# Beyond Dominant and Recessive

> Alleles remain separate, and each genetic tool reveals a different scale. Switch one cross between three inheritance patterns, read a family pedigree and a karyotype, and test a claim against blood-type counts from millions of U.S. donors. Afterwards you can predict ratios for incomplete dominance and codominance and use pedigrees and karyotypes as tools.

Course: Biology (DNA and inheritance). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/beyond-dominance/

Builds on: Mendel and Punnett Squares · Meiosis and Variation

## What you'll learn

- You will explain incomplete dominance (the heterozygote shows an in-between phenotype, as in pink snapdragons) and codominance (the heterozygote shows the effects of both alleles, as in roan cattle and the AB blood type), and predict genotype and phenotype ratios for these crosses.
- You will read a pedigree to follow a trait through a family, using the standard symbols, and decide whether a trait is likely dominant or recessive.
- You will read a karyotype to count chromosomes and recognize an extra or missing chromosome (for example trisomy 21), and explain that the same genes are present in nearly every cell with a nucleus even though cells use them differently.

In [Mendel and Punnett squares](https://stemhop.com/lessons/punnett-squares/), a dominant allele hid a recessive one. Pink snapdragons and roan calves break that rule. The first film showed why: the allele pairings stay fixed, and only how each pairing shows changes.

Guiding idea: **alleles remain separate, and each genetic tool reveals a different scale.** It holds for the one-gene crosses, pedigrees and karyotypes here. The environment can also change a phenotype, pedigree clues do not prove a model, and a karyotype cannot show alleles.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Pink snapdragons mean the red and white genes have blended together for good. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Crossing two pink snapdragons brings back red and white flowers. The color looks mixed, but each allele stays separate and can be passed on. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Crossing two pink snapdragons brings back red and white flowers. The color looks mixed, but each allele stays separate and can be passed on.
2. Dominant alleles are always better, or more common, than recessive ones. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Dominant means one copy is enough for a trait to show. Dominant alleles can cause disease, and medical geneticists track them in families. Real counts show recessive traits can be common and dominant traits rare. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Dominant means one copy is enough for a trait to show. Dominant alleles can cause disease, and medical geneticists track them in families. Real counts show recessive traits can be common and dominant traits rare.
3. A karyotype is a picture that shows each of a person’s genes. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Most chromosomes carry hundreds to thousands of genes, too small to see. Lab guides say karyotypes show chromosome number, size, shape and only large changes. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Most chromosomes carry hundreds to thousands of genes, too small to see. Lab guides say karyotypes show chromosome number, size, shape and only large changes.

## Explore: switch one cross between three patterns

Choose two parents and build their Punnett square. Switch among complete dominance, incomplete dominance and codominance without changing the genotypes. A real gene does not switch; the switch compares the rules on one grid.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Inheritance pattern switch: one cross, three patterns

**Try this.** Predict each result before you test it. Cross `RR × WW` in all three modes. Grow 100 `RW × RW` offspring and compare with the expected counts. Switch modes on the same cross: which counts change, and which stay the same? Finally, in the pedigree panel, shade a child of two unshaded parents and test both models.

## Explain: when neither allele hides the other

- allele
- heterozygous
- homozygous
- genotype
- phenotype
- incomplete dominance
- codominance
- multiple alleles
- pedigree
- carrier
- karyotype
- autosome

An **allele** is one version of a gene. A **homozygous** organism has two of the same allele, and a **heterozygous** organism has two different alleles. Your **genotype** is your pair of alleles, and your **phenotype** is the trait that shows.

For snapdragon flower color, `R` is the red allele and `W` is the white allele. Both are capitals, so neither symbol suggests that one hides the other.

**Incomplete dominance** means the heterozygote shows a phenotype in between the two homozygotes, as in pink `RW` snapdragons. Pink looks like mixed paint, but paint stays mixed. A pink plant still passes a separate R or W to each sex cell.

The first film’s pink × pink grid:

|  | R (1/2) | W (1/2) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| **R (1/2)** | RR, red | RW, pink |
| **W (1/2)** | RW, pink | WW, white |

> genotype ratio 1 RR : 2 RW : 1 WW, and phenotype ratio 1 red : 2 pink : 1 white

Red and white return: the alleles never blended.

**Predict.** Cross a pink `RW` snapdragon with a white `WW` snapdragon. Which colors should appear, and in what ratio?

> **Check your prediction.** The pink parent passes `R` or `W`; the white parent passes `W`. Expect pink and white offspring `1:1`, on average.

**Codominance** means the heterozygote shows the effects of both alleles. Snapdragon color is not codominant, so the first film switched to roan Shorthorn cattle; roan × roan gives `1` red : `2` roan : `1` white on average.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Two heterozygotes: the pink snapdragon is in between its parents, while the roan calf shows both, hair by hair. In both, the alleles stay separate. Image: on the left, a red snapdragon and a white snapdragon with a pink-flowered offspring; on the right, a red Shorthorn cow and a white bull with a roan calf, and a zoom on the calf's coat showing red hairs and white hairs growing side by side.

**Key idea:**

In incomplete dominance the heterozygote is in between; in codominance it shows the effects of both alleles; in both, the alleles stay separate and return in the next generation.

ABO blood type adds **multiple alleles**: a population can have more than two versions of a gene, although each person carries only two. The ABO gene has three common alleles, IA, IB and i. The table adds the genotypes the first film skipped.

| Blood type | Genotypes in the usual model | Markers on red blood cells |
| --- | --- | --- |
| A | IA IA or IA i | A |
| B | IB IB or IB i | B |
| AB | IA IB | A and B |
| O | ii | neither |

IA and IB are codominant, and each is dominant to i.

**Predict.** In the usual model, what blood types can children have if one parent is type AB and the other is type O?

> **Check your prediction.** The AB parent passes IA or IB; the O parent passes i. Expect type A or B, about half of each.

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* ABO blood types as markers on red blood cells: type AB carries both, because the IA and IB alleles are codominant. Image: four red blood cells. The first carries triangle-shaped A markers, the second square-shaped B markers, the third both kinds, and the fourth none.

The environment can change a phenotype too.

**Predict.** Must genetically matched bigleaf hydrangea cuttings have the same flower color if they grow in soils with different acidity?

> **Check your prediction.** No. In many bigleaf hydrangeas, the same plant has bluer flowers in acidic soil and pinker flowers in less acidic soil.

Every prediction so far came from a cross someone could plan. Nobody plans crosses between people, so human genetics needs wider views: families first, then whole chromosomes. The second film makes that change.

**Film transcript: From Families to Chromosomes**

### Film transcript: From Families to Chromosomes

The first film kept allele tiles separate while the phenotype changed. How can we follow those copies when people cannot be crossed for an experiment? We must use evidence that already exists, then match each question to the right scale. Each view can answer only some questions.

A pedigree turns a family into a model. Squares and circles stand for people, and shading marks the chosen trait. Lines connect partners and children. Generations stack downward, letting a pattern unfold through time. The shape is a symbol, not a genotype. The parents do not show the trait, yet their child does. Which simple model fits this clue better: dominant or recessive? Hold both possibilities beside the family before you decide.

A recessive model can fit. Each unshaded parent may carry a recessive allele, and the child may receive both copies. This pattern points toward recessive inheritance, but a small family does not prove it. The parents are carriers in this simple model. Geneticists test a model against every person, not a striking branch. A dominant trait usually appears in each generation, and a shaded child usually has a shaded parent. A new DNA change can be an exception. A small family can still fit several explanations. Alleles remain separate, and each genetic tool reveals a different scale. A pedigree works at the family scale. It can test inheritance models, but it cannot show the allele copies directly.

Now zoom from a person into a cell with a nucleus. A karyotype sorts photographed chromosomes into matched pairs by size and shape. It answers questions about whole chromosomes and large changes. Matched partners make an extra or missing copy visible. An extra chromosome is large enough to count. A single gene, such as the ABO gene, is far too small to identify here. The picture can reveal scale-sized changes, not every inherited detail. A karyotype cannot identify a person's ABO alleles. Nearly every body cell with a nucleus carries the same DNA and genes.

Skin and muscle cells differ because they use different gene sets. Mature red blood cells lose their nuclei, leaving no chromosomes to count. Start with the question, then choose the view. Use a cross for possible allele combinations, a pedigree for family patterns, and a karyotype for whole chromosomes.

No view can answer every genetics question. Match the tool to the scale of evidence.

From the film

- Each genetic tool reveals a different scale: cross, family or whole chromosome.
- A pedigree tests inheritance models against people across generations.
- Pedigree clues are not proof, especially in a small family.
- A karyotype shows whole chromosomes and large changes, not single alleles.

## Explain: reading a family pedigree

The second film showed how to test a **pedigree**, a chart showing who has a trait across generations. The full key adds what the film left out: which shape is which sex, and how people are numbered.

- A square is a male, and a circle is a female.
- Shading marks a person who shows the trait. The legend always says what the shading means.
- A horizontal line joins two partners. A vertical line drops from it to their children.
- Roman numerals (I, II, III) label generations, and numbers label people within a generation.

The film’s two clues apply to genes on the **autosomes**, the chromosomes that are not sex chromosomes. In the recessive clue, each unshaded parent of a shaded child must be a **carrier**, a heterozygote who carries a recessive allele but does not show the trait. In the dominant clue, a shaded child usually has a shaded parent. Once in a while, though, a new change in DNA starts a dominant trait in a family with no history of it. These are clues, not proofs. A small family may fit both models.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge squarecirclehorizontal linevertical linecarriershaded symbol squarecircleblankblankblankblank Word bank: 

**Key idea:**

A pedigree lets you test whether a dominant or a recessive model fits a family. A shaded child of two unshaded parents points to a recessive trait.

## Explain: a karyotype counts whole chromosomes

A **karyotype** is a picture of a cell’s chromosomes sorted into matched pairs by size and shape. A typical human body cell with a nucleus has 46 chromosomes in 23 pairs: 22 pairs of autosomes and one pair of sex chromosomes, usually XX or XY.

**Predict.** A karyotype shows one X and no second sex chromosome. How many chromosomes does that cell have?

> **Check your prediction.** It has 45 chromosomes, written 45,X. This chromosome pattern is linked to Turner syndrome.

Having three copies of chromosome 21, instead of two, is called trisomy 21. A cell with it has 47 chromosomes. It is the most frequent cause of Down syndrome. The CDC estimates that about 1 in 640 babies born in the United States has Down syndrome.

As the second film showed, nearly every body cell with a nucleus has the same genes, and skin and muscle cells differ because they use, or **express**, different sets of them. Mature red blood cells, which lose their nucleus, are the most common cells in your body. To see how cells copy DNA, read [that lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/dna-structure-and-copying/).

**Key idea:**

A karyotype shows the number and shape of whole chromosomes, so it can reveal an extra chromosome 21. Nearly every body cell with a nucleus carries the same genes but uses them differently.

## Elaborate: model predictions and real blood-type counts

| Row | What it describes | Share (%) | Kind of number |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | Red offspring, pink × pink snapdragons | 25 | expected by the model |
| 2 | Pink offspring, pink × pink snapdragons | 50 | expected by the model |
| 3 | White offspring, pink × pink snapdragons | 25 | expected by the model |
| 4 | U.S. blood donors with type O | 48.8 | measured |
| 5 | U.S. blood donors with type A | 36.0 | measured |
| 6 | U.S. blood donors with type B | 11.3 | measured |
| 7 | U.S. blood donors with type AB | 3.9 | measured |

Rows 1 to 3 are the expected shares for a pink × pink cross, from the OpenStax Biology 2e textbook (2018); they are not counts of real plants. Rows 4 to 7 come from American Red Cross records of 7,449,831 U.S. donors, March 2018 to February 2023. Allen and colleagues published them in PLOS One (2026), counting each donor once.

**Predict.** Which blood type was most common among these donors, and is it dominant or recessive in the usual model? What does the existence of type AB as its own group tell you about IA and IB? Which rows could change in a different group of people?

> **Check your prediction.** Type O was most common although `ii` is recessive. Rows 4 to 7 depend on the sample; rows 1 to 3 are model predictions. Type AB shows IA and IB are codominant.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim about what happens when neither allele is fully dominant, using this data.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: The data show that when neither the A nor the B allele is dominant over the other, blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: Among U.S. donors, blank percent were type AB, and type O, which is recessive, was blank percent.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: This makes sense because people with IA IB show blank, and dominance tells you blank but not blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** When neither allele is dominant, the heterozygote has its own phenotype. Among 7,449,831 U.S. donors, 3.9 percent were type AB, a group that exists only because IA and IB are codominant and both markers show. The data also show that dominance does not predict how common a type is: type O, the recessive ii genotype, was the largest group at 48.8 percent. One limit is that donors are not a random sample of everyone. The same study found that hospital patients’ blood types differed from donors’, so another group could give different shares.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

A plant breeder has pink snapdragons. One idea is that pink is the heterozygote in an incomplete dominance pattern. Another is that pink is a third, true-breeding color. Plan crosses that would tell these ideas apart.

> **One way to do it.** Cross pink plants with other pink plants, and also cross pink plants with white plants.
>
> - **Independent variable:** the type of cross, pink × pink or pink × white.
> - **Dependent variable:** the number of red, pink and white offspring.
> - **Constants:** the same soil, water, light, pot size and growing time for all plants.
> - **Control of pollen:** remove each flower’s pollen-making parts before they ripen, brush on pollen from the chosen parent, and cover the flower so insects cannot bring other pollen.
> - **Repeated trials:** use several different pink parents.
> - **Sample size:** grow at least 100 offspring per cross, because small counts swing widely.
>
> If pink is RW, pink × pink should give about 1 red : 2 pink : 1 white, and pink × white about 1 pink : 1 white. If pink is true-breeding, pink × pink gives only pink.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

Alleles remain separate, and each genetic tool reveals a different scale: a cross shows allele pairings, a pedigree tests models across a family, and a karyotype counts whole chromosomes.

**Science practices you used:** predicting before testing, using a Punnett square and a pedigree as models and naming their limits, telling model predictions from measured data, and planning controlled crosses with enough offspring.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/beyond-dominance/
