# DNA Is the Genetic Material

> DNA carries inherited information; complementary pairing gives each strand a copying rule. This lesson follows the evidence from Griffith's mice to Avery's purified transforming principle, Hershey and Chase's labelled phage, and the 1953 double helix, keeping each result inside the limits its authors stated. Afterwards you can read enzyme-sensitivity and tracer data, use base-pairing rules to work out base composition and strandedness, and explain how Meselson and Stahl tested the copying proposal.

Course: Genetics and Molecular Biology (DNA: copying, changing, repairing). Level: core university (third year). About 18 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/dna-the-genetic-material/

Builds on: Chromosomes and Meiosis: The Physical Basis of Mendel's Laws

## What you'll learn

- Explain what Griffith's 1928 mouse experiment showed about a transforming principle, and what it did not identify.
- Interpret the enzyme-sensitivity evidence that Avery, MacLeod and McCarty used to argue the principle was DNA, and state the objection it could not fully exclude.
- Explain how sulfur-35 and phosphorus-32 separated phage protein from phage DNA, and state the limits of the Hershey and Chase result.
- Use base-pairing rules to calculate base composition, strandedness and helix length, explain how complementary pairing suggests a copying mechanism, and describe the Meselson and Stahl density experiment that tested it.

The first film followed a heritable change to DNA. Everything in this lesson serves one idea:

> **The one idea. DNA carries inherited information; complementary pairing gives each strand a copying rule.**
>
> *Scope:* the identity claim is built here from pneumococcal transformation and DNA-phage experiments. The copying rule assumes canonical Watson-Crick pairing in duplex DNA; pairing supplies sequence information, not the machinery of replication.

A genetic material must store a great deal of information that differs among individuals and species. It must be copied faithfully before cell division, so an ordinary mitosis gives both daughters the same set. It must act by directing what the cell makes. These demands follow from [chromosomes and meiosis](https://stemhop.com/lessons/chromosomes-and-meiosis/).

Chromosomes contain protein and DNA. Protein looked the better candidate: it has about 20 amino-acid building blocks, while DNA has four bases and was thought to repeat simply. For nucleotide structure, see [nucleotide metabolism](https://stemhop.com/lessons/nucleotide-metabolism/).

## From a heritable change to an assay

The film’s rough and smooth cells were pneumococcus (*Streptococcus pneumoniae*), whose serological types are set by the polysaccharide capsule. Smooth (S) strains have a capsule and can kill a mouse; rough (R) variants lack it and are generally harmless.

The film left out the mice. In January 1928, Frederick Griffith injected mice with a small dose of living R bacteria derived from type II together with heat-killed type III S bacteria. One control series showed that the heated culture was sterile. Some mice died, and from them Griffith recovered living, encapsulated type III bacteria that bred true.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Griffith's result established a heritable change to the dead donor's type, but it did not identify the responsible substance. Image: a syringe loaded with a few living plain rough bacteria of type II origin and heat-killed capsule-coated type III smooth bacteria is injected into a mouse; the mouse dies and living gold-haloed type III bacteria are recovered that breed true; an inset shows neither ingredient alone gives this.

Griffith suggested that a specific protein structure in the dead cells let the living ones make the capsule. He left an **assay**, a scored experimental readout: transformation to the donor’s type, kept by descendants.

Later work at the Rockefeller Institute showed the change could be made in culture and then with extracts free of cells. Oswald Avery, Colin MacLeod and Maclyn McCarty purified the active fraction from type III cells and tested it on type II-derived R cells. In their 1944 paper, the nitrogen-to-phosphorus ratio and ultraviolet absorption matched nucleic acid. The protein-digesting enzymes were crystalline trypsin and chymotrypsin, and the RNA-digesting one was ribonuclease (RNase). The inherited change was specific to the donor’s type.

**Predict.** Why did each enzyme preparation need to be tested on a known substrate before the transformation result meant anything?

> **Check your prediction.** An unchanged transformation assay is informative only if the enzyme was active. A failed protease could leave a protein agent untouched, just as a failed ribonuclease could leave RNA untouched. Showing that each preparation digested its known target makes “activity remained” evidence against that target being required.

Their conclusion, “principally, if not solely” highly polymerized DNA within the limits of their methods, made DNA the leading candidate. The hedge left one objection open: a protein below the detection limit might be the real agent, with DNA as its carrier. The design problem asks how to answer it.

## An independent tracer test

The film’s phage was T2, a virus of *Escherichia coli*; see [bacterial and phage genetics](https://stemhop.com/lessons/bacterial-and-phage-genetics/). Its gold and blue paths stand for real [isotope tracers](https://stemhop.com/methods/isotope-tracers/). Cysteine and methionine put sulfur in protein, while DNA has none. DNA’s backbone is rich in phosphorus, while protein has little. Alfred Hershey and Martha Chase therefore used sulfur-35 to label protein and phosphorus-32 to label mostly DNA.

In their summarized result, about 75% of the sulfur came off into the fluid after blending, but only about 15% of the phosphorus did. Progeny carried less than 1% of parental sulfur and 30% or more of parental phosphorus.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Hershey-Chase tracer: where does each label end up after blending?

The authors assigned the coat a role in delivering DNA and said it probably had no function in intracellular phage growth. They left entry of sulfur-free material other than DNA undetermined, and a quarter of the sulfur stayed with the cells, so the result supports “most DNA entered, and most coat stayed out,” not “no protein entered.”

Heredity followed DNA; the next question is how that molecule could be copied.

**Film transcript: How One Strand Specifies Another**

### Film transcript: How One Strand Specifies Another

The first film traced inherited information to DNA. How can DNA make a copy? The clue is not the helix shape by itself. It is the matching rule inside a duplex. We will carry the first film's blue DNA into a picture made only of labelled blocks.

Start with base composition, the percentages of adenine, thymine, guanine and cytosine. Across double-stranded samples, adenine lies close to thymine, while guanine lies close to cytosine. A model must explain both matches while allowing different samples to carry different base sequences. Place two blue rails side by side, running in opposite directions. In canonical Watson-Crick pairing, adenine pairs with thymine, and guanine pairs with cytosine. The paired blocks explain the whole-duplex ratios. The rails are schematic, not molecular structures. Now unzip one short rail, leaving its partner positions empty. The old blocks remain blue. New blocks will arrive with green outlines.

Predict the new partner for the sequence shown on screen. Remember, adenine selects thymine, and guanine selects cytosine. Which blocks fill the empty rail? Each position admits its complementary block. The second rail is therefore specified by the first, not guessed. Reverse the reading direction, because the two strands are antiparallel. When both old rails separate, each can guide one new partner. One duplex can therefore become two matching duplexes. That is a copying proposal, not yet an experiment. It predicts that every daughter duplex keeps one old strand and receives one new strand. Give old strands a heavy marker and new strands a light marker.

Their combined density can reveal which strands stay together. Before transfer, DNA forms a heavy band. After one generation in light nitrogen, every duplex should contain one heavy and one light strand. That gives one hybrid band. After another generation, half the duplexes remain hybrid, while half contain two light strands. If parental strands stayed together, separate heavy and light bands would appear after the first generation. If old material dispersed through both strands, one band would shift gradually. The observed hybrid band, followed by hybrid and light bands, matched strand retention. The pattern, not exact density, is the test.

Pairing does two jobs in this model. It explains why complementary bases match across a duplex, and it lets each old strand specify a new sequence. The density bands test whether each daughter keeps one parental strand. They do not test every enzyme step. Structure supplied a rule; experiment tested its consequence.

From the film

- Complementary pairing lets each DNA strand specify a new partner.
- Whole-duplex base composition follows A equals T and G equals C.
- Density bands tested the prediction that each copy keeps one parental strand.

## The double helix: constraints before a model

The second film built the pairing rule from matched bars and rails. These are the measurements behind them.

**Base composition asks what must match.** The matched bars come from Erwin Chargaff’s laboratory at Columbia University, which around 1950 measured base composition, the percentage of all bases that are A, T, G or C, in DNA from many sources. Composition varied among species, arguing against a simple repeat. Within each sample, A was close to T and G close to C. Pairing requires those equalities only across double-stranded DNA as a whole.

**Fibre diffraction asks what geometry must fit.** At King’s College London, Rosalind Franklin and Raymond Gosling, and separately Maurice Wilkins with Alexander Stokes and Herbert Wilson, recorded X-ray patterns from DNA fibres. Franklin and Gosling showed that water content switches fibres between A and B forms. For B form, they measured a 3.4-angstrom spacing and a 34-angstrom repeat, judged the structure probably helical with phosphate outside, and considered two chains probable.

Their 1952 B-form pattern, later called Photograph 51, was shown to James Watson by Wilkins in early 1953. Wilkins, Stokes and Wilson found similar patterns from several sources, including biological ones. Diffraction could constrain repeated geometry, but not reveal base order.

**Model building asks whether one structure can satisfy both.** At Cambridge’s Cavendish Laboratory, Watson and Francis Crick built two right-handed chains around one axis. The chains run in opposite directions, like the film’s rails: they are **antiparallel**. Phosphates face outward. Bases face inward and pair by hydrogen bonds: adenine with thymine, guanine with cytosine. Their model, Franklin and Gosling’s paper and the Wilkins paper appeared together in *Nature* in April 1953.

Two refinements followed. Modern structures show three hydrogen bonds in a G-C pair and two in an A-T pair, but stacking between flat bases contributes greatly to helix stability; see [water and weak bonds](https://stemhop.com/lessons/water-weak-bonds/). The 1953 model assumed 10 base pairs per turn. Later measurements of B-DNA in solution gave about 10.5.

**Predict.** Two B-form segments have the same number of base pairs, but one has more G-C pairs. Using the dimensions here, is one segment longer?

> **Check your prediction.** No. Length is base pairs times the rise per base pair. Hydrogen-bond counts do not enter, so equal base-pair counts give equal calculated lengths under this model.

### Work from the pairing rules

Assume perfect Watson-Crick pairing in a duplex and percentages over every base in the sample.

**Predict.** A double-stranded DNA sample is 22% A. What percentages are T, G and C?

> **Check your prediction.** T equals A, so T is 22%. That leaves 56% for G plus C. Because G equals C, each is 28%.

> **A = T, G = C, and A + T + G + C = 100% in double-stranded DNA.**

**Predict.** A viral genome has A 25%, T 33%, G 24% and C 18%. What do the ratios say about strandedness?

> **Check your prediction.** The bases total 100%, but A does not equal T and G does not equal C. Under the perfect-pairing assumption, they are not paired across two full strands, so this is single-stranded DNA. Thymine with no uracil supports DNA, but sugar chemistry distinguishes DNA from RNA.

For helix dimensions, a **base pair**, abbreviated bp, is one paired position across the two strands. A 3,000 bp B-form segment with a rise of 0.34 nm per base pair and about 10.5 bp per turn has:

> **length = 3,000 × 0.34 nm = 1,020 nm, about 1.0 micrometre**
>
> **turns = 3,000 ÷ 10.5 = 285.7, about 286**

The 1953 model’s 10 bp per turn would give 300 turns. Rise is per base pair, so do not double it for two strands.

### From complement to copying

The film’s unzipped rail is the second half of the one idea: complementary pairing gives each strand a copying rule. To write a partner 5’ to 3’, pair the bases and then reverse the order, because the strands are antiparallel. In a second *Nature* paper later in 1953, Watson and Crick proposed that the chains separate and each serves as a template for a new partner.

The film’s density bands are the 1958 test by Matthew Meselson and Franklin Stahl. They grew *E. coli* on heavy nitrogen, moved it to light nitrogen and separated DNA by density: all hybrid after one generation, equal hybrid and light after two. [DNA replication](https://stemhop.com/lessons/dna-replication/) takes the mechanism further.

## Design problem: make the claim no larger than the data

A purified extract from heat-killed S type III cells turns type II-derived R cells into type III. Remaining activity is: untreated 100%, trypsin plus chymotrypsin 100%, ribonuclease (RNase) 100%, deoxyribonuclease (DNase) 0%, and heating to 65 C 90%. A critic proposes that a protein below 0.1% is the agent. What do the data show, and what would answer the critic?

> **One way to do it.** **Claim:** activity requires intact DNA and survives treatments that digest most protein and RNA. The small heat loss shows relative heat stability but does not identify the molecule.
>
> **Limit:** a detection limit cannot prove that a trace protein is absent, and that protein might resist the proteases used.
>
> **Next tests:** follow activity during purification. If activity per microgram of DNA stays constant while protein falls tenfold or more, a protein contaminant becomes harder to defend. Test dose response, though a co-purifying contaminant could follow DNA. Transfer another trait, such as drug resistance; later work by Rollin Hotchkiss and others did this. A protein account would then need a different trait-specific contaminant for each preparation. Finally, test an independent system, as Hershey and Chase did.
>
> Together, the 1944 and phage results made DNA the strongest candidate in these systems without making either experiment universal by itself.

## Going deeper

### The 1944 preparations

The active material’s nitrogen-to-phosphorus ratio ran from 1.58 to 1.75 across four preparations.

### Chargaff’s second rule

Each strand of most double-stranded genomes also comes close to A = T and G = C. This is Chargaff’s second rule; pairing does not require it.

### Franklin and the Nobel Prize

Franklin died in 1958. The 1962 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine went to Watson, Crick and Wilkins. The Nobel Prize has almost never been given after death; since 1974 its statutes have barred this, with rare exceptions such as death after announcement.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/dna-the-genetic-material/
