# The Cell Theory and Its Evidence

> The cell theory, that every living thing is made of cells and every new cell comes from a cell, needed more than better tools: a tool shows a detail only if the detail is larger than the tool's limit, and the theory also took comparing many living things and testing where new cells come from. You zoom a simulated microscope until objects of different sizes come into view, learn the six ideas of the cell theory, and read tables of tools and discoveries. Afterwards you can state the cell theory, explain why resolution decides what a microscope can show, and say how a scientific theory differs from a hypothesis and a law.

Course: Biology (Cells). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/cell-theory-evidence/

Builds on: What Am I Made Of?

## What you'll learn

- You will state the six ideas of the cell theory as Virginia lists them: all living organisms are made of cells; cells are the basic unit of life; all cells arise from pre-existing cells; metabolism happens inside cells; hereditary information (DNA) is passed from cell to cell; and all cells have the same basic composition.
- You will explain how the cell theory grew from better light microscopes, comparisons and experiments, and how later tools (stains and the electron microscope) extended it, and use resolution to explain why some cell parts were seen only later.
- You will tell a scientific theory apart from a law and from a hypothesis, using the cell theory as an example of a theory that is well supported and was revised as evidence grew.

**The first film ended with Hooke’s cork boxes: in view, but not enough to build a theory on.** Now test its rule on real objects.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Hooke's thin slice of cork showed rows of tiny walled boxes, the walls of dead cells. Image: a piece of cork with an exceedingly thin slice being lifted off, and a magnified circular view of the slice showing rows of empty, walled boxes like a honeycomb.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. All cells are basically the same shape and size. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Measurements under microscopes show huge differences. Many bacteria are about 1 to 2 micrometers long, a human cheek cell is about 50 to 80 micrometers across, and the yolk of an unfertilized chicken egg is a single cell you can hold. Shapes vary too, from flat sheets to long threads. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Measurements under microscopes show huge differences. Many bacteria are about 1 to 2 micrometers long, a human cheek cell is about 50 to 80 micrometers across, and the yolk of an unfertilized chicken egg is a single cell you can hold. Shapes vary too, from flat sheets to long threads.
2. There are only two kinds of cells: plant cells and animal cells. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Bacteria and archaea are living things made of cells, and their cells are neither plant nor animal cells. Fungi and many single-celled organisms in ponds have their own kinds of cells too. Microscopes and, later, other laboratory methods showed this variety. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Bacteria and archaea are living things made of cells, and their cells are neither plant nor animal cells. Fungi and many single-celled organisms in ponds have their own kinds of cells too. Microscopes and, later, other laboratory methods showed this variety.
3. The cell theory is just a guess, since it is only a theory. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** In science, a theory is a well-tested explanation that ties together many lines of evidence. The cell theory rests on a very large number of observations of many kinds of living things, made with many different tools. It has also been corrected as new evidence came in, which is how scientific theories work. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** In science, a theory is a well-tested explanation that ties together many lines of evidence. The cell theory rests on a very large number of observations of many kinds of living things, made with many different tools. It has also been corrected as new evidence came in, which is how scientific theories work.

## Explore: zoom in and see what appears

The simulation gives you a microscope with a **magnification** slider (how many times larger the image looks) and a switch for the type of tool: a hand lens, a light microscope or an electron microscope. A set of objects sits on the slide: a frog egg (about 1 mm across), a human cheek cell (about 50 to 80 µm), a bacterium (about 1 to 2 µm long), a virus (smaller than a bacterium) and a ribosome (about 0.02 to 0.03 µm). A micrometer (µm) is one thousandth of a millimeter. Before each step, compare each object’s size with the tool’s limit.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Zoom and resolve — what can each tool show?

**Try this.**

1. Predict which objects you can see with the hand lens. Write your guess down, then test it.
2. Switch to the light microscope and turn the magnification all the way up. Predict whether the ribosome will appear, then check.
3. Find the lowest magnification at which you can trace the cheek cell’s outline all the way around. Does turning it higher show the virus?
4. Switch to the electron microscope. Which objects appear now that did not appear before?

> **The one idea.** A tool shows a detail only if the detail is larger than the tool’s limit, its **resolution** (the smallest gap at which two points still look separate). So a whole cell can be clear while its parts are not.
>
> *Scope:* the rule is about making out a shape or a part, not about whether an object shows up at all. The 0.2 µm limit belongs to ordinary light microscopes; special methods beat it (see the Biology II note).

## Explain: seeing smaller things

- cell
- cell theory
- metabolism
- DNA
- magnification
- resolution
- stain
- electron microscope
- hypothesis
- theory
- law

Here are all three tools against the simulation’s objects. A **nanometer** (nm) is one thousandth of a micrometer.

| Tool | Smallest detail it can separate (about) | Can it show (and everything larger)… |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Unaided eye | about 0.1 mm (100 µm) | an African clawed frog egg, about 1 mm across |
| Ordinary light microscope | 0.2 µm | a cheek cell or a bacterium |
| Electron microscope, biological samples | 1 to 2 nm (0.001 to 0.002 µm) | most viruses, or a ribosome |

These are typical values for biological samples; real values vary with the instrument and the sample. An **electron microscope** forms its image with a beam of electrons instead of light. Electrons travel as waves with a much shorter **wavelength** (the distance from one crest to the next) than visible light, so electrons can separate much finer details (see Going deeper). In practice, the lenses and the delicate sample, not the wavelength, set the 1 to 2 nm limit. Ribosomes, the cell’s protein builders, are about 0.02 to 0.03 µm across, far below the light microscope’s limit. That is why they were seen clearly only with electron microscopes.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge frog eggcheek cellbacteriumvirusribosomelimit of the light microscope frog eggcheek cellblankblankblankbl

**Predict.** Many bacteria are about 1 to 2 µm long. One of Leeuwenhoek’s surviving microscopes separated details 1.35 µm apart. Could it show a bacterium’s shape and parts? Could it show anything at all?

> **Check your prediction.** Its parts, no: they are far smaller than 1.35 µm. Its shape, only roughly at best. The 1 to 2 µm is the bacterium’s length, and a rod is narrower than it is long. So a long rod might look slightly stretched, and a short one like a round blur. Anything at all, yes: an object near or below the limit can still show up as a blurred speck. Detecting something is not the same as resolving it.

Resolution is not the only problem. Many cells are almost clear inside. A **stain** is a dye that sticks to some cell parts more than others. It adds **contrast**, a difference in darkness between a part and its background. Stains made parts inside clear animal cells, such as the nucleus, much easier to see.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* The same cells unstained and stained: the stain makes the nucleus stand out. Image: the same three cheek-type cells in a microscope field, first unstained and almost invisible, then stained so the cells are tinted and each nucleus shows as a dark oval.

**Key idea:**

A whole cell can be clear while smaller or low-contrast parts are not. Stains made many parts easier to tell apart, and electron microscopes later resolved much finer details inside cells.

## Explain: the six ideas of the cell theory

The claim about cells is the **cell theory**, the scientific explanation of how cells relate to living things. A **cell** is the smallest unit that can carry out all the processes of life. Virginia lists six ideas:

1. All living organisms are composed of cells.
2. Cells are the basic unit of life.
3. All cells arise from pre-existing (already existing) cells.
4. Metabolism occurs within cells.
5. Hereditary information (DNA) is passed from cell to cell.
6. All cells have the same basic composition.

**Metabolism** is all the chemical reactions that happen in a living thing, such as breaking down sugar to release energy for the cell to use. Enzymes speed these reactions inside cells ([that lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/enzymes-at-work/)). **DNA** is the molecule that carries hereditary information. When a cell divides, each new cell gets a copy ([that lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/cell-cycle-and-mitosis/)).

“Same basic composition” means that cells are built from the same main kinds of molecules: proteins, lipids, carbohydrates and nucleic acids ([that lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/macromolecules/)). Typical cells have a membrane around them, a watery inside and DNA. The details still differ between kinds of cells.

The same basic plan does not mean the same size or shape: compare the simulation’s frog egg and bacterium. Viruses are not made of cells ([that lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/living-or-not/)).

**Key idea:**

Every living thing is made of one or more cells, and every new cell comes from a cell that already existed.

Idea 3 had to be fought for, and the second film shows how, starting from comparisons of **tissues**, organized groups of cells that work together.

**Film transcript: Where Do New Cells Come From?**

### Film transcript: Where Do New Cells Come From?

Idea three says every cell comes from a cell. The first scientists to argue for cells everywhere did not think so. So where did they think new cells came from? By the 1830s, improved microscopes were in use. The argument was not only about seeing. In 1838, Matthias Schleiden described plant tissues as made of cells. In 1839, Theodor Schwann compared plant and animal tissues, such as tadpole cartilage. He found the same cellular plan. Comparison was the key step. Many kinds of tissue, plant and animal, showed one shared plan. That was evidence that plants and animals alike are built of cells. But Schleiden and Schwann also thought new cells could form inside a structureless fluid. Picture a crystal growing in a solution.

No cell divides to make it. Schleiden proposed this for plants. Schwann extended it to animals. So there were two models. In the fluid model, a new cell forms inside a structureless fluid, and no cell divides. In the division model, one existing cell splits into two. Suppose you could watch a growing tissue for a while. What would each model lead you to expect to find?

The fluid model predicts new cells taking shape out of fluid, with no cell dividing. The division model predicts a series of stages. One cell pinches in two, then its daughters split again. Watching over time can tell the two models apart. In 1852, Robert Remak published evidence that new cells form when existing cells divide. In 1855, Rudolf Virchow spread the idea widely in a short article. Every cell comes from a cell. Remak's evidence came first; Virchow made it widely known. The fluid idea was wrong, so it was dropped. The core stayed: plants and animals are made of cells. A corrected idea took the fluid idea's place: cells come from existing cells.

That is how a scientific theory works. It is a well-tested explanation, tied to many lines of evidence. When strong new evidence appears, it can be revised. Being revised does not make it a guess. One limit on the rule. Every cell comes from a cell is about cells living today. How the very first cells arose is a separate question that scientists still study.

From the film

- Schleiden and Schwann compared many plant and animal tissues and found the same cellular plan.
- They also thought new cells could form inside a structureless fluid, like a crystal, with no cell dividing, and that part was wrong.
- Remak published evidence in 1852 that new cells form when existing cells divide, and Virchow spread the idea in 1855: every cell comes from a cell. That rule is about cells living today; how the very first cells arose is a separate question.
- The cell theory kept its core and replaced the wrong part with a corrected idea, which is how a well-tested scientific theory changes.

## Explain: a theory that grew and changed

The other ideas arrived differently. Schwann already treated cells as the places where nutrition and growth happen, which points toward idea 4. The idea that DNA carries hereditary information (idea 5) came much later.

Three words people often mix up:

| Word | What it is | Example |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Hypothesis | A testable statement about nature | Hypothesis: all plant tissues are made of cells. Prediction: thin slices of other plants will show cells too. |
| Theory | A well-tested explanation of some part of nature, supported by many lines of evidence | The cell theory |
| Law | A description of how something behaves under stated conditions | The law of conservation of mass (below) |

A **prediction** is what you should observe if a hypothesis is true.

**Predict.** The cell theory rests on a huge amount of evidence. With enough more, will it become a law?

> **Check your prediction.** No. A theory and a law do different jobs. The **law of conservation of mass** says that when a chemical reaction runs in a closed container, the total mass stays the same; it does not say why. The **atomic theory**, the explanation that matter is made of atoms, says why: a reaction rearranges atoms but does not create or destroy them. No amount of evidence for atoms will turn the atomic theory into the law of conservation of mass.

**Key idea:**

A theory explains and a law describes a pattern. Supporting evidence can strengthen a theory, and contrary evidence can lead scientists to revise it; neither turns a theory into a law.

## Elaborate: tools and discoveries over time

In the 1670s Antonie van Leeuwenhoek already saw living single-celled organisms, which he called animalcules. Compound microscopes use two or more lenses in a row. They did not clearly beat his best single lenses until improved microscopes came into use in the 1830s, the decade of Schleiden and Schwann. So tools were part of the wait, but not all of it: animalcules had been known for more than 150 years, and the theory still needed the work in the Ideas table.

**Tools**

| Year | Tool | Magnification (times) | Smallest detail separated (µm) | Note |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Before 1723 | Leeuwenhoek microscope (one of two surviving ones studied in 2021) | 266 | 1.35 | A single bead-shaped lens |
| 1933 | Ruska’s electron microscope | 12,000 | not reported | Electrons can form a magnified image |
| 1937 | Electron image of a diatom shell | 3,500 | 0.13 | A diatom is a single-celled alga with a glassy shell; the caption gives 130 nm, finer than the light limit |
| Today | Ordinary light microscope | – | 0.2 | The typical limit for biological samples |

**Ideas**

| Year | Who | What they did | Kind of work |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1665 | Hooke | Saw small chambers in cork and called them cells | Looking |
| 1838 | Schleiden | Described plant tissues as made of cells | Comparing |
| 1839 | Schwann | Found the same cellular plan in animal tissues, such as tadpole cartilage | Comparing |
| 1852 | Remak | Published evidence that new cells form by division | Observing cell division, which tested the fluid idea |
| 1855 | Virchow | Spread the idea: every cell comes from a cell | Stating the corrected idea |

Hooke’s magnification and smallest separated detail are not reported in these sources. The tables are a compilation, not one measured data set (sources in Going deeper).

1. How many times greater was the magnification of Ruska’s 1933 microscope than that of the Leeuwenhoek microscope in the table? Round to the nearest whole number.
2. The Leeuwenhoek microscope in the table separated details 1.35 µm apart. An ordinary light microscope today separates about 0.2 µm. About how many times finer is the modern limit?
3. The Tools table lists no tool between the Leeuwenhoek microscope (before 1723) and Ruska’s 1933 microscope, although microscopes had improved in the 1830s. Look at the Ideas table: besides better microscopes, what kind of work moved the theory forward from 1838 to 1855?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers the essential question: why did it take better tools, and more than tools, to build the cell theory? Use the two tables.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The cell theory needed blank and also blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: The Tools table shows that blank, and the Ideas table shows that the steps from 1838 to 1855 came from blank.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This matters because a tool can show a detail only when the detail is blank than the tool's limit, and a theory needs blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** The cell theory needed better tools and also many comparisons and a corrected idea. Hooke saw cork chambers in 1665, but the claim that animals share the cellular plan came only in 1839, after many plant and animal tissues were compared. Microscopes had improved in the 1830s, but the steps from 1838 to 1855 came mainly from comparing tissues and testing how new cells form with those improved microscopes, not from a new kind of tool. Tools mattered too: the caption of a 1937 electron image of a diatom gives 130 nm (0.13 µm), finer than the 0.2 µm light limit.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Hooke cut his cork slice exceedingly thin. Does the thickness of a slice change how many separate cells you can count in one view of a light microscope? Plan a fair test using an onion or a potato, a light microscope and slides.

> **One way to do it.** - Hypothesis: If the slice is thinner, then more separate cells will be countable in one view, because fewer layers of cells overlap.
> - Independent variable: slice thickness, for example very thin, medium and thick.
> - Dependent variable: the number of cells with walls you can trace all the way around in one field of view.
> - Constants: the same onion or potato, microscope, magnification, light setting and stain.
> - Comparison: the thickest slice serves as the baseline.
> - Repeated trials: make five slides at each thickness, count three views on each, and calculate the mean for each thickness.
> - Safety: cutting thin slices needs a sharp blade. Use a guarded blade or a peeler, cut away from your hand, and work only with an adult’s permission.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Hooke’s cork put cells in view. Claiming them for all life took better light microscopes, many comparisons and a corrected idea about new cells. Stains showed pale parts more clearly, and electron microscopes later showed much finer details inside cells. A theory built that way is a well-tested explanation, not a guess.

**Science practices you used:** predicting before testing, reading data tables, telling a hypothesis, a prediction, a theory and a law apart, modeling resolution and its limits, and planning a fair test.

## Going deeper

### Why even a good lens blurs

Physicists call the first film’s spreading of light through a lens opening **diffraction**. The 0.2 µm limit is typical, not exact for every microscope or viewing direction. Shorter wavelengths make smaller smudges, which is why electrons help. A stretched, blurry phone photo is only a loose comparison: photos also blur from poor focus, motion or too few pixels.

### Archaeal membranes

Archaea build their membranes from lipids that differ from those of bacteria, plants and animals in both their chains and the chemical links that join them. This is one of the main features that sets archaea apart.

### Where the table’s numbers come from

Two of the few surviving microscopes made by Antonie van Leeuwenhoek, both made before 1723, are in museums in Leiden and Utrecht. A 2021 study (Cocquyt and colleagues, Science Advances) scanned their lenses and reported their magnifications. One, labelled V7017, magnified 118 times, and no resolution was reported for it; its single lens was ground and polished. The other, UM-1, magnified 266 times and separated details 1.35 µm apart, and its lens was a single bead shape; the 1.35 µm value is an earlier measurement that the study cites. The 1933 magnification and the 1937 diatom image come from Ernst Ruska’s 1986 Nobel Lecture. Dates for Schleiden, Schwann, Remak and Virchow come from the OpenStax Microbiology textbook (2016).

### Viruses near the limit

The table says most viruses because a few unusually large viruses come close to the light microscope’s limit or pass it.

### Metabolism outside cells?

“Metabolism occurs within cells” is the Virginia wording. Some reactions do run outside cells, such as digestive enzymes working in the gut. But those enzymes are made by cells, and most of metabolism happens inside cells.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/cell-theory-evidence/
