# Crossing the Membrane

> With no energy spent, a substance that can cross a membrane moves down its own gradient, and for water that means toward the side with more trapped solute; moving a substance uphill costs the cell energy, often from ATP. Why does a cucumber slice left in salty water get lighter and go soft? You will set the salt around a model cell and watch water move, switch on a protein pump, then read real mass data from a cucumber demonstration. Afterwards you can explain how a cell membrane lets some things in and keeps others out, and plan an osmosis test with potato pieces.

Course: Biology (Cells). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/crossing-the-membrane/

Builds on: Water and Life · What Am I Made Of? · Respiration and ATP

## What you'll learn

- You will describe the cell membrane as a selectively permeable double layer of lipids with proteins, and explain how that structure supports transport, cell communication and cell recognition.
- You will explain passive transport (diffusion, osmosis, facilitated diffusion) as movement from high to low concentration that needs no energy from the cell, and active transport (pumps that use ATP, endocytosis, exocytosis) as movement that needs energy, including against a concentration gradient.
- You will plan an investigation of how concentration affects osmosis, and use plant-tissue mass-change data to find the concentration at which water neither enters nor leaves on balance.

Now take the first film’s rule into real cells. **Leave one slice of cucumber in salty water and another in plain distilled water overnight. The salty slice gets lighter and turns soft and floppy, while the other slice gets heavier.** That happened in a filmed Open University demonstration. The same idea explains a stranger fact: drinking seawater leaves a person more dehydrated, not less.

> **The one idea.** With no energy spent, a substance that can cross a membrane moves on balance down its own gradient, from more concentrated to less. Water is no exception: it moves toward the side with more dissolved particles that cannot cross, because each drop there holds fewer water molecules. Moving a substance uphill, or carrying a big load in a bubble of membrane, costs the cell energy, often from ATP.
>
> *Scope:* water and uncharged substances crossing a cell membrane in dilute solutions like body fluids. A **solute** is any substance dissolved in water, such as salt or sugar. Charged ions also feel the membrane’s voltage; Biology II covers that.

Check what the first film showed, then one new idea. Agree or disagree?

1. Once molecules are spread out evenly, they stop moving. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** They keep jiggling. As the film’s tally showed, crossings go on equally both ways: no net movement. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** They keep jiggling. As the film’s tally showed, crossings go on equally both ways: no net movement.
2. Water always moves toward the side that has more water. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Water moves on balance toward the side with more dissolved stuff that cannot cross, such as salt. The cucumber data below test that. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Water moves on balance toward the side with more dissolved stuff that cannot cross, such as salt. The cucumber data below test that.
3. The cell membrane is a solid wall with holes in it. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** The membrane is a thin double layer of fatty molecules with proteins in it, and its parts move. In a 1970 experiment, scientists fused a mouse cell with a human cell and tagged each one’s surface proteins with glowing labels. In most fused cells the two sets of labels mixed within about 40 minutes at body temperature. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** The membrane is a thin double layer of fatty molecules with proteins in it, and its parts move. In a 1970 experiment, scientists fused a mouse cell with a human cell and tagged each one’s surface proteins with glowing labels. In most fused cells the two sets of labels mixed within about 40 minutes at body temperature.

## Explore: put a cell in salt water

In the osmosis chamber you set how salty the solution is around a plant cell or a red blood cell. Arrows show net water movement, and the cell swells, holds its size or shrinks. A second control switches on a protein pump that moves a substance from lower to higher concentration and counts the ATP it spends. The speeds in the model are for display, not measured rates.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Osmosis chamber: a cell in salt water

**Try this.**

1. Start with a red blood cell in a solution exactly as salty as the cell. Find how the arrows show crossings that go on with no net movement.
2. Make the outside much less salty. Predict what the red blood cell will do. Then switch to a plant cell, keep the same solution, and compare.
3. Make the outside much saltier than the cell. Predict which way the arrows point and what happens to each kind of cell.
4. Turn on the pump. Note which way it moves its substance, compared with the water, and what the ATP counter does.

## Explain: a thin, choosy boundary

- selectively permeable
- concentration gradient
- diffusion
- osmosis
- facilitated diffusion
- passive transport
- active transport
- hypertonic
- hypotonic
- isotonic
- endocytosis
- exocytosis

Every cell has a **cell membrane**, a thin boundary between the cell and its surroundings. The first film drew it as two rows of **phospholipids**, fat-like molecules with a water-loving head and two fatty tails that avoid water.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge phospholipid headsfatty tailschannel proteincarrier proteinreceptor proteinsugar chains phospholipid head

Proteins sit in this double layer, and many span it. The parts drift sideways, as the fused mouse and human cells showed, so the membrane is flexible, not a wall. It is **selectively permeable**: some substances cross easily and others hardly at all.

The membrane does three jobs.

- **Transport.** It controls which materials enter and leave the cell, and how.
- **Communication.** Receptor proteins on the surface bind signal molecules from outside, such as many hormones, and set off a response inside the cell.
- **Recognition.** Chains of sugar attached to surface proteins and lipids act like name tags. They help cells tell their own kind from others, which your immune system relies on.

A screen door is a fair analogy: it lets air in and keeps flies out. But a screen has fixed holes, while a membrane chooses by size, charge and its proteins.

**Key idea:**

The cell membrane is a moving double layer of lipids with proteins, and that build lets it choose what crosses, receive signals and recognize other cells.

## Explain: moving downhill with no energy

**Passive transport** is movement across a membrane down a **concentration gradient**, the first film’s difference in concentration between two places, and it needs no energy from the cell. It has three forms.

- **Diffusion** is spreading down a gradient, like the first film’s dye and oxygen.
- **Facilitated diffusion** is diffusion through a membrane protein. Channel proteins form water-friendly tunnels, and carrier proteins grab a molecule and change shape to pass it across. Glucose enters many of your cells by carriers, still moving from high to low.
- **Osmosis** is the first film’s net movement of water across a selectively permeable membrane.

### Which solutes count for osmosis

A solute that crosses freely spreads until it is even on both sides and leaves no lasting difference in water. So mainly solutes that cannot easily cross count, such as salt, which mostly cannot cross the lipid layer.

Three words describe the solution outside a cell compared with the inside, counting only trapped solutes: *hyper-* means more, *hypo-* means less, *iso-* means the same.

**Predict.** A plant cell and a red blood cell both sit in distilled water, and both are saltier inside. Water enters each one. What, if anything, stops it?

> **Check your prediction.** A plant cell has a stiff **cell wall** outside its membrane. As water enters, the cell presses on the wall and the wall presses back. That push is **turgor pressure**. It stops net water entry although the cell is still saltier inside (water still crosses both ways), and it holds up the leaves and stems of soft, nonwoody plants. A red blood cell has no wall, so it swells until it may burst.

| Solution outside the cell | Plain meaning | Net water movement | Plant cell | Red blood cell |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| **Hypertonic**: more trapped solute than inside | Saltier outside | Out of the cell | Loses turgor and wilts, like salted lettuce; in strong salt the membrane pulls away from the wall | Shrinks |
| **Isotonic**: same as inside | Balanced | None; water crosses both ways equally | Limp, with no push on its wall | Keeps its shape |
| **Hypotonic**: less trapped solute than inside | Less salty outside | Into the cell, until something stops it | Swells until its wall pushes back; firm | Swells, may burst |

**Worked case: drinking seawater.** Seawater holds about 35 grams of dissolved salts in each kilogram, according to NOAA. That is far saltier than your body fluids, which pull on water about as much as a 0.9% salt solution. Swallowed seawater sits in your gut, not next to most of your cells. Once its salt is absorbed, the fluid around your cells gets saltier, which can draw water out of them by osmosis. NOAA explains that your kidneys can only make urine less salty than seawater, so getting rid of the extra salt takes more water than you drank. The body loses water overall.

**Key idea:**

Water runs toward the side with more trapped solute until the two sides balance or a push from the other side, such as a cell wall’s, stops the net flow.

A living animal cell, though, keeps sodium much higher outside and potassium much higher inside. The second film shows what holding those differences costs.

**Film transcript: Paying to Go Uphill**

### Film transcript: Paying to Go Uphill

In the first film, whatever could cross ran downhill for free. So how does a cell keep so much sodium outside, and so much potassium inside? Look at an animal cell's membrane. Sodium shown in orange, is much higher outside the cell. Potassium shown in purple, is much higher inside. Each ion sits at the top of its own hill. A few channels in the membrane leak.

Sodium trickles in, and potassium trickles out. Each ion runs downhill, and the two differences start to shrink. A leak channel is an open tunnel, so ions pass through it only downhill. For ions, the hill also depends on the membrane's voltage.

Biology II covers that part. A pump is different. It grabs ions, changes shape, and spends energy to carry them uphill. Watch one cycle of the sodium-potassium pump. First, three sodium ions bind to the pump on the inside of the cell. The pump spends one ATP, the molecule that carries usable energy around the cell. The pump changes shape and releases the three sodium ions outside. Now two potassium ions bind on the outside. The pump changes shape again and carries them in. Both trips went uphill, against each ion's gradient. Every cycle, one ATP spent, three sodium out, two potassium in. While the pump keeps running, the meters hold steady, even though the leaks never close.

Movement that uses the cell's energy, often from ATP, is active transport. It can move a substance against its gradient. Diffusion and osmosis are passive transport, and need no energy from the cell. Now the cell runs out of ATP. The leak channels stay open. Which way will sodium move now? And which way will potassium move? Pause and predict.

The pump freezes. Sodium leaks in and potassium leaks out, both downhill. The two differences slowly shrink. The first film's rule has taken over again. So holding a difference is not a one-time payment. The leaks undo the pump's work all the time. The pump must keep spending ATP, cycle after cycle. Stop paying, and the differences drain away. That gives you one test for a substance crossing on its own. Is it going downhill? Then it is passive and free. Is it going uphill? Then the cell is paying.

From the film

- Active transport uses energy from the cell, often from ATP, and it can move a substance against its gradient.
- Each cycle, the sodium-potassium pump uses one ATP to move three sodium ions out and two potassium ions in, both uphill.
- Sodium and potassium leak back down their gradients through channels all the time, so the pump must keep working to hold the differences.
- Without ATP the pump stops, and the sodium and potassium differences slowly shrink.

## Explain: paying to move uphill

The second film’s pump moved single ions uphill. That is **active transport**, paid for with the cell’s energy, often from ATP ([the respiration lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/respiration-and-atp/)). Loads far too big for any channel or pump travel in **vesicles**, small bubbles of membrane, and this also needs energy.

- **Endocytosis** brings material into the cell. The membrane folds inward around it, and the pocket pinches off as a vesicle inside the cell. Some white blood cells engulf bacteria this way.
- **Exocytosis** releases material from the cell. A vesicle joins the cell membrane and spills its contents outside. [The organelles lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/organelles-as-a-system/) follows these vesicles.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Endocytosis folds the membrane around a load and pinches off a vesicle inside the cell; exocytosis runs the other way. Both use energy from the cell. Image: two rows of three frames. Top: a particle outside a cell membrane, the membrane folding around it, and a vesicle pinched off inside. Bottom: a vesicle inside the cell, the vesicle joining the membrane, and its contents spilling outside.

**Key idea:**

Active transport uses energy, often from ATP, to move substances against their gradient or to carry big loads in vesicles by endocytosis and exocytosis.

## Elaborate: weighing cucumber slices

In the Open University demonstration, one peeled cucumber slice went into water with added kitchen salt and one into distilled water. Each was blotted and weighed over time.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* In salty water a cucumber slice loses water and goes soft; in distilled water it gains water and stays firm. Image: two glass dishes, one of salty water and one of distilled water, each with a peeled cucumber slice; a small strip shows a slice being blotted and weighed; below, the slice from salty water droops while the other stays flat.

| Slice | Time in the liquid | Starting mass (g) | Mass then (g) | Change in mass (%) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Salty water | 1 hour | 26 | 24 | −7.7 |
| Salty water | 2 hours | 26 | 23 | −11.5 |
| Salty water | Overnight | 26 | 21 | −19.2 |
| Distilled water | 1 hour | 22 | 23 | +4.5 |
| Distilled water | 2 hours | 22 | 24 | +9.1 |
| Distilled water | Overnight | 22 | 30 | +36.4 |

Source: Janet Sumner, Open University (OpenLearn) filmed demonstration and transcript, accessed October 2026; no date is given. Masses were read to the whole gram, the salt was added as two spoonfuls with no concentration reported, and there was one slice for each liquid. Mass is a stand-in for water: some liquid can also soak into the cut surface and the spaces between cells. Percent changes are calculated from the reported masses:

> percent change in mass = 100 × (final mass − starting mass) ÷ starting mass

1. Describe the trend for each slice over time.
2. The distilled-water slice gained 8 grams overnight and the salty slice lost 5 grams. Why is percent change a fairer way to compare them than grams?
3. Can these data tell you the salt concentration at which a slice would neither gain nor lose mass? Explain what is missing.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers this: why did the cucumber slice in salty water lose mass while the slice in distilled water gained it? Use the table.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that water moved blank the slice in salty water and blank the slice in distilled water.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: Overnight, the salty slice changed by blank% and the distilled-water slice changed by blank%.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This happens because water moves by osmosis toward the side with more blank, so the salty water was blank to the cucumber cells.

> **Compare with a model answer.** Water left the slice in salty water and entered the slice in distilled water. Overnight, the salty slice went from 26 to 21 grams, a change of about −19%, while the distilled-water slice went from 22 to 30 grams, about +36%. In osmosis, water moves on balance toward the side with more dissolved solute. The salty water was hypertonic to the cucumber cells, so they lost water and turgor and the slice went soft. Distilled water was hypotonic, so water moved in. These data come from one slice in each liquid, with the salt concentration not stated, so they cannot show the balance point.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Plan an investigation to find the sugar concentration at which potato pieces neither gain nor lose mass. Name your variables (what you change and what you measure), constants, control and sample size, and say how you will stay safe.

> **One way to do it.** - **Independent variable:** sucrose concentration, for example 0.0, 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4, 0.6, 0.8 and 1.0 mol/L.
> - **Dependent variable:** the percent change in mass of each piece.
> - **Constants:** one potato, same-size pieces, the same volume of solution, temperature, soaking time and blotting method.
> - **Control:** the 0.0 mol/L dish of distilled water, with no added sugar.
> - **Sample size and trials:** at least three pieces in each solution, assigned at random. Find each piece’s percent change, then the mean and spread.
> - **Analysis:** plot mean percent change against concentration and find where the line crosses zero, between a gain and a loss. If every piece gained or every piece lost, the balance point lies outside your range.
> - **Safety:** care with the knife, labelled dishes, no tasting.
>
> The zero point estimates where the potato cells neither gain nor lose water under your conditions. It does not measure exactly what is dissolved inside them, because their turgor pressure against their walls also affects how much water they take in.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

One rule answers both opening questions: with no energy spent, water runs toward more trapped solute. Cucumber cells lose water straight into the salty water around them. Seawater works in two steps, as the worked case showed: absorbed salt can draw water from your cells, and getting rid of that salt costs more water than you drank. The cell spends energy only to move a substance uphill, as the pump does, or to carry a load in a vesicle.

**Science practices you used:** making predictions and testing them with a model, calculating percent change from measured masses, reading a data table and naming its limits, and planning a fair test with a control, repeated pieces and a mean.

## Going deeper

### How few water molecules are missing?

For the first film’s salty drop: in an idealized 0.9% salt solution, each unit of salt splits into a sodium and a chloride ion, and only about 5 or 6 of every 1,000 particles are those ions. So body fluid has only about half a percent less water than pure water, yet in pure water that small gap is enough to burst a red blood cell.

### Salt in the Chesapeake Bay

The Chesapeake Bay Program describes its head and tidal rivers as below 0.5 parts per thousand of salt and its mouth as averaging 25 to 30 parts per thousand. A cell from the bay’s mouth, in balance with the water there, is placed in water from the bay’s head. Is it in a hypertonic, isotonic or hypotonic solution? (Hypotonic: the water outside now holds far less trapped solute than the cell.)

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/crossing-the-membrane/
