# Adaptations for Survival

> Adaptations help in particular settings; populations change over generations, not individuals. You test what happens when snow melts before a hare changes color, sort physical and behavioral adaptations, and use survival estimates from Montana hares and attack counts on Florida clay mice to explain trade-offs, variation and population change.

Course: Life Science (Living together). Level: grades 7–12. About 40 minutes.
Lesson page (link this one when citing): https://stemhop.com/lessons/adaptations-for-survival/

Builds on: Habitat and Niche · Predators and Prey

## What you'll learn

- You will explain physical adaptations (body coverings, coloration and structures that help a living thing get resources or avoid predators) and behavioral adaptations (actions or patterns such as migration and hibernation), with examples.
- You will explain that adaptations help an organism meet its needs in a particular ecosystem, that adaptations usually have trade-offs, that individuals of a species vary, and that populations, not single animals, adapt over many generations.
- You will read survival data for snowshoe hares whose coats matched or did not match the ground, and make a claim, with evidence and reasoning, about how coloration helps survival.

**In fall, a snowshoe hare’s brown fur turns white over several weeks. On snow it is hard to see, but what if the snow melts early and the hare is still white?**

Snowshoe hares live in snowy forests in Canada and the northern United States, including Montana. Scientists there put radio collars on hares and checked on them each week to answer one question: does a coat that stands out cost a hare its life?

**The one idea:**

Adaptations help in particular settings; populations change over generations, not individuals.

**Scope:**

Here, an adaptation is an inherited trait that helps survival and reproduction in a particular ecosystem. Population change means that inherited traits become more or less common. It does not mean that one animal never learns, grows or responds.

What do you think? Decide before you read.

1. Animals adapt because they want or need to. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** White hares in Montana did not move to snowier spots, and many stayed the wrong color for the ground. Traits change in a population over many generations, when animals with helpful inherited traits leave more young. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** White hares in Montana did not move to snowier spots, and many stayed the wrong color for the ground. Traits change in a population over many generations, when animals with helpful inherited traits leave more young.
2. Animals are perfectly adapted to where they live. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Adaptations usually have a cost somewhere. A white coat hides a hare on snow, but the same coat stands out on brown ground. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Adaptations usually have a cost somewhere. A white coat hides a hare on snow, but the same coat stands out on brown ground.
3. All animals of one species have the same adaptations. Agree Disagree **Scientists disagree:** Hares in the same Montana forest turned white at different times. In some places with little snow, snowshoe hares stay brown all winter. These differences matter when the weather changes. What scientists think **Scientists disagree:** Hares in the same Montana forest turned white at different times. In some places with little snow, snowshoe hares stay brown all winter. These differences matter when the weather changes.

## Explore: change when the snow melts

Each dot on this hillside is a hare. You choose when the snow melts and when the hares change color. A warmer-climate switch makes the snowy season shorter. Hares that stand out are highlighted, and a bar shows how many are lost to predators each week.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Hare coat match: change when the snow melts

First melt the snow early with the usual color-change timing, and watch which hares stand out.

**Predict.** Now turn on the warmer-climate switch, run the season with the usual timing, and note the survivors. If you move the color change two weeks earlier, will the final number of survivors rise, fall or stay about the same? The slider moves both the fall and the spring change, so think about both seasons before you test it.

The model shows only color. Real predators also use smell, sound and movement, and real hares differ in many ways.

## What counts as an adaptation?

- adaptation
- physical adaptation
- behavioral adaptation
- camouflage
- migration
- hibernation
- trade-off
- variation

An **adaptation** is an inherited trait that helps survival and reproduction in a particular ecosystem. Inherited means passed from parents to their young. Scientists also name a third group, **physiological adaptations**, which are about how the body works inside.

- A **physical adaptation** is a feature of the body: a body covering, a color, or a structure.
- A **behavioral adaptation** is an action or a pattern of actions.

| Adaptation | Type | How it helps |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Hare’s large, furry back feet | Physical (structure and covering) | Spread its weight on soft snow; keep feet warm |
| Hare’s white winter coat | Physical (coloration) | Harder for predators to see on snow |
| Eastern box turtle’s shell | Physical (covering) | Shields its soft body from predators |
| Great blue heron’s long legs | Physical (structure) | Wades into water to catch fish |
| Monarchs flying south in fall | Behavioral (migration) | Reach a warmer place for winter |
| Groundhog’s winter hibernation | Behavioral and physiological (hibernation) | Needs much less food while food is scarce |

The hare’s white coat is **camouflage**, coloring that helps an animal blend into its background.

Bird beaks work a bit like tools. A cardinal’s short, thick beak cracks seeds. A hummingbird’s long, thin beak reaches nectar deep in a flower. A heron’s long, sharp beak grabs fish.

**Predict.** Where does the tool comparison break? Name one thing a person can do with a tool that a bird cannot do with its beak.

> **Check.** You can put a tool down or pick up a different one, but a bird cannot swap its beak.

*Interactive on the lesson page:* Tap to enlarge large, furry back feetwhite winter coatbrown summer coatwhite hare on bare ground blankwhite winter coatb

**Key idea:**

Inherited body features or behaviors can help a living thing get resources or avoid predators, but which trait helps depends on the setting.

## Behaviors, trade-offs and variation

The film placed hibernation in both groups; here is where the line falls. **Hibernation** is a deep, inactive state some animals enter for winter. Going into a burrow and staying inactive is the behavior. Inside, the groundhog’s heart beats much more slowly and its body cools, which is a change in how the body works. It is not ordinary sleep: the groundhog warms up and wakes briefly now and then.

**Migration** is a regular journey between places used in different seasons. Many monarch butterflies pass through Virginia in fall on their way to Mexico, and the monarchs making the trip have never made it before. Many behaviors like these are instinctive, so animals do them without being taught. How animals respond to seasons is the topic of [the next lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/daily-and-seasonal-rhythms/).

*Figure (AI-generated illustration).* Migration moves monarchs to a warmer place, while hibernation lets groundhogs need much less food when food is scarce. Image: two panels. On the left, a line of monarch butterflies flies across a fall field along a dashed arrow; on the right, a groundhog lies curled up, hibernating, in a burrow under a snowy hillside.

A **trade-off** means a trait helps in one way but costs in another, like the white coat on bare ground or the turtle’s heavy shell in the film. A trade-off is not a failure; no living thing is perfectly adapted.

**Variation** means differences among individuals of a species. In Montana, some hares turned white earlier than others. Variation is a difference between hares, not a change inside one hare: a hare cannot choose a new coat, because its molt follows a yearly schedule. Day length seems to help set that schedule. Snow can shift spring timing somewhat, but not enough to keep every Montana hare matched.

So does a mismatched coat change survival enough to matter across generations? The second film follows the evidence.

**Film transcript: What the Hare Data Show**

### Film transcript: What the Hare Data Show

The first film showed one coat helping on snow and costing on bare ground. But does standing out actually change a hare's survival? Scientists in Montana fitted hares with small radio collars. Each week, they checked signals and tried to find each animal again. They estimated how white each coat was. They also scored nearby snow and averaged it into a weekly value for each site.

Contrast was the gap between a hare's coat whiteness and its site's weekly snow cover. A mathematical model then estimated weekly survival at different mismatch levels. These are estimates for groups, not guarantees for any single hare. When a hare was missed, the model estimated its coat color between observations. That step adds uncertainty, so the results remain rounded estimates. Before the estimates appear, predict the direction. As coat and ground differ more, should estimated survival rise, stay level, or fall?

The estimates fell as mismatch grew. The fully mismatched estimate was lower than the matched estimate, while partial mismatch sat between them. Camouflage is not a shield. A matched hare may die, and a mismatched hare may survive. The estimates change the chance; they do not decide any one hare's fate. A second team tested color more directly with clay mice. They placed light and dark models on light sand and dark soil. Bite, beak, and claw marks recorded attacks. On each ground, the model that mismatched received more attacks.

Color matching mattered in both places. Add the attack bars. Most marks landed on models that mismatched their ground. This held across both habitats. The pattern follows matching, not one color. The studies strengthen each other, but neither proves color caused every hare's death. Real predators also use movement, sound, smell, and cover. Now return to variation.

Hares in one population begin changing color at different times. Some timing may fit a changing snow season better. Snow can shift spring molt timing somewhat, but not enough to keep every hare matched. The hares also did not move to snowier resting spots. If a tendency to turn brown earlier is inherited, hares that have it may survive and leave more young. Across many generations, that tendency may become more common. Adaptations help in particular settings; populations change over generations, not individuals. One hare molts within life, but it does not choose inherited timing. The evidence links visible mismatch with lower estimated survival in Montana.

Variation gives selection something to act on, if timing is inherited. The field setting still matters.

From the film

- A coat that mismatches the ground can make prey easier for predators to find.
- The Montana values are weekly survival estimates, not guarantees for every hare.
- Variation means individuals in one population do not all have the same traits.
- Adaptations help in particular settings; populations change over generations, not individuals.

## Survival of matched and mismatched hares

Here are the rounded model estimates from 186 hares at two Montana sites. Snow cover was a weekly average for each site, and for weeks when a hare was missed, the model also estimated its coat color.

| Coat compared with the ground | Difference between coat whiteness and snow cover (percentage points) | Estimated chance of surviving one week (percent) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Matched (white on snow, or brown on bare ground) | 0 | 96 |
| Partly mismatched | 60 | 92 |
| Fully mismatched (for example, all white on bare ground) | 100 | 89 |

Source: Zimova, Mills and Nowak, Ecology Letters (2016), Discussion and Figure 3. Hares were near Seeley Lake (2009 to 2012) and Gardiner (2010 to 2012), Montana. These are rounded estimates from a model, not counts of hares, and the true values could be somewhat higher or lower. On average, each hare was badly mismatched for less than one week a year. The worry is that shorter snow seasons will make those weeks more common.

**Predict.** A drop from 96 percent to 89 percent is a drop of how many **percentage points**? For groups of 100, how many hares would the estimates leave alive in each group?

> **Check.** The difference is 7 percentage points. Out of 100, the estimates give about 96 matched survivors and 89 fully mismatched survivors. This is an expectation for groups, not a promise about any one hare.

A second team tested color directly with clay mice.

| Model color | Ground | Attacks recorded (number) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Dark | Light beach sand | 5 |
| Light | Light beach sand | 2 |
| Light | Dark inland soil | 16 |
| Dark | Dark inland soil | 5 |

Source: Vignieri, Larson and Hoekstra, Evolution (2010), Table 1. Models sat out in the field at Topsail Hill Preserve State Park (beach) and at an inland site, in Florida.

**Your turn.** What fraction of all 28 attacks hit models that did not match the ground?

> **Check.** Mismatched models (dark on sand, light on soil) received 5 + 16 = 21 of 28 attacks, or three out of four. The study’s statistics test showed that chance alone was unlikely to explain the difference.

## Who changes?

A **population** is all the members of one species in one area. The second film traced how an inherited tendency to turn brown earlier may become more common over many generations. This is natural selection, which you will study in [a later lesson](https://stemhop.com/lessons/natural-selection-in-action/). The film left out one risk: if the climate changes faster than the population can change, the population can struggle.

**Key idea:**

Adaptations usually have trade-offs, individuals vary, and inherited traits become more or less common in a population over many generations.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Make a claim that answers this question: what happens to a white hare when the snow melts early? Use both tables.

Claim Your answer to the question, in one sentence.

Start with: When the snow melts early, a white hare is blank likely to survive, because blank.

Evidence The data that support your claim.

Start with: Matched hares had an estimated blank percent chance of surviving a week, and fully mismatched hares had blank percent. Mismatched clay models got blank of 28 attacks.

Reasoning Why the evidence supports the claim, using the science.

Start with: A coat that does not match the ground makes it blank for predators to blank, so blank.

> **Compare with a model answer.** When the snow melts early, a white hare in Montana is less likely to survive than a hare that matches the ground. There, matched hares had an estimated 96 percent chance of surviving a week, and fully mismatched hares had 89 percent, 7 percentage points lower. In Florida, mismatched clay models got 21 of 28 attacks. A coat that stands out is easier for predators to find. One limit: the hare numbers are model estimates from two Montana sites over about three years, so they cannot show that coat color caused each death. Studies of hares in the Yukon found no such cost in spring, so the cost may differ from place to place.

Saved in this browser only.

### Design problem

You cannot test live hares at school. Plan a safe classroom test of whether matching the background protects prey, using paper “prey” and classmates as “predators.”

**Predict.** If you move the same white and brown paper prey from a white background to a brown one, which color should become easier to find? Name the independent variable and the dependent variable before opening the plan.

> **One way to do it.** - **Question:** Are paper squares that match the background picked up less often than squares that do not?
> - **Independent variable:** whether a square matches the background (white squares and brown squares on a white sheet, then on a brown sheet).
> - **Dependent variable:** the number of each color picked up.
> - **Constants:** 20 squares of each color, each 1 cm by 1 cm, a sheet about 1 m by 1 m, and 15 seconds per turn.
> - **Control:** the same mix of squares on both backgrounds, so color matching is the only change.
> - **Repeated trials:** five classmates each take three turns on each background. Find the mean for each color.
> - **Safety:** use only paper, keep the floor clear so no one trips, and pick up every square afterward.
>
> If matching squares are picked up less on both backgrounds, the result supports camouflage. Your test is a model: real predators also use smell and movement.

## Evaluate: check your thinking

When snow melts early, a white hare stands out on brown ground, and in Montana mismatched hares had a lower estimated chance of surviving each week. A lasting change in timing can happen only across generations, if hares vary in an inherited way and some leave more young.

**Science practices you used:** making predictions and testing them with a model, reading data tables, calculating a difference in percentage points, planning a fair test with constants and repeated trials, and naming the limits of a model and of the data.

---

From STEMhop (https://stemhop.com), free lessons by Christopher Deppmann. Lesson text © the authors. Practice questions: https://stemhop.com/lessons/adaptations-for-survival/
