# Evidence for Change Over Time

> Fossils reveal life's change through time, even with gaps; matching structures and protein sequences point to common ancestry. You will compare fossils, arm and leg bones, and the same protein in humans and other animals, then use the evidence to make a claim about which living things are close relatives.

Course: Life Science (Change over time). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/evidence-for-change/

Builds on: DNA: The Code of Life · Natural Selection in Action · Domains, Kingdoms and DNA

## What you'll learn

- You will explain how the fossil record shows that many kinds of life existed, changed and went extinct, and how their environments changed too.
- You will explain why matching body structures and similar DNA and protein sequences are strong signs of a common ancestor, and why the theory of evolution is a well-tested explanation, not a guess.
- You will read real protein data comparing humans with other animals, along with fossil and bone comparisons, and make a claim with evidence and reasoning about which animals are most closely related.

**Virginia’s state fossil is a scallop shell called *Chesapecten jeffersonius*. It is millions of years old, yet it looks much like a scallop shell on a beach today.** These fossils come from old sea-floor deposits that show along Virginia rivers such as the James. What can old shells, bones and sequences tell us about life’s history?

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A fossil scallop in Virginia's old sea-floor deposits records both past life and a past environment. Image: above, a shallow sea with scallop shells on its sandy floor; below, the same place today, with a river flowing past a low bank whose layers include a band of fossil scallop shells. An inset compares a stony fossil scallop shell with a modern scallop shell that looks a lot like it.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Evolution is just a theory, so it is only a guess. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** In everyday talk, a theory is a hunch. In science, a theory is a well-tested explanation backed by a lot of evidence. It also makes predictions. For example, it predicts that close relatives will have similar DNA, and when scientists check, they do. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** In everyday talk, a theory is a hunch. In science, a theory is a well-tested explanation backed by a lot of evidence. It also makes predictions. For example, it predicts that close relatives will have similar DNA, and when scientists check, they do.
2. Humans came from chimpanzees. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Humans and chimpanzees share a common ancestor that lived millions of years ago. After the split, each group changed along its own branch. Neither one turned into the other, so both can be alive today. Their DNA is very alike, which fits a shared ancestor. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Humans and chimpanzees share a common ancestor that lived millions of years ago. After the split, each group changed along its own branch. Neither one turned into the other, so both can be alive today. Their DNA is very alike, which fits a shared ancestor.
3. Every living thing that died left a fossil, so the fossil record is complete. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Most dead plants and animals rot or get eaten. Fossils form only in special conditions, such as quick burial in mud or sand. So the record has gaps, but the fossils we have still show clear patterns of change. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Most dead plants and animals rot or get eaten. Fossils form only in special conditions, such as quick burial in mud or sand. So the record has gaps, but the fossils we have still show clear patterns of change.

- evidence
- fossil
- fossil record
- extinct
- common ancestor
- DNA sequence
- hypothesis
- theory

**Evidence** is information from observations or measurements that supports or argues against an idea. The first film defined a **fossil**, the preserved remains or traces of a living thing from the past, and showed why the **fossil record**, all fossils found so far, has gaps.

**The one idea:**

Fossils reveal life’s change through time, even with gaps; matching structures and protein sequences point to common ancestry.

**Scope:**

fossils show what lived, changed and went extinct, and in what environments. Matching structures, in living or fossil animals, and the same protein compared across species help test relationships. No single fossil, limb or protein settles every relationship.

## Read the fossil record

Here are the four patterns from the first film, in Virginia:

- **Existence and diversity.** Many kinds of life lived that are not alive now.
- **Extinction.** A group is **extinct** when no living members are left. Trilobites, extinct sea animals with hard shells, are found in western Virginia rocks.
- **Change.** Old forms look like, but are not the same as, living ones. The state fossil scallop is one example.
- **Environments.** Sea shells in Virginia’s coastal plain show that a shallow sea once covered that land.

The early fossils in this table sit on separate branches, not on steps in one line of ancestors.

| Group | Example fossil and place | About how old (millions of years) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Fish | Haikouichthys, China | about 518 |
| Four-legged animals | Ichthyostega, Greenland | about 365 |
| Mammal relatives | Morganucodon teeth | about 205 |
| Bird-like dinosaurs | Archaeopteryx | about 150 |

**Predict.** Does the oldest fossil found show the exact day its group began?

> **Check your prediction.** No. It shows that the group existed by then. Some groups have older fossils than these, and new finds can push dates back.

## Compare the same parts

Hold out your arm. It has one upper arm bone, two lower arm bones, wrist bones and finger bones. A cat’s front leg, a whale’s flipper and a bat’s wing have the same set. Their shapes, sizes and jobs differ.

A **common ancestor** is an early population that two or more kinds of living things came from. Inherited changes can reshape an old set of parts, so a shared ancestor with this bone map explains the match best.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge upper arm bonetwo lower arm boneswrist bonesfinger bones upper arm boneblankblankfinger bones Word bank: 

**Predict.** A butterfly wing and a bird wing both fly, but only the bird wing has bones. Does the shared job show that they are close relatives?

> **Check your prediction.** No. The job is alike, but the build is different. Scientists compare how parts are built and where they sit.

**Key idea:**

The same parts in different shapes are strong signs of a shared ancestor when they match by construction and position.

The second film adds an independent test and asks what to do when two tests disagree.

**Film transcript: Two Clues, One Family Tree**

### Film transcript: Two Clues, One Family Tree

How can a bat wing and a protein point to the same relatives? The first film used fossils to track change through time. Now we will test relationships among the branches. A common ancestor is an earlier population from which later groups came.

Picture one branch splitting. Each new branch inherits old features, then changes in its own direction. A human arm, cat leg, whale flipper, and bat wing have an upper bone and paired lower bones. Wrist and finger bones follow. Shapes and jobs differ, but positions match. Scientists compare construction and position, not only jobs.

Inherited changes can reshape an old set of parts. That shared bone map points back toward a common ancestor. Sequences offer a test. A DNA sequence is the order of its bases. Many genes carry instructions for proteins. Scientists can line up the same protein from several species, position by position. Some inherited DNA changes remain in later populations. Branches split at different times, so closer relatives usually have more similar sequences. Usually matters.

Changes do not build up at one steady rate. Now test two clues. Species A and B share a blue structure that C lacks. A teal protein strip joins A with C. Have the clues agreed, and should any branch turn green yet? No. The clues support different groupings. Keep the branches gray, check the comparison, and collect more evidence. A conflict is not something to hide. It is a question to investigate. Now a different case. Two species share a structure that a third species lacks. The protein strip groups that same pair. When independent clues agree, their shared branch is the stronger explanation. This is how a scientific theory earns trust. Each line of evidence could have told a different story.

Evolution predicts broad agreement among fossils, structures, and sequences. Their broad patterns largely agree. One limb or one small protein cannot settle every relationship. Similar jobs can evolve in different structures.

Scientists compare more body parts, more sequences, and the fossil record. Return to the family tree. Matching parts show inherited construction. Similar sequences in the same protein add an independent check. When both fit one branch pattern, common ancestry explains the match best. The clues do different jobs. Fossils place life in time.

Bones of living and fossil animals, plus sequences, test relationships. Their broad agreement supports evolution, while every uncertainty stays visible and open to testing.

From the film

- Matching structures and protein sequences point to common ancestry.
- Compare body parts by their construction and position, not only their job.
- Fewer differences in the same protein usually point to closer relatives.
- When clues conflict, scientists check more evidence.
- When independent clues agree, their shared branch is the stronger explanation.

## Compare sequences

A **DNA sequence** is the order of the bases A, T, C and G along a piece of DNA. Many genes carry the code for a protein, as you saw in [DNA: The Code of Life](https://stemhop.com/lessons/dna-the-code-of-life/), so a protein difference comes from a difference in its gene’s DNA.

The second film said closer relatives *usually* have more similar sequences. “Usually” matters: changes do not build up at one steady rate, and one short protein is not a complete family tree. DNA also helps sort living things into groups, as in [Domains, Kingdoms and DNA](https://stemhop.com/lessons/domains-kingdoms-and-dna/).

## Explore: build an evidence board

Pick two living things and one kind of evidence, then place the pair on a family tree.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Evidence board: compare two living things

**Try this.**

1. Predict whether a whale’s flipper has the same bones as your arm. Choose whale and human, pick bones, and check.
2. Predict which is the closer relative of humans, a chicken or a chimpanzee. Use the DNA bars to test it.
3. Predict where a fish will join the family tree. Look at the fossil timeline, then place it on the tree and see.

## Work with real protein data

Cytochrome c is a small protein that helps your cells release energy from sugar. Many animals make it. The table counts how many of its 104 positions differ from the human protein.

| Animal | Differences from human (out of 104 positions) |
| --- | --- |
| Human | 0 |
| Chimpanzee | 0 |
| Rhesus monkey | 1 |
| Mouse | 9 |
| Dog | 11 |
| Horse | 12 |
| Chicken | 13 |
| Eastern diamondback rattlesnake | 15 |

Source: one reviewed cytochrome c sequence per animal from the UniProt protein database, retrieved in October 2026 and compared position by position for this lesson.

**Predict.** Based only on this protein, which two animals differ from humans the least? Which differs the most?

> **Check your prediction.** Not counting humans, chimpanzee and rhesus monkey differ least; the rattlesnake differs most. This broad pattern fits common ancestry, but one protein cannot settle every relationship by itself.

1. How many positions match between the human and horse proteins?
2. The chicken differs from humans at 13 positions and the rattlesnake at 15. Is a gap of two enough to decide which is closer to humans?

**Predict.** Chimpanzees show no differences in this protein. Does that mean their whole DNA is the same as ours?

> **Check your prediction.** No. This table compares one small protein, not the whole genome. Other genes should be checked too.

- The animal with the fewest differences is blank, so it is probably blank.
- This fits the bone evidence because blank.
- One limit of these data is blank.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim about which animals in the table are the closest relatives of humans. Use the protein data and one other kind of evidence from this lesson.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The closest relatives of humans in this table are blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: The blank protein differs from ours at blank of 104 positions, while blank differs at blank. The arm bones of blank also blank.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: Fewer differences mean blank, because blank. The bones agree because blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Chimpanzees and rhesus monkeys are the closest relatives of humans in this table. Their cytochrome c differs from ours at 0 and 1 of 104 positions, while the chicken differs at 13 and the rattlesnake at 15. Changes in DNA build up over time, so species that split more recently share more of the same sequence. Monkeys and apes also have arm bones like ours. So do the other mammals, so the bones show shared ancestry, and the protein data show which animals are closest. One limit: this is one small protein from one animal of each kind, so other genes should be checked too. Do not use this one protein to call the chicken closer than the rattlesnake. Birds and snakes split from our line at the same branch point, so they are equally related to us. The protein just changed a little more on one of their branches.

Saved in this browser only.

## Why scientists call it a theory

A **hypothesis** is a possible explanation that a test can support or reject. A **theory**, as the first film said, is a well-tested explanation backed by many lines of evidence, and it makes predictions that can be checked.

The theory of evolution says that populations change over time and share common ancestors. Natural selection is one important cause, as you saw in [Natural Selection in Action](https://stemhop.com/lessons/natural-selection-in-action/); new mutations and chance also change populations. The theory predicts broad agreement among fossils, structures and sequences. Each could have told a different story. Instead, their broad patterns largely agree; when details conflict, scientists check more evidence.

**Key idea:**

A scientific theory is a well-tested explanation. Fossils, body structures and sequences are three of the many kinds of evidence that support evolution.

## Design problem: model burial and decay

Hard remains and fast burial make fossils more likely. This model tests only short-term decay.

**Predict.** Which should break down less: an apple slice buried in damp sand, an unburied slice, or a shell?

> **One way to test it.** - **Question:** Do apple slices (soft remains) rot less when buried in damp sand than when left unburied on top of the same damp sand? Do shells change at all?
> - **Independent variable:** buried under 3 centimetres of damp sand, or laid unburied on top of the same damp sand.
> - **Dependent variable:** a rot score after 7 days, from 0 (fresh) to 3 (very soft, mouldy or smelly). Mass can mislead, because slices can dry out or pick up water and sand.
> - **Constants:** the same slice size, cups, water and room.
> - **Control:** unburied slices. Cover every cup the same way. Add clean shells to both groups as a hard-part check.
> - **Trials:** five cups of each kind; find the mean rot score.
> - **Safety:** use clear covered cups, wear gloves, never taste anything, and let the teacher discard anything mouldy. Wash your hands.
>
> If buried slices score less rotten, burial slowed decay in this model. They may not, since damp sand still lets air in. Real fossils form best when remains are buried fast in fine mud with little oxygen and no scavengers, which this model leaves out. Shells should barely change. This is not real fossil formation, which takes thousands of years or more.

## Going deeper: Virginia’s changing coast

The shallow sea recorded by the state fossil was here long before the Chesapeake Bay. The Bay began to fill as sea level rose after the last ice age, about 10,000 years ago. The old shells and the younger Bay record different changes in the same region.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Return to the guiding idea: fossils reveal life’s change through time, even with gaps; matching structures and protein sequences point to common ancestry. The state fossil scallop looks much like living scallops because scallops share common ancestors and have changed over time.

**Science practices you used:** asking a testable question, planning a fair test with a control, telling a hypothesis from a theory, and making a claim from evidence and reasoning.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/evidence-for-change/
