# Building a Tree of Life

> Trace shared derived traits to branch points to find the closest relatives. You will score traits in a small group of animals, build and read a cladogram, and weigh evidence from body structures, embryos, fossils and DNA. Then you will defend why a fish-shaped whale belongs with mammals and why hippos are its closest living relatives.

Course: Biology (Classifying life). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/building-a-tree-of-life/

Builds on: DNA: Structure and Copying · From DNA to Protein

## What you'll learn

- You will explain that scientists classify organisms by shared ancestry, read from inherited traits (similar structures, how embryos develop, the fossil record, and DNA and proteins) rather than from looks or habitat, and that a shared genetic code and shared chemical reactions point to common ancestry.
- You will build and read a cladogram from shared derived characteristics, knowing that branch points stand for common ancestors and that branch lengths show time or amount of change only when the tree gives a scale.
- You will use fossil, embryo and DNA evidence to make and defend a claim about where an organism belongs on a tree.

The first film ends on a surprising pair: whale and hippo. Now try the same reasoning on six animals and decide which trait separates each new branch.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* A whale's fishlike shape fits swimming, while its inherited mammal traits and DNA evidence place it with hippos. Image: a tuna and a whale with its calf swimming in the sea, the whale breathing at the surface, and a hippo standing in a river nearby, with a dashed bracket grouping the whale and the hippo.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Scientists group organisms by how they look, where they live and what they eat. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Looks, homes and diets can match in organisms that are not closely related; a shark and a dolphin are both sleek swimmers. Biologists compare inherited evidence instead. Body form still counts, but only when the likeness comes from shared inherited parts. When several lines of evidence agree, the grouping is trusted more. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Looks, homes and diets can match in organisms that are not closely related; a shark and a dolphin are both sleek swimmers. Biologists compare inherited evidence instead. Body form still counts, but only when the likeness comes from shared inherited parts. When several lines of evidence agree, the grouping is trusted more.
2. A cladogram shows life going step by step from simple to complex, with humans at the top. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** A cladogram is a branching diagram, like a family tree of cousins. On a tree of living groups, every tip has been evolving for the same amount of time since their shared ancestor. You can spin the branches around a branch point, and the tree still means the same thing, so no tip is the top. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** A cladogram is a branching diagram, like a family tree of cousins. On a tree of living groups, every tip has been evolving for the same amount of time since their shared ancestor. You can spin the branches around a branch point, and the tree still means the same thing, so no tip is the top.
3. Humans evolved from chimpanzees. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Fossils and DNA show that humans and chimpanzees share a common ancestor that lived long ago. Since that ancestor, both lines have kept changing. Living chimpanzees are our close cousins, not our grandparents. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Fossils and DNA show that humans and chimpanzees share a common ancestor that lived long ago. Since that ancestor, both lines have kept changing. Living chimpanzees are our close cousins, not our grandparents.

## Explore: build a tree one trait at a time

A **cladogram** is a branching diagram of proposed relationships. In the builder, choose a trait, and the animals that lack it branch off first. Each trait marks a group within the whole sample. Added from backbone to hair, the traits pick out smaller and smaller groups. Another order changes the steps, not the finished tree. A DNA panel then checks the tree with another kind of evidence.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Cladogram builder: add one trait at a time

**Predict.** Which animal will branch off first when you add “backbone”?

> **Check your prediction.** The lancelet branches off first because it is the only animal in this set without a backbone.

Now try a different order, spin branches around a branch point and open the DNA panel. Ask what changed in the drawing and what, if anything, changed in the relationships.

**The one idea:**

Trace shared derived traits to branch points to find the closest relatives.

**Scope:**

a derived trait first appeared in one ancestor and passed to its descendants, so it is newer than the group you compare. A trait every sampled organism has, like a backbone among vertebrates, is inherited too but cannot split them. A tree is a supported model of the organisms and evidence it includes. It says nothing about organisms left out, and new evidence can test it.

## Explain: the evidence for shared ancestry

- classification
- homologous structures
- embryology
- fossil record
- common ancestor
- genetic code
- cladogram
- shared derived characteristic
- branch point

**Classification** is the grouping of organisms by how they are related. The first film’s limb pattern is a **homologous structure**: a body part built from the same basic parts because it came from a **common ancestor**. A common ancestor is an earlier population from which two or more groups descended. Name the bone sets yourself in the figure.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge upper arm bonetwo forearm boneswrist bonesfinger bones upper arm boneblankblankfinger bones Word bank: tw

**Embryology** is the study of development before birth or hatching. Early fish, chick and human embryos have a tail and neck folds called pharyngeal arches. In fish, openings form between the arches, and several arches support gills. In humans the grooves between the arches never open into gill slits. The arches form parts of the jaw, ear and throat, and the tail shrinks. Human embryos do not turn into fish.

The **fossil record** is the collection of preserved remains and traces of past life, placed in time order by the rock layers they are found in, including groups that no longer exist.

Beyond the film’s DNA insertions, scientists compare matching DNA and protein sequences. The more two species’ sequences match, the more recently they usually shared an ancestor. At a deeper scale, almost every organism reads DNA with the same **genetic code**. The code matches each three-letter word in a gene’s message to an amino acid or a stop signal. Some organisms and mitochondria read a few of these words differently, but these are small changes to the same code. Most organisms also share basic reactions for breaking down sugar. A shared code and shared chemistry are best explained by common ancestry. [The protein-synthesis lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/protein-synthesis/) shows how the code works.

**Evidence check:**

A nearly universal genetic code and shared chemistry point to a common origin for life, while smaller differences help resolve later branches.

**Predict.** A backbone occurs in every vertebrate in a sample. Can it separate the turtle from the salamander and leopard in that sample?

> **Check your prediction.** No. A trait shared by every organism in the group cannot split that group. A later trait, such as the amnion, is needed.

In a clean teaching table, a shared derived trait found in some animals but not others can mark a branch. With real data, scientists also test that it was inherited once, not lost or evolved twice. The second film puts such traits on branches and reads the tree.

**Film transcript: Read the Branch Point**

### Film transcript: Read the Branch Point

The first film followed inherited evidence to a surprising pair. Once evidence is scored, how does a branching tree turn it into a claim about relatives? The answer is not the nearest tip. It is the path back to a shared branch point.

Begin with a trait table. Each row is an organism, and each column is one inherited feature. A present mark lights up in teal. When the same marks form a smaller group inside a larger group, the groups are nested. A tree can show that nesting. A useful marker is a shared derived characteristic. It first appeared in one ancestor and passed to that ancestor's descendants. Move its mark from the table onto the matching branch. Every tip beyond that mark belongs to the marked group in this tree. A branch point, also called a node, represents a common ancestral population. Start at two tips and trace both lines toward the root.

Stop at the first node shared by both paths. A pair sharing a later node is more closely related in this tree. Trace shared derived traits to branch points to find the closest relatives. Now spin the whale and hippo branches around their shared node. The tips trade places. Did the relationship change, or did only the drawing move? Follow both paths before you decide.

Only the drawing moved. Both paths still meet at the same node, so the relationship is unchanged. Tip order cannot decide relatedness. This tree also has no top or goal. Every living tip has continued changing since its ancestors split. Branch length needs a key. On a plain cladogram, a long line can be empty space for layout. It does not automatically mean more time or more change. Some trees add a scale for time or change. Read that scale before comparing lengths. A tree can only use the organisms and evidence included. New fossils, sequences, or traits can test its branches. Different evidence may disagree, so scientists compare several lines and treat the tree as a supported model.

Scientists can update that model when stronger evidence changes the supported branching order. The clean classroom table is a starting case, not every case. So do not read across the tips. Trace backward. Find the first node shared by both paths, then ask which shared derived trait marks that branch. Rotation changes the picture, and a scale can change what length means. The branching order carries the relationship.

From the film

- Trace shared derived traits to branch points to find the closest relatives.
- A shared derived trait marks a group that inherited it from one ancestor.
- The closer pair meets at a more recent shared branch point.
- Rotating branches does not change the relationships.

## Explain: read and build a cladogram

The second film defined a **shared derived characteristic**, a trait that first appeared in one ancestor and passed to its descendants, and a **branch point**, or node, the common ancestor of every branch that grows from it. It also showed that spinning branches or stretching unscaled lines changes only the drawing. It left out two points. A trait counts as derived only compared with the rest of the sample. And a node is an ancestral population that lived in the past, not a single individual; living species sit at the tips.

**Tree reading:**

Put a finger on each tip, trace toward the root and stop at the first branch point both paths share.

## Elaborate: score six animals and place a whale

This table scores five traits in six animals. A 1 means present and a 0 means absent. The lancelet, a small fishlike animal without a backbone, is the **outgroup**, the animal used for comparison.

| Animal | Backbone (1/0) | Jaws (1/0) | Four walking legs (1/0) | Amnion (1/0) | Hair (1/0) |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Lancelet (outgroup) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Lamprey | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Tuna | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Salamander | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Turtle | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 |
| Leopard | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 |

These scores are a teaching dataset from a published biology textbook figure, not measurements of individual specimens. The source calls one trait the “amniotic (shelled) egg”. Here it means an embryo that grows inside a protective membrane called the amnion, which is why a leopard scores 1 even though it is born alive.

The 1s nest: five animals have backbones, four have jaws, three have four walking legs, two have an amnion and one has hair.

**Predict.** Which trait separates the lamprey from the other vertebrates? Is the turtle closer to the leopard or the salamander, and which trait decides?

> **Check your prediction.** Jaws separate the lamprey: it has a backbone but no jaws, so it branches off before the jaw trait. The turtle is closer to the leopard. Both share the amnion, which the salamander lacks, so their paths meet at a more recent branch point. Legs, jaws and a backbone are shared by all three, so they cannot decide.

Hair marks the leopard branch in this sample. Real datasets are rarely this neatly nested: traits can be lost or arise independently, and kinds of evidence can disagree.

DNA gives separate evidence. In a made-up example, whale and hippo share insertions at three matching DNA spots, while pig and cow share one different insertion.

**Predict.** One DNA spot groups whale with pig, while several other spots group whale with hippo. Should one spot decide the tree?

> **Check your prediction.** No. One odd result could reflect missing data or another problem, so it should not outweigh several checked, independent insertions at the same locations in every species.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim about where a whale belongs on the tree of life, using evidence from fossils, embryos and DNA.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: A whale belongs on the blank branch, and its closest living relatives are blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: Whales breathe with blank and feed their young blank. Fossil whales such as blank had blank. Whale DNA shares blank with hippo DNA.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: These traits were inherited from a common ancestor because blank, so the whale’s fishlike shape is blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** A whale belongs on the mammal branch, and its closest living relatives are hippos. Whales surface to breathe air with lungs, whereas tuna use gills, and whales feed their young milk, a trait that marks mammals. The fossil whale Maiacetus had four limbs with hands and feet, and dolphin embryos briefly grow hind-limb buds that later stop growing. These fossils and embryos show that whales came from four-legged land mammals. A 1999 study found DNA insertions shared by whales and hippos, which points to hippos as their closest living relatives. The fishlike body is a later change that fits life in water. One limit is that the six-animal table here has no whale and cannot place it by itself.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

Plan a study to test whether whales are closer to hippos or to pigs, using inserted pieces of DNA. Say what you would measure and what result would support each answer.

> **One way to do it.** - **What you measure:** at many matching DNA spots, whether an inserted piece of DNA is present or absent in whales, hippos, pigs, cows and an outgroup such as a horse.
> - **Prediction if whales and hippos are closest:** several insertions found in whales and hippos but not in pigs.
> - **Prediction if hippos and pigs are closest:** several insertions shared by hippos and pigs but not by whales.
> - **Constants:** look at the same DNA spots in every species, and use the same lab method for each sample.
> - **Checks:** sequence each spot to confirm the insertion is really there. Test more than one individual of each species, and use many spots, not one, so that a single odd result cannot decide the answer.
> - **Ethics:** use DNA from museum tissue, stranded animals or zoo samples, so no animal is harmed for the study.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Check your CER answer: each piece of evidence should be an inherited trait that marks a branch, not a resemblance. Lungs distinguish the whale from the tuna in this comparison, milk places it among mammals, and shared DNA insertions pick out hippos. Use the rule once more: follow the shared derived traits back to the shared node.

**Science practices you used:** reading a data table of scored traits, building a model of relationships and naming its limits, using several lines of evidence to support a claim, and planning a test that could prove a claim wrong.

## Going deeper

### Classification ranks and embryo drawings

Classification is also a nested list from broad to specific: domain, kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species. Each level holds fewer organisms that share more traits. [The domains-and-kingdoms lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/domains-and-kingdoms/) covers the broadest levels.

Some old textbook drawings made vertebrate embryos look more alike than they really are. Biologists now compare photographs of real embryos. The shared structures are evidence; the embryos are not identical.

### Where the trait table comes from

The trait scores come from a published biology textbook figure (copyright 2005), shown in City Tech (CUNY) course slides for BIO1201 (spring 2019 course website).

### Dates for the whale evidence

The fossil whale Maiacetus is about 47.5 million years old. Dolphin embryos grow hind-limb buds that stop growing around week five.

### The 2005 chimpanzee genome comparison

In 2005 a team compared the genome of one chimpanzee, named Clint, with human DNA. Across about 2.4 billion bases that could be lined up, they found 1.23 mismatches per 100 bases, so about 98.8 percent matched. That figure covers only the aligned parts, not every difference between the two genomes.

**Predict.** Using those numbers, about how many of every 1,000 aligned bases differ between humans and chimpanzees?

> **Check your prediction.** About 12. Multiply 1.23 differences per 100 bases by 10 to get 12.3 differences per 1,000 aligned bases, then round to a whole base.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/building-a-tree-of-life/
