# Evidence for Evolution

> Independent evidence that agrees strengthens an explanation of common descent. How do we know what lived millions of years ago, and how do we know we are related to other species? You order fossil layers, count DNA differences between species, and read real fossil ages and DNA comparisons for whales and humans. Afterwards you can explain how each kind of evidence works and judge a claim using several lines of evidence together.

Course: Biology (Evolution). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/evidence-for-evolution/

Builds on: DNA: Structure and Copying · Meiosis and Variation

## What you'll learn

- You will explain that evidence from many fields (fossils, rocks, embryos, anatomy, genetics and biochemistry) agrees on one history of common descent, which is why the theory of evolution is well supported, and judge a claim using several lines of evidence.
- You will explain how the fossil record shows the history of life, how rock layers give relative ages and radioactive dating gives ages in years, and why the record is incomplete.
- You will explain how comparing DNA between species (comparative genomics) shows common ancestry: species with more similar DNA usually share a more recent common ancestor.

**Rocks in Pakistan and Egypt hold fossil whales with leg bones. Living whales still carry small hip bones deep inside their bodies.** Virginia State Parks reports fossil shark teeth along the Potomac shore at Westmoreland State Park. Maryland’s Calvert Cliffs on the Chesapeake Bay expose fossils of whales and sharks. How can rocks and living bodies reveal life millions of years ago?

> **The one idea.** Independent evidence that agrees strengthens an explanation of common descent.
>
> *Scope:* Here, independent evidence means observations made with different methods that test the same branching history. Agreement makes an explanation stronger. It does not make every fossil a direct ancestor, and the conclusion can still be revised.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. DNA tests are only useful for figuring out who someone is, like at a crime scene. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** DNA does identify people, but scientists also line up the DNA of whole species and count the differences. Comparing genomes this way, called comparative genomics, shows which species are close relatives. For example, it grouped whales with hippos among the hoofed mammals. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** DNA does identify people, but scientists also line up the DNA of whole species and count the differences. Comparing genomes this way, called comparative genomics, shows which species are close relatives. For example, it grouped whales with hippos among the hoofed mammals.
2. Evolution is just a theory, so it is really just a guess. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** In everyday talk, a theory is a hunch. In science, a theory is a tested explanation that ties together many observations. The theory of evolution is supported by fossils, rock dating, anatomy, embryos and DNA, and each of these could have shown a different pattern but did not. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** In everyday talk, a theory is a hunch. In science, a theory is a tested explanation that ties together many observations. The theory of evolution is supported by fossils, rock dating, anatomy, embryos and DNA, and each of these could have shown a different pattern but did not.
3. If humans came from apes, there should not be any apes left today. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Humans did not come from today’s chimpanzees. Humans and chimpanzees descend along separate branches from a common ape ancestor that lived long ago. Both branches kept going, so both are alive today, in the same way that you and your cousins share grandparents and are all alive at once. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Humans did not come from today’s chimpanzees. Humans and chimpanzees descend along separate branches from a common ape ancestor that lived long ago. Both branches kept going, so both are alive today, in the same way that you and your cousins share grandparents and are all alive at once.

## Explore: stack rock layers and count DNA differences

Stack rock layers that each hold a fossil and put them in order from oldest to youngest. Then line up a short stretch of DNA from five species, base by base, and count the differences to build a similarity table.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Rock layers and DNA: two ways to read the past

**Try this.**

1. Before you stack the layers, predict which fossil is the oldest. Then build the stack and check your prediction.
2. Tilt or flip part of the stack. Predict whether the bottom layer is still the oldest, then test it.
3. Predict which species will have the fewest DNA differences from humans. Count the differences and see.
4. Compare a longer DNA stretch instead of a short one. Predict whether your ranking of relatives will change.

## Use rock order, then test its limits

- fossil
- fossil record
- relative dating
- radioactive dating
- comparative genomics
- common ancestor
- homologous structure
- vestigial structure
- embryology
- theory

The first film built the rock timeline and introduced dating and gaps. Its terms: a **fossil** is the preserved remains or traces of past life, the **fossil record** is all fossils found so far, arranged by age, and **relative dating** orders layers without ages in years.

How incomplete is the record? Life has existed for about 3.5 billion years or more, and most of it left no fossils. Most dead organisms decay or are eaten before burial. Fossils form more often when a body is buried quickly in mud or sand under water, so sea animals are better recorded than forest animals.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge top layer with shark teethvolcanic ash layerfossil whale boneoldest bottom layerolder to younger top laye

**Radioactive dating** uses radioactive atoms in certain minerals to estimate a rock’s age in years: the starting atoms change into product atoms at a steady rate. For fossils millions of years old, it usually dates minerals in nearby rock, not the bone itself. The first film’s two ash layers are the lucky case. More often no volcanic layer is nearby, so scientists match the fossil’s layer to dated rocks elsewhere using **index fossils**, remains of species that lived for a known span of time.

Different atoms suit different spans of time. Carbon-14 can date young bone itself, but only up to about 50,000 years old. Fossil whales millions of years old are far too old for it.

**Key idea:**

Rock layers give the order of fossils, radioactive dating gives their ages in years, and the record has gaps because most living things never fossilize.

Rocks order and date whale fossils, and fossil bones give clues to relationships. The second film tests that history independently, with living bodies and DNA.

**Film transcript: Four Tests of Whale Ancestry**

### Film transcript: Four Tests of Whale Ancestry

The first film placed fossil whales in time. If that history is right, what should we find inside living whales and their DNA? Keep one branching tree in view. A common ancestor is an ancestral population from which later species descended. Branches split; they do not form a ladder.

Living species sit at the tips. DNA passes from parents to offspring. Small copied changes can travel down a branch. Nearby branches have had less time to collect different changes. Matching DNA stretches are therefore usually more similar. Suppose an insertion spread through the ancestral population of whales and hippos before they split, and was never lost. Where should matching markers appear today? Choose whale and hippo, whale and fish, or all three.

The matching markers should reach whales and hippos. Researchers found shared insertions at the same spots in the genome. That pattern groups whales with hippos among even-toed hoofed mammals. That grouping does not mean hippos became whales. Both living groups occupy separate tips. They share an earlier population, then each branch continued changing. Relatives are not automatically ancestors. Anatomy tests the tree another way. Homologous structures come from one structure in a common ancestor. A whale flipper, a human arm and a bat wing hold the same set of bones, arranged differently. Living whales also carry small hip bones that support no legs.

They are vestigial: reduced parts that have lost all or most of the job they did in ancestors. Vestigial does not mean useless. In males, these bones anchor muscles used in mating. Development supplies a fourth test. A spotted dolphin embryo begins hind-limb buds. The signals that keep a limb growing switch off early or never appear. The buds stop and break down. The embryo is not replaying its ancestors. Now bring the lanes together. Gold fossils show change through time. Blue DNA places whales on a mammal branch. Green anatomy and teal development preserve inherited patterns. Different methods fit one history. Agreement is not certainty, and each test has limits.

Fossil sequences do not identify direct parents. Similarity matters only for comparable DNA. A useful structure can still record ancestry. A scientific theory is a tested explanation that connects many observations. Evolution predicts related patterns before each evidence lane is opened. Confidence grows when those patterns appear across methods, not because any label says proof. Each method could have pointed to another history. Instead, their patterns agree within their limits.

Independent evidence that agrees strengthens an explanation of common descent.

From the film

- Shared DNA insertions group whales with hippos among the even-toed hoofed mammals.
- Living structures and embryos can preserve evidence of shared ancestry.
- Vestigial does not mean useless: a reduced inherited structure can keep a job.
- Living relatives share ancestors; one did not become the other.
- Independent evidence that agrees strengthens an explanation of common descent.

## What a DNA percentage does—and does not—measure

**Comparative genomics** compares the genomes, the whole DNA, of different species. DNA changes build up along each inherited lineage, so species that split recently have had less time to collect differences. In matching stretches, more similar sequences usually mean a more recent **common ancestor**, the ancestral population both species descended from.

In 2005, a team compared the genome of a chimpanzee named Clint with the human genome. Across about 2.4 billion lined-up bases, 1.23 of every 100 differed.

> percent matching = 100% − percent different = 100% − 1.23% = 98.77%, or about 98.8%

That number counts single-base differences in matching regions only. It leaves out other kinds of difference, so a “percent similar” depends on what was compared.

**Predict.** One study counts matching DNA bases, while another counts genes with a similar gene in another species. Can you rank the two percentages from most to least related?

> **Check your prediction.** No. The denominators differ: one percentage is about bases and the other is about genes. Compare percentages only when they measure the same kind of feature in comparable regions.

The second film’s insertion test comes from a 1999 study of inserted pieces of DNA in whales and hoofed mammals. Insertions shared at the same spot were likely inherited from one ancestor.

**Key idea:**

Species with more similar DNA in matching regions usually share a more recent common ancestor.

## What the other evidence can and cannot show

Each method below has a limit, shown in the last column.

| Method | What it supports | What it does not show by itself |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Paleontology and geology | Legged whale fossils from Pakistan and Egypt occur in layers dated tens of millions of years old | That one named fossil was the direct ancestor of the next |
| Anatomy | Living whales retain small hip bones inside their bodies | When the hind legs were reduced, or in which ancestor |
| Embryology | Pantropical spotted dolphin embryos begin hind-limb buds that later disappear | That an embryo replays a series of adult ancestors |
| Genetics | Shared DNA insertions group whales with hippos | That hippos were whale ancestors |
| Biochemistry | Whales share the nearly universal genetic code, the same three-base codes for amino acids, with other life | Which animals are the closest relatives of whales |

A **homologous structure** is a body part in different species that comes from the same structure in a common ancestor: a whale flipper, a human arm and a bat wing hold the same set of bones, arranged differently. A **vestigial structure** is a reduced body part that has lost all or most of the job it did in ancestors.

Vestigial does not mean useless. The second film showed one job: in males, the hip bones anchor muscles used in mating, as anatomists described long ago. A 2014 study added another line of evidence: across whales, dolphins and porpoises, the hip bones were larger in species where males have larger testes for their body size.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A vestigial structure: living whales carry small hip bones that hold up no legs, yet in males they still anchor muscles used in mating. Image: a living whale in side view with a small pair of hip bones shown deep inside its lower body and no legs attached. An inset zooms in on one hip bone with a muscle band attached.

**Embryology** is the study of how an organism develops before birth or hatching. The second film’s dolphin buds stop growing and break down around the fifth week.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Spotted dolphin embryos start hind-limb buds, then the buds stop growing and break down. The embryo is not replaying its ancestors; it starts a limb and then stops. Image: two simple outlines of a dolphin embryo. The earlier one has a small hind-limb bud near its rear; in the later one the bud is gone and only a dashed outline marks where it was.

A **theory** in science is a well-tested explanation supported by many lines of evidence, such as the theory of evolution. For natural selection, one of the main ways that change happens, and for how new species form, see [Natural Selection and New Species](https://stemhop.com/lessons/natural-selection-and-speciation/).

**Key idea:**

Agreement among fossils, anatomy, embryos and DNA makes the whale explanation stronger than any one clue alone.

## Elaborate: read DNA comparisons and fossil ages

Before comparing values in this table, check that they measure the same quantity on a compatible scale. The fossil ages can be ordered as approximate ages in millions of years, though three are rounded.

| Comparison or fossil | Value (% or millions of years ago) | What the number measures | Source |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Human and chimpanzee | 1.23% differ (98.77% match, calculated) | Single DNA bases in about 2.4 billion lined-up bases | Chimpanzee genome team, *Nature*, 2005 |
| Human and mouse | about 85% identical | DNA bases in protein-coding regions, average | NHGRI summary, 2010 update |
| Chicken and human | about 60% | Chicken genes with a similar human gene | NHGRI release, 2004 |
| Fruit fly and human | about 60% | Genes shared; no single comparison method given | NHGRI fact sheet, 2020 update |
| *Pakicetus* | about 50 | Rounded teaching age for the group | Burke Museum activity |
| *Ambulocetus* | about 49 | Rounded teaching age for the group | Burke Museum activity |
| *Rodhocetus* | about 47 | Rounded teaching age for the group | Burke Museum activity |
| *Maiacetus inuus*, Pakistan | about 47.5 | Age of the rock layer holding two skeletons | Gingerich and colleagues, *PLoS ONE*, 2009 |
| *Basilosaurus isis* WH 10001, Egypt | about 37.5 | Age of the rock layer holding one skeleton, Wadi Al Hitan | Voss and colleagues, *PLoS ONE*, 2019 |

Sources: the chimpanzee row compares one chimpanzee, Clint, with the human reference genome. The mouse, chicken and fly values are published summaries from the National Human Genome Research Institute (NHGRI), not one study. The first three fossil ages come from a Burke Museum classroom activity, not measurements of one skeleton.

1. Put the five fossils in order from oldest to youngest. How many million years separate *Pakicetus* and WH 10001?
2. The mouse value counts matching bases, and the chicken value counts genes. Can you use them to rank mouse and chicken as human relatives? Why or why not?
3. Does the fossil order prove that each whale was the parent species of the next one?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: are whales related to land mammals? Use the fossil ages and at least one other line of evidence from this lesson.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The evidence shows that whales blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: The oldest whale fossil in the table, blank, is about blank million years old and blank. Living whales have blank. DNA shows blank.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: These lines of evidence count because blank. Together they blank, even though blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Whales descend from land mammals. In the table, Pakicetus has a teaching age of about 50 million years, and Maiacetus, at about 47.5 million years, kept all four limbs with hands and feet. Basilosaurus fossils from Egypt, about 37.5 million years old, include small hind-limb and foot bones. Living whales carry small hip bones, and DNA insertions group whales with hippos among the hoofed mammals. These are independent kinds of evidence that point the same way. One limit: the ages are rounded or come from one or two skeletons, and the order of fossils does not show that any one was a direct ancestor.

Saved in this browser only.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

The evidence agrees on one answer: whales descend from ancestors that walked on land.

**Science practices you used:** ordering rock layers and naming a model’s limits, calculating a percent and a difference from a data table, checking whether two numbers measure the same thing, and making and judging a claim from several lines of evidence.

### Design problem

Some people say a whale’s small hip bones are leftovers with no job. Plan a study, using museum skeletons, to test whether the hip bones are linked to mating in male whales.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** In male whales, do species with relatively larger testes also have relatively larger hip bones?
> - **Independent variable:** relative testes size of each species, from published records.
> - **Dependent variable:** hip bone size and shape, measured the same way on every skeleton.
> - **Constants:** adult males only, the same measuring tool and method, and every size divided by body length, so large and small species can be compared.
> - **Control:** measure a rib from each skeleton too. If ribs also track testes size, the link is not special to the hip bones and may come from overall body size instead of mating.
> - **Sample size and repeated trials:** many species and several skeletons per species; measure each bone more than once. The 2014 study used 130 whales, dolphins and porpoises from 29 species.
> - **Ethics:** museum skeletons harm no living animal.
>
> If hip bones track testes size and ribs do not, the bones likely still serve mating. This is a pattern, not proof of cause.

## Going deeper

### How the two whale skeletons were dated

The ages of the *Maiacetus* and *Basilosaurus* skeletons in this lesson come from tiny fossils of sea plankton in the same rock layers. Those plankton layers were matched to rocks elsewhere that other radioactive atoms had dated.

### What the 1.23 percent leaves out

The same study also found about five million places where short pieces of DNA had been added or lost, which the 1.23% leaves out. A 2025 study of complete ape genomes compared regions that earlier work had skipped.

### The 2014 hip-bone study in numbers

The 2014 study measured hip bones from 130 whales, dolphins and porpoises of 29 species. A rib measured as a check did not track testes size the way the hip bones did.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/evidence-for-evolution/
