# Energy Flow and Productivity

> Energy fixed by plants leaves every feeding step by one of three doors, passed up as production, dropped into detritus or lost as heat, so production shrinks by a product of fractions at each level. This lesson defines gross, net primary and net ecosystem production as rates, shows how each is estimated with bottles, harvests and flux towers, and follows energy through consumers and into detritus as an annual budget. Afterwards you can compute consumption, assimilation, net production and trophic transfer efficiencies from rates in matched units, keep detritus in the budget, and say why the "10% rule" is a rough benchmark rather than a law.

Course: Ecology and Evolution (Ecosystem processes). Level: core university (third year). About 21 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/energy-flow/

Builds on: Predation and Community Effects · Population Growth and Regulation

## What you'll learn

- Define gross primary production, autotrophic respiration, net primary production and net ecosystem production, state the sign convention of net ecosystem exchange, and explain why GPP is always an estimate.
- Explain how production is estimated with light and dark bottles, harvests and component sums, and eddy-covariance towers with flux partitioning, and what each method actually measures.
- Build an energy budget for a consumer (ingestion, egestion, assimilation, respiration, production) and compute consumption, assimilation, net production and trophic transfer efficiencies from rates with units.
- Explain how low transfer efficiency can limit food-chain length, why the 10% figure is a rough benchmark with wide spread, and why detritus belongs in every ecosystem energy budget.

The first film opened the three doors on one feeding step and found 6% passed up to the herbivores. It left out how anyone measures these flows, what happens one step higher, and where the dead matter goes.

> **The one idea.** At every feeding step, energy leaves by one of three doors: **passed up** as consumer production, dropped into **detritus** (uneaten, or as feces), or lost as **heat**. The share passed up is a product of three fractions, consumption × assimilation × net production efficiency, so production shrinks fast up a food chain.
>
> *Scope:* a simplified budget of rates over one period (usually a year), in one currency per area. It assumes production not eaten during the period enters detritus (in real budgets some stays as living biomass, is eaten along another food-web link, or is exported). Small losses such as excreted wastes are lumped with detritus or neglected. Production shrinks as long as consumers eat no more than the production below them (Going deeper). Energy never returns to the producers: it is stored for a while or leaves as heat. Only matter cycles.

The machinery belongs to Biochemistry: the [light reactions](https://stemhop.com/lessons/light-reactions/) make ATP and NADPH, the [Calvin cycle](https://stemhop.com/lessons/calvin-cycle/) uses them to fix CO2, and [oxidative phosphorylation](https://stemhop.com/lessons/oxidative-phosphorylation/) recovers energy from food through a [proton-motive force](https://stemhop.com/lessons/proton-motive-force/) (vocabulary in [basic concepts of metabolism](https://stemhop.com/lessons/metabolism-basic-concepts/)). Here you keep the totals.

## Production is a rate: GPP, NPP and NEP

**Production** is the rate at which new organic matter, or its energy, is formed per unit area or volume per unit time, such as kJ m−2 yr−1 (kilojoules per square metre per year) or g C m−2 yr−1 (grams of carbon). **Biomass** (standing crop) is a stock: how much is there at one moment, in g m−2 with no time unit. A small stock can sit on a large production if it turns over quickly, as fast-dividing phytoplankton do.

Real plants often respire roughly half of the energy they fix.

> **Equation card: How much of what the producers fix is left over for everything else to eat or store.**
>
>     NPP = GPP − Ra
>
> In words: Net primary production is gross primary production minus what the producers respire.
>
> - NPP: what is left after the producers’ own respiration: the energy available to everything else (kJ m−2 yr−1)
> - GPP: the total rate of photosynthetic fixation by the producers, the first trophic level (a step in feeding defined by what an organism eats) (kJ m−2 yr−1)
> - Ra: what the producers (autotrophs, organisms that make their own food) themselves respire (kJ m−2 yr−1)
>
> Sanity check: If producers respired nothing, NPP would equal GPP. If they respired everything, NPP would be zero. A common slip is to call GPP “what is left after plants respire”; that is NPP.
> Try one number In the first film’s budget, NPP = 12,000 − 6,000 = 6,000 kJ m^−2 yr^−1: the plants keep half of what they fix.

**Net ecosystem production** (NEP) subtracts **Reco**, the respiration of the whole ecosystem: Ra plus the respiration of animals, fungi and bacteria.

> **NEP = GPP − Reco**

NEP is what is fixed and not respired. If no organic matter is carried in or out (by water or harvest, say), it is what the ecosystem stores, and **GPP = Reco + NEP**: everything fixed is either respired or stored. In an open system some fixed carbon is exported, and imported organic matter also changes the stock.

## Measuring it: bottles, harvests and towers

No method observes GPP directly at ecosystem scale; each measures one door, or the net, and infers the rest.

**Light and dark bottles.** Seal paired bottles of lake or sea water, keep one dark, and incubate both. Write Ostart for the oxygen at the start, L for the final oxygen in the light bottle, D for the final oxygen in the dark bottle, and t for the incubation time. The light bottle gains oxygen from photosynthesis and loses it to respiration, so its change is **net community production = (L − Ostart) / t**.

**Predict.** The light bottle already gives you a net. What does the dark bottle tell you that the light one cannot?

> **Check your prediction.** The heat door on its own, for the whole community in the bottle. The dark bottle only respires, so its loss is **respiration = (Ostart − D) / t**. Photosynthesis is the light bottle’s net gain plus what respiration took away, so add the two lines.

> **Equation card: Gross photosynthesis in a bottle of water, from two oxygen readings.**
>
>     GPP = (L − D) / t
>
> In words: Gross primary production is the light-bottle oxygen minus the dark-bottle oxygen, divided by the time.
>
> - GPP: gross primary production, here as gross oxygen production by all the bottle’s photosynthesizers, per litre per unit time (mg O2 L−1 h−1)
> - L: final oxygen in the light bottle (mg O2 per L)
> - D: final oxygen in the dark bottle (mg O2 per L)
> - t: incubation time (h)
>
> Sanity check: If nothing photosynthesized, the two bottles would end the same, L = D, and GPP would be zero. GPP should also equal net community production plus respiration.
> Try one number Round invented values: oxygen starts at 10 mg/L, and after 2 hours the light bottle reads 11 and the dark bottle 9. Net community production = (11 − 10) / 2 = 0.5. Respiration = (10 − 9) / 2 = 0.5. GPP = (11 − 9) / 2 = 1.0 mg O2 L^−1 h^−1, which is 0.5 + 0.5.
> Where it comes from optional (L − O_start) / t + (O_start − D) / t = (L − O_start + O_start − D) / t = (L − D) / t. The starting value O_start appears once with a minus and once with a plus, so it drops out.

This assumes equal respiration in light and dark and no gas escape. The bottle also holds bacteria and zooplankton, so its net is **community** production, not phytoplankton NPP, in oxygen units until a stated conversion to carbon is justified.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Paired bottles of the same water are sealed and incubated, one in the light and one kept dark, with dissolved oxygen measured at the start and end. The light bottle's change is net community production, because the bottle also holds bacteria and zooplankton. Image: two identical sealed bottles of water side by side, one clear with sunlight falling on it and one wrapped in dark cover, with a close-up of a sealed stopper and a start-and-end pair showing oxygen measured before and after incubation.

**Harvests and component sums.** In grassland, clipping and weighing the plants at the season’s peak gives a rough, usually low estimate of aboveground NPP. In forest, add the separately measured parts: Ji Young An and colleagues summed woody growth, litterfall and fine-root growth in nine stands in the Gwangneung Experimental Forest, Korea, where fine roots made up 18 to 44% of the estimated NPP. Where NPP is high in the first place depends largely on temperature and water, the subject of [climate and biomes](https://stemhop.com/lessons/climate-and-biomes/).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Forest NPP is estimated by adding separately measured parts: woody growth, litterfall and fine-root growth from ingrowth cores. Any part left out is missing from the total, and in nine Korean stands fine roots made up 18 to 44% of the estimated NPP. Image: cutaway of a forest plot showing three separate measurements, a tape around a trunk for woody growth, open traps catching leaves for litterfall, and a gold-outlined soil core with fine roots growing in, with close-ups of a trap and the core.

**Eddy-covariance towers.** Fast sensors above the canopy record how vertical gusts carry CO2 up and down. When rising gusts carry less CO2 than sinking ones, the forest is taking carbon in. Averaged over a year, this gives **net ecosystem exchange** (NEE), the net flow of CO2 from the ecosystem to the air. The tower sees only this net; a **partitioning model** splits it into GPP and Reco, commonly by fitting respiration to night-time data (no photosynthesis) and extrapolating it into the day. Methods disagree at the same site (Going deeper), so GPP is an estimate with a method attached.

**Predict.** A forest stores carbon this year, and its tower counts release to the air as positive. Will its NEE be positive or negative?

> **Check your prediction.** Negative. With release counted as positive, NEE = Reco − GPP, the mirror image of NEP, so an ecosystem that takes up carbon has a negative NEE. Check the sign convention before you read any flux graph.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A tower above the canopy measures the net exchange, NEE; GPP and Reco are then separated from it by a partitioning model, often by fitting night-time respiration and extrapolating it into the day. GPP is an estimate with a method attached. Image: a lattice instrument tower rising above a forest canopy, with wavy arrows showing CO2 carried up and down in gusts past its sensors. A solid two-headed arrow above the canopy is labeled measured net exchange (NEE), and dashed arrows from a partitioning model are labeled estimated GPP and Reco. Night and day insets show measured night-time respiration rising from the forest, then a dashed respiration arrow extended into the day beside a downward photosynthesis (GPP) arrow.

## Following energy through a consumer

Feeding links ([predation](https://stemhop.com/lessons/predation/), [mutualism, parasitism and coevolution](https://stemhop.com/lessons/mutualism-parasitism-coevolution/)) are the pipes. In symbols, the first film’s doors for one consumer are what it **ingests**, I; its feces, **egestion**; what it **assimilates**, A; its respiration, R; and its **production**, P.

> **A = I − egestion P = A − R**

The first film’s three valves are three ratios: **consumption efficiency**, I / P below (P below is the production of the level eaten); **assimilation efficiency**, A / I; and **net production efficiency**, P / A. Their product is the **trophic transfer efficiency** (TTE): production at one level over production at the level below, in matched units and time.

> **Equation card: What fraction of one feeding level’s production becomes production at the next level up.**
>
>     TTE = (I / P below) × (A / I) × (P / A) = P / P below
>
> In words: Transfer efficiency is consumption efficiency times assimilation efficiency times net production efficiency, which comes to this level’s production over the production below.
>
> - TTE: production at one level divided by production at the level below
> - I: what this level ingests. I / P below is the consumption efficiency. (kJ m−2 yr−1)
> - P below: production of the level below (kJ m−2 yr−1)
> - A: what this level assimilates (ingested minus egested). A / I is the assimilation efficiency. (kJ m−2 yr−1)
> - P: this level’s production, new tissue and offspring. P / A is the net production efficiency. (kJ m−2 yr−1)
>
> Sanity check: Assimilation and net production efficiency always lie between 0 and 1. Consumption efficiency does too as long as consumers eat no more than the production below them, and then the product is no larger than any one factor. The units cancel, so TTE has none.
> Try one number The first film’s herbivores: TTE = 0.30 × 0.40 × 0.50 = 0.06, a 6% transfer.
> Where it comes from optional Multiply the three fractions: I on top of the second cancels I on the bottom of the first, and A on top of the third cancels A on the bottom of the second. What remains is P / P below.

Door sizes differ between animals: assimilation efficiency tends to be higher for carnivores, because animal tissue is easier to digest than plant cell walls. Net production efficiency tends to be low in birds and mammals, which respire most of what they assimilate, much of it to keep warm, and higher in many invertebrates and fish.

**Worked problem.** Carry the first film’s made-up budget (one square metre, one year, kJ m−2 yr−1) up to the predators and into the dead matter, with no imports, exports or net decomposer growth. Production that is not eaten enters detritus; predator production, with no one above it, is kept as new predator biomass. From the first film: NPP 6,000, and herbivores ingest 1,800, egest 1,080 and produce 360. Predators ingest 200, egest 100 and respire 60. Decomposers respire 3,240.

**Predict.** The predators keep the same three doors. Will their link pass on 6% too?

> **Check your prediction.** No, about 11%.
>
> 1. *Predators.* A = 200 − 100 = 100. P = 100 − 60 = 40. TTE = 40 / 360 = 11.1%. Check with the three efficiencies: 200 / 360 = 0.556, 100 / 200 = 0.50 and 40 / 100 = 0.40, and 0.556 × 0.50 × 0.40 = 0.111.
> 2. *Detritus.* Inputs are ungrazed plant production 6,000 − 1,800 = 4,200, herbivore feces 1,080, herbivore production that predators did not eat 360 − 200 = 160, and predator feces 100: total 5,540. Decomposers respire 3,240, leaving 2,300 as detritus. Detritus not yet decomposed piles up, so this year’s books count it as stored.
> 3. *Whole system.* Total respiration = 6,000 + 360 + 60 + 3,240 = 9,660. NEP = 12,000 − 9,660 = 2,340, which is the 2,300 of detritus plus the 40 of predator production. Check: 9,660 + 2,300 + 40 = 12,000.

No single number describes both links. Decomposers (bacteria, fungi and detritus feeders) respired 3,240, against 420 for the herbivores and predators combined: in this budget most NPP never passed through a grazer. Neither a ratio of biomasses (stocks carry no time unit) nor gross growth efficiency, P / I, is a transfer efficiency (Going deeper).

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Energy budget ladder — one invented square metre, one year

That decomposer lead came from invented numbers. The second film tests it in a real salt marsh.

**Film transcript: Where the Marsh Grass Goes**

### Film transcript: Where the Marsh Grass Goes

In the made-up budget, decomposers respired far more than the grazers and predators. Most plant production was never eaten by a grazer at all. Was that just a quirk of invented numbers? In a real ecosystem, where does the plants' production actually end up each year? John Teal asked this on the coast of Georgia. He built an energy budget for a salt marsh, and published it in 1962. One grass dominates these marshes, smooth cordgrass It grows in the tidal mud and makes a great deal of plant matter each year. A grazing-chain picture of ecology predicts the obvious route.

Grass feeds the herbivores, and then the herbivores feed the predators. Teal did not assume the route. He assembled the budget from measurements of the grass and the algae on the mud. It also drew on measurements of the animals and bacteria living there.

Insects and other animals graze on the living grass. Will they take most of its production, or only a small part? Only a small part. In Teal's budget, the purple pipe to the grazers was thin. The grazing chain was a side channel. Much of the grass died instead, and broke into fragments. Bacteria used those fragments, and so did animals that feed on detritus. Those detritus feeders are themselves eaten. So detritus is not a dead end for animals. It is a second route into the food web. Every organism on this route respires. Each one releases heat through a grey door. The energy never returns to the grass. Only matter cycles. Nutrients return to the grass through its roots.

Carbon returns as carbon dioxide, which the leaves fix again. The energy comes from fresh sunlight. Teal's budget also left a remainder. After the respiration of bacteria and animals, about 45% percent of net production was left over. He took it as available to leave the marsh with the tides. But it was a remainder, not a measured export. Even so, the study changed the picture. With others' work on decomposing marsh grass, it moved detritus from a footnote to the centre of coastal budgets.

So keep the brown door in every budget. In this marsh, most grass production went that way rather than to grazers, and respiration released its energy as heat.

From the film

- In Teal's Georgia salt marsh, insects and other animals grazing living cordgrass took only a small part of its production.
- Most grass production went to detritus rather than to grazers: it died, broke into fragments and fed bacteria and detritus-feeding animals, which are themselves eaten.
- Energy in detritus can feed decomposers, detritus feeders and their predators, but it never returns to the producers: respiration releases it as heat, and only matter cycles.
- Teal's figure of about 45% of net production available to leave with the tides was a remainder, not a measured export.

## Detritus, transfer efficiency and the 10% rule

Two things the second film left out. Later reviews found little quantitative evidence that Teal’s tidal remainder was actually exported; how much marsh production supports food webs in the estuary beyond became a question for later work. And how far the detrital route it showed, rather than the grazing chain, supports higher trophic levels in a given system is still open. The matter that returns to producers is the subject of [nutrient cycling](https://stemhop.com/lessons/nutrient-cycling/).

How big is the passed-up share in real food webs? From 48 published aquatic food-web models, Daniel Pauly and Villy Christensen derived in 1995 a mean transfer efficiency of about 10%, the classic support for the **10% rule**: a rough benchmark from aquatic models, not a law (Going deeper). A 2026 synthesis of 2,052 estimates from 122 studies found a lower average energy transfer efficiency, about 6% (by coincidence, the made-up first link’s value), highest in marine systems and lowest on land. Real links can be far lower or higher.

**Predict.** At 10% per step, a top predator at the fourth trophic level (counting producers as level 1) receives 0.1% of NPP: three transfers, 0.1 × 0.1 × 0.1 = 0.001. What does it receive at 6% per step?

> **Check your prediction.** 0.06 × 0.06 × 0.06 = 0.000216, about 0.022% of NPP, roughly a fifth of what the 10% rule gives. Small changes in efficiency matter once multiplied.

That fast shrinking is one likely reason food chains are short, though not the only proposed limit (Going deeper).

### Design problem

Students incubate light and dark bottles of lake water for 6 hours. Initial dissolved oxygen is 8.0 mg/L; at the end the light bottle reads 9.2 mg/L and the dark bottle 7.4 mg/L. These are invented numbers. Calculate net community production, respiration and GPP per hour. Then say what these numbers can and cannot tell you about the lake’s phytoplankton, and how you would improve the study.

> **One way to do it.** Net community production = (9.2 - 8.0) / 6 = 0.20 mg O2 L−1 h−1. Respiration = (8.0 - 7.4) / 6 = 0.10 mg O2 L−1 h−1. GPP = (9.2 - 7.4) / 6 = 0.30 mg O2 L−1 h−1, which equals 0.20 + 0.10, a useful check.
>
> What the numbers rest on: respiration is assumed equal in light and dark (in the light it can differ) and the bottle sealed. Bacteria and zooplankton are in the bottle, so these are community respiration and community production, not phytoplankton NPP. The figures are oxygen per litre per hour at one depth on one day. Converting them to carbon needs stated quotients: a photosynthetic quotient (moles of O2 released per mole of CO2 fixed) for production and a respiratory quotient (moles of CO2 released per mole of O2 used) for respiration, and an annual areal rate needs measurements through the water column and the seasons.
>
> To improve it, run replicates at several depths through the year, keep incubations short enough that oxygen does not build up unrealistically, and report each result with its spread.

## Going deeper

### Splitting a tower’s net flux

Besides night-time extrapolation there are light-response fits and neural networks trained on environmental drivers; a 2020 study applied a neural-network method to 36 FLUXNET2015 sites, and agreement among methods is not independent validation. At one Scots pine forest at Hyytiälä, Finland, over 2013 to 2017, daily GPP estimates from two methods based on carbonyl sulfide, a gas leaves take up along with CO2, averaged 7% and 23% above the CO2-based estimate.

### When a fraction exceeds 1

Assimilation and net production efficiency cannot exceed 1, because each is a share of what the consumer took in. Consumption efficiency can: when consumers eat down a standing prey stock, they ingest more than the production below them. The product still holds by algebra, but consumption efficiency is then no longer a share of the prey’s production, and a single link’s transfer can look larger over that period.

### Gross growth efficiency

**Gross growth efficiency**, P / I, is production over ingestion: a property of one consumer, not a transfer between levels.

### Where the 10% figure came from

Pauly and Christensen used their mean to estimate the primary production needed to sustain world fisheries. It is also not Lindeman’s law: Lindeman compared successive levels of his lake as ratios, but defined them on a different basis.

### Food quality

Producers short of nitrogen or phosphorus may limit transfer to herbivores even when carbon is plentiful, so energy is not the only currency that matters.

### Chain length and ecosystem size

A 2000 study of 25 northern temperate lakes (Post, Pace and Hairston, Nature) found that food-chain length increased with lake size but not with productivity.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/energy-flow/
