# Domains, Kingdoms and DNA

> Scientists sort living things with several kinds of evidence, from the microscope to DNA, and new evidence can move a living thing to a new group. You climb an evidence ladder with six living things, sort organisms with four clues into domains and kingdoms, and read real protein comparisons for two fungi, a human and two plants. Afterwards you can place organisms in domains and kingdoms and explain why new evidence can change the groups.

Course: Life Science (Organizing and classifying life). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/domains-kingdoms-and-dna/

Builds on: Sorting Living Things · Inside a Cell · Plant Cells and Animal Cells

## What you'll learn

- You will explain how living things are grouped into three domains (Archaea, Bacteria and Eukarya) and into kingdoms using four clues: whether cells have a nucleus, which cell parts they have, how many cells they have, and how they get food.
- You will use DNA comparisons and the history of classification to explain how new technology gives new evidence that can change how living things are grouped.
- You will read real data on how the number of kingdoms changed over time and on how alike one protein is in different organisms, and make a claim with evidence about where fungi belong.

**A mushroom pops up on a dead log after rain. It does not walk, swim or fly away.** For a long time, many scientists grouped mushrooms with plants. Today fungi have a kingdom of their own, and DNA comparisons strongly support a surprising answer: fungi are closer to animals like you than to an oak tree. How can a molecule show that?

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Scientists sort living things only by how they look. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Scientists also compare DNA and proteins. In 1993, two scientists compared 25 proteins in animals, fungi and plants. The results strongly supported fungi being closer to animals than to plants, even though a mushroom looks more like a plant. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Scientists also compare DNA and proteins. In 1993, two scientists compared 25 proteins in animals, fungi and plants. The results strongly supported fungi being closer to animals than to plants, even though a mushroom looks more like a plant.
2. Once a living thing is put in a group, the groups never change. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** In 1735, living things were sorted into two kingdoms, plants and animals. Microscopes, cell studies and then comparisons of molecules each added new evidence. By 1990 scientists had proposed three domains above the kingdoms. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** In 1735, living things were sorted into two kingdoms, plants and animals. Microscopes, cell studies and then comparisons of molecules each added new evidence. By 1990 scientists had proposed three domains above the kingdoms.
3. All microorganisms are basically the same kind of living thing. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Bacteria and Archaea look alike under a light microscope, and neither has a nucleus. But comparing a molecule that all cells share showed they are very different. Yeast is a microorganism too, and its cells have a nucleus, like yours. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Bacteria and Archaea look alike under a light microscope, and neither has a nucleus. But comparing a molecule that all cells share showed they are very different. Yeast is a microorganism too, and its cells have a nucleus, like yours.

> **The one idea.** Scientists sort living things with several kinds of evidence: what eyes see, what a microscope shows, tests of feeding and cell chemistry, and DNA. New evidence can move a living thing to a new group. On the top rung, scientists compare the same gene or protein across living things and build family trees from many genes before they trust a grouping. Groups that many genes put together probably share a more recent **common ancestor**, an organism both groups descend from.
>
> *Scope (for every “match” or “closer” in this lesson):* the ladder orders kinds of evidence, not dates. One match count is a clue, not proof: one group’s gene can change faster, so the closest match is not always the closest relative. A closer relative is not the same kind: fungi are closer to animals, but a mushroom is not an animal.

## Explore: sort living things by evidence

The slider adds one rung at a time; kingdom boxes appear only on the DNA rung. There, a bar shows how alike one protein is for the pair you pick, using the mean of real pairs in the Elaborate table (mushroom for two fungi, oak for two plants, deer for a human).

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Sort by evidence

**Try this.**

1. Predict the paramecium’s box on the DNA rung: animals, plants, fungi or its own. Then test it.
2. Pick the mushroom and the deer, then the mushroom and the oak. How far apart are the bars? Elaborate asks whether a gap that size can be trusted.

## Explain: six kingdoms inside three domains

- nucleus
- cell wall
- chloroplast
- Bacteria
- Archaea
- Eukarya
- protist
- fungus
- DNA sequence
- common ancestor

You met the levels of classification, from domain down to species, in [that lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/sorting-living-things/). A **nucleus** is the part of a cell that holds its DNA. A **cell wall** is a stiff layer outside the cell membrane. A **chloroplast** is a green part where a cell makes sugar (glucose) using light. **Bacteria** and **Archaea** are two domains of tiny, mostly single-celled organisms with no nucleus; they look alike but differ in cell chemistry and genes. **Eukarya** is the domain of all organisms whose cells have a nucleus.

Many US textbooks use six kingdoms: Bacteria and Archaea each get one, and four are inside Eukarya. A **protist** is an organism with a nucleus that is not a plant, animal or fungus, such as a paramecium; protists are a mixed group (see Going deeper). A **fungus** is an organism such as a mushroom, mold or yeast.

**Predict.** Baker’s yeast is a single cell, like a paramecium. It has a nucleus and a cell wall but no chloroplasts, and it takes in sugar as food. Is it a protist or a fungus?

> **Check your prediction.** A fungus. One cell does not make it a protist: its wall, missing chloroplasts and feeding match the Fungi row below.

| Kingdom | Nucleus? | Cell wall? | Chloroplasts? | Cells | Food |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Bacteria | No | Most have one | No | Mostly one | Some make it, some take it in |
| Archaea | No | Most have one | No | Mostly one | Some make it, some take it in |
| Protists | Yes | Some | Some | Most one, some many | Some make it, some take it in |
| Fungi | Yes | Yes | No | Most many; yeast one | Take it in |
| Plants | Yes | Yes | Yes, in green parts | Many | Most make it |
| Animals | Yes | No | No | Many | Take it in |

In the figure, name each numbered part.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge BacteriaArchaeaEukaryaFunginucleus blankblankEukaryablanknucleus Word bank: Archaea, Bacteria, Fungi blan

**Key idea:**

A microscope shows three clues (nucleus, cell parts, one cell or many); other tests add how it gets food.

## Explain: new tools bring new evidence

Read the Groups column first: 2, 3, 4, 5 kingdoms, then domains. The DNA rung compares sequences, the order of building blocks in DNA or in the RNA and proteins made from it.

| Year | Scientist | Groups | New evidence behind it | Rung |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1735 | Linnaeus | 2 kingdoms of living things | Body parts seen by eye | Eyes |
| 1866 | Haeckel | 3 kingdoms | Tiny living things that were neither plant nor animal | Microscope |
| 1938 | Copeland | 4 kingdoms | Cells with no nucleus put in their own kingdom | Microscope |
| 1969 | Whittaker | 5 kingdoms | Fungi separated by how they get food | Microscope and feeding tests |
| 1977 | Woese and Fox | Found a third main line of life, later named Archaea | Comparing the sequence of a molecule all cells have (ribosomal RNA) | DNA (sequences) |
| 1990 | Woese, Kandler and Wheelis | Named the three lines **domains**, a level above kingdoms | Molecule comparisons | DNA (sequences) |

Not every fungus feeds on dead wood like the first film’s mushroom: others feed on living hosts or trade with living plants, taking sugar and giving water and minerals.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A fungus cannot make sugar from light, so it releases digesting substances outside its cells and takes in the small, dissolved pieces. Image: mushrooms growing from a fallen, rotting log. An inset zooms in on a few fungal cells against the wood: in three steps the cells release digesting substances, the wood breaks down into tiny dissolved bits, and the cells absorb those bits.

**Key idea:**

New kinds of evidence, from microscopes to DNA comparisons, can change how living things are grouped.

Cell clues and feeding cannot say who the fungi’s closest relatives are, so the second film climbs to the DNA rung.

**Film transcript: Reading the DNA Rung**

### Film transcript: Reading the DNA Rung

Cell clues and feeding showed that a mushroom is not a plant. They cannot show who its closest relatives are. How could the cells' own instructions tell you? The first film climbed three rungs of the evidence ladder. Now climb the top rung, DNA, with the same six cards. The order of the chemical letters in a stretch of DNA is its DNA sequence. Each protein is built from a gene's instructions. So comparing proteins is another way to compare genes. A protein is a chain of building blocks called amino acids. To compare, line up the same protein from two living things. Each place in the line is a position. At each position, the building blocks match, or they do not.

Here is a made-up example, only ten building blocks long. Line up living thing A with living thing B, and count the matches. Then line up A with C. A matches B more closely in this one protein. That is one clue that A and B may share a more recent common ancestor. That is an organism both groups descend from. But a match count is a clue, not proof. One group's version can change faster than another's. So scientists build family trees from many genes before they trust a grouping. In 1993, Sandra Baldauf and Jeffrey Palmer looked at 25 proteins from animals, fungi, plants and other living things. One protein is called EF-1 alpha. In this protein, the animals and fungi they studied share an extra stretch, 12 building blocks long.

Do the plants have it too? Decide what each answer would mean. The plants did not have it. The simplest story is one change, in an ancestor that animals and fungi share but plants do not. And all four proteins they used to draw family trees grouped animals with fungi. So the evidence supports this tree. Fungi and animals sit on neighbouring branches. Plants sit farther off. Fungi and animals share a more recent common ancestor than either shares with plants. Many other proteins agree. One last warning. A closer relative is not the same kind. Fungi are closer to animals, but a mushroom is still not an animal. Closer means a more recent common ancestor.

From the film

- To compare two living things, scientists line up the same protein or gene and count the positions that match.
- Compare one living thing with two others using the same protein; a clearly higher match is one clue to a more recent common ancestor.
- A match count is a clue, not proof, so scientists build family trees from many genes before they trust a grouping.
- In one protein, EF-1 alpha, the animals and fungi studied shared an extra stretch of 12 building blocks that the plants lacked.
- Being closer to animals does not make a mushroom an animal.

## Elaborate: compare one protein in five organisms

The second film’s example was made up. Here are real counts for EF-1 alpha, about 460 positions long, which all five organisms make. Comparing the same protein gives evidence about the gene that holds its instructions. But these percents count matching amino acids, the building blocks of a protein. They do not count matching letters in the gene’s **DNA sequence**, the order of its chemical letters ([that lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/dna-the-code-of-life/)). Baker’s yeast and bread mold are fungi, like the mushroom. Thale cress, a small weed used in plant research, and wheat are plants, like the oak. You, the human, are the animal, like the deer.

| Pair compared | Kind of pair | Matching positions (out of positions compared) | Match (%) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Human and baker’s yeast | Animal and fungus | 371 of 460 | 80.7 |
| Human and bread mold | Animal and fungus | 387 of 461 | 83.9 |
| Baker’s yeast and thale cress | Fungus and plant | 339 of 461 | 73.5 |
| Baker’s yeast and wheat | Fungus and plant | 336 of 457 | 73.5 |
| Bread mold and thale cress | Fungus and plant | 342 of 462 | 74.0 |
| Bread mold and wheat | Fungus and plant | 345 of 458 | 75.3 |
| Baker’s yeast and bread mold | Fungus and fungus | 394 of 460 | 85.7 |
| Thale cress and wheat | Plant and plant | 425 of 446 | 95.3 |

Source: protein records from the NCBI Protein database, compared with NCBI’s BLAST program on 23 October 2026 for this course. These percents are for one protein, not for all of the DNA. The table has no animal-and-plant pair.

In the dot chart, each dot is one pair; higher dots matched more.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Every animal-and-fungus pair matched EF-1 alpha more closely than every fungus-and-plant pair did, by several percentage points. Image: a dot chart drawn by code from the table above, one dot per pair, grouped by kind of pair, on a 60 to 100 percent scale. Brown animal-and-fungus dots sit above all four green fungus-and-plant dots.

1. Find the mean match for the two animal-and-fungus pairs. Then find the mean for the four fungus-and-plant pairs.
2. Which is higher, and by about how many percentage points?
3. Which pair matches best of all? Why does that make sense?

**Predict.** From the human’s side, bread mold matched about 3 percentage points better than baker’s yeast. Does that make bread mold a closer relative of humans than yeast is?

> **Check your prediction.** No. Both are fungi, so on the family tree they are equally related to animals. The two percents cannot show why yeast’s version differs. Perhaps it changed more; yeast also matches both plants a little less. The animal-and-fungus gap is different: both animal-and-fungus pairs beat all four fungus-and-plant pairs. Even so, it is one protein, and many genes must agree.

- The fungi matched the blank more closely than the blank.
- This suggests that fungi share a more recent common ancestor with blank.
- One limit of this data is blank. (Hint: compare the human with yeast and with bread mold.)

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: where do fungi belong, and how can DNA evidence change that? Use the table.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that fungi are closer to blank than to blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: The two animal-and-fungus pairs have a mean match of blank percent, while the four fungus-and-plant pairs have a mean of blank percent.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: A higher match means blank, so fungi share a more recent common ancestor with blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Fungi are closer to animals than to plants. The two animal-and-fungus pairs have a mean match of about 82.3 percent. The four fungus-and-plant pairs have a mean of about 74.1 percent. A higher match means the protein is more alike, which suggests a more recent common ancestor. So fungi should not be grouped with plants. One limit: this is one protein from only five organisms, with one animal. Scientists trust the claim more because many other proteins agree.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

A fungus takes in food. Does baker’s yeast, a single-celled fungus, need sugar to stay active? Plan a test. Active yeast gives off a gas, carbon dioxide, which you can collect in a balloon.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Does yeast give off more gas when it has sugar to take in?
> - **Independent variable:** sugar added (0 grams or 10 grams).
> - **Dependent variable:** the distance around the balloon, in centimetres, after 30 minutes.
> - **Constants:** 7 grams of yeast, 100 millilitres of warm tap water, the same size bottle and balloon, the same room.
> - **Control:** the bottle with yeast and water but no sugar.
> - **Trials:** three bottles of each kind; find the mean of each.
> - **What results mean:** larger balloons with sugar show the yeast takes in sugar and breaks it down. Similar balloons would mean this test did not show a clear effect of sugar.
> - **Safety:** use warm tap water, never a flame or stove. Wear goggles, do not taste anything, and wash your hands.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Back to the one idea: cell clues and feeding moved the mushroom out of the plants, and the DNA rung put it beside the animals. Your two means differed by about 8 percentage points; the yeast and bread mold results showed why one protein needs backup from many genes.

**Science practices you used:** sorting organisms with evidence, reading a data table and finding a mean, making a claim with evidence and naming a limit, and planning a fair test with a control and repeated trials.

## Going deeper

DNA shows that protists come from many separate branches of Eukarya. Some look-alikes, such as water molds, share the fungus clues, but DNA shows they are not fungi. And for some genes, the archaea version is more like the version in your own cells than the bacteria version is.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/domains-kingdoms-and-dna/
