# The Citric Acid Cycle: Harvesting Electrons

> The citric acid cycle makes almost no ATP itself, just one GTP (or ATP) per turn. Its real product is high-energy electrons — three NADH and one FADH2 per acetyl-CoA — carried off to the electron transport chain where most of the cell's ATP is actually minted. Its intermediates also serve as raw material for building fatty acids, amino acids, heme and glucose, so the cell must refill them. Watch one carbon, count the cofactors, and notice that every turn ends by rebuilding oxaloacetate: in net terms oxaloacetate is a catalyst, not a fuel, a misconception that costs many exam points.

Course: Biochemistry (Central Metabolism). Level: university elective. About 25 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/citric-acid-cycle/

Builds on: The Pyruvate Dehydrogenase Complex: The One-Way Gate to the Cycle · Glycolysis: The Investment-and-Payoff Pathway · Metabolism: Basic Concepts and Design

## What you'll learn

- Explain the cycle's true job — harvesting high-energy electrons (3 NADH + 1 FADH2 per acetyl-CoA) — and why the 1 GTP and 2 CO2 are byproducts, not the point.
- Show that oxaloacetate acts catalytically: each turn rebuilds it, so turning the cycle does not use it up, even though its carbon atoms are swapped over many turns (a common misconception).
- Walk all eight enzymes as a two-stage factory — Stage One (steps 1–4) burns two carbons to CO2 and banks 2 NADH; Stage Two (steps 5–8) rebuilds oxaloacetate and banks 1 GTP, 1 FADH2, and 1 NADH.
- Locate the main control points (citrate synthase, isocitrate dehydrogenase and α-ketoglutarate dehydrogenase) and apply the rule of thumb: ATP/NADH = STOP, ADP/NAD+/Ca2+ = GO.
- Account for why O2 is not a substrate of the cycle yet is absolutely required, and finish the ATP math to ~10 ATP per acetyl-CoA (~30–32 per glucose).

**Add a pinch of a four-carbon acid to minced pigeon breast muscle, and the muscle burns far more oxygen than oxidizing that pinch could ever explain.**

That is what Szent-Györgyi and then Krebs saw when they measured the muscle’s oxygen use. The acid was not being used up as fuel. It was being reused, over and over, to burn something else. That reuse is what makes the citric acid cycle a cycle.

*The film above follows the electrons; the ledger below follows the chemistry step by step.*

## Where we are, and what the cycle is for

Glycolysis handed off two pyruvates and warned us the real bottleneck was NAD⁺. Here that warning comes due. In the mitochondrial matrix, pyruvate dehydrogenase turns each pyruvate into acetyl-CoA, releasing one CO₂ and one NADH. One glucose, two acetyl-CoA, two turns of the cycle. Everything below is per acetyl-CoA.

The film above follows the cycle’s real product into the electron transport chain. The scale of that handoff is stark: one NADH’s electron pair, handed to oxygen, releases about 220 kJ/mol; the cycle’s lone GTP is worth about 30.

**Predict.** An oxidation state counts the electrons a carbon has lost to its bonding partners (negative if it has gained them): each bond to O or S counts +1, each bond to H −1, a bond to C 0. Carbon in CO₂ is at +4. In the acetyl group, the methyl carbon (CH₃) is at −3 and the carbonyl carbon (bonded to CoA) at +3. How many electrons must come off to make both into CO₂? If each dehydrogenase removes one pair, how many dehydrogenases should the cycle have?

> **Check your prediction.** Eight electrons: 7 from the methyl carbon (−3 to +4) and 1 from the carbonyl carbon (+3 to +4). Four pairs, so four dehydrogenases, and the cycle has exactly four.

> **The one idea to carry through this lesson: follow the electrons.** The cycle loads carriers and the chain empties them; the four-pair count follows from oxidizing an acetyl group to carbon dioxide.

The count gives you the number of pairs, four, without memorizing. It does not say which carrier takes each pair (step 6’s chemistry does) or which atoms leave as CO₂ (the carbon section), and it holds only while nothing is drawn off (last section).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Follow the electrons. Each turn oxidizes one acetyl group: its eight electrons leave as four pairs, one at each dehydrogenase (steps 3, 4, 6 and 8), on three NADH and one FADH2. Oxaloacetate goes in at step 1 and comes back at step 8, so it cancels from the net equation. The carriers must be emptied by the electron transport chain before they can be loaded again. Image: the citric acid cycle as a clockwise ring of eight numbered steps. An acetyl group enters at step 1. Steps 3, 4, 6 and 8 are highlighted in gold; each sends one electron pair onto a carrier (NADH at 3, 4 and 8, FADH2 at 6), and all four carriers flow to the electron transport chain and on to oxygen. Two CO2 leave at steps 3 and 4. An inset shows oxaloacetate on both sides of the net balance, crossed out, leaving one acetyl group in and four electron pairs out.

## Burn the fuel, then rebuild the machine

Hold the eight enzymes as two stages, like a fireplace: Stage One burns the firewood down to CO₂, and Stage Two sweeps the ashes into a new fireplace, rebuilding oxaloacetate. Each stage loads two carriers. Two of the four oxidations actually come in Stage Two.

### Stage One: the carbons leave (steps 1–4)

**1 · Citrate synthase** joins 4-carbon oxaloacetate (OAA) to 2-carbon acetyl-CoA, making 6-carbon citrate. A *synthase* uses no ATP; the energy comes from cleaving acetyl-CoA’s high-energy thioester.

**2 · Aconitase** turns citrate into isocitrate by moving its hydroxyl (–OH) to a neighboring carbon. No redox happens here.

**Predict.** Citrate already has an –OH. Why can’t the next enzyme just oxidize citrate?

> **Check your prediction.** Citrate’s –OH sits on a carbon with no hydrogen (a tertiary alcohol). Making C–OH into C=O means removing that carbon’s hydrogen, and there is none to remove without breaking a carbon–carbon bond. Aconitase moves the –OH to a carbon that has one.

**3 · Isocitrate dehydrogenase** carries out the first oxidative decarboxylation: oxidize, then remove a carboxyl as CO₂. Out come **CO₂ #1** and **NADH #1**. Textbooks often call it the cycle’s **rate-limiting step**, and that is the answer exams usually expect. In living tissue, control is shared with citrate synthase and α-ketoglutarate dehydrogenase.

**4 · The α-ketoglutarate dehydrogenase complex** carries out the second: **CO₂ #2** and **NADH #2**. It is the twin of pyruvate dehydrogenase.

Which two carbons left is a puzzle for later.

### Stage Two: oxaloacetate is rebuilt (steps 5–8)

**5 · Succinyl-CoA synthetase** is the cycle’s only substrate-level phosphorylation, a phosphate made directly by the reaction rather than by the chain. Cleaving succinyl-CoA’s thioester drives GDP to GTP (or ADP to ATP, depending on the enzyme isoform).

**6 · Succinate dehydrogenase** is the odd one out. It sits in the inner mitochondrial membrane and *is* Complex II of the ETC, feeding electrons straight into the chain.

**Predict.** Step 6 takes two hydrogens off succinate’s CH₂–CH₂ to make fumarate’s C=C. Which carrier gets the pair, and why not NAD⁺?

> **Check your prediction.** FAD. Those electrons are too low in energy to reduce NAD⁺: handing them to NAD⁺ would cost about 68 kJ/mol under standard conditions. The FAD held inside the enzyme sits at a far more positive potential than NAD⁺, so accepting the pair costs little, roughly 6 to 20 kJ/mol depending on the value used, and ubiquinone, the chain’s next carrier, pulls them on.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Succinate dehydrogenase is the cycle's only inner-membrane enzyme and is also Complex II of the electron transport chain. Its enzyme-bound FAD passes electrons through the complex to ubiquinone; the other cycle enzymes work in the matrix. Image: a cut-open mitochondrion with cycle enzymes in the interior and, spanning the inner membrane, a gold block labeled succinate dehydrogenase, Complex II, drawn passing electrons on toward the electron transport chain. The FAD cofactor is simplified in the drawing; it is permanently bound to the enzyme.

**7 · Fumarase** adds water across fumarate’s double bond to make L-malate.

**8 · Malate dehydrogenase** regenerates OAA and loads **NADH #3**, closing the ring. This step is unfavorable on its own, but citrate synthase uses up OAA the instant it appears, pulling it forward. The steps are coupled, not independent.

| Step | Product | Carbons | Loaded or made |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | citrate | 6 | — |
| 2 | isocitrate | 6 | — |
| 3 | α-ketoglutarate | 5 | NADH, CO₂ |
| 4 | succinyl-CoA | 4 | NADH, CO₂ |
| 5 | succinate | 4 | GTP |
| 6 | fumarate | 4 | FADH₂ |
| 7 | malate | 4 | — |
| 8 | oxaloacetate | 4 | NADH |

## Add it up: oxaloacetate cancels

The last column sums to **3 NADH, 1 FADH₂, 1 GTP, 2 CO₂**. Write the turn as one reaction. One OAA goes in at step 1 and one comes out at step 8, so OAA appears on both sides and cancels:

> **acetyl-CoA + 3 NAD⁺ + FAD + GDP + Pᵢ + 2 H₂O → 2 CO₂ + 3 NADH + FADH₂ + GTP + CoA-SH + 2 H⁺**

That answers the pigeon-muscle puzzle. The added acid joins the cycle’s pool of four-carbon intermediates, and every turn hands the acceptor back, so each added molecule carries many acetyl groups through, each sending its electrons to oxygen.

As the film’s roundabout shows, OAA is the reusable platform, not the fuel, so a small pool supports many turns. Its atoms are replaced over time, as the next section shows.

Check the tally against your own: tap through the eight steps, or press “Turn the whole cycle”.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* The citric acid cycle · 8 steps tap a step to reveal it Running total 0 NADH0 FADH₂0 GTP0 CO₂ Electron pairs 0 / 4 regul

## Which carbons leave? A puzzle the net equation cannot answer

Two carbons come in as acetyl and two leave as CO₂, but are they the same two? Oxaloacetate (OAA) has a carboxyl group (–COO⁻) at each end and two middle carbons, one carrying a C=O. In the carbon tracker below, acetyl’s carbons (methyl and carbonyl) are orange and OAA’s are navy.

Citrate synthase bonds acetyl’s methyl carbon to OAA’s C=O carbon. Citrate’s central carbon (OAA’s old C=O carbon) then carries three branches: an orange arm from acetyl (ending in the old carbonyl carbon, now a carboxyl), a navy arm from OAA (ending in a carboxyl), and a navy carboxyl. Every CO₂ leaves as a carboxyl, so which carboxyls do steps 3 and 4 remove?

**Predict.** You add acetyl-CoA labeled at both carbons and let exactly one turn finish. Is any label in the CO₂?

> **Check your prediction.** None. Aconitase moves the –OH onto the navy, OAA-derived arm. Isocitrate dehydrogenase oxidizes it and removes the carboxyl beside it, the navy one on the central carbon: CO₂ #1. α-Ketoglutarate dehydrogenase removes the carboxyl at the far end of the same navy arm: CO₂ #2. The orange carbons are untouched in the first turn. The atoms that leave are older ones.

Citrate’s two CH₂–COO⁻ arms look identical on paper. How does aconitase tell them apart? The arms are chemically identical but sit in mirror-image positions around the central carbon, so an enzyme that grips citrate at three points holds it in only one orientation, the way a right glove fits only one hand. Citrate *looks* symmetric, but to the enzyme it is not. Alexander Ogston pointed this out in 1948, after tracer results first seemed to rule citrate out as an intermediate.

**Then real symmetry takes over.** At step 5 the chain becomes succinate, ⁻OOC–CH₂–CH₂–COO⁻, which reads the same from either end, so no enzyme can tell the ends apart. The old carbonyl carbon is now one of the two end carboxyls, with even odds for each; the old methyl is one of the two middle carbons. That is why the tracker turns every carbon half orange at succinate. Fumarate is symmetric too, so the odds carry into the new OAA, ends to ends and middles to middles. Each turn removes the two end carboxyls of the OAA it starts with:

Share of each acetyl carbon’s label released as CO₂, turn by turn:

| Acetyl carbon | Turn 1 | Turn 2 | Turn 3 | Turn 4 | Later turns |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Carbonyl (the one bonded to CoA) | 0 | all | — | — | — |
| Methyl | 0 | 0 | ½ | ¼ | half of what remains, each turn |

The methyl carbon lingers because a middle carbon must first be moved to an end, and each turn does that only half the time.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Follow the carbons through one turn, then the next

## Oxygen and the throttle: one demand story

The film above shows the indirect dependence: oxygen is required to empty the carriers, but is not a substrate of any cycle reaction. NADH hands its electrons to Complex I and returns as NAD⁺, so in a respiring cell the cycle can turn no faster than the chain empties its carriers.

**Predict.** Cut off the oxygen. Which steps stall, and why?

> **Check your prediction.** The four dehydrogenases stall first, because each needs an empty carrier. Without O₂ the chain backs up and the small, fixed NAD⁺ pool fills up as NADH, leaving steps 3, 4 and 8 nothing to load. Step 6’s FAD empties only into ubiquinone, and with the chain backed up that pool is already full of electrons. The other steps back up behind them; with little OAA coming out of step 8, step 1 slows to a crawl too.

The cell reads two gauges: how full its carriers are (NADH/NAD⁺) and how full its ATP supply is (ATP/ADP). The best-known control points are the two irreversible oxidative decarboxylations, **isocitrate dehydrogenase** and **α-ketoglutarate dehydrogenase** (held back by its products, NADH and succinyl-CoA), with citrate synthase (limited by oxaloacetate (OAA) supply, slowed by its products) as a third. The rule: **ATP and NADH = STOP** (the cell is rich; high NADH means full carriers). **ADP, NAD⁺ and Ca²⁺ = GO** (calcium works differently, below). Rising ADP speeds the respiratory chain, so NAD⁺ comes back faster, and ADP also activates isocitrate dehydrogenase directly. Pyruvate dehydrogenase gates entry upstream by the same logic.

**Calcium is a separate signal, a push rather than a gauge.** When a muscle contracts, some of the Ca²⁺ released to drive contraction is taken up into mitochondria. There it activates isocitrate dehydrogenase and α-ketoglutarate dehydrogenase, and pyruvate dehydrogenase through PDH phosphatase, its best-established targets. Its main effect is not on emptying carriers: it raises NADH production the moment work starts.

## Cash the carriers

> **Equation card: How much ATP one glucose yields once every carrier is cashed at the electron transport chain.**
>
>     ATP per glucose = 2 + 2 × N + 2 × T + 2 × s
>
> In words: Two ATP made directly in glycolysis, plus the two NADH from pyruvate dehydrogenase, plus two turns of the cycle, plus the two NADH from glycolysis at whatever value the shuttle gives them.
>
> - N: ATP per NADH at the ETC, about 2.5 (FADH₂ gives about 1.5) (ATP per NADH)
> - T: ATP per turn of the cycle, about 10 when N is 2.5 (3 NADH × 2.5 + 1 FADH₂ × 1.5 + 1 GTP) (ATP per acetyl-CoA)
> - s: ATP per glycolytic NADH, set by the shuttle that carries its electrons into the mitochondrion (1.5 or 2.5)
>
> Sanity check: The cycle's own GTP is 2 of the total, about 6 to 7%. Almost all the ATP comes from cashing the carriers.
> Try one number Glycerol-phosphate shuttle (s = 1.5): 2 + 2 × 2.5 + 2 × 10 + 2 × 1.5 = 2 + 5 + 20 + 3 = 30 ATP per glucose. Malate-aspartate shuttle (s = 2.5): 2 + 5 + 20 + 5 = 32 ATP per glucose.

So one glucose gives roughly **30 to 32 ATP**, and the shuttle decides which. Cashing the carriers is the next chapter, oxidative phosphorylation and the electron transport chain, where oxygen finally takes the stage.

## Where the catalyst rule stops: amphibolic and anaplerotic

In a real cell, intermediates are drawn off. The cycle is **amphibolic**: it serves both breakdown and building. Citrate is exported for fatty-acid synthesis, α-ketoglutarate becomes glutamate and other amino acids, succinyl-CoA builds heme, and oxaloacetate (OAA) feeds gluconeogenesis. Each withdrawal takes carbon that would have become OAA, so the pool would shrink. The cell refills it by **anaplerosis**: in many tissues chiefly pyruvate carboxylase (glutamine is a major source in dividing cells), which adds CO₂ to pyruvate to make OAA and is switched on by acetyl-CoA, a feedforward signal (“fuel is arriving; build more of the platform”).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* The cycle is amphibolic: its intermediates are siphoned off to build fatty acids, amino acids, heme and glucose. In many tissues pyruvate carboxylase is a major refill route, adding CO2 to pyruvate using ATP and activated by acetyl-CoA; glutamine is a major input in dividing cells. Image: a clockwise citric acid cycle loop with outward arrows from citrate, alpha-ketoglutarate, succinyl-CoA and oxaloacetate to fatty-acid synthesis, amino acids, heme and gluconeogenesis; an inset shows pyruvate carboxylase converting pyruvate to oxaloacetate, with acetyl-CoA as an activator.

When the cycle’s enzymes break, its intermediates can drive cancer. Mutations in succinate dehydrogenase and fumarase let succinate and fumarate pile up as **oncometabolites** in paragangliomas and kidney cancer. Mutant IDH1 or IDH2, the NADP⁺-dependent cousins of the cycle’s NAD⁺-dependent IDH3, gain a new activity: they make 2-hydroxyglutarate, scrambling the epigenome in gliomas and leukemias, while IDH3 still runs step 3. IDH inhibitors are now real drugs.

## Going deeper

The main line above does not depend on these details.

### Citrate synthase’s pull

Citrate synthase works by ordered induced fit: binding oxaloacetate (OAA) makes the enzyme clamp shut, creating the acetyl-CoA site. The citryl-CoA intermediate is hydrolyzed while still bound, so the thioester energy is not wasted. The step is one of the cycle’s most exergonic (ΔG°′ ≈ −31.4 kJ/mol) and effectively irreversible: the committed step that pulls the whole cycle forward.

### Pyruvate dehydrogenase’s twin

The α-ketoglutarate dehydrogenase complex shares pyruvate dehydrogenase’s E1/E2/E3 architecture, its five cofactors (TPP, lipoic acid, CoA, FAD, NAD⁺) and its substrate channeling, which tunnels intermediates from one active site to the next without ever letting them diffuse free.

### Synthase versus synthetase

A synthetase, unlike a synthase, uses or makes a nucleotide triphosphate. Succinyl-CoA synthetase (step 5) runs in the direction that makes GTP, through a phosphohistidine intermediate: a histidine in its active site is phosphorylated on the way.

### The Warburg effect

In the Warburg effect, tumors run glycolysis hard even with oxygen available. It is a related rewiring at the cycle’s entrance: more pyruvate is turned into lactate rather than entering the cycle as acetyl-CoA, although many tumors keep a working cycle, often fed by glutamine.

### Krebs and the urea cycle

Krebs had already found the urea cycle in 1932, five years before this one. That work taught him what to look for in the pigeon-muscle experiments: find the molecule that comes out unchanged, and you have found the catalyst at the heart of a cycle.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/citric-acid-cycle/
