# Classification Changes

> Classification changes when new evidence changes the best-supported picture of ancestry. You will remodel a five-kingdom tree with new evidence cards, follow the ribosomal RNA comparison that separated Archaea from Bacteria, and read real similarity scores from the 1977 study. Afterwards you can explain why groups change and support a classification claim with molecular evidence.

Course: Biology (Classifying life). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/classification-changes/

Builds on: Domains and Kingdoms · Building a Tree of Life · DNA: Structure and Copying

## What you'll learn

- You will explain that classification changes when new evidence changes the best-supported picture of ancestry, and that molecular biology and DNA sequencing have led scientists to reclassify many organisms.
- You will explain how comparing ribosomal RNA led to the three-domain system (Woese and Fox 1977; Woese, Kandler and Wheelis 1990), and give one other example of reclassification from DNA or protein evidence.
- You will make, support and evaluate a claim that classification systems can adapt to new scientific discoveries, using real sequence-comparison data.

Now test the first film’s reasoning on a tree, other organisms and real data.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Once scientists put an organism into a group, it stays there for good. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Whole groups have moved. A 1977 comparison of ribosomal RNA separated methane-making microbes from typical bacteria. Nuclear DNA studies from 2001 to 2010 supported splitting African elephants into two species. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Whole groups have moved. A 1977 comparison of ribosomal RNA separated methane-making microbes from typical bacteria. Nuclear DNA studies from 2001 to 2010 supported splitting African elephants into two species.
2. If scientists reclassify something, earlier scientists were bad at science. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Earlier biologists used the evidence they had: body form, cell structure and how organisms get food. DNA and RNA comparisons added new evidence. Revising a group to fit better evidence is careful science. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Earlier biologists used the evidence they had: body form, cell structure and how organisms get food. DNA and RNA comparisons added new evidence. Revising a group to fit better evidence is careful science.
3. Fungi are more closely related to plants than to animals. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Fungi look plant-like, but a 1993 protein comparison strongly supported fungi being closer to animals. Fungi had already received their own kingdom in 1969. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Fungi look plant-like, but a 1993 protein comparison strongly supported fungi being closer to animals. Fungi had already received their own kingdom in 1969.

## Explore: remodel a tree with new evidence

Start with the five-kingdom tree many biologists used in the 1970s. Add an RNA comparison, a test of cell-membrane fats or a set of gene sequences. Each card redraws the tree and names the evidence that moved a group.

**Predict 1.** Will the final supported tree depend on the order of the cards, or only on which evidence is present?

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tree remodel: add evidence, watch the tree change

**Try this.**

1. Before any card, predict which kingdom will split first. Then add the RNA card.
2. Test Predict 1: add the cards in two orders.
3. Watch where Fungi sit after the gene card. Did they move toward plants or animals?
4. Remove one card. Which branch loses support?

## Build the model: evidence tests a tree

- classification
- kingdom
- domain
- phylogeny
- embryology
- protist
- ribosomal RNA
- Archaea
- Bacteria
- Eukarya

**Classification** sorts living things into groups based on relationships. The groups nest inside one another. A **kingdom** is a large group, such as plants or animals. A **domain** is the largest group, above kingdom.

A **phylogeny** is the history of ancestors and descendants, often drawn as a branching tree. Classification groups are meant to follow that history. Biologists test a phylogeny with several kinds of evidence:

- **Structure:** body parts and cell parts, such as a nucleus or cell wall.
- **Embryology:** the study of early development, before birth, hatching or sprouting.
- **DNA and RNA:** the order of bases in genes and other molecules.

> **The one idea.** Classification changes when new evidence changes the best-supported picture of ancestry.
>
> *Scope:* New evidence includes a new reading of old evidence. The rule describes modern classification. Early schemes, such as Linnaeus’s, sorted by similarity. Some changes only rename a group. One result does not settle every branch.

## How ribosomal RNA exposed a hidden branch

The first film showed how lists of **ribosomal RNA** (rRNA) pieces compare distant cells. rRNA is the RNA that forms much of every ribosome. Each overlap score ran from 0, no overlap, to 1, the same. In 1977, Woese and Fox interpreted the film’s two-way pattern as evidence for three major lines of descent: eubacteria, archaebacteria and urkaryotes. The scores have no units, are not percentages of DNA and cannot date a split.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A repeated pattern of rRNA-piece overlap placed methane makers together and apart from typical bacteria. Image: four steps from left to right. Two methane-making cells and one typical bacterium each hold ribosomes; their rRNA is cut into short pieces, the pieces from each are listed in a column, and the two methane makers' lists share many pieces while a methane maker and the bacterium share few.

In 1990, Woese, Otto Kandler and Mark Wheelis proposed three domains:

- **Bacteria:** familiar single-celled prokaryotes, such as *E. coli*.
- **Archaea:** single-celled prokaryotes that differ from bacteria in their RNA and membranes.
- **Eukarya:** organisms whose cells have a nucleus, including animals, plants, fungi and protists. The paper spelled this name Eucarya.

**Predict 2.** If Archaea is a group based on ancestry, must every archaeon live in an extreme place?

> **Check your prediction.** No. The 1977 samples included one that grows best at moderate temperatures. In 1992, archaea were found in ordinary coastal seawater. Habitat alone does not define the domain.

**Key idea:**

Comparing rRNA, which all cells share, revealed Archaea as a domain separate from Bacteria.

Archaea moved because a repeated pattern challenged one old group. Does every new result move a branch? The second film tests that question on smaller branches.

**Film transcript: When Evidence Redraws a Branch**

### Film transcript: When Evidence Redraws a Branch

Archaea moved because a repeated pattern challenged one old group. How do we decide whether another branch should move? Start with the current tree as a claim. Then ask which relationship each new comparison supports. Fungi once seemed plant-like because they grow in place and have cell walls. On our tree, a mushroom icon begins beside a plant. That placement is a hypothesis about ancestry.

Looking alike can suggest a group, but the branch must survive other tests. Protein comparisons supplied another test. Several protein trees grouped the sampled fungi with animals. Shared added or missing stretches supported the same relationship. The mushroom branch slides beside the animal branch. This does not mean animals came from modern mushrooms. A result can be a clue, not a final verdict.

Confidence grows when different comparisons support the same branch and sampling is broad enough. Conflicting results send scientists back to methods, markers and organisms. The tree stays open to testing. A new evidence card supports the branch already drawn, and no strong comparison challenges it. Should scientists move that branch, keep it, or erase the whole tree?

Choose before the card reaches the joint. Keep it. New evidence does not require movement. It may strengthen the present relationship instead. Revision belongs where the evidence changes the picture. Scientists should not rebuild every branch because a well-supported branch was tested. The same logic reaches species.

Nuclear DNA supported treating forest and savanna elephants as separate species. Yet one large study sampled very few animals of each kind. Broad stretches of DNA strengthened the split, while the small sample kept a limit visible. DNA comparisons also placed whales among even-toed hoofed mammals, with hippos as their closest living relatives.

Gene sequences split the old Protista kingdom into many branches. These changes differ in scale, but each asks which tree fits the evidence. Each change still needs its own evidence and its own limits. Reclassification changes the scientific model. It does not make organisms switch ancestors, and it does not prove earlier scientists careless. They used the evidence available. Better tools can reveal patterns that shape, habitat or a short comparison could not show. Ask these questions whenever a group changes. What relationship did the old tree claim? What new pattern challenges it? What important limits remain? Those questions turn a changed label into a clear evidence-based scientific explanation.

From the film

- Classification changes when new evidence changes the best-supported picture of ancestry.
- Scientists revise the classification model; organisms do not switch ancestry.
- New evidence can strengthen a branch instead of moving it.
- Different kinds of molecular evidence can test relationships suggested by appearance.
- A classification claim stays open to more evidence.

## Other groups that moved

The second film gave the logic of each move. Here are the numbers, dates and limits.

- **Fungi and animals.** In 1993, trees built from four protein sequences grouped animals with fungi. Across 25 proteins, the sampled animals and fungi shared four insertions or deletions (added or missing stretches of amino acids). Plants, protists and bacteria lacked them.
- **Two African elephants.** Nuclear DNA support for two species, forest and savanna, began in 2001. A 2010 study added 39,763 DNA bases from 375 places in the nuclear genome. It sampled only one or two animals of each kind, so it could not settle every detail.
- **Whales.** With whales placed among the even-toed hoofed mammals, some biologists call the combined group Cetartiodactyla. Others widen Artiodactyla to include whales.

**Predict 3.** If two group names cover the same whales and hoofed mammals, must they show different phylogenies?

> **Check your prediction.** No. Cetartiodactyla and a widened Artiodactyla can name the same branch. Evidence decides where whales sit on the tree. Which name to use is a separate choice.

A reclassification makes the groups fit the current evidence better, not perfectly, so they can be revised again.

**Key idea:**

Scientists revise the classification model; organisms do not switch ancestry.

## Use real data: the 1977 similarity scores

Each score compares the rRNA-piece lists of two laboratory samples.

| Sample A | Sample B | Kind of pair | Similarity score (no units, 0 to 1) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Yeast (*Saccharomyces cerevisiae*) | Duckweed (*Lemna minor*) | Within eukaryotes | 0.29 |
| *Escherichia coli* | *Bacillus firmus* | Within bacteria | 0.25 |
| *Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum* | *M. ruminantium* | Within methane makers | 0.51 |
| Yeast | *E. coli* | Between groups | 0.05 |
| Yeast | *B. firmus* | Between groups | 0.08 |
| Yeast | *M. thermoautotrophicum* | Between groups | 0.11 |
| Yeast | *M. ruminantium* | Between groups | 0.11 |
| *E. coli* | *M. thermoautotrophicum* | Between groups | 0.11 |
| *E. coli* | *M. ruminantium* | Between groups | 0.12 |

Source: Woese and Fox, PNAS 1977, Table 1. The names are those used in 1977. These nine pairs came from a larger table, so this is a chosen teaching set, not a random sample.

**Predict 4.** Before calculating means, compare the ranges. Is any selected between-group score higher than any selected within-group score?

> **Check your prediction.** No. The largest selected between-group score is 0.12. The smallest selected within-group score is 0.25. That separation describes this chosen set, not every possible sample.

1. Find the mean of the three within-group scores and the six between-group scores.
2. Compare *E. coli* with *B. firmus* against *E. coli* with each methane maker.
3. Explain which placement for the methane makers fits this evidence.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: can sequence evidence justify changing how we classify life? Use these 1977 scores.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that the methane makers blank, so classification blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: The within-group mean is blank while the between-group mean is blank. The two methane makers scored blank with each other but only blank with E. coli.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: A higher score means blank. Because the methane makers blank, scientists were right to blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** The scores support placing the methane makers in their own group, so classification can change with new evidence. The mean of the three within-group scores is 0.35, and the mean of the six between-group scores is about 0.10. The two methane makers scored 0.51 with each other but only 0.11 and 0.12 with E. coli, which scored 0.25 with another bacterium. A higher score means more shared rRNA pieces, so the methane makers are more like each other than like typical bacteria. One limit: these are nine chosen pairs from one 1977 table, and the scores cannot date the splits.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

You think a newly found pond microbe might be an archaeon, not a bacterium. Plan a sequence comparison.

**Predict 5.** Why would comparing it with one archaeon and one bacterium be weaker than using several of each?

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Is the pond microbe’s rRNA more similar to known archaea or known bacteria?
> - **Independent variable:** the comparison organism, using several known archaea and bacteria.
> - **Dependent variable:** percent matching bases in the same rRNA gene.
> - **Constants:** the same gene, sequence length and computer method for every pair.
> - **Control:** compare two known bacteria and two known archaea to show within-group scores.
> - **Repeated trials and sample size:** sequence the pond microbe more than once and use at least five organisms from each domain. One unusual comparison organism could mislead.
> - **Second evidence line:** check another gene or membrane fats, since one marker can mislead.
> - **Safety:** treat unknown microbes as possible germs and grow them only in a supervised lab.
>
> If the microbe scores clearly higher with every archaeon than with every bacterium, and the second marker agrees, the evidence supports calling it an archaeon.

## Going deeper: systems change, and testing continues

Each date below marks publication of a scheme, not the year everyone agreed.

| Year | Scheme | What changed |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1735 | Linnaeus, *Systema naturae* | Living things sorted as plants or animals (minerals too) |
| 1866 | Haeckel | Protista added as a third living kingdom |
| 1938 | Copeland | A four-kingdom system, with bacteria apart |
| 1969 | Whittaker | Five kingdoms, with Fungi apart from plants |
| 1977 | Woese and Fox | RNA evidence for three major lines of descent |
| 1990 | Woese, Kandler and Wheelis | Three domains placed above the kingdoms |

Many US textbooks use six kingdoms: Archaebacteria, Eubacteria, Protista, Fungi, Plantae and Animalia. A **protist** is a eukaryote that is not a plant, animal or fungus. Virginia’s Biology standards keep Protista as a kingdom, so you will use it. Newer trees divide protists into separate groups because some are closer to animals or plants than to other protists.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge plants or animalsProtista addedFive kingdomsThree domainssix kingdoms plants or animalsblankblankThree do

Testing continues. Since 2015, genome studies have placed eukaryotes inside the Asgard archaea. If that model is right, eukaryotes grew from within Archaea, leaving two primary branches of cellular life rather than three. Studies from 2023 and 2025 disagree about the exact branch, and scientists still use the three domain names.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

The methane makers looked like bacteria, but their rRNA showed a line of descent the microscope could not. Classification changes when new evidence changes the best-supported picture of ancestry.

**Science practices you used:** using a model and naming its limits, calculating and comparing means, and making and judging a claim from evidence.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/classification-changes/
