# Competition and Cooperation

> Limited resources can restrict populations; cooperation can help members meet their needs. Members of one population and members of different species can compete without fighting, while cooperation can help a group get food, stay safe and raise young. You run a model tube, read Gause’s 1934 paramecium counts, compare each population alone and sharing food, and trace how living and nonliving limiting factors restrict populations and how a change in one population can affect others.

Course: Life Science (Living together). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/competition-and-cooperation/

Builds on: Photosynthesis Feeds the World · Food Webs and Energy

## What you'll learn

- You will explain how members of populations compete for the resources they need (food, water, shelter, mates and territory), how plants compete too, and how members of a population cooperate to meet their needs, as honeybees, wolves and schools of fish do.
- You will explain limiting factors, the biotic and abiotic things (such as food, water, shelter, disease and predation) that can restrict how many of a species can live in an ecosystem, and how a change in one population in an interdependent community affects others.
- You will read Gause’s paramecium counts, grown alone and together, and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, about how competing for the same food changed each population.

The first film showed both paramecium kinds ending lower when they shared one food supply. It left three things for you to work out. What stops a single population from growing? When did the shared-tube effect begin? How can you tell which kind lost more?

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Competition is always about fighting. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Gause’s paramecia never fought. They ate the same bacteria, and bacteria eaten by one were gone for the other. Once the counts stopped rising, Gause saw the paramecia eat each day’s bacteria until the liquid cleared. Competing often means getting a limited thing first or using it better. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Gause’s paramecia never fought. They ate the same bacteria, and bacteria eaten by one were gone for the other. Once the counts stopped rising, Gause saw the paramecia eat each day’s bacteria until the liquid cleared. Competing often means getting a limited thing first or using it better.
2. Plants do not compete with each other. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Plants need light, water and minerals from soil, and a crowded patch has only so much of each. A tall plant can shade a short one, so some plants grow taller or turn their leaves toward the light. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Plants need light, water and minerals from soil, and a crowded patch has only so much of each. A tall plant can shade a short one, so some plants grow taller or turn their leaves toward the light.
3. Only different species compete. Members of one species do not compete. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Members of one species need many of the same things: the same food, the same shelter and mates of their own kind. So they often compete with each other. Ecologists see this in plants and animals. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Members of one species need many of the same things: the same food, the same shelter and mates of their own kind. So they often compete with each other. Ecologists see this in plants and animals.

## Explore: share a tube of food

The model shows paramecia as colored dots and tracks their populations with bars for 20 days. You control the daily food, whether a second kind enters, and **food overlap**: how much of the same food both kinds use.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Share a tube of food: one kind or two

**Predict 1.** Keep one kind alone. If you change its daily food from medium to low, how will its highest bar change?

> **Test your prediction.** Run medium food, then low food. The population grows in both runs, but less food supports a lower population. It does not grow forever in either run.

Now add the second kind. Run one test with the same food and one with different food. Record which setup lets both populations remain common. The first film listed what this model leaves out, so check its pattern against real counts.

## Read the evidence: alone and together

- population
- community
- competition
- cooperation
- limiting factor
- biotic factor
- abiotic factor
- interdependent

The first film defined a **population**: all the members of one species in one area at one time. It also defined **competition**: needing the same resource when there is not enough for all. A **community** is all the populations in an area that interact. A **resource** is something a living thing needs, such as food, water, shelter, a mate or **territory**. Territory is the area an animal uses and keeps others out of.

Every day, Gause added a fresh, measured amount of bacterial food to each tube and counted a measured sample.

| Day | P. aurelia alone (per 0.5 mL) | P. caudatum alone (per 0.5 mL) | P. aurelia, sharing (per 0.5 mL) | P. caudatum, sharing (per 0.5 mL) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 |
| 2 | 14 | 10 | 10 | 10 |
| 4 | 56 | 11 | 58 | 29 |
| 6 | 189 | 56 | 202 | 88 |
| 8 | 330 | 137 | 221 | 124 |
| 12 | 610 | 199 | 302 | 83 |
| 16 | 560 | 179 | 363 | 55 |
| 25 | 510 | 180 | 350 | 20 |

These are mean counts in a 0.5 mL sample from Gause’s 1934 book *The Struggle for Existence*. Only eight days are shown. From day 20, Gause took samples from similar tubes together.

Start with day 25 and compare each kind with itself:

- *P. aurelia:* 510 alone − 350 sharing = **160 fewer** per sample.
- *P. caudatum:* 180 alone − 20 sharing = **160 fewer** per sample.

The drops match, but the effects were not equal. Twenty is a small part of 180, while 350 is still a large part of 510.

**Predict 2.** On day 12, aurelia had 610 per sample alone and caudatum had 199. Was aurelia about two, three or six times as common?

> **Check the calculation.** Divide 610 by 199. The result is about 3.1, so aurelia was about three times as common.

Now find it in the table: on which day was caudatum highest when sharing, and what happened after that?

> **Check your reading.** Day 8, at 124 per sample. After that it fell on every day shown, to 20 by day 25, but it had not reached zero.

On days 4 and 6, both kinds were higher together than alone. The table does not show how much food each kind received. Once crowded, the paramecia ate each day’s bacteria until the liquid cleared. Running out of food helped stop their growth, though Gause wrote that other conditions in the liquid mattered too.

**The one idea:**

Limited resources can restrict populations; cooperation can help members meet their needs.

**Scope:**

This rule applies when living things in a population or community share needs. It does not mean every shared resource causes competition, competition always removes a species, or cooperation removes environmental limits.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the question: how did sharing the same food change each population? Use the table. Here sharing means using one tube and one food supply, not cooperating.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: When the two kinds shared a tube, blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: On day 25, caudatum had blank per sample alone and blank sharing, while aurelia had blank alone and blank sharing.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This happened because both kinds ate blank, so blank. The table cannot tell us blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** By day 25, sharing a tube had held both kinds back, but caudatum much more. On that day, caudatum had 180 per sample alone but only 20 when sharing. Aurelia had 510 alone and 350 sharing. The effect came later: on days 4 and 6, both kinds were higher when sharing. Both kinds ate the same bacteria, so food eaten by one was gone for the other. Aurelia stayed more common. The data have limits: these are lab tubes, not a pond, the counts come from small samples, and they do not show how much food each kind got, so the table alone cannot prove food was the only cause.

Saved in this browser only.

## Competing for what you need

Every living thing needs matter and energy. Animals get both from food. Plants capture energy from sunlight and take in water, carbon dioxide and minerals, as you saw in [the photosynthesis lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/photosynthesis-feeds-the-world/). Most of these needs are limited.

The first film showed quiet competition in a tube. Outside the lab, two male deer may push with their antlers in the breeding season, and robins on one lawn hunt the same worms. Plants compete for light, water and minerals. A tall plant can shade a short one. Depending on the plant and its neighbors, plants may grow taller, spread longer roots or turn leaves toward light.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge a tall plant shading a shorter oneleaves turned toward the lightroots of neighbors spreading into the sam

**Predict 3.** In the cut-away garden, which limited resource is shared above ground, and which two are shared below ground?

> **Check your prediction.** The plants share light above ground. Their roots draw water and minerals from the same soil below ground.

**Key idea:**

Living things compete when they need the same limited resource, and often that means getting it first, not fighting.

Over many generations, inherited traits that help individuals get food may help them leave more young. So competition can shape helpful traits called adaptations, as [the natural selection lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/natural-selection-in-action/) explains. Kinds that use different foods or places compete less; [the habitat and niche lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/habitat-and-niche/) develops that idea.

Needing the same resource can hold living things back. But members of one population can also work together.

**Film transcript: When Working Together Helps**

### Film transcript: When Working Together Helps

The first film showed two populations drawing from one limited supply. If limits hold populations back, how can working together help? Gold food dots leave the tube and enter a honeybee colony. The same resource now moves along green paths. The picture changes, but the question about limited needs remains.

Cooperation happens when members of a population work together to meet their needs. In a colony, workers collect food, guard the hive, and care for young. They also pass liquid food from bee to bee. The shares are not always equal. The picture separates the jobs so their different effects stay easy to follow. Imagine every worker collecting food while nobody guards or cares for young. Which needs would go unmet? Watch the green paths, and decide what different jobs add to the group. Hold the whole colony in mind, not one worker.

Different jobs connect several needs at once. One worker brings food, another guards, and another tends young. Together, the workers meet several colony needs at once. Each linked job supports needs that one collector cannot cover.

Cooperation helps, but every worker still needs resources. Other populations cooperate in different ways. A wolf pack can catch large prey such as elk. A tight school can make one fish harder for a predator to catch. Working together can help members get food or stay safe. Cooperation does not remove limits. A limiting factor is anything in the environment that can restrict a population.

Living factors are biotic, such as food, disease, and predators. Nonliving factors are abiotic, such as water and temperature. Shelter can be living or nonliving, depending on what provides it. Populations in a community are interdependent. A change in one can affect another. If disease reduces a rabbit population, foxes have less food. The disease strikes rabbits directly, then reaches foxes through their food link. The foxes can be affected even if the disease never infects them. Limited resources can restrict populations; cooperation can help members meet their needs. Both can happen in the same population.

Cooperation changes what members can accomplish together. Help and limits belong in the same picture. It does not make food, water, shelter, disease, or predators disappear.

From the film

- Limited resources can restrict populations; cooperation can help members meet their needs.
- Cooperation happens when members of a population work together to meet their needs.
- Living and nonliving limiting factors can restrict how many of a species live in a place.
- Because populations are linked, a change in one population can affect others.

## Working together

The second film defined **cooperation** and followed honeybees, wolves and fish. Working together does not make every share equal, and it does not remove limits. [The predators and prey lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/predators-and-prey/) follows the wolf example further.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Cooperation can help population members share work, catch food or lower one individual's risk. Image: three panels. Worker honeybees on comb pass a drop of liquid food, tend a larva and guard the entrance; a wolf pack runs together around an elk; a tight school of small fish swims close together as a larger fish approaches.

**Key idea:**

Working together can help members of a population get food, stay safe and raise young.

## Limiting factors and linked lives

A **limiting factor** is anything in the environment that can restrict which species, or how many of a species, live in an ecosystem. The second film sorted these into **biotic factors** (living) and **abiotic factors** (nonliving).

| Limiting factor | Biotic or abiotic | How it can limit a population |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Food | Biotic | Less food means fewer young survive. |
| Water | Abiotic | In a dry summer, some animals and plants die. |
| Shelter | Either | Too few dens or nest holes leave some animals exposed. |
| Disease | Biotic | Sickness can spread faster in a crowded group. |
| Predation | Biotic | Predators eat some members of the population. |
| Cold weather | Abiotic | A hard freeze can kill many animals at once. |

A hollow tree is living shelter; a gap in rocks is nonliving shelter. Because populations depend on one another, the community is **interdependent**, and the second film traced one link, from rabbits to foxes.

**Predict 4.** A disease kills many rabbits. Besides leaving less food for foxes, what will probably happen to plants the rabbits ate?

> **Check your prediction.** With fewer rabbits eating them, the plants will probably grow more. One population change can spread along more than one link.

**Key idea:**

Living and nonliving limiting factors can restrict populations, and linked populations can affect one another.

### Design problem

Plan a test of whether crowding makes plants compete. You can use radish seeds, pots, potting soil, water and a balance.

**Predict 5.** If each pot gets the same water, will adding more plants give each plant more, less or the same water?

> **Check your prediction.** Less. The amount per pot stays the same, but more plants draw from it. The experiment must measure growth to test whether that change matters.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** How does the number of plants in a pot affect how much each plant grows?
> - **Independent variable:** plants per pot, such as 1, 4, 8 and 16.
> - **Dependent variable:** mean mass of each plant in grams after three weeks. Pull the plants, rinse off the soil, blot them dry and weigh them. Then divide each pot’s total plant mass by its number of plants.
> - **Control:** pots with one plant, which has no neighbors to compete with.
> - **Constants:** pot size, the same soil, the same water in mL each day, the same light and the same temperature.
> - **Repeated trials:** at least three pots for each crowding level.
> - **What results would mean:** if mean mass per plant falls as crowding rises, the plants were probably competing for light, water or minerals.
> - **Safety:** wear gloves or wash your hands after handling soil. Do not eat the plants or seeds.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

By the last day shown, sharing had held both of Gause’s paramecium kinds back, but caudatum much more. Remember the rule: limited resources can restrict populations; cooperation can help members meet their needs.

**Science practices you used:** making predictions with a model and naming its limits, reading a data table and comparing numbers, making a claim backed by evidence and reasoning, and planning a fair test with a control and repeated trials.

## Going deeper

### How Gause took his counts

Gause’s tubes held 5 mL of liquid. The counts come from Table 3 of his 1934 book *The Struggle for Existence*, pages 144 to 145.

### Plants and the shade of neighbors

In a 2017 greenhouse study, plants changed how they grew when green filters copied the shade of crowded neighbors. Under short neighbors they grew most upright, which can help a plant get above the others.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/competition-and-cooperation/
