide production stays the same. Which sensor is mainly driving the rise, and what happens to alveolar PCO2 while it does?

> **Check your prediction.** Mainly the carotid bodies, which respond to low arterial oxygen; nothing here raised carbon dioxide. With production unchanged, the extra breathing is more than production requires, so alveolar PCO2 falls, a state called **hypocapnia**.

**Worked problem.** The second film showed the direction; here are the numbers. Illustrative values for an adult human at rest: tidal volume (one breath) 500 mL, 12 breaths per minute, and 150 mL of **dead space**, the conducting airways, which have no alveoli and exchange no gas.

1. **Minute ventilation**, total air moved, = 12 x 500 mL = 6,000 mL per minute.
2. **Alveolar ventilation**, fresh air reaching alveoli, = 12 x (500 - 150) = 4,200 mL per minute.
3. Breathe rapidly and shallowly, 24 breaths of 250 mL: minute ventilation = 24 x 250 = 6,000 mL per minute, unchanged.
4. Alveolar ventilation = 24 x (250 - 150) = 2,400 mL per minute, 57% of before.
5. At steady state, breathing ordinary air, alveolar PCO2 is about 0.863 x carbon dioxide production (mL per minute) / alveolar ventilation (L per minute). With production held at an illustrative 200 mL per minute, alveolar PCO2 would rise from about 41 to about 72 mmHg.

Gas carriage in blood is in [carrying oxygen and carbon dioxide](https://stemhop.com/lessons/oxygen-transport/), and acid-base adjustment in [the kidney](https://stemhop.com/lessons/kidney/).

### Design problem

Birds have one-way airflow driven by air sacs. Alligators have none. How would you find out whether air moves one way through an alligator’s lung, and what would the result tell you?

> **One way to do it.** Put directional probes, such as heated thermistors, in identified bronchi of live alligators: flow the same way during inspiration and expiration means one-way flow there. This is the approach Farmer and Sanders reported in 2010. Then take the brain and breathing muscles out of the question by pumping air in and out of an excised lung through the trachea. If one-way flow persists and the airways have no flap valves, the lung’s own structure, most likely its airway geometry, produces it. As a control, a mammal lung on the same pump should show flow reversing with each breath; if not, the probes or pump are at fault.
>
> Limits: Farmer and Sanders’s pump tests used four lungs, one live animal had a direction-sensing probe, and only some bronchi were measured.

## Going deeper

### Ranking flow arrangements, and a tracer aside

In 1972 Johannes Piiper and Peter Scheid compared idealized models of the three arrangements under the matched conditions of the Predict above: countercurrent transferred the most gas by their measure, crosscurrent next, the mixed pool of a mammal lung least. When the surface is small or thick, the arrangements barely differ. The textbook rule that air takes two breaths to pass through the bird lung is a schematic; helium tracer work in songbirds found some inhaled gas reaching the front air sacs within one breath.

### What Haldane and Priestley could not yet see

They argued that carbon dioxide reached the brain’s respiratory centre through the arterial blood; separate sensor cells had not yet been found.

### Sensing carbon dioxide in the brainstem

In mice, retrotrapezoid nucleus neurons carry two pH sensors that work in parallel, the proton-sensing receptor GPR4 and the potassium channel TASK-2; losing GPR4 alone removes much of this response (see [GPCRs and G proteins](https://stemhop.com/lessons/gpcrs-and-g-proteins/)).

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/gas-exchange/
