# Chromosome Number and Structure: Aneuploidy and Rearrangements

> Chromosome changes matter through DNA dose, gene context, and meiotic balance. Follow a missed separation through meiosis I and meiosis II, use centromere-linked DNA markers to infer its origin, and explain why some aneuploidies are better tolerated than others. Then use the same rule for polyploidy, deletions, duplications, inversions and translocations, and choose which chromosome test can reveal each change.

Course: Genetics and Molecular Biology (Inheritance). Level: core university (third year). About 20 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/chromosome-changes/

Builds on: Chromosomes and Meiosis: The Physical Basis of Mendel's Laws · Sex Linkage, Dosage Compensation and Non-Mendelian Inheritance · Reading Pedigrees: Human Inheritance

## What you'll learn

- Explain why extra or missing chromosomes change gene dosage and usually cause pregnancy loss or a syndrome, using trisomy 21, 45,X and 47,XXY, and why extra or missing sex chromosomes are better tolerated than autosomal ones.
- Predict the gametes produced by nondisjunction at meiosis I and at meiosis II, and use centromere-linked DNA markers to infer which parent and which division erred.
- Distinguish autopolyploidy from allopolyploidy, and deletions, duplications, inversions and translocations by their effect on dose and their behaviour in meiosis.
- Choose among karyotype, FISH, chromosomal microarray and sequencing to detect a given chromosome change, and say what each one misses.

**In 1959 Jérôme Lejeune, Marthe Gautier and Raymond Turpin counted 47 chromosomes, not the usual 46, in cultured cells from nine children with Down syndrome.**

The extra chromosome, later numbered 21, connected chromosome content to a condition described for nearly a century. But count is only the clue: a cell can have 46 chromosomes and extra chromosome 21 material, and a rearrangement can change a gene without changing total DNA.

> **The one idea. Chromosome changes matter through DNA dose, gene context, and meiotic balance.**
>
> *Scope:* this rule covers the whole-chromosome and segment changes in this lesson. Dose asks what DNA was gained or lost; context asks what a breakpoint disrupted or joined; balance asks what chromosome combinations meiosis can pass on. It does not predict phenotype from chromosome size alone.

## From one missed separation to four gametes

The first film followed one replicated pair through **nondisjunction**, a failure of chromosomes to part, at each [meiotic division](https://stemhop.com/lessons/chromosomes-and-meiosis/): a meiosis I error leaves two **disomic** products (two copies, n + 1) and two **nullisomic** ones (none, n − 1); a meiosis II error leaves one of each plus two normal products. With a normal egg these give **trisomic** (three copies) and **monosomic** (one copy) zygotes, both forms of **aneuploidy**: the gain or loss of individual chromosomes, short of a whole set.

Now scale up, keeping the film’s classical model: one error, otherwise normal divisions, all four products recovered.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Nondisjunction: which gametes, which zygotes

**Predict.** Follow chromosome 21 in an invented set of 100 meiocytes (cells entering meiosis): 70 divide normally, 10 err at meiosis I and 20 err at meiosis II. How many of the 400 products are disomic?

> **Check your count.** Meiosis I errors give 10 × 2 = 20 disomic products and meiosis II errors 20 × 1 = 20 more: 40 disomic, 40 nullisomic and 320 normal in all. With normal partners, that would give 10 percent trisomic, 10 percent monosomic and 80 percent euploid (normal-number) zygotes. These are invented teaching numbers, not measured human rates.

## Which parent, which division?

An **informative DNA marker** has distinguishable parental alleles. Put one tightly linked to the chromosome 21 centromere: the father carries alleles 1 and 2, the mother 3 and 4. Near the centromere, homologues can carry different alleles, while sister copies usually match.

**Predict.** Child A has marker alleles 1, 3 and 4. Which parent supplied the extra chromosome, and which classical division failed?

> **Check the fingerprint.** The two different maternal alleles, 3 and 4, came from both maternal homologues, so the extra chromosome is maternal and the pattern points to maternal meiosis I. By contrast, a child with 1, 3 and 3 has two copies of one maternal allele, consistent with maternal meiosis II.

One condition: a crossover between marker and centromere can make sisters differ at the marker, so a meiosis II error can resemble meiosis I, and the reverse. Markers as close to the centromere as possible reduce that risk. Human eggs also make error patterns beyond the classical two-step model (Going deeper).

## Apply dose: aneuploidy in people

As the first film ended, most aneuploid human embryos are lost. Of the autosomal trisomies only 21, 18 and 13 are seen regularly at birth, and trisomy 21 is by far the commonest. Down syndrome occurs in about 1 in 700 births in widely cited United States estimates; the figure varies by population and rises strongly with maternal age. Most cases are free trisomy 21 (a separate extra chromosome); family marker studies found that most free trisomy 21 is maternal in origin and that most maternal errors arise at meiosis I.

Also in 1959, other laboratories tied an extra X to Klinefelter syndrome and a missing X to Turner syndrome. **Turner syndrome** occurs in females; about half have monosomy X, a 45,X [karyotype](https://stemhop.com/methods/karyotyping-and-chromosome-fish/), while the rest have mosaicism (a mix of cell lines), a partly lost X or a rearranged X. Most 45,X conceptions are thought to be lost during pregnancy, and many survivors are mosaic. **Klinefelter syndrome** is most often 47,XXY, a male with an extra X, not 47,XYY.

**Predict.** The X chromosome is larger and carries more genes than chromosome 21. Why is an extra X usually better tolerated than an extra 21?

> **Check the dose.** As [sex linkage and beyond](https://stemhop.com/lessons/sex-linkage-and-beyond/) explains, typical mammalian body cells largely inactivate each X beyond one, so an extra X adds much less active dose than its size suggests. Extra or missing active copies of the genes that escape X inactivation are thought to explain many remaining features of 47,XXY and 45,X. The Y also carries few genes. Better tolerated does not mean harmless, as the 45,X losses show.

## Whole extra sets: polyploidy

A **polyploid** has complete extra chromosome sets. An **autopolyploid** has extra sets from one species, often after a gamete fails to reduce its chromosome number. An **allopolyploid** combines sets from two or more species, usually after hybridization and chromosome-set doubling.

Bread wheat is a hexaploid allopolyploid: six sets and 42 chromosomes, two from each of three ancestral grasses, so each ancestral set has a partner. Genes such as *Ph1* limit pairing with close relatives from the other ancestral sets, so meiosis forms ordinary pairs.

**Predict.** Why do triploid seedless bananas rarely form seeds, while wheat with six sets can make balanced gametes?

> **Check the pairing.** Three matching sets cannot split evenly at meiosis, so nearly every triploid gamete is unbalanced. Wheat’s sets each have a partner, so they form balanced pairs. Most bananas grown on a large scale are triploid.

Polyploidy is common in flowering plants and rare in animals. Plants often self-fertilize or spread without sex, so a new polyploid need not find a matching partner, and they appear to tolerate dose shifts more readily. Some fish and frogs are animal exceptions. Human triploidy, with 69 chromosomes, is almost always lost during pregnancy.

So pairing, not dose alone, decides whether gametes come out balanced. The second film shows a chromosome that breaks, rejoins, loses no DNA and still pairs awkwardly at meiosis.

**Film transcript: Break, Rejoin, Segregate**

### Film transcript: Break, Rejoin, Segregate

The first film changed whole-chromosome dose. Can a chromosome rearrangement matter when no DNA seems missing? Follow the same coloured blocks through breakage and meiosis. A chromosome is more than a counted object. Its blocks carry genes, and their order provides context. For any rearrangement, ask what material changed dose, what breakpoint changed context, and what products meiosis can make. Remove one block and the chromosome has a deletion. Its genes now have lower dose. A missing segment cannot supply its genes. Copy one block and the chromosome has a duplication. Those genes now have higher dose. An extra segment supplies another copy.

The red gauge tracks both changes. Now cut out several blocks and return them in reverse order. That is an inversion. No block is lost, so dose can stay balanced. The chromosome count also stays unchanged. During meiosis, homologous blocks bend into a loop to align. A reciprocal translocation exchanges segments between nonhomologous chromosomes. Move a teal end segment from blue to a grey chromosome, and return a grey segment.

Total dose may stay balanced even though both chromosomes have new neighbours. Balanced dose does not guarantee no biological effect. A breakpoint can interrupt a gene block. It can also place pieces from different genes together. The result depends on which sequence meets the breakpoint. These are changes in gene context, not whole-chromosome count. The carrier still faces meiosis.

Normal and translocated partners must align matching blocks. All four chromosomes form a cross-shaped group. The way this cross separates decides whether each gamete receives one copy of every block. Which separation preserves one copy of every coloured block: opposite chromosomes moving together, or neighbouring chromosomes moving together? Look at the block ledgers.

Opposite partners preserve one copy of every block. This alternate segregation makes normal or balanced gametes. Neighbouring partners give each gamete an extra copy of one segment and no copy of another. This adjacent segregation makes unbalanced gametes. That explains a common puzzle. A carrier can be healthy because their chromosome set is balanced. Yet meiosis can produce unbalanced gametes. Balance must therefore be tested at both levels. The rearrangement's consequence depends on breakpoint context and segregation, not chromosome count alone. Trace three things after every break. Ask what material was gained or lost. Ask which genes were interrupted or newly joined.

Then ask which chromosome combinations can pass through meiosis. Rearrangements matter through DNA dose, gene context, and meiotic balance.

From the film

- Rearrangements matter through DNA dose, gene context, and meiotic balance.
- Deletions and duplications directly lower or raise DNA dose.
- A balanced translocation can still make unbalanced gametes, by adjacent segregation.
- A balanced exchange can still disrupt or join genes at its breakpoints.

## Broken and rejoined

The second film built these changes from blocks; here are the patients, inversion crossover products and fusions it left out.

In people, deletions and duplications show the dose part of the rule. Loss of part of chromosome 5’s short arm causes cri du chat syndrome. A small deletion at 7q11.23 that includes the elastin gene underlies Williams syndrome. In 1991 Lupski and colleagues associated a 17p duplication with Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease type 1A.

A **pericentric** inversion includes the centromere; a **paracentric** inversion does not. One crossover inside a paracentric loop produces one dicentric chromatid (two centromeres), which breaks at anaphase, and one acentric fragment (no centromere), which is lost. One crossover inside a pericentric loop gives two chromatids, each carrying a duplication and a deletion. Either way the recombinant gametes are unbalanced, so few recombinants appear among offspring.

A **Robertsonian translocation** is a fusion, not a swap of ends: it joins the long arms of two acrocentric chromosomes, whose centromere sits near one end, and loses most of their tiny short arms. In humans the acrocentrics are 13, 14, 15, 21 and 22. Those short arms carry repeated ribosomal RNA genes and other repetitive DNA; the remaining acrocentrics retain many rRNA-gene copies. So a carrier can have 45 chromosomes and usually be unaffected. If a fusion carrying chromosome 21 material travels with a free 21, the child can have translocation Down syndrome with 46 chromosomes.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A Robertsonian carrier can have 45 chromosomes and balanced long-arm dose, yet passing a 14;21 fusion with a free 21 gives three doses of chromosome 21 material in a 46-chromosome child. Image: a slate chromosome 14 and a gold chromosome 21 fuse at their long arms while their tiny short arms are lost. One inset shows a carrier's three relevant rods; another shows a gamete with the fused rod plus a free 21 meeting a normal egg, giving a child with three doses of gold 21 material.

The **Philadelphia chromosome** is a real case of the second film’s reciprocal translocation, a swap of segments between nonhomologous chromosomes. It is the small chromosome 22 left by an acquired 9;22 exchange in blood cells. Nowell and Hungerford saw it in 1960, Rowley’s banding in 1973 suggested it was half of a swap, and in the 1980s other laboratories found the joined genes, *BCR* and *ABL*; the fusion protein is a tyrosine kinase that stays switched on (see [oncogenes](https://stemhop.com/lessons/oncogenes/)). Here the critical change is gene context, not simply total dose.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* The acquired 9;22 exchange places BCR beside ABL, making a fusion whose tyrosine kinase stays switched on even without a net chromosome-dose change. Image: a normal chromosome 9 and a smaller chromosome 22 on the left; on the right they have swapped end segments, leaving a small chromosome 22 and a chromosome 9 with extra gold material. An inset shows blocks named BCR and ABL joining into one block beside a switch in the on position.

## Choose a test by the question

First ask: **dose, context or balance?** Then choose the measurement.

- A **G-banded [karyotype](https://stemhop.com/methods/karyotyping-and-chromosome-fish/)** counts chromosomes and compares their band patterns. It is the routine genome-wide test that directly shows balanced rearrangements, but sees only changes of roughly 5 to 10 million base pairs or larger, balanced or not. Some genome sequencing and optical genome mapping methods can also find balanced changes.
- **FISH** uses a fluorescent DNA probe for one chosen region, often about 100 thousand base pairs. It works in nondividing nuclei, but says nothing about regions outside its target.
- A **chromosomal microarray** measures segment dose across the genome. Where probes are dense, it can find gains and losses down to tens of thousands of base pairs, depending on array and region. It is blind to balanced changes, and a dose-only array can miss triploidy. In one large prenatal study, microarray found an additional clinically relevant deletion or duplication in 6.0 percent of karyotypically normal samples from pregnancies with a structural anomaly.
- Breakpoint-focused or genome **sequencing** can sometimes resolve junctions at or near base-pair scale, depending on method and repetitive sequence. It has shown that rearrangements that look balanced under the microscope can break genes or hide small losses (Going deeper).

**Predict.** A child’s banded karyotype looks normal, yet a dose-only microarray finds a small loss on one chromosome. Why could the karyotype miss it, and what kind of change could the array itself still miss?

> **Check the tests.** The loss is below the karyotype’s routine resolution; the array reads dose far more finely where probes are dense. It would still miss a balanced rearrangement, because no dose changes, and can miss triploidy.

### Design problem

A man with typical features has 45 chromosomes, including a Robertsonian 14;21 translocation, and a child with Down syndrome. Explain why he is unaffected, list his gametes, identify the zygotes expected to survive with a normal egg, and choose tests to confirm the explanation.

> **One way to do it.** He has two doses of the long arms of 14 and 21, one free and one fused; the lost short arms’ rRNA genes have copies on other chromosomes.
>
> The free 14, free 21 and fused t(14;21) pair as a group of three. In the usual 2:1 split, six gamete types result; a rare 3:0 split is omitted:
>
> 1. 14 + 21: normal.
> 2. t(14;21): balanced carrier.
> 3. t(14;21) + 21: translocation trisomy 21 after fertilization.
> 4. 14 alone: monosomy 21.
> 5. t(14;21) + 14: trisomy 14.
> 6. 21 alone: monosomy 14.
>
> Types 4, 5 and 6 are expected to be lost early in pregnancy. If all six gametes were equally frequent and only types 1, 2 and 3 survived, one in three liveborn children would have Down syndrome. Observed risks are well below that conditional value, and published series find lower risks when the father is the carrier than when the mother is.
>
> Karyotype the child and both parents; the expected child has 46 chromosomes, including t(14;21) and two free 21s. FISH with a chromosome 21 probe can confirm the extra dose. This is a mechanism exercise, not reproductive advice.

## Going deeper

### Human egg errors and age

In human eggs, sister chromatids can separate early at meiosis I. In **reverse segregation**, both pairs of sisters split at meiosis I. In donated human eggs, Gruhn and colleagues found a U-shaped relation between donor age and aneuploidy, with higher values among the youngest and oldest donors. That finding concerns aneuploid eggs from donors, not live-born trisomy 21 risk, which rises with maternal age.

### When balanced does not mean harmless

Balance depends on resolution. Redin and colleagues sequenced apparently balanced abnormalities from 273 people with congenital anomalies. They revised 93 percent of the [karyotypes](https://stemhop.com/methods/karyotyping-and-chromosome-fish/), found complexity hidden from karyotyping in 21 percent of abnormalities, and judged gene disruption likely to contribute in at least a third. This selected cohort cannot say how often a healthy carrier’s rearrangement hides a small loss or disrupts a gene.

### Sex determination and extra chromosome sets

Some animals, including fruit flies, set sex by counting X chromosomes during a short window of early development. An extra chromosome set can upset that count.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/chromosome-changes/
