# The Chesapeake Under Pressure

> Extra nutrients feed algae; bacteria use oxygen while poor mixing limits replacement; effective fixes cut nutrients first, rebuild habitat, and track recovery over time. Follow nutrients from land to the Bay, test fixes in a watershed model, and read Bay data on nitrogen, low oxygen and underwater grass. Afterwards you can explain eutrophication step by step and plan and judge a fix for a Virginia watershed.

Course: Biology (Ecosystems). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/chesapeake-under-pressure/

Builds on: Matter Cycles · Respiration and ATP · Populations and Carrying Capacity

## What you'll learn

- You will explain how human activities (reducing forest cover, releasing more and different chemicals, intensive farming) and natural events (fires, droughts, floods, earthquakes, climate shifts) change ecosystems and can reduce their capacity to support life.
- You will explain eutrophication step by step: extra nutrients feed algae blooms, the algae die and are decomposed by bacteria that use up oxygen, and low-oxygen water harms animals.
- You will use Chesapeake Bay data on nutrient loads, low oxygen and underwater grasses to design, evaluate and refine a solution that reduces human effects on a Virginia watershed.

**Each summer, water near the bottom of the Chesapeake Bay’s deep channel typically holds too little oxygen for crabs and fish to stay. People call it a dead zone.**

No one pours in a chemical that soaks up oxygen. How can fertilizer on fields far up the Susquehanna, Potomac and James leave the Bay’s floor short of oxygen, and can people fix it?

**The one idea.**

Extra nutrients feed algae; bacteria use oxygen while poor mixing limits replacement; effective fixes cut nutrients first, rebuild habitat, and track recovery over time.

**Scope:**

this rule explains nutrient-driven summer low oxygen and the logic of nutrient management in the Chesapeake Bay. It does not predict one year’s hypoxic volume by itself, because river flow, temperature, wind and mixing also change oxygen.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Human activities do not significantly affect the environment. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Scientists measure nutrients in Bay water and the rivers that feed it. A 2018 study found that nitrogen in Bay water fell about 23 percent after 1984 as pollution was cut, and underwater grass regained about 17,000 hectares. Human choices moved those numbers. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Scientists measure nutrients in Bay water and the rivers that feed it. A 2018 study found that nitrogen in Bay water fell about 23 percent after 1984 as pollution was cut, and underwater grass regained about 17,000 hectares. Human choices moved those numbers.
2. What people do on land does not affect rivers and bays. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Rain washes lawn fertilizer and manure into streams, wastewater plants release treated water into rivers, and air pollution drops nitrogen onto land and water. Stream gauges and water samples track these nutrients downstream to the Bay. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Rain washes lawn fertilizer and manure into streams, wastewater plants release treated water into rivers, and air pollution drops nitrogen onto land and water. Stream gauges and water samples track these nutrients downstream to the Bay.
3. Once an ecosystem is damaged, nothing can be done. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** In Virginia’s Great Wicomico River, researchers built oyster reefs starting in 2004, and by 2009 they estimated about 185 million oysters there. Underwater grass has also partly come back. Recovery is real, but slow and usually partial. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** In Virginia’s Great Wicomico River, researchers built oyster reefs starting in 2004, and by 2009 they estimated about 185 million oysters there. Underwater grass has also partly come back. Recovery is real, but slow and usually partial.

## From a watershed to bottom water

- watershed
- runoff
- nutrient
- eutrophication
- dissolved oxygen
- decomposer
- hypoxia
- riparian forest buffer
- submerged aquatic vegetation
- restoration
- criteria
- constraints

The first film followed nutrients from a field to bacteria on the Bay floor. Its terms:

- A **watershed** is all the land that drains into one river, lake or bay. The Bay’s covers parts of six states and Washington, D.C. In Virginia, the Potomac, fed by the Shenandoah, and the Rappahannock, York and James drain to the Bay.
- **Runoff** is rainwater that flows over the ground instead of soaking in, carrying what it picks up. A **nutrient** is a substance living things need to grow; here, nitrogen and phosphorus.
- **Dissolved oxygen** is oxygen gas mixed into water, measured in milligrams per liter (mg/L). Fish, crabs and oysters take it in through their gills. Water too low in oxygen for most animals, usually below 2 mg/L, is **hypoxia**; in the Bay it forms mostly in bottom water.
- An **algal bloom** is a sudden, thick growth of algae. A **decomposer** is a living thing that breaks down dead matter.
- **Eutrophication** is the enrichment of water with nutrients, which feeds too much algae growth and can lead to oxygen loss.

> extra nutrients → algal bloom → algae die and sink → bacteria decompose them and use oxygen → low-oxygen bottom water

Animals that can swim away leave; others may sicken or die. Because the chain takes months, scientists forecast each summer’s dead zone from the nutrients rivers carried in spring.

### Why deep water runs short

The first film showed how summer layers keep new oxygen from reaching the bottom. Picture that bottom water as a closed room full of breathers.

**Predict.** A storm mixes the layers before the nutrient supply changes. What should happen first to oxygen near the bottom?

> **Check your prediction.** It should rise. Mixing brings oxygen-rich surface water down before the dead algae change. Here the closed-room picture breaks down: a storm opens the door.

Shallow, well-stirred water usually escapes the long summer dead zone, but not always.

**Predict.** In a shallow, nutrient-rich cove, should oxygen be lower near sunset or just before sunrise?

> **Check your prediction.** Just before sunrise. At night algae stop photosynthesis but keep using oxygen, so oxygen can drop very low even where the water is shallow.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge runoffalgal bloomdead algaebacteriafresh river waterhypoxia runoffalgal bloomblankblankblankblank Word ba

## People and nature both change ecosystems

An ecosystem’s capacity to support life depends on habitat, light, oxygen and food. Large disruptions include eutrophication, climate shifts and catastrophes.

| Change | Cause | One effect |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Clearing forest for farms, roads and houses | People | More runoff and soil reach streams |
| Intensive farming with fertilizer and manure | People | Extra nutrients, some stored in soil and leaking out years later |
| Releasing chemicals in wastewater and from industry | People | Nutrients; some contaminants can harm wildlife reproduction |
| Burning fuel in cars and power plants, and ammonia gas from manure and fertilizer | People | Nitrogen falls from the air onto land and water |
| Wildfire | Nature, sometimes people | Storms afterward wash ash and soil into streams |
| Drought or flood | Nature | Changes how much fresh water and nutrient reach an estuary |
| Climate shift (warming) | Mostly people today; nature in the past | Warmer water holds less oxygen and speeds oxygen use |

**Key idea:**

human activities and natural events both change habitat, light and oxygen, which can lower how much life an ecosystem supports.

People cannot stop heavy rain, but the first four rows are choices people make. The second film shows where a cleanup budget can act on them.

**Film transcript: Design a Fix That Can Be Tested**

### Film transcript: Design a Fix That Can Be Tested

The first film followed nutrients from land to low oxygen. Where should a limited cleanup budget act? A useful plan cuts the cause first, rebuilds habitat, and works within real limits. Restoration means returning a damaged ecosystem toward health. Criteria say what a solution must achieve, such as lowering nitrogen or adding habitat. Constraints are limits, including money, land, and time. The budget bar is one constraint, so every choice has a trade-off. Start upstream. A forest buffer is a strip of trees and shrubs beside a stream. It slows runoff, traps soil, and can remove nitrate from water underground.

Winter cover crops hold soil and take up leftover nitrogen. Both act before nutrients reach the Bay. Wastewater upgrades remove more nitrogen at a treatment plant. Oyster reefs work differently. Oysters filter particles, and the reef shelters other animals. Reefs rebuild habitat, but they do not replace cutting nutrients. In this plan, underwater grass is a readout, not a tool. Cleaner water can let it return where conditions suit it. Place each tool beside the step it can change.

Land and treatment tools can reduce orange nutrient flow. Reefs add habitat directly, and cleaner water can let underwater grass return. So a plan cuts nutrients first, then adds habitat as its criteria and budget allow. No single readout tells the whole story. Nitrogen load, the total delivered over time, tracks a pressure entering the Bay.

Summer oxygen tracks a condition animals need. Underwater grass tracks habitat. A plan may improve one before another, so keep all three gauges beside the same map. Suppose nutrient flow drops after a new fix. Which change should appear first: less nutrient pressure, or a fully regrown grass bed?

Less nutrient pressure can appear first. Grass recovery often lags: the water must clear, and plants need time to spread back. Stored nitrogen can also keep leaking from soil for years, so even the nutrient drop can be slow.

Track each criterion over time instead of judging one sample. A strong plan states what evidence would count before work begins. Measure the pressure, the condition, and the habitat response. Repeat measurements across several years. Keep the comparison fair, and report when the evidence supports only part of the plan. Build the plan, measure the results, and compare them with a place that received no fix. If results are unclear, refine the design and test again. The causal chain tells you where to act. Measured criteria tell you whether the plan works.

From the film

- Effective fixes cut nutrients first, rebuild habitat, and track recovery over time.
- Criteria say what a plan must achieve; constraints limit the plan.
- Buffers, cover crops and wastewater upgrades can reduce nutrient inputs.
- Oyster reefs rebuild habitat but do not replace cutting nutrients.

## Fixing a watershed by design

Human activity is not always harmful. In the second film’s terms, **restoration** is returning a damaged ecosystem toward health. **Criteria** are what a solution must achieve, such as cutting a set amount of nitrogen. **Constraints** are limits such as money, land and time. What the film left out:

- A **riparian forest buffer** also holds the bank with its roots. Its plants and soil microbes remove nitrate from water seeping through the ground. How much nitrogen it stops depends on its width, soil and water flow.
- Cover crops are planted after the fall harvest and grow through winter.
- A 2022 study linked large drops in city nutrient pollution to wastewater plant upgrades. It also found that nitrogen falling from the air declined across the watershed from 1985 to 2019.
- Virginia has rebuilt oyster reefs in the Lafayette, Lynnhaven and Piankatank rivers.

The habitat these tools aim to bring back includes **submerged aquatic vegetation**, underwater grass usually rooted in shallow bottoms. It shelters young crabs and needs light. A 2018 study found that as nitrogen in Bay water fell, underwater grass regained about 17,000 hectares, roughly 42,000 acres.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Cover crops and a forest buffer hold soil and nutrients on land, while oyster reefs and underwater grass add habitat; reefs do not replace cutting nutrients. Image: a winter field covered with low green cover crops slopes to a stream lined by a strip of trees and shrubs whose roots grip the bank. An inset shows a shallow Bay bottom with an oyster reef and a bed of underwater grass where a young blue crab hides.

**Key idea:**

cutting nutrients and rebuilding habitat can help an ecosystem recover, and good fixes meet their criteria within real constraints.

### Test a cleanup plan

The model gives you a fixed budget for five fixes: forest buffers, cover crops, wastewater upgrades, oyster reefs and stormwater ponds. Each fix has a cost and a nitrogen effect. Its readouts are the second film’s three gauges: nitrogen load, summer oxygen and underwater grass. The values are relative, and real responses often lag by years.

1. **Predict.** Which single fix will lower nitrogen most for its cost? Write the reason from the causal chain, then spend the full budget on that fix.
2. Reset and split the same budget across three fixes. Decide first whether the plan should cut more nitrogen, rebuild more habitat or balance both. Predict better or worse, then test it.
3. Reset and spend the whole budget on oyster reefs. Predict the change in nitrogen load, then check all three readouts.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Watershed fix designer — spend a budget, read the Bay

## Read the Bay’s evidence

Ask three questions of the table. Did nutrient pressure fall? Did habitat respond? Did oxygen follow a smooth path?

**Predict.** If modeled nitrogen load falls, must the modeled hypoxic volume fall in every following year?

| Measure | Year | Value | Units | Kind of number |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Total yearly hypoxic volume | 2023 | 199 (± 26) | km³·days | model estimate |
| Total yearly hypoxic volume | 2024 | 497 (± 65) | km³·days | model estimate |
| Total yearly hypoxic volume | 2025 | 462 (± 60) | km³·days | model estimate |
| Nitrogen load to the Bay | 2009 | 297.1 | million lb per year | model estimate |
| Nitrogen load to the Bay | 2025 | 252.7 | million lb per year | model estimate |
| Nitrogen goal | goal in the 2026 progress release | 219.5 | million lb per year | target, not a measurement |
| Underwater grass, areas mapped in both years | 2024 | 76,835 | acres | aerial mapping |
| Underwater grass, areas mapped in both years | 2025 | 82,968 | acres | aerial mapping |
| Lafayette River restored reefs beating oyster targets | 2022 | 2 of 3 | reefs surveyed | field survey |

Hypoxic volumes come from the Virginia Institute of Marine Science Chesapeake Bay Environmental Forecast System historical table, read in October 2026. They are whole-Bay model estimates of water below 2 mg/L added up day by day. One km³·day is one cubic kilometer of hypoxic water lasting one day. A separate VIMS recent-years table gives different values for the same years, so compare only numbers from one table.

Nitrogen numbers come from the Chesapeake Bay Program’s 2026 progress release. Its model of the whole watershed estimates what the practices do under average weather. It does not report the nitrogen rivers carried in one wet or dry year. Grass areas come from the VIMS 2025 preliminary survey. Reef results come from NOAA Fisheries’ report of VIMS monitoring.

> **Check the prediction.** No. River flow, temperature and wind vary, so yearly oxygen estimates can bounce even while nutrient pressure falls. Two years are too few to judge a trend or test a cleanup.

1. How much did the modeled nitrogen load fall from 2009 to 2025? What percent of the 2009 load is that, and how much more must it fall to reach the goal?
2. Nitrogen loads fell, yet 2024’s hypoxic volume was about two and a half times 2023’s. Name two other things that could explain this.
3. Why compare grass only in areas mapped in both years?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: how do human actions change the Bay, and can we do anything about it? Use this data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that people blank the Bay, and that blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: Modeled nitrogen loads fell from blank to blank million pounds per year, underwater grass in matched areas went from blank to blank acres, and blank of 3 surveyed reefs beat their targets.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: Less nitrogen feeds blank algae, so decomposers use up blank oxygen and more light reaches blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** The data show that people change the Bay and that cutting pollution can help it recover. Modeled nitrogen loads fell from 297.1 million pounds per year in 2009 to 252.7 in 2025, about 15 percent. In areas mapped in both years, underwater grass grew from 76,835 acres in 2024 to 82,968 in 2025, and 2 of 3 surveyed Lafayette River reefs beat their oyster targets. Less nitrogen feeds fewer algae, so decomposers use less oxygen and more light reaches the grass. One limit: hypoxic volume rose from 2023 to 2024, so three years of model estimates cannot show a trend, and one year of grass data cannot prove what caused the gain.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem: test a buffer

Does a strip of plants between a field and a stream reduce the nitrogen in runoff? Plan a fair test with trays of soil, and say how you would refine it if the result is unclear.

**Predict.** Buffer and control runoff have the same nitrate concentration, but the buffer tray makes less runoff. Did the buffer reduce the nitrate leaving the tray?

> **Check your prediction.** Yes. The nitrate leaving equals concentration times runoff volume, so the same mg/L in less water means less nitrate left the tray.

> **One way to do it.** Set up six identical trays of the same soil, tilted to the same angle. Three get a strip of grass sod at the low end, the buffer. Three stay bare, the control.
>
> - Independent variable: buffer strip or no buffer strip.
> - Dependent variables: nitrate in the runoff, measured in mg/L with aquarium test strips, and runoff volume.
> - Constants: soil, slope, the amount of dilute plant fertilizer containing nitrate (check the label) on each tray, the water poured and the waiting time.
> - Repeated trials: three trays of each kind, repeated on a second day. Compare means.
> - Safety: wear gloves and goggles, never taste the water, wash your hands, and dispose of runoff as your teacher directs.
>
> Lower mean nitrate and runoff from buffer trays on both days supports the buffer. If results overlap, widen the strip, add trays or try another plant. Trays are a model, not a stream; they test only water flowing over the surface. A real buffer also works underground, and it has a constraint: the farmland it takes.

## Going deeper

### A law, a model and a distant disturbance

In 2010, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency set a limit on nitrogen, phosphorus and sediment entering the Bay: the Chesapeake Bay TMDL, or total maximum daily load. Each state wrote a Watershed Implementation Plan for its share.

In one computer-model study of the Bay, warming cancelled roughly 6 to 34 percent of the oxygen gain from cutting nitrogen. The story “A Bay that never happened,” under Stories & asides, tells what else that study found.

Natural disturbances can also arrive from far away. The 2002 Denali Fault earthquake in Alaska sloshed a Nevada desert pool and disturbed spawning areas of the Devils Hole pupfish.

## Check your thinking

The one idea again: extra nutrients feed algae; bacteria use oxygen while poor mixing limits replacement; effective fixes cut nutrients first, rebuild habitat, and track recovery over time. Judge them over years, because weather makes single years bounce.

**Science practices you used:** asking a question about a Virginia problem, planning a fair test with a control and repeated trials, reading a data table and calculating a percent change, using a model and naming its limits, and making a claim from evidence.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/chesapeake-under-pressure/
